r/Planetside • u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force • Jun 03 '14
Liberator vs Lightning and Liberator vs Max Round 1
So I've been meaning to calculate the ttk's of skyguards and bursters vs libs. I started with the dalton and will move to the shredder later. I also want to compare lock on's but that will be later.Big shout out to /u/shaql and /u/calder87 for some help with finding/getting numbers on resistance. I did my best in finding out these values, but if you think there are any discrepancies let me know.
To start, i'll list out HP and resistance values, and then i'll show my estimated ttk for a ** specific situation **. Take note that my situation is all a calculation and of course other variables play in.
So, Liberators have 5000 hp with a base 35% resistance to heavy flak. These are things like AA turrets and Skyguards. They have 90% resistance from light flak like bursters.
Lightnings have 3000 HP with a 100% percent resistance to splash damage. They have a 58% resistance from damage on their top armor. They also have -25% resistance from Dalton rounds (AP FTW)
Max's have 2000 HP with a 50% resistance to a direct dalton round, and 50% reduction from splash.
Now, onward to the TTK's.
** * The Situation * ** A Dalton lib is hovering 250 m above the top of a lightning. Skyguards deal 200 damage up to 100 m and 150 after 300m. I used the 150 damage value for this test, though I might be wrong. ( Not sure what other damage value I could use) With a lib having 35% resistance to flak from skyguards, the damage would actually be about 98. Meaning it would take 51 shots from the skyguard to kill a lib. Now the skyguard has a reload of 3 seconds with a mag size of 70. It also fires at 480 rpm. At 480 rpm, it fires about 8 shells per second, meaning it will take about 6 seconds to kill the lib hovering. Now i'm going to factor in the avg accuracy of skyguard users thanks to DA and their amazing stats page. I used the NC version, hopefully that doesn't rustle the feathers of you guys too much. The AVG accuracy of the user is about 26.6%, meaning the AVG player will hit about 19 rounds of the 70 round clip. This means that it will take about 3 clips to kill the lib and with a reload at 3 seconds, the TTK would end up being about 33 seconds.
Now I know that the accuracy value from DA is going to have some problems because these values come from people that are shooting moving targets, infantry, the hills, etc., but this is all i've got to base it off of.
Continuing on, let's say the lib is shooting the skyguard. The Dalton has a 2.5 second reload and is single shot. The shells from a Dalton have a convenient velocity of 250 m/s ( I didn't factor in the other velocities because they're going to be less than one and therefore pretty minimal). Each Dalton shell deals direct damage of 1825. Lightning's once again have top resistance of 58% minus the Dalton shell AP value of -25% so they even out at 33% resistance. Because of this, each round will deal about 602 damage direct. ( Don't forget that lightnings have 100% resistance to splash) That gives the Dalton about ** 5 shots ** to kill the lightning. It will therefore take about 17.5 seconds to kill the lightning ( with the 250 m/s velocity of the shells meaning every round takes about a second to hit the lightning from 250 meters up).
Now, on to the Max's, the spawn room heroes if you must.
This will be kind of funky because maxes can be assumed to use both arms and not just one. I once again chose the NC values from the DA website for bursters and I used the left arm because this one will be the one used for most dual AA situations. The avg users have 28% accuracy with bursters. After 200 meters bursters do 20 direct damage plus 56 indirect. This means that a max will do a ** whoppping 76 damage flat** ( OMG OP). But wait, the lib has a 90% resistance value to light flak from bursters. Meaning every shell 7.6 damage ( RIP Bursters) Lets assume people are running Dual bursters. Yay 15 damage! At this point I figured I was wrong, maybe I read something wrong but those are the damage values I got. Thats way to low and therefore i'm going to assume I did something wrong because that would mean the lib would need to be shot 328 times to die....
Onward to the libs response to the max. Maxs have 2000 HP and have a 50% percent resistance to Dalton rounds. Meaning each Dalton shell will deal about 913 damage. This means that it will take 3 Dalton rounds to kill the max. This means it will take about 8 seconds. When I attempt to add in indirect damage, I add 700 making the actual damage per shell to about 1263. Meaning a 2 shot kill and a ttk of 4.5 seconds.
This was just some interesting info and I'd love it if someone wanted to compare the numbers, but that's what I got. I'll be doing some more with
Edit #1: With the help of some Redditside members, I've come to see some disorder in my numbers. First off the direct damage from the bursters and skyguard is void. As of now with 100% accuracy the TTK will end up being 20.5 seconds. I'll do some testing on my own in Friday to verify these numbers and also test the shredder damage. Big thanks to /u/Kislen aka OPScatmax on Connery.
5
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14
Are you kidding me? Thanks for your work, but this is completely misleading. Why did you only account for accuracy of the ground units? DA lists the Dalton accuracy with about 53%. That changes the Lib against Lightning comparison completely!
I am sorry if I missed something, but this is really biased right now.
2
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Hmm. Let me change that, I actually DID account for Dalton accuracy in my notes. Need to format then real quick.
1
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14
I just went to the VR and tried the Dalton against the Lightning. I only needed 3 shots to kill it. I don't know if it's different in a real fight, but probably not.
2
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
From the top? Maybe the resistance values are off or maybe lightnings do take damage from splash.
1
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14
Yes, from the top. I really don't know how many shots it takes normally because I am almost never gunning with the Dalton.
2
1
u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14
Since the Dalton's splash damage can also damage vehicles, i think that indirect hits are also considered good when it comes to calculating the accuracy, thus skewing the results since it's quite easy to get a lot of indirect hits against vehicles. It would be great an accuracy stat that only takes direct hits in account, but i don't think the API makes that distinction...
-2
u/Gave_up_Made_account SOLx/4R Jun 03 '14
That is because people are shooting at infantry with the Dalton. You don't miss a tank if you are hovering 250m above them.
3
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14
And you only hit with 26.6% of your skyguard shots in that case?
0
u/Gave_up_Made_account SOLx/4R Jun 03 '14
To be fair I don't think the Skyguard can shoot straight up so the tank may need to move around to get a shot. The Lib would be free to fire away that whole time. His writeup isn't perfect but it is decently accurate. In any case he left out the Tank Buster. That is probably the main problem with the Lib versus vehicles.
2
u/AngerMacFadden Jun 03 '14
Skyguard can back up to get the fire arc with the bonus of being a moving target.
0
u/Gave_up_Made_account SOLx/4R Jun 03 '14
Moving in an easily predictable line over uneven terrain while trying to readjust aim. If I can snipe infantry in a tank with AP rounds it can't be much harder to hit a tank driving painfully slow in reverse.
2
-2
u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14
When people use the Dalton, they feel fine firing 10 shots against aircraft to hit only one. And in farm situations, people feel fine spamming all their ammo.
Have you used a Dalton? It isn't hard to hit a tank even while moving full speed at a distance.
2
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
Yes. But this is just not a fair comparison. If you take the Dalton skill out of the equation you should do the same with the Skyguard.
0
u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14
Or.... you can identify a specific situation and, assuming an adequate skill level reasonable for this situation, also assume specific accuracies for both parties.
If the Skyguard is driving full speed during this, then the accuracy of both should reflect this. If they're both stationary, then the accuacy of both should reflect this.
My point was that a near 100% accuracy should be assumed for the Dalton, as even average gunners can reliably hit a Skyguard.
2
u/milgrim Miller [UMVS] Jun 03 '14
Sorry, but that's just not really objective anymore then. Only SOE could do that because they (probably) have better numbers. Who else knows Skyguard vs. Liberator accuracy stats? ESFs are way smaller and the accuracy against Libs is probably higher because of that. And while a Lib with a Dalton in farming mode might have really high accuracy numbers against armor, they probably drop off when it gets attacked by a Skyguard.
So what would be your reasonable assumption for all these values? What would be your specific situation?
This thread is a great way to start a discussion about this, but the numbers have to be right and the conditions have to be equal. Assuming 100% accuracy is the best way to do that.
0
4
u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
For flak damage you must use indirect hits, the shells burst near aircrafts and never actually hit them; it takes about 80 130-140 flak hits to kill a lib, definitely more than a reload.
Direct hits count only when dealing with ground vehicles and infantry.
Source: testing it in VR.
Edit: the dalton's splash damage is also capable of harming vehicles, so it also must be taken into account. It takes 3 rounds to the top of a lightning to kill, 4 with top armour.
edit2: i was wrong, 80 hits was the result of an apparently outdated test on pts, just did it again on live and it's about 140 hits.
2
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Let me double check the stats, that may or may not make a huge difference.
1
u/NihilCredo Jun 03 '14
Source: testing it in VR.
Splash damage has been fucked in VR since forever. Try testing it on the PTS.
1
u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14
Only infantry dummies are immune to splash damage in VR, flak works as intended.
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Are you using my situation as a the metering? 250 meters is what I was referring to. And are you also saying that bursters and skyguard do the same damage? I got all my numbers. Planetside wiki.
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Yeah I'm seeing the Planetside wiki is wrong. Do you just know by fact or did you do the math to tell how many shots it would take?
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Yeah I did values that accounted for different accuracy, but that should only change the TTK. The amount of shots will obviously be the same. This makes me wonder how the damage fall off works. I want to know how much damage each shot will do. Thanks for the change of numbers though.
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Gotcha. So 5000*.0071=35.5 per shot. 35.5*140=4,970 which I can buy as being a kill with fire damage taking the last 30 off.
2
u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14
Yeah, i'm sorry for that, the VR testing was done a few weeks ago on the PTS, i just did it again on Live and it's around 130-140 hits as you said.
Weird stuff.
3
u/-Progapanda [F00L] Jun 03 '14
Yeah, 2-shotting Burster Maxes with a Dalton practically never happens.
1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
In the actual battle situation the skyguard will deter the Lib if playing it smart. This has never been an issue. If the Lib has composite armor I agree that flak and tank shells are not powerful enough.
1
u/BITESNZ Leader of Villains [VILN] Jun 03 '14
Shredders make me flee like a girly bitch ... everytime.
0
u/PKwolf [HIVE] Jun 03 '14
Way to factor in accuracy for everything but the Liberator. These threads are getting far too obvious.
2
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Did your read the comments? I said that I have the factor for them to. Let's chill out and read everything before we start commenting sir.
0
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
58-25 is 33 no? The math itself isn't bad. The values may be corrupted due to the wrong ones being used, but the actual computations are wrong.
1
u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14
Elaborate, last time i checked, 58-25=33.
2
u/Cswic ZAPS Jun 03 '14
But that's not how damage is calculated...
Here's an example:
Van AP shot deals 2000 damage.
Sunderer has all around armor value of 45%.
Sunderer has AP resistance of 25%.
OP's way.
45% + 25% = 70% resist total (he added 58 resist + -25 resist to get 33 net). 2000 * .3 (amount not resisted) = 600 damage done per shot.
Base sundy HP of 4000 / 600 = 6.6 shots to kill.
Correct way:
AP damage of 2000 * .55 = 1100 (amount of damage done based solely on sundy armor).
1100 * .75 (since sundy has AP resist of 25%) = 825 damage per shot.
4000 / 825 = 4.85 shots to kill. So 5 shots.
Now using your way, that means a sunderer should easily be able to survive 5 Titan AP shots with 1/4th of it's HP left.
Here's van AP vs sundy on live currently:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4oSqFuRMck
So 5 shots to kill with the last shot doing some overkill damage aka roughly 4.85 shots.
Also, OP flipped numbers in his examples. If he says a lightning has a net resist of 33%. Then that means a dalton shell deals 1825 * .67 = 1223 of direct damage.
Instead he wrote that a dalton shot deals 1825 * .33 = 602 damage, which is really the amount of direct damage the lightning resists.
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
0
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
Got all my numbers from Planetside wiki. I've been told I used the wrong numbers.
3
u/JusticiaDIGT Solo Lib Jun 03 '14
Fine that you take into account accuracy for the skyguard, but the accuracy will not be 25% against a low hovering lib.
Also, it takes 3 rounds to kill a Lightning with a Dalton. (I don't think anyone runs top armor)