r/Planetside • u/TasteLikeVomit • Jun 03 '14
The big ESF debate
It would be nice if everyone could have their say in the balancing and other topics regarding the various ESF's. Some topics include and are not limited to; Balancing Contrast against other empire ESF's Air to air Air to ground Countering ESF's (sky-guard, lock-ons)
Suggestions can also be included (buffs, nerfs) to make the game overall more enjoyable from everyone/ fair.
25
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
Coyotes, in my opinion are way too powerful for what they're supposed to be. As a secondary weapon, they should supplement the primary (think MBTs), not replace it. I've ran into far too many people firing nothing but their coyotes while maneuvering in a way that makes them incredibly hard to hit with a nosegun.
I'm not someone that gets mad at people for using weapons that SOE gives them, but I seriously think they need to be looked at. Even something as simple as a reload speed increase would appease me.
9
3
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 03 '14
Coyotes are the reason I log out most of the time. They are not used by new pilots that would require some help, but by rather experienced pilots simply abusing the sh*t out of the weapon.
There are three ways of fixing things:
Removing afterburners completely for people running a secondary
Buffing fueltanks to 1.5 times of the current amount
Removing the "Hover-Penalty" on fuel consumption when using AB-tanks
5
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I think that instead of nerfing coyotes, perhaps external AB should just be doubled. Then people who pick lolpods will still be killed by coyotes.
5
Jun 03 '14
I think the damage is ok on the A2A missiles and coyotes. We just don't have viable counters aside from "kill them faster." There have been endless floods of ideas on this subject. Adapting some of the defensive slot items (composite, stealth) and tweaking tomcat/proton behaviors would bring these weapons right into line and give people a feeling of agency when it comes to lock-on fights.
2
u/Sniper061 DAUN Jun 03 '14
Coyotes, in my opinion are way too powerful for what they're supposed to be. As a secondary weapon, they should supplement the primary (think MBTs), not replace it. I've ran into far too many people firing nothing but their coyotes while maneuvering in a way that makes them incredibly hard to hit with a nosegun.
I have to agree with some of the other comments. I think coyotes are fine as they are. I like to run with my PPA for the anti-infantry ability. Nothing beats sneaking up on a wall full of infantry and just mowing em down.
Secondaries for ESF's aren't meant to be a supplement to the primary weapon. Instead, they are supposed to be a SECOND primary weapon. Albeit one that should fill a different role. So yes, while there are lots of people running nosegun+coyotes and dominating in the air, others like me use them as my anti-air defense on a anti-ground oriented vehicle. What do you expect me to do, shotgun slow moving orbs of death your way so they can be dodged while I am torn apart?
7
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I think a ground attack ESF should be ineffective against air.
Back when I was using the Light PPA (this was before coyotes were released), I sacrificed the ability to kill air for the ability to farm infantry. When I was using rocket pods (with a rotary), I sacrificed the maneuverability that AB tanks gave me against air for the versatility of being somewhat effective against all types of targets.
The problem with coyotes is that they give you all the a2a firepower you need, which lets you run an AI primary with a sound mind. The regular lockon missiles aren't like this. You shouldn't be able to have your cake and eat it too.
1
Jun 03 '14
theproblem isn't that they are secondary so should be worst than the primary, it is that they are better than what should be the main a2a weapon
1
1
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jun 03 '14
they should supplement the primary
but you play vanu, where halbard/sauron is better than the main mag gun due to simmilar/better DPS and superior FOV :0
10
u/PassionateL0ver PSBL (´◉◞౪◟◉`) Jun 03 '14
Increase ESF mobility (vertical movements and reduce inertia) to make dodging and overall flying easier for new pilots.
Slightly decrease noseguns damages to ESF or ESF resistance to noseguns to reduce the gank factor in winning a dogfight.
Make stealth dodge coyotes or make coyotes behave like the lib hyena.
Make lockons dodgeable by maveuvering like they used to be.
Change the flight ceiling system to make it like the death field of warpgates (immunity for drop pods) or increase it to 1500m so that you can flank using high altitude gals and counter those with ESF squadrons.
Dogfighting should be fun and easy to learn the basics but with an important learning curve and skill ceiling.
5
u/Jessedi Jun 03 '14
If the flight ceiling was raised to 1500 I think we would need all aircraft to render at 1500. At least plane to plane. You don't want it where an entire squad of ESF's to flank over your head and not even render.
2
Jun 03 '14
Might encourage all ESFs to travel at higher altitudes and make ground attack much more risky. Would also put a premium on situational awareness.
And I could more easily live out my fantasy of diving out of the sun, guns blazing, onto a pack of unsuspecting farmers.
1
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 03 '14
Being able to fight other aircraft at high altitude in peace, without random flak spotting you and blowing you to bits?
3
u/yoyowaterson Jun 03 '14
decreasing time to kill INCREASES gank factor. the longer it takes the kill the more important numbers become. so 3 enemies can gank a single esf.
the longer TTK, the LESS skill in aiming and manuever matters, as multiple other factors start to intrude in a fight b/n esfs. G2A locks, Flak, other esfs, libs, gals, ground fire.
longer ttk just means, if you get jumped or into a 1v1 fight, you can evade and stretch out a fight till help arrives. which is the current favored tactic of the lock-on gank squads currently. run in circles while two other zerglings shoot tomcats at a single enemy.
1
Jun 03 '14
I'm sorry, but a 3v1 fight should pretty much always result in the death of the lone plane.
The only question should be how many you can take with you before the end.
1
u/JusticiaDIGT Solo Lib Jun 03 '14
How does the Hyena behave differently from the Coyotes currently?
5
u/levarn [WASP] Varn Jun 03 '14
A lower rate of fire combined with a larger clip makes it far more a sustained fire weapon, reducing the DPS/alpha strike capacity and (presumably) giving people with noseguns a chance against them up close. I am not necessarily advocating this change, but they do behave differently in that way.
1
u/JusticiaDIGT Solo Lib Jun 03 '14
I know all of that but I thought he was arguing some sort of mechanics change for Coyotes (that Hyenas already had). Guess it was just poorly phrased or my poor understanding of what he meant :)
0
u/PassionateL0ver PSBL (´◉◞౪◟◉`) Jun 03 '14
3
u/JusticiaDIGT Solo Lib Jun 03 '14
That doesn't really tell me how they behave differently, mechanics wise. Sure, there are differences in rate of fire etc, but my question is how they behave differently.
1
u/GrilledChickenVS [NACHO] Jun 03 '14
It's the fire rate and velocity the makes them behave differently.
5
5
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14
To be very frank it's like this yo. There are probably only somewhere around 15 percent of the player base that has more than 100 hours in the air. The air gameplay in this game is kind of weird. Most people that fly have been doing it pre ESF update, though don't get me wrong I'm sure some people hopped in the air after the update. Many people who couldn't really dogfight were permanently grounded when they began to get wrekt by coyotes. Therefore there's not a lot of us remaining and in general we don't have a big say, so unless we have some profound concepts that not only help peasants but help us too, I doubt we will see the changes we want.
-1
u/Ellieindahouse Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
mkgrider23 has got it spot on!!
The "Air Purists" are a minority whose changes they desire won't be acknowledged by SOE as they don't relate to the majority of "Peasants" and will only make it worse for said peasants if actually implemented.
U don't really see "the other side" because these lower skilled players are having fun with their coyotes / lock-ons esp in an air squad of 2-3+ in the present gank meta. Enough fun such that they enjoy the status quo and don't post about wanting the balance changed.
Credit to anyone trying to start a discussion, but of all the aspects of PS2, Air game is one of the LEAST LIKELY to ever have any balance towards a more "Competitive" aspect similar to the beginning.
Everyone (Ace or peasant) alike will just have to accept it. Personally, I enjoy lockons and coyotes. For the easy mode they provide (Last thing I want is to exert myself after a hard day's work) and the rage tells I get. :D
Peace!
3
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 03 '14
How do you think about large goups of aces with coyotes? Because that is what is happening right now as a reaction to the frustration caused by the sheer amount of secure damage these weapons put out without requiring a lot of skill.
-1
u/Ellieindahouse Jun 04 '14
The only group of people that really really suffer from this are extremely new players flying esfs with minimal skill and no wingmen.
For explanation's sake - If an ace were to be at level 8-10, and a intermediate / new-ish flyer were to be at level 4-7.
In a 3v3 / 5v5 fight (With a pack of level 8-10 vs a pack of level 4-7).
No matter what, there would still be significant collateral damage on the side of the aces. Even if they were to "win" - Quite a few of their esfs would be taken down.
By the sheer nature of A2A (Basic squad voice comms of A2A focusing firing a target = 1 ESF down immediately)
Coyotes (The intermediate flyer in a 1v1 vs an ace with coyotes will prob lose, but he is dealing definite damage to the ace (due to only needing to fire coyotes in the general direction - enough for his friend to finish him off)
Also taking into consideration if the intermediate pack gets the jump first on the pack of aces and immediately takes out 1 esf first, they are more than likely to win with the numerical advantage and having the extra esf to hover lock :D
Which is partly the reason y some aces get so mad. Because they know in a pure nose-gun situation they would probably have the clear upper edge. But with the introduction of coyotes / a2a by soe and the air squad / gank meta. They get killed a lot more by "Lesser-skilled" players.
Make no mistake, these lesser skilled pilots understand whats happening. And they know in a straight up 1v1, they will prob get owned. But hey, they are still getting kills this way and its fun for them even though the other side (which is a small minority) begs to differ.
3
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14
Sigh. Another one misses the point. None of the veteran pilots complain about getting killed by low BRs using Coyotes. The problem is that Coyotes are so strong that most of the good pilots (those you rank as level 8-10) started using them too because they are better off with them. The accuracy that you need to have with a nosegun to be able to compete with the DPS of the Coyotes is so high that is practically out of reach for a human being, especially if the other ESF is actively dodging. Even rguitar would be bigger threat if he used Coyotes, he doesn't strictly because of fairness reasons and outfit rules, not because he thinks fuel pods are stronger.
Watch this video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EitZRLt2G3w. At 4:19 it says "if ability B is 10% stronger than ability A but 3 times harder to execute, then ability B is only better if you are a machine".
Coyotes are meant to be a tool to help new players, but it's impossible to ever become so good that you'd never need them over the nosegun, because Coyotes are too strong. And if all you'll ever use to dogfight is a crutch weapon, something that holds your hand, then dogfighting will get boring to you pretty quickly in comparison of how fun it would remain if you eventually felt like you had to learn to use the nosegun to keep getting better.
0
u/Ellieindahouse Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14
And if all you'll ever use to dogfight is a crutch weapon, something that holds your hand, then dogfighting will get boring to you pretty quickly in comparison of how fun it would remain if you eventually felt like you had to learn to use the nosegun to keep getting better.
Respectfully disagree.
Let me provide some Real In-game examples.
Libs that mainly pull for those easy 1-12 hover-farm situations. They are not very skilled. Cant hold their own against other more skilled lib krews, neither can they take on esfs. And they don't really fly libs with the goal of training to be good in lib vs lib / lib vs air combat.
BUT, till today, they are never in short supply. U always see them, Intermediate lib krews that focus on the easy 1-12 fight hover farm. Do they get bored of it? Nope. Even when they get raped by a skilled lib krew. They just switch continent.
2. Tankers (both lightning / heavy tanks) that look for a stalemate at base templates like that of crimson buff (The one where u have that tower like structure). Park themselves on the nearby hill, and shell the tower / spawn shield areas for like 20-30 mins (however long the stalemate lasts) We have all seen them.
If they go up 1 v 1 against another experienced tanker who has made the effort to train his accuracy while moving etc. will they get demolished? Yup. But yet they still pull the tanks for that "Boring" spam fest without the goal of improving overall tank play.
You get the point? U are only speaking for people like yourself that train to get better and challenge yourself.
But planetside is made up of people from all across the spectrum. I am referring to people that belong to the above category who play not to improve but are fine with developer-provided crutch situations as long as they get kills. To them, THAT IS FUN (While it may not be FUN for you).
Apply this same category of people to ESFs and you can see why these intermediate pilots don't get bored with their coyote / a2a air squads and crutch / ez mode kills even though they know they will get stomped 1v1.
2
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14
Yeah, that might be the reason why there is a lot of squads (5 or more) aces with coyotes. The problem isn't the players that need the help of coyotes, it's the players that are good enough without them but still use them.
And the second the intermediate pilot thinks he is good engough now to use the nosegun he gets destroyed in a heartbeat. Coyotes are not really helping you to learn the ins and outs of a2a combat, that is another problem i see with them.
To make your argument more valid you should have suggested, that whenever there is someone engaging someone else, RNGJesus steps in and decides who wins, that way the playing field is level and everyone quits the game because there is no room for improvement.
6
u/Ellieindahouse Jun 03 '14
Not to be a wet blanket @ OP but of the MAIN points mentioned:
Coyote Nerf
A2A locks becoming dodge-able
Flight ceiling increase
Won't happen anytime in the foreseeable future and probably not ever for a long time to come.
Present Air Game Balance is intended by SOE and "Sky Knights" are a vocal minority whose concerns SOE don't really care about.
2
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 03 '14
The problem is, that the so-called "Sky Nights" actually are the ones helping newer players getting into the game (if asked politely). The same goes for all other areas of the game: There have to be players to teach other players in a game this complex. This group might be a minority, but it can help introducing players to the game to an extent no tutorial will ever be able to...
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I thought A2A lock ons were dodgeable. I was under the impression they were predictive so going to a dive near the ground or weaving around mountains or obstacles makes them collide with the scenery.
3
u/Ellieindahouse Jun 03 '14
Yes. They can still be "dodged" that way by making them hit terrain aka flying behind a mountain.
The dodging that others are referring to is a "Reverse-Cobra" manoeuvre where your esf could dodge an incoming a2a missile in mid air by tilting its nose back upwards.
It was not intended and was patched by SOE.
2
u/yoyowaterson Jun 03 '14
no, they cant be dodged just by going behind terrain. you have to block line of sight between you and the tracking enemy esf. if you dont break that line of sight the missile will hit you no matter what.
you have to consider where the enemy esf is, not the missile. Not completely different but significant enough that it helps to know that.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 03 '14
IIRC they're still predictive so smart flying can make them hit off terrain. Its not perfect but it still works most of the time.
I know this because I quite like the A2AM pods in their current state.
2
Jun 03 '14
They need a reduction in turning ability. They should not be able to turn sharper than 90 degrees or so, imo. Add in a lower initial velocity with a ramp up and you've got a weapon that is tailored for distance and performs poorly at close range. That makes vehicle stealth a solid tactical counter by giving more time for a pilot to close distance.
If composite armor severely reduced coyote damage (40-50% reduction) you'd have a solid strategic counter there.
It would give each defensive slot item a role, add more pilot choices, introduce a skill-based counter to tomcats (dodging), and would not require damage changes for the weapons themselves.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 03 '14
Agreed, problem is very few pilots will be willing to give up NARS for Stealth or Composite even if they did provide advantages against A2A weaponry.
2
Jun 03 '14
Then the 'fault' would lie with them. If a counter exists and you choose not to use it, you're responsible. You can't take a generalist build and expect to excel in every situation.
3
u/yoyowaterson Jun 03 '14
There are two main issues that need to be addressed accessability and balance.
1 Accessibility for beginners
a The improvements from certing should be loaded to the front end, not the back end of the certification purchases.
b The less certed your esf the lower the default respawn timer and air resource costs.
c default Flares and not taking up a current slot (note the air radar doesnt help newbs, having enemy activity selected on the map filter by default would).
d lock ons need a nerf, lock ons from the ground and air absolutely destroy newb pilots, they were an attempt to cause issues for "aces" all they did was give ALL pilots the dps of "aces" and allow everyone to farm new pilots mercilessly. Severly limiting the air game to those who have the experience to deal with very OP lock ons. I cant stress how badly this is effecting playability for newer pilots. It is DESTROYING the air game.
2. Balance
esf vs esf balance
a make all the guns have an equal muzzle velocity, leave the current bullet drops the same, (vs none, tr a little bit, nc a good bit)
b give the mossie rotary back its rounds you took away previously (five i think)
c vortek needs a larger total ammo pool
2. Esf vs everything else balance
a undo the most recent nosegun nerf
b undo the most recent esf armor to EVERYTHING nerf
c nerf banshee, and ah to infantry maybe ppa,,, not sure about ppa
d make lol pods specifically anti armor AP rounds remove blast radius
e remove extra penalty for initial AB use
f shorten g2a lock tracking range, and nerf the instant acquisition time if you dont make flares a default additional slot
In review, Ground currently dominates ESFS in the air, Libs dominate esfs in the air, and a2a locks dominate esf to esf fighting.
newbs are being slaughtered by a2a locks, g2a locks, flak libs and "aces"
allow newbs to pull more and more frequently till they are certed up, and make the gains from the cert purchases up front with marginal increases on the back end. and PLEASE consider default flairs (no cert cost, and make them standard stand alone slot for all esfs) esp if you decide not to nerf locks ons ground and air.
Undoing the armor and nosegun overall nerfs on the esfs, should bring them back more on par with armor on the ground, and most importantly with libs in the air, who currently rule the skies.
Currently libs own the skies and esfs are just renting space from them, and ironicly libs really hurt the ground in ways esfs cant even come close.
If any developer would like to sit down and chat with some of the best and most experienced esf, lib and galaxy pilots in the game, contact me and I will get you onto the Prey teamspeak, and you can discuss air2air, newb vs vet, and a2ground balance all day long.
3
u/PolarbearGaming EDIM Jun 03 '14
ESFs are completely balanced against ground....not so much air. Right now Tomcats and Coyotes are kinda stupid. Coyotes are cheap because they abuse game mechanics. The mechanic they abuse is latency. They can do a 90 degree turn because on the shooters screen, they are head on with the enemy ESF. Also, stealth needs to tighten up the cone that they can autolock.
Tomcats are broken. If I could dodge tomcats, awesome. Riight now, you cant dodge them. Also, the reload speed is stupid quick for something takes away about 40% of your health.
1
u/MorphingShadows WSNeo Jun 03 '14
Tomcats are buggy as fuck. The lockon range is unusually low for it's role.
2
u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] Jun 03 '14
As a ground peasant I can deal with ESFs without lockons. Sure they get me but if they hover too long they get decimated.
It IS the libs that are the problem. I'd prefer the solution to be a boost for ESF vs Lib rather than more lock ons from ground. I think everyone is in agreement that there are far to many of those already.
For the few times I go in the air I typically run a stealth/ afterburners/ rotary. I do feel gimped and get wrecked quickly. I feel that running this setup makes me a better pilot in the end and I'm more concerned with raising my skill ceiling rather than short term kills. Having stealth provide some benifit to coyotes would be nice. Im not expirerenced enough in the air game to feel confident in calling for any nerfs though.
Im more being the voice of a inexpierence trying to communicate my thoughts on attempting to learn the air game.
5
u/GlennBeckistan [DA] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
Remove afterburners if you're not running afterburner fuel pods.
Allow transitioning between flight and hover modes with a key and put a "Flight Mode:" display on the dashboard, allowing for hover, flight, or blended modes (the last being the model we currently have, and the default when an ESF is pulled).
New pilot quality of living - Being able to perform a reverse maneuver should become easier, now that you can initiate hover mode instead of waiting for a visual cue.
ESF v ESF - Running coyotes or A2A lock-ons would give up the ability to reverse maneuver as effectively as running afterburners. They maintain their strength in an ambush role, but lose strength when the fight starts on equal footing.
ESF v Ground - Running rocketpods and hovering would make it difficult to disengage from ground to air without afterburners, which encourages doing fly-bys and limits staying power.
ESF v Liberators - The ability to stay in hover mode until you want to leave it allows ESFs to maintain their distance easier. Accidentally leaving hover mode due to pitching up and then flying towards the liberator is frustrating. Couple that with liberator afterburners being so effective at closing distance and its hard to make any progress. It requires so much time to gain distance again and re-establish hover mode that now their auto-repair has kicked in.
Anyway, that's what I've been kicking around in my head.
0
u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Jun 03 '14
Engagement radar as a Passive certline would be another great tweak.
-1
u/nelson1tom [DRED] PlanetSnide Jun 04 '14
Removing AB if youre using a secondary would be disastrous. A2G is the usually the best way for air to actually contribute to the fight.
3
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
Saron and Coyotes need a nerf and Mosquito Rotary a buff. A2A lock-ons need to be dodgeable. Besides that it's just minor things, like the flight ceiling which is too low.
5
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
What's wrong with the Saron (honestly asking, I don't use it myself)?
2
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
The scythe is the king of 1v1 encounters. I can beat pilots that are much better than me just because I'm using the Saron. Of course it is supposed to be the strength of the Scythe, but I think, especially due to the velocity, the advantage is too big. The Hailstorm is fine imo, none of the rotaries need a nerf. I would even welcome an overall ammo capacity increase for them.
6
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I always thought that the Scythe's 'trait' was supposed to be velocity, seeing as the Mosquito has more damage per magazine and the Reaver has more damage per bullet.
I'm certain that the Saron is best at 1v1 plinking at range, but doesn't that put it at a disadvantage at closer ranges?
2
u/DrSPAZZINATOR Connery: WTAC/BAID Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
The scythe's noseguns have faster ttk than the mossie's counterparts and higher velocities than both other esf's counterparts.
1
u/sushi_cw Connery Jun 03 '14
The scythe's noseguns have higher ttk than the mossie's counterparts
Actually, they don't. For the most part they're about the same, with the Scythe guns having a very slight advantage.
Source (Play with the range and accuracy settings, most of the time the Scythe guns have slightly lower TTK than Mossie)
1
u/DrSPAZZINATOR Connery: WTAC/BAID Jun 03 '14
I meant Faster TTK, got mixed up with higher and faster. I'll fix that.
1
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 03 '14
Give the needler a further 10 bullets on top of the ones it got recently, then maybe the damage per mag trait will be comparable to the smallest hitbox and fastest velocity nose cannon.
1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
Let's look at a Scythe vs Reaver: The reaver needs to come close the the Scythe, otherwise it will just be defeated at render range. Now closing distance is much harder than maintaining it. When I face a Reaver pilot I can just keep reversing while he tries to come closer and this gives me an easy time in hitting him with my Saron. He also has a huge hit box to make it even easier. However I think the Reaver itself is fine, when it comes to jumping other aircraft from behind and close range fighting it is great.
Let's look at Scythe vs Mosquito: I think the Mosquito is just a worse Scythe in a 1v1. Both have a small hit box and longer range nose guns. So fights usually happen at longer ranges. Due to its velocity the Scythe has a significant advantage. I would also say it is even harder to hit than a Mosquito. So the Mosquito needs a significant larger magazine size. I think with the recent needler buff the difference would be significant enough if the Saron would be tuned down a bit (either magazine size or velocity nerf). The M18 rotary however desperately needs its magazine size back, I don't see much people using it.
I am however not sure how the balance between ESF looks for more inexperienced pilots.
1
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I think that magazine size on the default noseguns should be as high as it currently is, simply because new pilots have a hard time getting a lead on their target, wasting many bullets in the process.
I'm not in a position to say if the Saron needs a nerf or not, but if it does I'd rather it be something like damage per bullet or reload speed.
1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
That makes sense. I wonder how it would work out if the VS nose guns had no bullet drop and lower velocity.
1
Jun 03 '14
It's not the gun that's winning you the 1v1s. It's that damn front cross section that, as long as your not is toward the enemy, it's hard as shit to hit.
2
2
2
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I agree with everything but, I'm not sure if a saron needs a nerf, or the scythe hitbox needs to be bigger... or the needler just needs a buff. I'd probably go with giving the mossy a HUGE magazine. Having 15 bullets more than the saron is not worth it for having a bigger hitbox and less velocity. Having 30/40 bullets more, and suddenly we have two comparable noseguns.
1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
Saron and Needler would be comparable then, but Reaver vs Scythe would still heavily favor the Scythe.
1
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 03 '14
I'm not so sure. If you go for a conventional hoverfight then sure, the scythe will win. When the reaver starts getting closer and more aggressive, the strong points of the scythe aren't as useful, and the reaver with its high burst DPS and V thrust becomes a contender to win.
But still, it depends on what skill level we're talking about. If two mediocre pilots face each other, I reckon the scythe always wins, but the reaver, with its high skill ceiling (i.e rushing), is harder to work with until you get into ace level. At ace standard, the rush is extremely effective against a scythe.
2
1
u/Alfarandals In CARV we trust. [INI] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
The first version of the coyote on live, before they changed it was really nice. I was able to kill infantry decently with a magazine and it wasn't a little overpowered as it is right now against ESF. Thats was a really nice and balanced weapon that was offering a new kind of gameplay between tomcat and Hellfire. However today new players can make something against good players thats kill them in approximatly less than 6 seconds with their nosegun.
Also i think that SOE should change Hornet to be more different than Rocketpods, because at this time, it's not really interesting to use it. I mean the TTK with hornet is low compared to rocketpods and the only interesting thing is that you can fire with your nosecanon while guiding your missiles. It's more a weapon to play a fun gameplay mechanic but not really viable.
3
u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Jun 03 '14
It truly baffles me. Everyone agreed the semiauto coyotes on Pts/at launch were in a good place, then SOE made them full auto and buffed the ROF...
2
u/SpaceIco (Connery) [EXƎ] A son of Helios Jun 03 '14
Someone mentioned hornets! Yay! I really enjoy using the hornet, or want to, but generally can't be bothered to use them because no one else does. You need to swarm for them to be effective, really, as their range is really, really short. You have to get very close to the ground and maintain sight on your target unlike fire-and-forget lolpods so even diving runs are tricky. You give up too much for too little in return. They pack a good punch so I'm not sure a flat out range increase is the answer, but I'd really, really like to see them get some attention.
1
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 03 '14
If I encounter a new player using coyotes, he lives right to the point where I emptied my magazine, the thing with coyotes is that they are so easy to use, that experienced players just (ab)use them to get easy kills. There should not be such thing as an "easy kill".
1
Jun 03 '14
i want coyotes gone,these were created for new players but are extremely expensive and is giving new infantry a lock on shot gun which only requires you to point in the general direction to lock on and kill. we already have a2a missiles which i'm more than fine with and ground missiles which i'm also fine with what is the gap that coyotes fill?
next i want to stop that ridiculous 'negative' acceleration, it is so fucking annoying and exists for no reason
1
u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14
INB4 Hornets.
They let you 1v1 an MBT that is being repaired by two maxed our repair guns. Already strong enough.
That is all.
1
u/SpaceIco (Connery) [EXƎ] A son of Helios Jun 03 '14
Hornets are a bitch to use though. You have to maintain line of sight to your target all the way to impact and they've got a short effective range. They're good for picking off a lone tank, but that's about it.
1
u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14
450m isn't that short. And completely shutting down a 450 resource vehicle manned by 2 people is pretty damn effective.
1
u/SpaceIco (Connery) [EXƎ] A son of Helios Jun 03 '14
Fair enough, though that's in completely ideal circumstances. Real-world why are they so infrequently used? Keeping the crosshairs on a tiny, probably moving target at that range is pretty dang tricky and you've got to be either mostly stationary or moving in a direct line towards your target in order to keep the crosshairs on it right up until impact. I don't have enough experience with them to really comment on expert-level usage though. Any comment from someone who's bothered to aurax the hornet?
1
u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Jun 03 '14
Hornets are fine. I'd honestly love to see them replace rocket pods wholesale, or else tweak rocket pods to a weapon with only one or two reloads' worth of reserve ammo.
1
Jun 03 '14
ESFs should be focused on A2A, so I say nerf the A2G weapons whilst buffing A2A weapons against the Lib and Gal. ESF v. ESF balance is fine imo, but I don't dogfight so I could be wrong there.
1
u/MorphingShadows WSNeo Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
One big problem (for me at least) is that the air-to-air lock-ons (Tomcats) are inconsistent to the point where I'd just rather farm ground infantry instead (making me part of the problem), sometimes you aren't able to get a lock indicator to display. I've mentioned this before and another player confirmed that he noticed this as well, I don't know how to reproduce it however. Also, before it's mentioned I know how flares and stealth timers work, that's not the case here. Nothing happens.
Let's not forget the fact that after you've fired the missile, due to the the low range for the lock-on to occur it's extremely tedious to keep a lock on an enemy because the developers added a long range missile guidance concept that was designed for long ranged A2A missiles, but they made the missiles extremely short range for god knows what reason.
A2A missiles should either be short range fire-and-forget (No maintained tracking required after launching the missile), or keep the tracking system that they have now, but increase the missile range that that particular missile guidance system was designed for. If you combined it any other way, you're going to have the two unfun concepts like the original concept that was unfun for the victims (long range fire and forget) or the current one that we have now that is unfun for the users (short range semi active homing).
This is honestly my biggest gripe. I love missiles in air combat. I've played a ton of Ace Combat growing up, while this is far from actual air combat (ESFs function more like high speed attack helicopters), I would appreciate if missiles worked to the point where they made sense from a combat perspective. Not shoehorning in a range reduction and calling it a viable weapon for the situation that it was supposed to fulfill previously.
In short, there should been either short range missiles fire and forget missiles, or long range missiles with the current semi active homing mechanic that's in right now. Combining the two with a short range missile is not fun for either end.
1
u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 03 '14
ESFs are pretty well balanced right now. Noobs don't realize that their infantry guns do a significant amount of damage to ESFs. Seriously it's like 3 or 4 clips to knock an ESF out of the sky. I am one of the hated A2G pilots and it is only rarely that infantry will try to drive me off with anything other than dedicated AA.
I play infantry and pull ground vehicles a lot as well, and I feel that a bigger part of the problem is that infantry players who come to this game don't even try to defend themselves against air. I'll watch a whole platoon push to the next base with not a single player filling the anti-air role. Of coarse you are going to get slaughtered by something you don't try to fight back against. I have driven off enemy ESFs with an SMG or comparable gun just about every play session. When an ESF takes damage, any damage, they GTFO.
1
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 04 '14
ESFs are pretty well balanced right now.
In regards to A2G they may be pretty well balanced. But A2G isn't the whole story, i.e A2A.
1
u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 04 '14
I'll admit that I don't do as much A2A as I do A2G, mostly because I am working with a squad or platoon. I run A2A when doing escorts, and while I can understand why may hate the A2A missle options I find I die to rotaries and air hammers far more often. I try to balance my resources so I'm not sitting on 750 of anything, and I will alternate Air, Sunderers, and Infantry play according to what resources are full, and what my team most needs. I don't die to coyotes all that often, but rotaries get me regularly.
I don't do any dueling, as it doesn't interest me in this game, so perhaps in 1v1 hover duels the story is different. Overall I think ESFs are pretty balanced right now, but that does come from my personal experiences, and so is only my opinion.
1
u/nelson1tom [DRED] PlanetSnide Jun 04 '14
Increase hornet range. Nerf Coyotes and make tomcats dodgeable. Maybe default flares? Essentially, finish balancing the ESF update. Also you could remove the locust nose guns and no one would notice.
1
u/aigroti Cobalt [TRID] Jun 03 '14
Engagement radar by default to help pilots.
Get rid of rocket pods but increase damage to other aircraft like galaxies and libs. (I don't actually think rocket pods are OP but players get an easier score/hour ground pounding rather than looking for other air they could be countering so they cause the issue.)
3
u/ron65774 Cobalt Jun 03 '14
Removing rocket pods would mean a SC refund, which I highly doubt will happen.
1
u/aigroti Cobalt [TRID] Jun 03 '14
It's unlikely to happen but it's something that I think would greatly help the game.
Slap them on the Valkyrie for all I care and everyone who bought them just get them moved onto that.
1
1
1
u/GrilledChickenVS [NACHO] Jun 03 '14
Nerf the Magrider.
3
0
u/slingbladez [TBSQ] Emerald SlingBlade Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
I have spent 15days in my scythe and almost 2 days in my reaver. I love flying but i think the current state of the air game is terrible for new pilots and it needs to be adjusted. I know other ace's will downvote me into oblivion because they love their massive advantages over new pilots but something needs to change.
https://www.planetside2.com/players/#!/5428010618019907969/vehicles https://www.planetside2.com/players/#!/5428139972575721585/vehicles
Decreate Rate of Fire of the Coyotes
Greatly increase reload speed of Coyotes and A2A lock ons so that they aren't used as a primary
Decrease the impact of afterburner while in hover mode so that it gives aces a distinct advantage but not an overwhelming one.
Make stealth decrease effectiveness of coyotes and also eliminate ESF engine noise
Engagement Radar as a standalone cert line as default and have stealth negate it.
I want seasoned pilots to have a big advantage and not an overwhelming one. When the game originally came out it was pretty fun because people weren't doing reverse maneuver and weren't adept at ganking yet. You actually had good fights with other pilots and new pilots actually had a chance to do something.
1
u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14
The reverse maneuveur to me, feels like the Shuffle and wave-dashing glitches present in Super Smash Bros. Melee : if you don't know how to do them, you are cooked in any competitive context. Remember the "How to play ?" tutorial present in SSBM ?
1
0
-2
u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 03 '14
ESF's are fine?
I mean there's the usual bitching about Coyotes and breaches of Sky Bushido but really they're in a good place right now.
When people hate on air it's nearly always the Liberator that's the issue, not the ESF.
4
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14
ESF's are fine?
Are they?
I mean there's the usual bitching about Coyotes
Oh... so they're not fine, dress it up how you want to make it seem not that big a deal, but the 'usual bitching' about coyotes is because they are insanely overpowered. Sure people on the ground don't care about air to air balance, but coyotes are just too strong. I can see you're arguing from the ground perspective, I'm not saying libs aren't OP against the ground, but saying that people only hate against air with regards to the lib is just kinda narrow minded. You're saying that ESFs are in a good place against ground, therefore there are no problems? No, there are a lot of problems in the air to air game.
When people hate on air it's nearly always the Liberator that's the issue, not the ESF.
With A2G, yes. A2A, no, there are problems with the ESF game.
0
u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 03 '14
While it's not a popular opinion I think the hatred of Coyotes is wildly overblown, much like some Infantry players hatred of shotguns.
If I wanted to be super unpopular I'd say that "Nosegun + Afterburners" shouldn't be the only option for air to air and it doesn't really make sense that it should be the better choice than the "Nosegun + Anti Air Rockets" Heck fighting with Coyotes is a lot more intuitive than the frankly weird way you're meant to fight with Afterburners.
Maybe when you get to high level play they become unfair and ruinous, but hey, I'm not there and frankly balancing around 1 vs 1 between the blessed few is a bit silly anyway.
3
u/Themixeur Cobalt Zemixeur/VS/NC Jun 03 '14
The thing with comparing, lets say, semi auto shotguns and coyotes is that, when you miss one or two shots with your shotgun, you're as good as dead (if the player in front of you is not bad).
With the coyotes, you hardly miss and even if the pilot against you is good , he can't kill the coyotes source before you can start another launch.
1
u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 03 '14
Doesn't it take more than one launch to kill someone though?
I know Rotary TTK's in particular are ridiculously short. You probably CAN kill someone between reloads with that, though it'd require a level of accuracy I ain't got.
Default noseguns are more comparable in TTK's to Coyotes if you include missing a fair bit, but then again default nose guns have a lot more range than Coyotes. i wouldn't want to take a lib on with Coyotes, while a Needler is ideal.
1
u/Themixeur Cobalt Zemixeur/VS/NC Jun 03 '14
Even for the best pilots, it take some time to ground someone. More than 30s in a non-gank situation in my experience. With max reload, it's enough for the coyotes to kill you. So, if you're a good dodger (like me I think), it's a pretty solid choice !
1
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 04 '14
I believe you need something around a 40% nosegun accuracy (depending on which nosegun you're using and the distance you're at) to be equal with the coyote damage. Bare in the mind that the coyote user can also use the nosegun to do extra damage in between. Bare in mind that the coyote doesn't have to worry about precise aim so they can do all sorts of unpredictable moves to make them extremely hard to hit. Bare in mind that 40% nosegun accuracy is still only an accuracy reserved for aces.
but then again default nose guns have a lot more range than Coyotes.
If a coyote user is flying towards you to close the distance then, unless they're going in a straight line, the average person still won't do enough damage in order to survive the coyotes. If They're coming towards me in unpredictable jerky motions, then I doubt I could do an effective amount of damage in that time window of a few seconds which would give me the upper hand.
0
u/VithNix Cobalt [OWND] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 04 '14
As a player that flies Exclusively with Scout Radar/PPA/Coyote. I highly disagree. If some random noob in an ESF tries to sneak up on me whilst I'm doing my thing suppressing ground forces then sure, I have a pretty good chance of surviving and winning. If anyone that actually knows how to fly/dogfight relatively well comes at me with a nosegun though, I'll put up a fight sure. But PPA/Coyote is defiantly not going to save me.
That being said. I can understand the irritation and frustration, having come up against more than a few BR90+ with both nose-guns & Coyotes. It's annoying, but I can't really hold it against them. To them it's probably just another Auraxium in progress.
Overall however, I don't mind them and I feel that Coyotes are a good weapon for mixing things up, as well as helping less-able pilots learn to fly & dogfight independently from learning how to aim. Lets them focus on learning & improving one thing at a time, whilst giving them a chance to survive.
2
u/Themixeur Cobalt Zemixeur/VS/NC Jun 03 '14
For me, being good in air come down to three things : situationnal awareness, knowing how to dodge and being precise.
I'm not bad in situationnal awareness. And I'm not bad in precision either. But what I'm the better at, is being able to dodge. In a 2v2 or 3v3 I'm always the last one flying thanks to that. But in a regular 1v1, I can't compete with the more than average pilots in precision. Ulitmately, it take them sometime but they take me down. And when I say sometime, it's generally enough time for me to put enough, say, of my coyotes max reload (wich I already flied with thanks to friends) into them to take them down.
If I use coyote, I can take my banshee and be ridiculously good in A2A because of my greater ability to dodge. I still haven't found myself buying them, but sooner or later I will and I'll be ten times more efficient then know just because of that.
3
Jun 03 '14
coyotes are a ñlock on shot gun that you point in the general direction to locj¡k on and have almost no counters apart from flares
2
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 03 '14
Shotguns are not even nearly as OP as Coyotes, not even before all those nerfs. Except in some small rooms, you can use the terrain and some awareness to avoid getting within 10m of that shotgun user and easily kill him, you can't keep your distance from a Coyote Reaver charging at you at 400kph. It's a poor comparison.
If I wanted to be super unpopular I'd say that "Nosegun + Afterburners" shouldn't be the only option for air to air
It's not that we have some weird boner for the nosegun+AB combo, it's that it's the only skill based loadout, the rest are just crutches. I was looking forward to dogfighting with Mass Drivers, even if they were too hard to use and would get me killed more often than AB it sounded like a fun alternative, but they scrapped those so AB tanks remain as the only fun A2A secondary.
1
u/Fimconte Jun 03 '14
I wonder, which would be the most used ESF if they were made available for all empires for a few weeks...
;D
2
u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 03 '14
Probably the Reaver. Airhammer is pretty nice and it's just a good solid ESF and certainly the easiest to fly.
1
u/concussedYmir Jun 03 '14
I will always have a soft spot for the scythe and its generous hovering
1
u/VithNix Cobalt [OWND] Jun 03 '14
I'll always love my Scythe but if I had the chance to fly my very own VS Mozzie, I'd be all over that shit.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 03 '14
I actually think ESFs are in a decent condition with maybe the Mossy rotary needing a slight buff. My main complaint is the tank that is the Liberator.
0
u/sushi_cw Connery Jun 03 '14
TBH things are in a pretty good state for ESFs and there are much bigger issues with the game to take care of (e.g. resource system please!). But here are some things that would be nice:
Add a cockpit indicator for thruster position. This will make it easier for people to learn the tricks of flying, without really impacting high-level play.
Slightly increase reload time for Coyotes.
Make A2AMs dodgeable somehow.
Give M18 Rotary 3-5 more bullets.
0
-1
-1
u/mikethedevourer Jun 03 '14
Am I the only one who thinks Coyotes are just not that good? They can hit their target from a close-mid range if you predict and lead your shots with them, but they deal very little DPS and you sacrifice so much damage instead of just using your primary nose gun. They don't really scratch Libs and it's not even worth shooting at Gals, or much of anything on the ground besides perhaps some non-skyguard lightnings. The only purpose they serve is to open up or close a gank whenever you're hitting another ESF with your nose gun.
1
u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt Jun 04 '14
If you have trouble hitting with coyotes, then I doubt you'd be able to hit at all with your nosegun. They deal very high DPS, equivalent to around 40% nosegun accuracy.
1
u/mikethedevourer Jun 08 '14
The rocket velocity is very slow compared to the nose cannon, so hitting your nose shots is easier from mid range compared to the close range of the coyote.
0
Jun 03 '14
[deleted]
2
u/Themixeur Cobalt Zemixeur/VS/NC Jun 03 '14
I agree with some of your saying but one thing bothers me still :
esf now take longer to switch between flight and hover mode
The esf already take a HUGE time to switch between those modes. Its really, really bothering when I end up piloting (I mostly play infantry) and forbid me for getting better as a pilot.
12
u/Qqboxing MmMmYesss/NewAtFlyingmyTR Jun 03 '14
If they could make A2A lock ons dodgeable that would be nice. Other then that I don't have any real complaints