r/Planetside • u/[deleted] • Jun 02 '14
In regards to the almost inevitable shredder nerf...
Do it the right way. The traditional overnerf route is lazy at best, and downright malicious at worst. Instead of hard double- or triple-nerfs on multiple aspects of the weapon, go a bit easier. Leave it viable for AV/AA but inferior to the zephyr at AI.
SOE's track record for nerfs is AWFUL. They allow a weapon to remain OP for too long, then once everybody has resigned themselves to thinking it will never change, they buy it only to see it nerfed the next week , leaving it a festering pile of shit that isn't viable for anything. Then inevitably, they slowly tweak it back up to be less than viable and call it "tweaking"
My recommendations for the shredder are to nerf AV very minorly, at least triple infantry TTK, and leave AA potential almost unchanged. Thoughts?
I have zero hope SOE will do this, but I just wanted it to be said. I don't expect the shredder to be viable after the nerfs, and have stopped certing into it. GG SOE
8
Jun 02 '14
they don't need to nerf the shredder.
they need to nerf the total clip damage of the tankbuster and then add a loud ass fucking engine noise to the liberator itself.
2
u/Lanfeix DamThatGuy NC/Wat, EvanWilder VS/Mill and Lanfiex TR/Wood Jun 03 '14
dam straight its need some deep drone which put the shudders when the lib enters the killing feild
4
Jun 03 '14
festering pile of shit that isn't viable for anything.
Cough cough striker
Cough cough Vulcan
Cough cough prowler deploy
Cough cough TMG 50
Cough cough harasser
2
u/Burns_Cacti Jun 03 '14
Cough cough prowler deploy
wut. I mean, it arguably could use a velocity buff by a tad, but it's not bad. Especially not since the vanguard shield nerf.
1
Jun 03 '14
But it was nerfed before the shield nerf.
1
-1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jun 03 '14
What? Prowler Deploy? Pile of shit?
2
Jun 03 '14
the major velocity buff (recently rebuffed to ~75% of pre-nerf)
They said the increase in velocity made it too easy to hit aircraft.
Like it already wasn't the only MBT that couldn't 1 shot one of them.
1
1
6
2
Jun 02 '14
Dalton needs to be a 2hk on libs again. I think this small change had a massive effect on the game. I would like to see the Dalton become more like ap for tanks, no splash only direct hits so they cant farm infantry easily and 2hk on libs.
don't change the shredder. Its a stock weapon. It would be unfair to restrict new players. It was ok before the lib patch. no one called for lib Dalton resistance to be increased.
1
u/Nlioc [AIM] Jun 03 '14
no one called for lib Dalton resistance to be increased.
This. I've never understood why they made this change, I'd never heard a single complaint about libs dying to two dalton hits.
1
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 03 '14
I think that they wanted to give people another incentive to have a second gunner besides the new tail gun angle. You were meant to hit two Dalton shots and still get a kill if the tail gunner hit it a few times with a Walker or once with a Bulldog. What actually happens though is that Shredder+Walker Libs melt you so fast that you don't have time to adjust your shots, so unless you are Ling or Jaamaw and can lead by memory you will die before even getting the first hit.
2
u/Nlioc [AIM] Jun 03 '14
Even if you are Ling, or Jaamaw, or my gunner who is currently 9th for dalton kills, you can't hit them all. You miss one and a shredder lib will eat you
1
1
u/Gronzlo Jun 03 '14
As an infantry player, I have an easier time with Shredders than I do with the other Lib bellyguns (Zephyrs). However as a MAX I get wrecked unreasonably fast. That's the only nerf to the Shredder I can see happening.
-3
u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 02 '14
Shredder has been the same since launch, but if infantry masterrace just wants all vehicles nerfed into the ground. The liberator used to die in an instant to flak before it even damaged anything, now the liberator is finally made viable. The only problem I see here is that they are too strong against ESFs, Libs need no needs, ESFs just need a buff against Libs.
21
u/Cup_O_Coffey [L] || Ammathor Jun 02 '14
The Funny thing with the Shredder is that it hasn't been changed since Launch.
It's the exact same gun and it's gone from being "Oh Never use that because it's bad" to "Wah it's OP and needs to be Nerf'd" without the Weapons stats even being tweaked.