r/Planetside • • Jun 03 '14

Why is the Skyguard so terrible?

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

14

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14

The Skyguard shreds ESFs to pieces, when flying i enjoy hunting them with Hornets every once in a while but more often then not i'm always a small positioning mistake away from getting blown to pieces.
It's libs that have a loltastic time stomping them, because they can easily outdps a skyguard and tank its damage even without getting the jump on it. Heck, i can hunt down solo skyguards in my liberator without even using a gunner, just charge them, tankbust, switch to dalton, hit them. gg no re every time unless there's overwhelming AA.

I'd love to have an accurate slow-firing (like slightly slower than a Basilisk, not like a Titan) secondary mode that deals a fuckton of damage to aircrafts but doesn't burst like the normal flak mode, making it best for dealing with stuff that gets close to you but worse for fast-moving aircrafts and for anything that stays at a distance.
Get too close and slow to a skyguard and you'll get gibbed in 4 seconds, move fast and at 300 or so meters and you can be relatively safe unless you're facing the best gunner who ever existed.

Heck, for all i care it could replace the default mode altogether, less flak hitting ESFs flying 800 meters away would be welcome.

5

u/goodeone [UKIP] (Ceres) Jun 03 '14

Skyguards vs esfs are in a good place. Realistically speaking the changes that libs require are; lower resistance to flak (I'm not sure on percentages but it's too high), increase the sound of the engine a shite ton and change dumbfire resistances to - 2 decis = kill and 2 default = set on fire, the addition of flak armour should not make you more tanky to daltons and tank rounds as well.

These are reasonable changes that I think will go a long way.

3

u/Fergyrobots [PREY]Augr@Waterson Jun 03 '14

Composite armor*

There needs to be both a flak and composite armor, you shouldn't get the best of both worlds in one package. The galaxy could stand to recieve the same change and get granted an additional armor(flak, composite).

2

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14

Yes, on these changes i agree completely.
Libs can keep a good distance from tank barrels and dumbfire rockets while still being able to deal huge damage, they should be punished harshly if they allow those things to hit them.

0

u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver Jun 03 '14

Just an idea, but instead of changing Libs v flak (it's a very fine line at the moment..);

Nerf AA against ESFs, Buff ESFs against Libs.

1

u/goodeone [UKIP] (Ceres) Jun 03 '14

I'd agree to that change if you only buffed the dedicated AA noseguns against libs, to give pilots a reason to actually use the AA noseguns over the default noseguns. The buff however would be kinda hard to do and would have to be done on a gun by gun basis rather than a broad sweep

-2

u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14

There is no such thing as AA noseguns. The default ones are just made for longer ranges and the rotaries for closer ranges.

4

u/mkabla Miller [WASP] JesNC Jun 03 '14

Stop shooting at passing aircraft at render range.

Take cover. Pick your targets. Ambush them, if possible. AAA is no point & click adventure.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Because libs can sneak up on them

1

u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jun 03 '14

because libs are god, and a dedicated AA platform should be easily taken out by 2-3 lolpodders /s

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Facepalms