r/Planetside • • May 29 '14

A Strange Idea to fix G2A & A2G Combat

This could be a long-winded, so I'll dive right in.

Goals

  • Resolve air-ground battle-size scaling issues. I.e. Aircraft should not dominate small fights nor be dominated in large, but rather always be able to participate.

  • Remove uninteresting and/or annoying elements where possible.

  • Provide multiple combat options with varying levels of skill-scaling; weapons that are easy-to-use but relatively ineffective, and vice versa.

The Gist Of It

The idea is to divide the airspace in to three theoretical zones of vertical height, each being optimal for a specific kind of engagement between air and ground forces.

In the highest zone, which could be described as the Obstacle Zone, Dogfight Zone or the Low-Risk Zone, aircraft are at almost no risk of being damaged by ground forces, but cannot engage them too well due to sheer visibility issues. Effective G2A weapons at this range include obstacle weapons only. Obstacle weapons are weapons that cannot be fired directly at the aircraft, but rather deploy airborne obstacles (such as FLAK clouds) for the aircraft to avoid.

In the middle zone, which could be described as the Engagement Zone, or Medium-Risk zone, aircraft can effectively engage with ground forces, and vice versa. A pilot's ability to survive here depends on speed, reaction, mobility, etc. Effective G2A weapons at this range include the obstacle weapons as well as AA-specialised high-velocity dumb-fire weaponry, such as rocket launchers.

In the lowest zone, which could be described as the Death Zone, or High-Risk Zone, should they come under fire, aircraft will easily be destroyed by all manner of weaponry.

Actions to Take

  • Increase aircraft maximum speed, acceleration and manoeuvrability across the board.

This model relies on forcing aircraft to keep moving during engagements. The idea is that they should be glass cannons that will be easily destroyed by direct hits. Forcing aircraft to move should, in theory, prevent them from constantly maintaining firing angles that are most suitable to camping, while still enabling them to engage.

  • Reduce the defensive capabilities of all aircraft.

Same explanation as the prior point; aircraft must keep moving. If a Liberator floats above a spawn room (i.e. in the "death zone"), as few as two HA troops with regular AV rocket launchers should be able to pluck it out of the sky. Direct hits from ground forces should be the greatest threat to aircraft survivability.

  • Change FLAK & Bursters

Upon contact with an enemy aircraft, the FLAK gun's projectile will create three FLAK clouds (like a FLAK clusterbomb of sorts) around the target some distance away. Ideally, one would appear somewhere ahead of the aircraft, with two more somewhere above, below or behind it. The current firing speed of FLAK would probably have to be reduced, lest single players create ridiculously dense FLAK storms.

Affected aircraft must endeavour to avoid FLAK clouds. The clouds can be flown through, but contact causes slight damage and a reduction in thrust and velocity. The larger and more armoured an aircraft is, the less damage it receives from FLAK; speed effects remain about the same regardless of aircraft. Some FLAK alone should destroy an ESF if the pilot repeatedly fails to evade, but an exorbitant amount of FLAK contact should be required to destroy a Galaxy.

FLAK, and other such obstacle-weapons, should be the only practical G2A option when firing on aircraft in the high zone.

  • Add specialised AA dumb-fire rocket launchers.

These launchers are intended to be the mainstay of G2A fire against aircraft in the middle/engagement zone.

The idea is that even a Liberator, flying at full speed and evading, should be quite difficult to hit with these weapons without FLAK support to reduce its evasive efficiency. Hitting an ESF that is doing the same should be nearly impossible without such support.

Variations of these weapons could have different reload times, clip sizes, velocities and damage, giving players choices based on personal skill level, desired engagement range, and available targets, and whatever else. If you're worried about ESFs, you might pick a high-velocity launcher. If you're expecting Galaxies, or you're just awesome, you might pick a more damaging launcher with a slower projectile velocity.

  • Remove G2A lock-ons and all simple-to-use AA weapons such as the Walker

Lock-ons are boring for the wielder, and annoying for the victim. They, as well as all simple AA guns like the Walker and the current FLAK gun, seem to be the cause of G2A scaling issues in large battles.

Explanation

If I haven't completely stuffed this, you should be able to see what I'm getting at here. Under this model, aircraft would not be able to hover over small fights anymore for fear of being plucked out of the air by a couple of rockets; the same logic applies to large battles. To survive, aircraft must keep moving, avoid obstacles, and dodge rockets. The better a pilot, the better his engagement potential.

The best ESF pilots could, in theory, avoid dense FLAK fire from multiple sources while maintaining enough speed and evasive action to be nigh impossible to hit by AA rocket fire. The best counter for ESFs is still other ESFs.

Tweaking

This would clearly take a lot of work to implement due to the sheer amount of variables to tweak. Aircraft armour, maximum speed and acceleration, distance from FLAK target where FLAK clouds should appear, ideal engagement ranges and corresponding rocket launcher properties. All this stuff has to be balanced against everything else. A tough balance to strike, I'd say.

Extra Depth

Were this model to be used, there's plenty of room for new weaponry, personalisation, and whatever else. For example:

  • A highly damaging obstacle weapon that only actually fires a few seconds after being activated, but makes its trajectory known to all upon activation. This adds some obstacle diversity in the air, and could enable MAXs to use FLAK in synergy with this weapon as some sort of "funnel and catch" system.

  • A "FLAK-shield" that, when activated, gives immunity against FLAK for a few seconds.

Closing Notes

I know this idea is quite contrived and will almost certainly never see the light of day, but I have been kicking it around for a while and was simply wondering how the community would receive it.

One little disclaimer, by the way. I am overseas and haven't even played the game for a while. If my ideas are obviously not grounded in the current reality of play, well, fuck.

tl;dr flak is actually kinda like flak, no lock ons, faster, squishier aircraft, fast dumbfire AA rocket launchers, cake for everybody

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/Czerny [SUIT] Emerald May 29 '14

Remove G2A lock-ons and all simple-to-use AA weapons such as the Walker

Add specialised AA dumb-fire rocket launchers.

Have you tried firing dumbfire at ESFs, or even magriders at range? Removing G2A lockons is entirely unwarranted and removes one of the largest counters against air currently in the game. Unless you're going to give the heavy a portable flak cannon, this makes air far too powerful again.

1

u/Redbeardt May 29 '14

Have you tried firing dumbfire at ESFs, or even magriders at range?

The specialised AA dumbfire launchers are to fire rockets that move much faster than those of existing launchers do, and so hitting ESFs, even at range, would be possible.

Removing G2A lockons is entirely unwarranted and removes one of the largest counters against air currently in the game.

But these scale too much in large fights. The cooldown on countermeasures means aircraft cannot do anything but skirt the edges of large battles for fear of coming under repeated lock-on fire.

The AA launchers, in combination with the changed FLAK, should provide sufficient counter potential.

1

u/AngerMacFadden May 29 '14

Pilots complaining about ground fire means the ground fire is working almost as expected. I like the cloud cover idea.