r/Planetside • • Jun 03 '14

If the community agrees, how can we reduce A2G farming/spam and improve the air to air game.

Apologies in advance for the wall of text.

My main gripe is that ESF's have G2A options and this ruins the aesthetic of a combined arms game for me. I know that a part of the community will disagree with this statement, but hear me out. If ESF G2A options didn't exist, you would know that ESF's were hard counters to Lib's and other ESF's and that's what would be pulled to deter/destroy Lib's.

If ESF's were the primary and most effective anti-air aircraft option, you could then massively nerf Lib's against ESF's as a trade off for ESF's not having A2G. A player pulling a Lib would then have an actual pay off, Lib's would be efficient at A2G but not A2A and ESF pilot's would no longer have to be concerned about Lib's handing their arses to them.

However, when more than half of your friendly ESF's are too focused on A2G themselves, it gives Liberator's a lot of free reign. At the moment there is too much confusion and frustration around the roles of each aircraft which could have been resolved by giving each aircraft specific roles.

ESF pilots would still get to have their ESF air duels and would know that one of their primary objectives was friendly Lib escort and enemy Lib hunting, as Lib's would be the primary source of A2G in the game. You could then buff the A2G options of the Lib whilst nerfing their A2A capabilities, ground units would only in essence have Lib's to shoot at with G2A as ESF's would be engaging other air, not ground.

If a Lib was sat farming your base, you would know that ESF's, skyguard's and ground locks are your counters. ESF's would be very effective against Lib's. Another addition to help balance aircraft and ground would be to remove Walker's and Ranger's from MBT's, this change would help the game stay inside the theme that one vehicle should not have counters to everything.

I have lost count of how many times I have been in a Lib being engaged by enemy ESF's when less than half a hex away there is a friendly ESF, who could have easily helped, farming ground with lolpods. I also can't count how many times I've seen 2 ESF's of different factions farming ground with lolpods in the same hex, completely ignoring each other, as if they have some sort of truce.

However, it's a bit too late for that, SOE will not remove A2G options on ESF's that people have already purchased with SC/Certs.

Another option could be to remove AB tanks if a ESF has A2G on, this means they would have to tactically choose when to intercept ground targets as opposed to just hovering and then after burning away when things get too hot. Anything to make ESF's actually engage other air targets would be a life saver. Most people in aircraft do not want the challenge of fighting other air targets, they would rather farm ground, it is a lot, lot easier to gain certs this way.

Having an AA nosegun, lolpods and AB tanks for 200 air resources is ludicrous. It is the only set up in game that has a chance of countering every other type of unit in the game effectively. Planetside is a combined arms game, but why would you need the support of other vehicles/units if you can do everything by yourself? (kill infantry, ground vehicles and aircraft effectively.)

If AB is removed, the ground units benefit and the air game improves as more people will find it enticing to play A2A if they do not have the skill/patience to run A2G without afterburners. If Lib's get nerfed against ESF's, a lot of ESF pilots will be happy, it is a common complaint among ESF pilots that Lib's can too easily throw their weight around against ESF's.

I personally do not have a problem with this, a 2 man aircraft which costs more resources than a 1 man aircraft should beat a 1 man aircraft. A lib should counter 1 ESF, but never two or more depending on the situation.

Despite getting a A2A nerf, Lib pilots would also benefit, as they are more likely to/should have more people running A2A to protect their bombing runs if ESF A2G options are nerfed.

What do you think/are your suggestions/disagreements?

4 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

8

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 03 '14

No, nerfing Libs vs ESFs would leave the air to air game even more watered down than now. It is fun fighting a Lib with an ESF, especially if you want to take your chances and take on a skilled 3/3 crew solo (you are supposed to bring a wingman, but can go alone if you feel you are good enough). And it is fun to fight ESFs in a Lib, trying to maneuver your clumsy whale to find an opening to land a Tank Buster volley, or try to nail it with a Dalton shot.

What should change is that Lib vs tank fights should be as disputed as Lib vs ESF ones. An ESF will kill a Lib crew most of the times if they are all equally skilled, but the Lib will win if it's noticeable better than the ESF. In tank vs Lib fights, in contrast, a couple of BR1s can just hover over the best MBT crew of the server and casually delete it with the Shredder. Given enough skill, tanks should be able to defend themselves against Libs, just like Libs can defend themselves against ESFs.

People here say they don't like feeling forced to have to learn to use ESFs to counter Libs, and they are right, but you fix that by giving tanks and infantry better ways to fight back, not by making ESFs absurdly OP against Libs to make up for it.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I don't see ESFs as a problem.

The real boogeymen are Liberators.

3

u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 03 '14

I'm definitely going to make a post about this week. I'm going to compile ttks fire sky guards and lock ons with the ttks of libs and ESF's on them.

The problem is that ESF'S A2G power is pretty limited. It's libs that have better success.

3

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14

By making counter-play more prominent without needing specialized counters. Dumb-fires and tanks shooting at aircraft should be encouraged, not nerfed... it is a fun and skill based counter.

1

u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) Jun 03 '14

The problem that I've always seen in terms of MBT vs Liberators is that tanks are actually pretty decent at killing Liberators(less so since the resistance changes).

But, what they're good at is killing Liberators engaging OTHER targets or just flying along minding their own business. They're BAD at actually defending themselves from Liberators. That's the issue in my mind. I actually wouldn't mind if MBT's were able to fight back against Liberators more effectively. But, right now the only time I die to a MBT is basically the one I didn't notice, or the AP on 300m away that sniper me out of nowhere.

The Liberator on the receiving end of that has no counterplay and the MBT on the receiving end of a Liberator attacking it specifically has no counter-play.

How do you change this? No freaking clue.

1

u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 03 '14

Give G2A some bite against Liberators. Liberators farm infantry because any anti-air options against a Liberator are terrible.

Anyone getting farmed by an ESF kind of deserves it. ESF's are fine.

1

u/D16_Nichevo Jun 03 '14

I also can't count how many times I've seen 2 ESF's of different factions farming ground with lolpods in the same hex, completely ignoring each other, as if they have some sort of truce.

I'm sure a lot of ESF pilots eschew air combat (I know I do) but I'm sure equally many love it and simply have trouble finding the enemy aircraft.

Some solutions:

  • Let the mission system allow players to make air superiority and close air support missions. One hopes this is already planned.

  • Have an /airsupport channel similar to /orders but tweaked slightly for the intended users of that channel.

  • (Ambitious and hence unlikely) Have a radar system that allows pilots to see distant enemy planes on the map and/or on the HUD. Radar could be provided by certain bases; or it could be as simple as any time a plane is spotted (pressing Q or by using existing vehicle radars). For performance reasons it doesn't need to be real-time; an update every (say) five seconds would be good.

0

u/shockwave414 Jun 03 '14
  • One of the main problems is that ESFs carry waaaayyy too many rockets to be that maneuverable. I'm surprised they can even take off with almost 100 rockets on board. https://i.imgur.com/tgEYdyT.png

  • The other problem is that liberators have pinpoint accuracy. Sure there is some drop but how many videos are out of of ESFs getting one-shotted. They should have only guns like the duster, just not suck.

  • All ground vehicle weapons should be able to look straight up but, except for MBT main canons.

  • Finally, the AA is weak. The skyguard can skill an ESF here and there but is completely defenseless against armor and liberators. It should also be a two or three seater as a new vehicle. Not so easy to drive on bumpy terrain and accurately hit an ESF trying to lolpod you.

3

u/Sen7ryGun Juggernaut [JUGA] - Briggs server Jun 03 '14

I don't suppose you've ever carried 600 rounds of 7.62mm ammo and a 12 kg light machine gun by chance...

0

u/shockwave414 Jun 03 '14

What does that have to do with ESFs and liberators...

5

u/Czerny [SUIT] Emerald Jun 03 '14

There's a point where realism no longer applies and weapon weights go past that. How does a heavy wear so much armor and carry an LMG, several hundred rounds, a rocket launcher, several rockets, and still be able to sprint across a field?

0

u/shockwave414 Jun 03 '14

When they fix the resource system they should put in a sprint meter. However, HAs can't take out 10 tanks and ESFs all within a matter of minutes.

0

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 03 '14

Yet none of them are showing when I use my Flash. One explanation : hammerspace. I want to see my armed-to-the-teeth self already !

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Harassers can carry a lot of halberd rockets as well.

Liberators are by no means pinpoint accurate. Use your AB a bit instead of rushing like a tard.

This is a programming constraint

Do you take HE and then complain about not killing armor? The TTKs are fine. a 3 person aircraft beating 1 guy too clueless to not get flanked, despite having a dedicated A2A weapon is what PS2's about

0

u/shockwave414 Jun 03 '14

Harassers can carry a lot of halberd rockets as well.

So if SOE made it carry less nothing would really change. They are surrounded by ammo sunderers and base ammo towers.

Liberators are by no means pinpoint accurate.

They can one-shot ESFs flying at over 200kph. They are pinpoint accurate.

The TTKs are fine. a 3 person aircraft beating 1 guy too clueless to not get flanked, despite having a dedicated A2A weapon is what PS2's about

Ah, the old "the more people means it should automatically win" argument. So a 3 seater harasser should be able to take on a liberator...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

If you seriously think killing ESFs with your first shot at 200 m is by any means a result of them being pinpoint accurate, and not luck then you are even more butthurt than the usual infantryside retards on here. Also, the lib is supposed to be a bomber, to be able to wipe out ground targets. If you want to kill them, get an esf and plink at them from render. A lone skyguard can keep upto 3 esfs at bay if they are not coordinated, get 2 and you effectively form an anti lib crew as well. Keep your backs up against the walls/rocks, scan different areas instead of both of you looking straight up. And you can shred the lib if he isnt decent. But then again, skill is something you guys seem to hate except when it comes to rocket primaries, shotties, maxes.

-1

u/shockwave414 Jun 03 '14

If you seriously think killing ESFs with your first shot at 200 m is by any means a result of them being pinpoint accurate, and not luck then you are even more butthurt than the usual infantryside retards on here.

Can't believe I actually have to explain this. Accuracy is accuracy. Doesn't matter whether you intended to hit something or not. If you miss with the most accurate gun in the world, that's your problem, not the guns. The weapon itself is accurate, there is no recoil or spread on liberator guns. So that would in turn make the dalton and zepher accurate weapons.

Oh and nice job with the name calling. Usually helps when you can't make a good argument.

But then again, skill is something you guys seem to hate except when it comes to rocket primaries, shotties, maxes.

Who the hell are you taking to? Sounds like you're the butthurt one.

2

u/Arawnrua Jun 03 '14

You're dealing with confirmation bias as you see the esf getting daltoned in a video as proof that it happens all the time when in reality the reason you see all those videos is because it rarely happens and that is why people upload them when it does. It is like how on American news you hear about children getting abducted all the time when in reality we live in the safest time to be a child but the news always runs those stories because they know people will watch. No one uploads all the times they missed the esf..

0

u/ahiggs :flair_shitposter:High ping EU on Emerald Jun 03 '14

Remove lolpods? And make hornets more like AP.

That's the easiest thing I can think of. And yes, I use lolpods.

1

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Jun 03 '14

Hornets already allow any ESF to 1v1 an MBT, even with two maxed out repair guns going.

They do not need buffed.

0

u/WarOtter [BEST][HONK][KARZ]Ram Lib Best Lib Jun 03 '14

Liberators need a speed reduction by about a fifth. This would increase the effectiveness of air counters versus it, but still leave room for a liberator with support to be effective.

0

u/Sain7 Aurelie [TRID] Jun 03 '14

I think we only see the people who complain about things, and not those who think things are good as they are. I am worried this means the complaining people think that EVERYONE doesn't like those things.

I think liberators, ESFs and AA are in a pretty good place right now. To counter a 2/3 or 3/3 lib should require at least 2 people, and those people should expect to have to spend resources to do so.

Instead of cowering in the spawn when a lib passes over, grab 2 or 3 ESFs. Even nearly stock ESFs, when ganging up, will nail a camping lib (come down on him from the flight ceiling).

Skyguards can be pulled from EVERY base. Pull 2 or 3; if your base is camped, you've lost the fight, pull skyguards from the next base over and find a hill. People complain that libs can 1-clip skyguards, but it is not EASY. It takes a very competent and quite ballsy pilot, and a tanker who isn't paying attention. I do think that libs should be made much much louder, however.

At the end of the day, a team of very competent players in a tricky to master vehicle with thousands of certs poured into it which costs a large amount of air resources should... should not be countered by anything that isn't at least slightly comparable from either a resources (pull your own TB lib to gank them, or a couple of ESFs), skills/certs (pull a solid AA ESF and solo the lib, which is possible if you are a skilled pilot), or teamwork (get 2 or 3 people to... well, to do ANYTHING together; skyguards, ESFs, lockons, burster MAXes) perspective.

ESFs against ground have been nerfed time after time after time and are very balanced now, I would say. You already lose Extended Afterburner if you want to go A2G, and basically auto-lose to any competent AA ESF. Ground pulling one MAX, or skyguard, or manning one turret will drive you away.

I would like to see:

  • Libs made louder

  • AA get an increase in damage at close range (so TBing a skyguard or hovering near a spawnroom is incredibly dangerous)

  • AA get a decrease in damage at long range (so the most you can do at render distance is stop autorepair)

But that's it, in my opinion.