r/Planetside • • Jun 03 '14

I hate liberators for what they do to tank gameplay

tonight I was having a total blast bouncing around howling pass in my racer, stealth, ap, 1/2 prowler. I was stomping lightnings and popping harrassers left and right which is great, but then 2 guys I popped in a harrasser came out with vanguards. each of them were 2/2 and they came out and rekt me.

they were both br 30-40ish and I was stoked!!! north of howling pass, the area between snake ravine and peris, and the space all around indar ex are the best tanking spots in the entire game and good tank battles at any of these places are my numero uno favourite thing to do!

so I grab another prowler and I go vanguard hunting!!

nope. I get back there and 2 friendly TR libs are tanking burster and skyguard fire and killing every tank around the base. all friendly TR prowlers proceed to move up to the base and greedily try to fire into the base to support the infantry push.

liberators ruined that fight. liberators ruin every fight. they kill the skyguards and then they kill all the vehicles and then they camp the base.

I don't think they need to have all their damage capabilities nerfed. what they need is to be more killable, they need the tank buster to put a full health tank to 5% health FROM THE BACK OR TOP ARMOUR, and they need a huge loud obvious sound that everyone can hear from far away.

they need to fear skyguards and bursters. it should take 3 skyguard clips to kill a stock lib. it should take 4 no miss clips of burster fire.

they ruin small fights, they ruin tank fights, they ruin the fun of their allies and their enemies.

they suck, they are not fun for anyone but their crews.

fuck them in their stupid asses forever.

-I love my prowler.

edit: wow I've struck quite the nerve. I expected to wake up to a mountain of downvotes. let me be clear, I run libs sometimes and I don't want them being bad. I want them to be a part of the game and to work beside the other aspects of the game instead of just dominating it.

I'd say that if we are to ask for any changes let us propose 3 and let others pick 2.

1)bring tank busters total clip damage down to the point that it puts about 4 seconds of on fire life left in a tank from either the rear or top armour.

2)create a loud engine noise that is audible from at least the distance that you can hear galaxies

3)buff skyguard and burster overall clip damage. since ESFs don't deserve any extra on them I'd say you'd have to lower bullet velocity on both weapons so its harder to hit esfs with them but libs would still get the extra on them.

132 Upvotes

566 comments sorted by

32

u/avenger2142 HVAvenger Jun 03 '14

Two decis should kill a lib. Changing that was one of the stupidest things.

Really though, libs were meant to be anti-tank. That was their intended role really. 2 skyguards can clear the area of libs really fast.

18

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14

2 libs can clear the ground of everything really fast, in fact they can face tank a skyguard, get close and kill it.

7

u/Semajal Aeleva [ABTF] Miller Jun 03 '14

Ish, once you are being flakked you can't actually see ANYTHING. You have to nail the tankbuster clip and then a dalton, or a tankbuster clip in the rear then dalton. It isn't exactly easy to do.

14

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14

I understand that, but the point in trying to make is that libs are so strong they can pretty much stomp on their counters.

I don't see tanks taking two clips of tank buster shells turning around and instant gibb liberators. Liberators can do that to skyguards.

13

u/Da-Tou [ABTF] Shintyx Jun 03 '14

They can only stomp on them if they manage to sneak up really close, at a considerable risk. Every other time the Skyguard will successfully deter them from miles away.

It's the same with a Lightning killing an MBT. If the Lightning snuck up on it, it can kill the MBT, otherwise it's suicide. Doesn't mean the Lightning is OP. It also doesn't mean the MBT needs an inherent Lightning detection radar.

4

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14

I have shadow play footage of lib coming right onto me as I was shooting him from the distance, he just tank busted and daltoned, once I find out how to edit it I'll upload it to YouTube, it's 1.4gb.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

you just go away, repair then sneak in and gank the skyguards who never saw you come back.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rowleybirkin Jun 03 '14

Thank you. To read this thread you'd think every Lib pilot out there was doing this, when in reality the dive attack is pretty much restricted to career pilots.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Do you know how many clips of a skyguard it takes to down a lib?

→ More replies (10)

18

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14

2 skyguards can clear the area of libs really fast.

Until one of them comes back and tankbusts one skyguard at a time; been there, done that.

3

u/Tidher Mordent (Emerald) Jun 03 '14

Omnomnom.

4

u/Jmars04 [BRTD] MarseeeTR Jun 03 '14

2 skygaurds sitting in the same position are crap skygaurds. They need to be constantly moving so this does not happen/make it hard for the libs to re-aim.

5

u/ccfreak2k Jun 03 '14

By its nature we can't be constantly moving because it's virtually impossible to hit anything while moving in a Lightning.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sianmink [GOTR] MechazawaVS (Emerald) Jun 03 '14

If the lib comes back and finds the skyguard right where he was before that's called NOOB SKYGUARDING and he is bad and deserves to die.

As a skyguard you should never fire more than 2 clips before changing position.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Autoxidation [TIW] Jun 03 '14

2 dumbfires from the base launcher should kill a Lib too. I don't see why just Decis should get that ability. Restricting the 2 dumbfire limit to just the 1000 cert rocket launcher is a poor move.

9

u/Jmars04 [BRTD] MarseeeTR Jun 03 '14

I'm mainly a lib pilot and I 100% agree with you. I used to be scared of getting dumb fired but not so much any more.

1

u/AMatthersonPlayer Jun 03 '14

Because velocity is a thing.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Twisted_Karma Jun 03 '14

Libs were meant to be anti-tank, but skyguards are meant to be anti-air. Either make skyguards anti-air, or make libs a tank deterrent.

1

u/rowleybirkin Jun 03 '14

Don't two Deci's now put a Lib into burning? If so, that's as good as dead when you're in the air, so I really don't see it as that big a deal.

1

u/avenger2142 HVAvenger Jun 03 '14

Not it isn't. Not with fire suppression. And not with good libcrews who know how to bail and rep fast.

13

u/redsquizza [OC] Squizz (Miller) Jun 03 '14

and they need a huge loud obvious sound that everyone can hear from far away.

This is what I find really obnoxious about liberators. Yes swooping in low and sniping tanks is a risk / reward move but because the liberators are the ninjas of the skies with barely any sound until it's too late a lot of the risk is removed. Even more of the risk is removed these days as well because of the buff to durability liberators received.

Good luck reacting to a dead team mate tank with 3/4 whole flak clips before the ninja liberator disappears behind some terrain to hunt its next victim.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Yeah the engine noise kills the whole risk/reward argument.

3

u/gurgle528 [Lux0] Emerald - RIP SolTech Jun 03 '14

I remember when they were literally the ninjas of the sky when they could cloak due to a glitch

65

u/fiah84 Miller VS [MAP] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Liberators just need to be louder for a start. It's ridiculous that they're quieter than a harasser or flash.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I can hear infiltrators 200m away that are louder than Libs 50m away. This makes no sense...

10

u/TheLazySamurai4 [TxOH][WENI][SPTY] EMPs are better flashbangs, change my mind. Jun 03 '14

I can hear sensors and beacons being destroyed from 200m away, but not Libs at 75m -.-

8

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I can hear Higby's hair rustle 150m away, but not Libs at 50m.

3

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

I would actually say that is really only one of the problems with Libs. They are far from OP as many infantry masterrace ( and tank) people would claim. Just make liberators give off a shit ton of sound and you are good to go. Is anybody here even aware of why the hell they were buffed in the first place?? It's because skyguards were shredding them before they could even land off 3 shots. Liberators need to be more vulnerable to ESFs. That it, period. Liberators were free cert piñatas before this and now the are actually useful, but now everyone is bitching about them and how "OP" they are. Tank buster is fine, dalton is fine, flak armor should protect less against tank shots, and ESFs need a buff against Libs, that's really it.

3

u/fiah84 Miller VS [MAP] Jun 03 '14

I guess ESFs could use a slight buff against Libs (and I say this as an ESF pilot), but like you said, they used to be cert piñatas before this and I really don't want to go back to that. Hunting Liberators is pretty fun nowadays, if frustrating because you often can't finish them off.

2

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 03 '14

Exactly, all the ground plebs ( I'm one too, just look at my stats) seem to forget that liberators used to suck ass. Now they are finally useful, everybody hates this.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

I don't hate them being useful. I hate that they went from useless to game breaking.

I actually agreed with all the tank nerfs vs libs. skygaurds and flak deserve the job but right now they just can't do the job.

here's the thing. liberators, more than any other thing in the game MAGNIFIES pop imbalances. tanks can get you to the front door but not on point for the most part.

and I don't want to see anti liberator shields over bases as the only way to balance them.

a lone tank in a field can be overcome by a couple of guys with lock ons and a medic. a lib can tank all their shots wipe them, then land on their corpses for repairs.

libs last too damn long and survive too much concentrated fire.

I run stealth on my tank because I usually die when a few people decide they've had enough of me. not so with libs...

the changes I've proposed would make it so the natural enemies of libs would be able to do more than just deter them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Gwunt Jun 03 '14

This is such a great point, I love the ESF noises

→ More replies (3)

9

u/slingbladez [TBSQ] Emerald SlingBlade Jun 03 '14

That is my biggest beef with liberators right now. My other two are the rate of fire of the tankbuster and the speed/maneuverability of the liberator is ridiculous. It allows it to dive into a group of AA kill a skyguard and make it out. The ttk of tankbuster/dalton combo is obscenely low.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Agreed OP. A lot of the time it is either they're killing my tanks or they're slaughtering all the enemy tanks...

I've been playing long enough to know the people I'm fighting and often times our fights are shut down entirely by aircraft on either side. Not fun. Well, the air is having a blast.

Real tanking in this game involves fighting other tanks. Actually finding those fights is difficult, and everything else in the game is working to kill you at all times. You finally find those good fights aaaaaaand aircraft.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I has a sad.

1

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14

1

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14

You finally find those good fights aaaaaaand aircraft.

And trees too.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/DVSKevinNash Waterson Jun 03 '14

I hate tanks for what they do to infantry gameplay

16

u/Autoxidation [TIW] Jun 03 '14

I think infantry have a lot of counters to deal with tanks. Dumbfires, lockons, C4 on every class but Infiltrator, AV weapons on MAXes, AV mana turret, AV turrets at bases, and tank mines, some of which kill a tank instantly.

Infantry to do not have this number of counters to air.

28

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Killing tanks is fun and is something that almost every infantry unit has the capacity to do.

Also, considering the fact that Amerish and Esamir have been designed specifically to keep tanks out of infantry fights, and since most fights on Indar happen to be at bases where vehicles have a really hard time farming infantry.... What fights are tanks ruining?

Keep in mind, Tanks != zerg. If your fight is being ruined by 4x your numbers and there happen to be tanks, it isn't the fault of tanks. It is because you're getting attacked by 4x your numbers in the first place... In such a case you ought to be happy there's 50 tanks sitting outside your base doing nothing rather than 50 infantry surrounding your spawn room.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Hence why I run ap and HUNT VANGUARDS.

20

u/AngerMacFadden Jun 03 '14

Luckily heroic liberator crews work 'round the clock against this scourge.

12

u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver Jun 03 '14

Almost like this is a combined arms game, crazy I know.

4

u/AngerMacFadden Jun 03 '14

It is the combined part that gets lost in qq translations....Please devs the mission system needs you.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Arquinas VS Jun 03 '14

I hate infantry gameplay for what they do to strategy

6

u/Da-Tou [ABTF] Shintyx Jun 03 '14

I hate strategic gameplay for what it does to zerging.

9

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14

I hate the game, but there isn't a decent alternative.

NEXT DISCUSSION THREAD AHEAD !

6

u/alexm42 Mattherson Master Race Jun 03 '14

I don't hate infantry game play. It's rewarding and fun.

I do hate infantry-only players who go on the forums and rage against vehicles, with the end-goal of making pulling vehicles actually detrimental to your team's success instead of helpful. This game is a combined arms game, and actually does that quite well. But all the 1337 CoD players who refuse to enter vehicles don't understand that.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

To me they're mostly cert piñatas. Get 2x c4 on LA and rake in the certs man. Either that or have a squad drop as HA's behind a tank column and enjoy the fireworks. Or set up an AV nest outside the base with turrets and lock-ons. There's tons of fun ways to destroy tanks as infantry currently. Liberators, not so much.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I dont use my tank anymore but rather play infantry lately. It surely is a choice of personal preference, but the tank aspect spices things up. If you are not overroled by a zerg of course. Thats not fun.

Tanks are enemies where even your average infantry player stands a chance against. You can kill them even in small fights. This isn't the case for liberators. They only can be deterred, repair themselfes, come back and end the fight. THATs not fun. ESF have a similar problem to some extend, but it feels fairer against them.

2

u/MelonHeadSeb http://i.imgur.com/j4I1drJ.png Jun 03 '14

Stupid spawn camping Prowlers...

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

then Remove HE rounds from the game.

Then tanks will be more focused on Armored targets as there primary targets.

The fact that HE rounds even exist in this game is bad design.

8

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14

PPA is love, PPA is life; praise Vanu.

12

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14

PPA is fine. The Magrider sacrificing its secondary for AI? Say hello to my Vanguard.

8

u/Arquinas VS Jun 03 '14

Magburns away

10

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

You might have to expose your rear for that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/KlyptoK [TIW] Klypto Jun 03 '14

Nobody uses HE

2

u/feench Nobody expects the Auraxis ECUSition Jun 03 '14

I pulled HE once by accident. I died pretty quickly...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

You're right, we should remove HE and leave all the ways for infantry to kill tanks, that'll be totally balanced and fun for everyone.

How about no.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/eliteeskimo [ECUS] Jun 03 '14

Liberators need to have their resistance to Tank shells reduced back to normal. It shouldn't take 9 HEAT shells to down a composite Liberator and a Liberator shouldn't be want to face rush a Lockdown AP/HEAT Prowler. Currently Liberators are allowed to race rush MBT's and get away with it, or hover spam bases and take a few tank shells before finally being forced to run away to repair.

Liberators are OP right now, and the fact that he Skyguard acts as little more as a minor deterrence rather than an actual hard counter is pathetic.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Id settle for a buff to skyguard damage, an engine noise and no more 1 clipping with tank buster.

1

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 03 '14

Ya I hate how people say skyguards are still effective, the only thing they're effective at is scaring libs away after they fire a few salvos; a liberator who flys in low getting lit up by skyguard, dumfire rockets, and tank shells should not get away... they just speed over a hill repair, then repeat process again; it takes three skyguards with concentrated fire to kill a lib before it can turn around an retreat behind a hill, it shouldn't be that difficult.

9

u/badacki Waterson Jun 03 '14

Lol, I read this just as I exited the game after having my magrider blown up in literally 2 seconds by a tankbuster and a dalton hit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Feel you brother.

7

u/PerplexingPorkchops Connery 4 lyfe Jun 03 '14

Yeah that's been getting a little broken. I'm pretty sure a liberator now out DPSes anything but a vanguard or prowler at point blank. And, even worse, nothing can really stop them from taking a rear armour position. I can't kill it fast enough with my main gun. It's like having a flying tank on the battle field at this point.

6

u/alexm42 Mattherson Master Race Jun 03 '14

Liberator actually out-DPSes both. A Tankbuster/Dalton combo can kill my Vanguard in 2 seconds from the top or sides, an AP/Vulcan Prowler (Highest possible DPS from any tank) can only do that to my rear.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

The Lib out-DPSes everything at point-blank. A Composite Lib can hover in front of an MBT and face-tank it while Tankbusting it to death.

3

u/LEOtheCOOL Jun 03 '14

They should figure out how to put tank treads on the liberator.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/lowrads Jun 03 '14

Skyguards are kinda bad at everything.

7

u/Sam474 Jun 03 '14

Skyguards are AWESOME at killing Harassers!

1

u/backwardsforwards MX Jun 03 '14

TIL, thanks!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

no really... its what they're best at.

33

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ Jun 03 '14

Quoting myself from another post:

The Skyguard shreds ESFs to pieces, when flying i enjoy hunting them with Hornets every once in a while but more often then not i'm always a small positioning mistake away from getting blown to pieces.
It's libs that have a loltastic time stomping them, because they can easily outdps a skyguard and tank its damage even without getting the jump on it. Heck, i can hunt down solo skyguards in my liberator without even using a gunner, just charge them, tankbust, switch to dalton, hit them. gg no re every time unless there's overwhelming AA.

I'd love to have an accurate slow-firing (like slightly slower than a Basilisk, not like a Titan) secondary mode that deals a fuckton of damage to aircrafts but doesn't burst like the normal flak mode, making it best for dealing with stuff that gets close to you but worse for fast-moving aircrafts and for anything that stays at a distance.

Get too close and slow to a skyguard and you'll get gibbed in 4 seconds, move fast and at 300 or so meters and you can be relatively safe unless you're facing the best gunner who ever existed.
Heck, for all i care it could replace the default mode altogether, less flak hitting ESFs flying 800 meters away would be welcome.

29

u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jun 03 '14

I'd love to see the Skyguards automatically come with air-search radar. Seriously, the fact that we don't have this is silly, especially considering the fact that Liberators don't make any noise and constantly sneak up on tanks for Tank Buster + Shredder gankage.

I'd also like to see some sort of larger caliber round like the German 88mm anti-aircraft guns of WWII. The rounds would travel slower than 40mm Skyguard rounds and gun traverse would be considerably slower. Essentially this 88mm flak cannon would be better at killing Liberators and Galaxies but hitting smaller/faster ESFs would be more difficult.

9

u/EfPeEs Emerald Jun 03 '14

Both are great ideas. I've been thinking about what large caliber AAA would look like in Planetside for a while also.

6

u/YetAnotherRCG [S3X1]TheDestroyerOfHats Jun 03 '14

I think that would be the best way forward.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/alexm42 Mattherson Master Race Jun 03 '14

I'd like to see the base AA turrets come with air engagement radar.

3

u/shawnaroo Jun 03 '14

I think the larger caliber round idea is great, they just have to make sure that it's not too good against ground targets (like what happened with the German 88). While that'd obviously be great for whoever is driving it, I'm not sure it's best for game balance.

2

u/Emperorpenguin5 Reavers On Ice Jun 03 '14

Air radar no, more noise yes, However guys MOST of the sound coming from a liberator is bass, turn your bass way up on your turtle beaches...

You can have that flak cannon ONLY if it has a much smaller burst radius or requires direct hits, and travels at half the speed of the current skyguard. Also it would be sold as a new weapon EVERYONE would buy so Win win for SOE...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

11

u/redsquizza [OC] Squizz (Miller) Jun 03 '14

They unfortunately seem to lag behind the latest changes. I bought the Skyguard on launch based on the beta weapon. It was a mistake as they nerfed the Skyguard and left it in a bad state for a while. Eventually they got round to buffing it to a point where it was useful.

With the liberator update they've buffed them and again the Skyguard is now lagging behind where it should be effectiveness wise.

2

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 03 '14

I did the same thing, I loved the Beta Skyguard and how if you where a good aim with it you could hit aircraft from pretty far with it, I purchased it when game launched and was pissed as fuck it was nothing like beta; now it's horribly inaccurate at aircraft at range and is a death sentence against any other armored vehicle, Libs hunt down skyguards like they're 3 legged babies as well.

3

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] Jun 03 '14

Aside from changes to levels 1-3 of composite nothing was changed vs flak.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

If the recoil wasn't so ridiculous on them they might be a bit better. Also I don't understand how giant flak from the cannon can barely kill infantry at point blank range.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I honestly haven't had any problems with it. I know I'm one of many, but it isn't bad. Just my opinion.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 03 '14

The recoil isn't bad, the spread is fucking atrocious though.

6

u/KantaiWarrior Jun 03 '14

The fact that vehicles like this has recoil is silly. It defeats the idea of the tank, but saying this if they didn't have recoil they would be pretty OP if you could have prefect aim, unless they could nerf it in some other way.

10

u/badacki Waterson Jun 03 '14

Really though, skyguards suck really bad they need a buff for sure. Not even worth the 1000 certs...

29

u/Jade_Cros Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

One Skyguard is not too bad at deterring ESFs, but the problem is that once that air is deterred or destroyed the vehicle becomes worthless. I think they really need to implement a way for vehicles to refit weapons like MAX Units can.

4

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 03 '14

Skyguards hurt sundies. I like to use them to peck at vehicles while other tanks roll around and flank them

6

u/Jyk7 This is a flair Jun 03 '14

If my Sunderer has two gunners for the Basilisks, we can chase down and murder Skyguards. We can even take Magriders, especially when they've got their HE equipped.

4

u/Sianmink [GOTR] MechazawaVS (Emerald) Jun 03 '14

Yup skyguard will lose hard vs 2-basi sundie if you get within range.

10

u/enenra [BRIT] / [LAZR] / [CHEQ] Jun 03 '14

To be fair, 2 basilisk sundie wins against most things one on one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

1

u/pilotdude22 [AFX] Connery BR100 Jun 04 '14

They sure were worth the 1 SC from the winter sale.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

[deleted]

2

u/FischiPiSti Get rid of hard spawns or give attackers hard spawns too Jun 03 '14

Absolutely not, that was how the game started out, AA were point and click adventure games farming air all day from 2 bases away. The velocity nerf made them effective only at close range while requiring skill to be effective at long range.
The problem is that from 0m to 100m skyguards have the same effectiveness, while the tankbuster is most effective at close ranges. There is currently no risk of libs engaging them head on. If max damage would be increased, but dropoff would start earlier, the range at which tankbuster+shredder libs are most effective would be off limits, while having the same effect as a deterrent at medium+ ranges

4

u/Da-Tou [ABTF] Shintyx Jun 03 '14

Would make their range even more ridiculous. Invisi-Flak is already a problem. Plus, they're so far behind enemy lines that they're not possible to destroy until the base is already camped.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

[deleted]

4

u/alexm42 Mattherson Master Race Jun 03 '14

More damage at close range for all targets, and more damage at all ranges to Liberators. IMO this would be the best solution, both to the Skyguard sucking, and to the Liberator being the fun police's vehicle of choice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/stormdraggy Waterson Jun 03 '14

libs need a serious resistance nerf to AA fire. Everything else should do normal damage, but really if the accuracy of the Dalton and tankbuster power is going to stay then libs should really be helpless without ground forces targeting AA fire in support. 1 to 1, skyguards should have no trouble whatsoever defeating libs, that's their dedicated job after all.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Agreed.

10

u/Sandzibar Miller Jun 03 '14

Nerf their mobility and speed. One of the largest issues is how easy it is for them to escape death after over-committing. They dont suffer from bad positioning enough, not with the amount of firepower and control they can bring to bear.

I have also suggested that if they roll upside down then their wings fall off! - but that was mainly just to annoy Miller Lib pilots like Justicia and Seb. :)

10

u/Da-Tou [ABTF] Shintyx Jun 03 '14

Problem is, with all the invisible flak around it's often times impossible to know whether you are over committing until it's already to late.

Additionally, hit and run attacks are all that's possible to do in big battles. Take that away and scores of Libs will camp 12vs12 battles. Trying anything else already is frustrating enough but would become impossible.

2

u/Sandzibar Miller Jun 03 '14

I guess. Its almost impossible to make stuff viable in big fights, that doesnt absolutely crush and ruin the smaller ones.

Every time i see 4 TR libs over a base I go elsewhere now. I spend half my life redeploying.

2

u/noyoukeepthisshit Jun 03 '14

I dont get it this is not an issue on mattherson.

We just pull AA launchers and kill em.

1

u/Tidher Mordent (Emerald) Jun 03 '14
  • 1 to 1, HAs with G2G launchers should have no trouble whatsoever defeating Harassers. That's their dedicated job after all.

  • 1 to 1, AP Lightnings should have no trouble whatsoever defeating 2/2 HEAT/Basilisk MBTs. That's their dedicated job after all.

  • 1 to 1, A2A ESFs should have no trouble whatsoever defeating Shredder Liberators. That's their dedicated job after all.

IMO, none of the above is true. Yes, they'll have an easier time of it, and may even have a distinct advantage, but it should be far from a case of "no trouble whatsoever".

In the above Lightning/MBT scenario, the Lightning is a dedicated anti-tanker, while the MBT is relatively versatile but definitely not specialised. IMO, this is the equivalent of a Skyguard against a Shredder Liberator.

If the Skyguard/Lightning isn't careful, the Liberator/MBT will use its generally quite nasty firepower and tankiness to win.

Yes, you have a dedicated role. That does not grant you the ability to sit in one spot and assume everyone else is an idiot and won't sneak up on you.

-3

u/Semajal Aeleva [ABTF] Miller Jun 03 '14

A single man lightning should not be able to solo defeat a 3 man liberator.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

well look at it this way:

Liberators have incredible mobility, survivability, and effectiveness against ALL targets (infantry, tanks, MAXs, even fucking anti air.)

A Skyguard lightning is good against: air... kinda, sometimes. Still gets "rekt" by sneaky liberators.

The Skyguard lightning tank has a severely painfully specific niche of effectiveness whereas the liberator is effective against all targets. See the problem here?

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Autoxidation [TIW] Jun 03 '14

A single man Lightning should not be able to solo defeat a 3 man Harasser.

See how dumb that sounds? The Skyguard's only role is to shoot air. 1 Skyguard should counter 1 Lib. If they have more Skyguards, bring more Libs or ESFs.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

At the very least 2 skyguards should counter a lib. Right now the lib kills one and flys away.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Bananenweizen Jun 03 '14

And a 3 man Liberator should not be able to solo defeat a 5 man Galaxy and have an even chance against 3 man Sunderer. Uh-uh?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

41

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I hate liberators for murdering me from 20m away with no audible warning.

22

u/Da-Tou [ABTF] Shintyx Jun 03 '14

That I can agree with. Louder Libs!

9

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I'd love for them to be redesigned with more vertically-aligned jets at all speeds.

Then we'd have a good reason to make them roar when they're close.

6

u/finder787 🧂 [RMAR] Jun 03 '14

Well, you can at least hear the Tankbuster and Dalton firing at you...

assuming they suck at aiming...

8

u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 03 '14

What's that noi.. Oh. Is what normally happens.

3

u/Frozen-K Jun 03 '14

You don't even get the time to process that thought. You're just toast.

4

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14

It's not the liberator the problem, is the G2A defense, skyguards take years to kill a lib, Lock-ons can be avoided by diving into the ground and making the rocket crash, yet they are really good vs ESFs.

So buff Flak damage range at close distance, make the lib take just a bit more damage from flak, and for the love of Vanu, give new recruits effective G2A options; one buster is not good enough vs a lib, most of the time the belly gunner just drops death onto the newbie using the max in seconds (dat shredder be op).

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Yup skyguards need a huge buff.

5

u/john55223 Jun 03 '14

Libs are the problem. The current AA is really effective against ESF's, and buffing it would make ESF's unplayable.

3

u/Sianmink [GOTR] MechazawaVS (Emerald) Jun 03 '14

So just lower lib resistance to flak, tank shells and dumbfires. Done.

3

u/ArmadaVega Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

The Tank buster can actually kill a Vanguard in 1.8 seconds. And kill a Sunderer in around 3 seconds if combined with 1 Dalton shot.

It would take 6 NC Max's worth of resources to kill a tank that fast using 2x Falcons. That means a Liberator with a tank buster has the equivalent fire power of 2100 Infantry resources worth of maxes. For only the price of 350 Air resources.

On top of that, The Tank Buster's abilities don't require additional team mates, you can Pilot the Lib by yourself.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Yup fucking op lib is op

2

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14

For only the price of 315 Air resources.

And 100 certs to buy an uncerted Tank Buster.

1

u/ArmadaVega Jun 03 '14

1000 certs are required to unlock the second falcon, other wise it would take 12 maxes using 1 falcon each to kill the tank

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

[deleted]

7

u/Autoxidation [TIW] Jun 03 '14

And nothing can kill a Lib that easily!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

[deleted]

10

u/Autoxidation [TIW] Jun 03 '14

When the only counter to something is itself, it's OP.

→ More replies (30)

1

u/ArmadaVega Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

I would argue that C4 being 200 resources is quite high for only being an item and not a vehicle or max. It is the most expensive infantry item relative to its damage output. Where as, Libs are the most powerful vehicle but are not the most expensive.

Pulling a Vanguard will cost me 450 resources. There is only a max of 750 resources for Mech. You can only spawn 1 tank per resource dump. so if you lose Your tank too quickly, just once, you are locked out until the next resource dump.

A Liberator costs 315 resources, is more powerful then all aircraft, all ground vehicles, Maxes and all infantry. It would be more appropriate for a liberator to cost 450 resources.

Either a resource cost change or a Tank Buster nerf/remove.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/if-loop Vanguard/Reaver (Cobalt) Jun 03 '14

They shouldn't have changed the number of tank shells and dumbfires required to destroy a Lib. That was just stupid and unnecessary.

21

u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) Jun 03 '14

Warning: Long Post Incoming.

JK: It's 5 in the morning and I have to go to work in 2 hours.

1: Tankbuster: It's called a TANKbuster. It should wreck armor. The problem with it right now is how much extra power magazine size upgrage gives you. They balance the killing power around a stock magazine size then you add almost 50% more at max rank. Raise default mag size to 35(ish) and raise the number of rear shots to kill a MBT from maximum damage to the same. This will require more precision on the part of the Librerator to one clip MBT's. Won't really change hovering over and bombing but let's be honest, nothing will change that.

2: Resistances Resistance to tank rounds should probably go back to what it was. Comp armor should let you survive 1 extra round at maximum rank.

3: Flak Up close Skyguards(flak in general) needs more DPS on Liberators. At range they need less ability to be annoying as piss. Flak needs to not drop my framerate from 100+ to below 30 when I'm looking at it.

4: Auto-turrets Most bases should have auto-turrets as AA. Fairly low DPS but tanky enough to take a lot of work to kill. Essentially they will defend against 1 ESF or 1 Liberator just getting free kills by hover farming. However, they're easily taken out by ground targets so removing them will be a viable tactic on the part of the attackers to allow air to support and defending them will be good for the defenders.

And finally, I don't really even engage ground targets with my Liberator much unless they're in the way(or shooting at me) or I really feel like pulling out the Zepher to get my Farmville on. It's not much fun. It's very linear. Either I wreck shop and kill everything or I run into a flak nest and die or have to run instantly. That's why I spend most of my time fighting aircraft :D.

Edit: 5: Sound They should have a more audible sound. I want people to hear their death approaching and feel the cold chill down their spine as they realize it's too late to escape. Being silent and deadly is fun. But I think it would be more fun to see everyone run for cover when they hear me approaching. Yes... run... hide in your buildings and your spawnrooms. You'll have to come out eventually... and when you do... I'll be waiting.

Sorry... what were we talking about again?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Considering that we just got an "Air Deterrence" medal in the last patch, I don't think SOE gives a shit.

If an AA unit doesn't KILL air, then it doesn't DETER anything.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/nitramlondon Jun 03 '14

Libs laugh at skyguards nowadays. I don't expect to be able to destroy a lib with my single skyguard, but at least be a deterrent. On Miller most lib pilots charge you as soon as you hit them with a bit of flak and tank bust you in one clip.

Either buff the skygaurd or nerf the lolbuster.

3

u/FischiPiSti Get rid of hard spawns or give attackers hard spawns too Jun 03 '14

Maybe increase direct max damage, but add a harsher damage dropoff?

So if a lib tries to charge a skyguard he will be toast, but farther away its the same? Because on the other side of the coin, a year ago, either after launch or back in beta, i dont remember, but there was a time, when skyguards were king, there was no point in pulling air, because they demolished every flying vehicle in a 500 m radius.
Right now, as a deterrent(remember the scale) they work fine imo, but they cant defend themselves once the lib identifies it, and decides to charge in tankbustas blazing.

With added max damage at closer ranges, libs are forced to keep range where tankbuster, and shredder are not very effective

2

u/rowleybirkin Jun 03 '14

This is the only sensible solution. Make Skyguards a little nastier up close, but reduce the dropoff. Solves two problems at once - less worry about BS invisible flak for pilots, and more close range defence for ground units.

→ More replies (14)

1

u/Sen7ryGun Juggernaut [JUGA] - Briggs server Jun 03 '14

Infantry also hate tanks for what they do to infantry play too.

Welcome to the food chain.

13

u/Robo1 [7OXS]MarkedBullet(Briggs) Jun 03 '14

Except we don't have a biolab for tanks.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Or something above the lib in the foodchain.

10

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Someone doesn't play on Amerish, esamir.

Tanks have to deal with Ha, AT mines, c4 from all classes but Infil, AT maxes, battle sundaes, engi turrets, AND air units.

Meanwhile 70 % of the things that kill tanks are very ineffective fighting libs, and yet they are extremely good at what they do.

Can't say the same about skyguards.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

There are no walled areas where tanks can get in good fights. There are no points and no gaciluties that tanks can take.

12

u/MMOPTH Jun 03 '14

But tanks require significant sacrifice to pull. There are certain areas where they are terrible, or simply inaccessible, forced through chokes, have to cover large open distances, places where infantry have lots of cover etc. Libs face none of those restrictions, which is what makes them so powerful. It is basically a tank that can fly.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

[deleted]

3

u/WeightyUnit88 Cobalt [RIMG] - The Farmers' Friend Jun 03 '14

I love me some good ol' fashioned tank battles - when two tank zergs clash the farmers immediately charge in with their HE / Vipers and get annihilated by the calm, methodical AP tanks at the back with zooms - good times

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I farm the farmers.

2

u/WeightyUnit88 Cobalt [RIMG] - The Farmers' Friend Jun 03 '14

and thus, the never-ending spiral of farming continues to flow

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

And the Heat/HE guys ragetell cause they are getting farmed by AP MBTs...

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Furniss8u :flair_shitposter:Zone of Shittery Jun 03 '14

Its funny - they buff the lib and its resistances, but don't touch the skyguard

...Wot?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Everyone forgets something every once in awhile...

However, if they buff one thing they need to buff another.

1

u/ChipJiggins [Actual, Chip] Jun 03 '14

They didn't buff flak resistance

1

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 03 '14

No, but they buffed it for everything else, and now what use to be really dangerous thanks to dumfire rockets and tank rounds is actually a pretty safe tactic many times; why stay up high in the air where AA can easily target you, when you can fly low above the ground laughing at infantry hitting you with rockets, then Tankbust/bellyup/dalton/deadSkyguard.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I believe the problem is that gound-air interactions are too extreme.

To take infantry-tank interactions as an example, if an infantry player grabs an anti-tank loadout of some description (Engineers with MANA-AT turrets, Heavy Assaults, C4) there are very few situations where those infantry players cannot be effective against other enemy infantry should the situation progress to that: you still have an effective anti-infantry primary weapon for your class and even the anti-vehicle options can be used against infantry, just to less effectiveness than anti-infantry options.

Even if you take a tank that has anti-vehicle (AP) rounds and the enemy's vehicle forces are reduced/switch to infantry, you can still be relatively effective against infantry, even if less so than using dedicated anti-infantry weaponry. While you require greater precision to hit the target, the target will die in one hit and you have increased shell velocity, which takes out some of the difficulty in hitting such small targets.

With aircraft, infantry has considerably fewer options than against vehicles, counting C4, Tank Mines and the MANA-AV turret, leaving Heavy Assaults with lock-ons as the only none-MAX option. Apart from the fact that lock-on rocket launchers against aircraft are a considerably less interesting mechanic than dumbfire rockets against vehicles, they're incredibly easy to counter if you consider Indar's and Amerish's landscape. The other Infantry option is MAX units with Flak weapons which, while a considerably more fun mechanic, cost Infantry resources and set a cooldown, making it less appealing to people used to standard Infantry play or new players who have not certed the MAX suite.

Then there are Vehicle interactions with Aircraft. There are only two light vehicle weapons that are effective at most of the ranges you would be combatting Aircraft at, the Ranger and the Walker. Selecting these weapons instead of anti-vehicle or anti-infantry weapons doesn't just reduce your effectiveness against none-aircraft targets, but damn-near eliminates it, making it very difficult to get a firing angle on anything on the ground. The anti-vehicle options are trivial to negate by air by simply flying beyond their firing angle, and I hope I don't have to explain why the grenade launcher is completely nullified by air. Finally, the main weapons of tanks suffer much the same fate, not merely reduced but completely negated by aircraft, with the exception of the Skyguard, which is perhaps the best anti-air weapon in terms of versatility (given it has some, but reduced killing potential against infantry as well).

In short, there are too few weapons that even allow you to shoot at aircraft, and too few anti-air weapons allow you to shoot at ground targets. This means that aircraft are in the position where they either dominate the battle, or are dominated by anti-air, or are considered overpowered. By increasing the flexibility of both anti-air weapons by allowing them to shoot ground targets and increasing non-anti-air options' ability to shoot aircraft, you can afford to have more powerful aircraft while reducing the feeling of complete helplessness of ground forces, making aircraft an overall more fun force to use and fight against.

8

u/heimdahl81 Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Simple fix: Make stations where you can switch the weapon on a lightning . That way, if the air offense gets heavy, a few tanks can quickly switch to Skyguard to defend.

If you really want to get crazy with it, make it a commander ability. The tanker gets a little popup "The commander would like to switch your tank to Skyguard. Nanites will reform in 10 seconds: Yes/No".

If you want to get insane with it, give engineers a reconstruction gun that replaces their repair gun and allows then to switch weapons on any vehicle.

EDIT: There is also the idea I had a while back for an engineer deployable turret that is a single burster.

1

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] Jun 03 '14

Man it would be amazing to troll HE farmers by switching their turrets.

6

u/NotTodayBaby Jun 03 '14

Every time air discussion threads crop up it only reinforces how toxic the air game is.

Anti-air should be significantly more powerful, no it's not meant to be "just a deterrent", fuck that. Increase the damage but also increase the drop off, so AA acts a long range deterrent but everything straying too close to a dedicated anti-air platform gets cut in half as it should.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Pyrefrost Jun 03 '14

I think the general consensus is everyone hates tank buster, and with good reason.

2

u/Cpu46 Emerald Jun 03 '14

I think the Lightning Tank needs a heavy flack cannon. More or less a standard tank cannon with a higher elevation range and a large burst projectile. Would be near useless against ESFs due to lower projectile speed and a decently long reload between each shot but could set up some nice area of denial for the slower Libs and Galaxies.

2

u/Sirisian Jun 03 '14

The issue is actually a bigger part of the game. Nanite repair makes you invulnerable. You can fly around and bomb then just disappear for a few seconds and be at full health to do it again without landing.

2

u/Friednug Jun 03 '14

Nanites start to kick in after 12 seconds, and repair at a rate of 5.33% every 5 seconds - say you were at 25% in your lib it would take first 12 seconds to begin then an additional 70ish seconds of taking no damage to be back to 100%. Comp armor is actually a more efficient way to kill ground targets when you're expecting to take large amounts of damage, considering pilot and gunner are both engy and just land and rep.

3

u/Sirisian Jun 03 '14

Well that's generally not how the battle goes. I can fly around a base or tower hitting people with a dalton. I get a lock on and I ignore it. I get hit and then 12 seconds later as I'm still flying around I go back to full health. Another lock on and it repeats. Same for random AA. I'm never pushed back by the enemy.

Very similar to how most of my Galaxy gunning goes actually with bulldogs.

3

u/Friednug Jun 03 '14

I'm not debating on how your play goes man, im just saying it takes a long damn time to repair from low health to full health from nanites alone. If you are very low health it is always more efficient to land and repair rather than be floating around as a big target at low health.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KarlisL [56RD] JoeSMokes Jun 03 '14

I hate libs. Although, I'd be surprised if anyone has every spent 2 1/2 hours flying the same lib, which I know is probably often done by EIP, and the occasional HMRD, prowlers. I'm also sure any lightning driver who has ever ventured north of Crimson Bluff would say the TR Prowler should be nerfed out of existence as well.

What I have suggested in the past is this.

  1. Make the lib louder. Not a ton, but give it some noise. Maybe increased noise when the wings are rotated to a slow/hover position. All aircraft should make increased noise when using vertical thrust.

  2. Buff AA lockons. Maybe increase range based on the size of aircraft so the poor ESF guys don't get completely devastated. You don't see anyone popping flares anymore. Lock on rockets don't do damage to libs, and ESFs can just dodge or outrun them. Give the libs some fear of the ground and they will be less likely to stick that tank buster up your butt.

  3. Make fire suppression stop repairing once the fire is out. Why fire suppression has become a primary repair tool, I'll never know.

  • I love lamp.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/raumfahrer1 Jun 03 '14

two decimator hits should blow a lib to kingdom come

2

u/forever_tranced [TAS] Emerald Jun 03 '14

What if libs were vulnerable to small arms fire like ESFs? Would this help any? Would it not solve the problem but be a reasonable change?

2

u/caudice theChangginator Jun 03 '14

Liberators are stupidly OP right now. They are near unkillable in 1-12 ans 12-24 fights unless you have at least 2 bursters or skyguards

1

u/Bananenweizen Jun 04 '14

You can't kill a Lib with two Bursters. You can push them back from the bases in the open terrain, but elsewhere you wont be able even to deter the skyies from this on Lib with two Bursters.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Liberators....where do I start? -Dumbass squad wipe weapons, you have a full squad? well...I got this here Zephyr and uh...you fucked. -AA weapons need to do more damage

  • ALL THEY DO IS FARM!!! -Most of the pilots are assholes.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Weaverkill [VXP] Prowler fanatic of Briggs - Jun 03 '14

Revert the resistance to tank shells, sorted. If you're getting hit by tanks, you're a scrub and should not fly Liberators. Before the buff, I knew Liberator pilots that could survive easily, now.. you're laughing. 6-7 f***ing tank shells to take down an aircraft... just say that over to yourself a few times.

3

u/CollinBRTD Jun 03 '14

I think one thing nobody pointed out into the discussion.

If i am new to the game i know there is a tank. Its shooting me. Its killing me BUT i have a rocketluncher and lets try that and have a fight with him.

Sure I will solo loose against the tank BUT I had a fight, I had maybe an impact by getting some points when he blows.

On the other hand the libs and to some extent the ESF´s i can´t do a bloody thing. I just blow up and with the libs 50 % of the time you dont even know where it came from. Your head gets blown of right the second you step out of the spawns.

G2A fights are NOT connected in this game at all. NEW PLAYERS WILL LEAVE because of the LIB. They cant close the cert gap or the skill gap between them and the pilots.

Libs are VERY bad for the game. The only fun libs are being in one the rest just have a BAD experience.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

they kill the skyguards and then they kill all the vehicles and then they camp the base.

This is the sole entire problem with the Liberator as it stands today. It can engage and KILL any other unit in the game, in one loadout, with no compromises. It's also faster, more maneuverable, and tougher than any ground vehicle, and it costs less resources than a 2/2 MBT.

Oh yeah, and it flies.

Great at one thing is fine. Good at two things may be ok, if it comes with a mild liability. Great at everything, all the time, in one setup, with no downsides, is flat out broken.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Pestilence86 Jun 03 '14

You have to realize the fact that this game has infantry, tank and air game all at one place. Furthermore fights are not balanced, because everyone can choose to go where ever they want. If a group of 1 lib and 2 esf decide to kill all the tanks at Indar Excavation, then that happens and you have bad luck that you spawned your prowler for tank farming. Sometimes i spawn a lib and there are tons of enemy ESF, bad luck for me. Sometimes i spawn a skyguard and all enemy air disappeared, bad luck for me.

The thing that is problematic, in my eyes, is that you can move the air to another fight without big problems. You can also move infantry somewhere else (redeploy) without problems. Ground vehicles are not so easy to move. Perhaps you should be able to redeploy vehicles? Or get a resource refund for "selling" vehicles back to the vehicle pad, or something like that.

2

u/randomguyfromholland Miller BRTD CrazydutchTR Jun 03 '14

Im guessing you dont pilot liberators, do you?

They really are not as tanky as people claim they are. I agree that they should have a specific sound that will notify you of their approach.

A burster max should not be able to kill a lib in mere seconds. You must realise that it is a multi person vehicle. a 3/3 lib getting killed by one guy in a max suit is not balanced. It is a 3 man crew you are going up against. Any other weapon that would destroy 3 people easily by itself would be considered overpowered.

I fly liberators, and unless i come from an angle where the skyguard doesnt notice me and i can tankbust + gunner him, the skyguard will inflict major damage if not just kill a lib. Coming in from an angle where he doesnt see the lib also means going deeper into enemy territory most of the time, which brings aditional risks with it.

SOE also changed the physics of vehicles on fire so if you get a lib to that point, it is most likely dead.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Libs with Composite can take more AP rounds than a Prowler's front armor. If anything they're more tanky than people claim.

1

u/GR3MLIN Jun 03 '14

It's also always great getting sniped by enemy strike fighters from distances in which you can't counter or escape.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/lurkeroutthere [VMOP] Jun 03 '14

Oh joy, another anti-liberator thread populated by people who never use the lib. All of these should be retitled "Nerf everything but the thing I'm using now"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I mained lib before the update and stopped cause it becam even easier - wher is your god now?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/greenleaf121 Bonus Check Jun 03 '14

SOE plz buff the ranger so I can wreck shit on those liberators

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

The problem is not libs, it's tanks. AV turrets, phoenixes, lancers, ground locks, rocket pods, hornets, liberators, galaxy drops...all of these things make tanks a waste of resources and time.

Tanks need a re-balance.

1

u/GR3MLIN Jun 03 '14

I agree with this, I say give tanks about twice the meat and tank gameplay would feel... well... "tanky". I feel safer in a Harasser even post nerf.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

It'd certainly help the tanks, but I'd worry about MBT camping getting worse. Tank HP is needed, but it needs to go hand in hand with more space between bases to give tanks a place to fight other tanks. Not to be the nostalgia guy, but PS1 had a clear role for tanks. Foot zerging from base to base took FOR EVER and you HAD to have an AMS to overwhelm defenders which necessitated taking down defending vehicles which required the ground-based apex predator - the MBT.

What we really need are fewer bases per continent. In PS1 we had over a half-dozen continents to play across so you didn't need 40 bases and outposts per continent. PS2 was released differently and had to meet other needs with their continent design.

It'd be nice to see the newer continents have fewer and fewer bases. Hossin might end up being a real dream for tankers; the fog and tree cover means tank to tank battles are going to have less interference from long range infantry and aircraft interference...maybe. It's been a while since I've been on the PTS.

If we got a Searhus where most of the ground was near sea level and you had good wide open spaces between more fortified bases, I think it'd be a pretty popular place to play. If you could make the volcanic activity screw with thermal sights a bit, you'd probably really make people happy.

1

u/GR3MLIN Jun 03 '14

Most Libs I see become the focus of the fight as soon as they show up and go down quickly, or can be scared off easily. I know when me and my friends fly libs, we can hardly get into a decent fight and get off a few rounds before we are forced to retreat to repair. Couple ALL the ground fire they incur with other enemy libs and fighters and you will find most don't last very long unless they are really good.

1

u/KublaiKhagan [VIB] KublaiKhan Jun 03 '14

Tankers don't whine enough and therefor tankgame was removed in favor of "airgame".

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Every other 'cheese'; ESFs, Tanks, MAXs, etc...; have a counter which easily kills them. They are also FUN to overcome.

Not Liberators. They are not fun to kill.

1

u/supermate Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

i must agree with this as a person who had done many hours in a lib and tank. a lib is much to quiet for the vehicle that it is. the amount of times i have been sneaked upon and tb down to nothing i have lost count, i die more to libs that other tanks which is rather frustrating. but as a pilot i have notices that the flak now dose alot damage and locks are more effective than they were about 3 months ago.but i still think flack should do more damage.

and for the love of god give me my 2 shot kill with the vanies ap it was generally hard enough to hit that and now i have to hit them 3 times really higby, you ever tried???? but the lib dosent have a niche role to play they can do anti air ant ground and infantry all with 1 weapon i almost feel cheesy with a dalton as i have almost 2 k kills with it. where as a tank can only main 1 role at a time not including secondary weapon, i.e. anti infantry HE, ap anti tank or heat all rounder.

1

u/Stuhlgewitter Miller Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

Liberators are fundamentally flawed. They're neither attack helicopters nor bombers nor gunships, and they're practically designed for camping. Their role is pretty much "camp the defenseless enemy in case of air superiority".

Either turn them into Hinds, with different fixed weapon platforms for the pilot and a forward-facing medium gun (+ TV rocket?) for the gunner. This requires them to be relatively low altitude and face the enemy, making them more vulnerable vs ground but also more lethal.

Or turn them into bombers that make devastating bombing runs on ground targets, but have to rearm regularly and rely on gunners for anti air defense.

Of course they'll never rework the Lib. Not because SOE are jerks, but because people have grown to love the liberator, and also because it would be a nightmare to balance vs all other vehicles/weapons. And because people put a lot of money and certs into them.

1

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] Jun 04 '14

No one wants or needs an AOE dumbfired bomb.

Also it wouldn't work.

1

u/Stuhlgewitter Miller Jun 04 '14

Okay, thanks for your input, community spokesperson / PS2 technical director.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Nitro_R Waterson/Emerald [QPRO] Jun 04 '14

My suggestion is just to make the Hornet Missiles do uber damage to Liberators.
ESFs should have one loadout that can quickly dispatch Liberators.
Hornets suck at air-to-ground compared to to regular Rocketpods.
Why not add a functionality to specialize them into air torpedoes for Lib hunting?

1

u/kenken2k2 Jun 03 '14

when in skyguard, GUARD SKY !

8

u/Orabilis Vyander Jun 03 '14

Skyguards are boring. You just lightly tickle the foe until they leave you alone and bored.

1

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14

In Terran Auraxis, Libs are guarding from Skyguards.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

"all friendly TR prowlers proceed to move up to the base and greedily try to fire into the base to support the infantry push."

yeah... support the infantry push... that must be it.

1

u/Sirisian Jun 03 '14

Have your tank gunner use their AA gun?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Yes, let me slightly tickle the Liberator which will then kill me anyway.

For my trouble, I'll be completely gimped against anything else I happen to meet.

And, just to make sure everything is balanced, the best anti-tank gun on the Lib happens to also be the best anti-infantry gun and the best anti-air gun. And the Lib can also mount a pure AA without giving up its firepower.

1

u/Bananenweizen Jun 03 '14

How is it a relevant question?

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

So you're mad that Liberators are doing exactly what Liberators are supposed to do?

-1

u/Brandmon Cobalt Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

I was playing within my own niche, and I'm mad that others are playing within their own respective niche. Pls nerf not-my-own-niche.

This is one more reason why SOE stopped taking community banter seriously about, oh, several months ago and stopped having such discussions dictate balance decisions. And I'm glad they did.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

The problem is, and thats wha bad players like you don't get, is that the liberator has no niche. It's very good against everything and the only hardcounter is another lib with a slightly more specialized loadout.

If you can dominate everything isn't not a niche.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/snafucit [MERC] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Libs are incredibly easy to deal with as long as you are competent and have a few friends. You give me three HA's using grounder equivalents or two sky guards working together and no Lib crew will be able to linger in the area. Unless you are a good ESF pilot do not expect to kill a competent fully crewed lib team solo, usually takes two mid tier ESF to down a lib safely. It is one of the only vehicles in PS2 that some brain dead solo infantryman cannot out right deter or counter alone. Thats right boys and girls no easy mode c-4 express to kill this flying beast.

For a lib to reach its full potential it needs a crew. To be able to effectively counter a lib you need to match it with equal or greater levels of team work. Stop crying over being beaten by players working together and using combined arms to farm you. Look at what you are doing wrong and fix it rather then come here and cry for nerfs. You have more then enough tools to make any lib crew avoid you entirely if you could only count to potato and work together.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Madkipz Jun 03 '14

Yes. You love your prowler, but if not the lib then something else would have ruined you. MBT's get ruined all the time. Infact all ground vehicles are made out of paper mache.

It isn't the libs fault that your tank is made out of paper.

1

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14

From most other things that kill your tank (besides random cheese) there's actually a fight. Two MBTs? Probably die but holy shit will I go down fighting in a blaze of glory! And if I somehow win? That's memorable.

Liberator? Prepare your anus.

→ More replies (1)