r/Planetside • u/DaManisJ • May 29 '14
Coyotes or Tomcats?
"If you can't fight them, join them". That's what I intend to do. Which weapon is better for a2a?
2
3
u/DrunkCommy DAKKA DAKKA DAKKA May 29 '14
Are you getting into the thick of it and dogfighting? Coyotes
Are you hanging back, taking potshots, and chasing stragglers? Tomcats
0
u/rigsta EU - Miller May 29 '14
Best reply imo.
Also, inb4 sky knights.
1
u/_Equinox_ [QRY]>[BAX] May 29 '14
Hey, I'm a skyknight and frequently tell people who are mediocre pilots to get stealth, coyotes and a rotary and watch their performance leap.
1
u/rigsta EU - Miller May 29 '14
You're what I'd call a pilot.
When I say sky knight, I mean the few remaining die-hards who lament the loss of the anti-everything rotary. The ones who stand in their ivory tower and tell people that they should never ever use anything other than the default nosegun and fuel tanks.
Thankfully, most pilots have moved on.
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] May 29 '14
Rotary + AB tanks is actually a very useful build. Not just for the aces, but just for the average pilot wanting to improve your nosegun aim. The lack of specialized AI weapons forces you to become more accurate with the nosegun. I've got a loadout called "Training Craft" just for this purpose.
0
u/MrThimble [SOLx] Goodmonson May 29 '14
I love those people, refuse to use something in the game and then crying when they die to it thinking I give a shit about their "honour" It's adorable.
2
u/AngerMacFadden May 29 '14
For the honour. Real sky knights pick up where they left off after getting shot down because their acquisition timer ended shortly before dying. You won't get a rage tell from me, unless you start it.
2
u/MrThimble [SOLx] Goodmonson May 30 '14
Ah I like that and do that too, if I find someone better than me I try and hunt them down again and again like he's a boss in dark souls I feel the need to kill.
1
u/AngerMacFadden May 30 '14
Yeah we all have our favorites :) I don't generally go for revenge but if I see someone in a compromising position, I'll go for it.
0
May 30 '14
[deleted]
1
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO May 30 '14
Your post wans't polite and nice, it was extremly condescending.
2
1
u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 29 '14
Both have their situational advantages. If you're looking to be more aggressive and ambush, I would suggest coyotes. Looking to hang back and be a complete dick? Tomcats it is.
1
u/AngerMacFadden May 29 '14 edited May 29 '14
Tomcat are good when you are a wingman. They let you contribute without crowding Lead's shots. By yourself you have to watch out waiting wasting time trying to use them up close. You will get easy kills shooting other enemies already engaged. Coyotes are better for up close fighting. If you can hover duel you will wreck with good aim.
-6
-2
u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald May 29 '14
Tomcats, they are both skilless but at least with tomcats you have to aim, with coyotes just aim in their general direction and you will get the hits. Plus tomcats synergize really well with the default noseguns which you should be using for A2A. Just go with tomcats and upgrade their lockon time.
-3
u/MarkZwei May 29 '14
It's funny; there's a mossie pilot who aurax'd all the ESF weapons.
Tomcats ranked the worst at A2A. Below the goddamn Banshee. It is so bad that he had to use it to snipe kills; it took him longer to fight with them than without. So bad that you're likely to win if you just turn around while being locked on to.
He also wasn't terribly impressed with Coyotes, but much more effective than tomcats.
3
u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) May 29 '14
Then he was lying. Tomcats might be a pain to GET the kill with. But they're very effective weapons even 1v1 and in groups they're just silly strong.
3
u/DrSPAZZINATOR Connery: WTAC/BAID May 29 '14
He was referring to Hader, who on many occasions stated that while the tomcats one the fight for him, finishing off the target with them was a pain in the ass. The actual amount of damage done with them to the kill count was largely disproportional.
1
u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) May 29 '14
I know and I watched Headers video about them. That's basically what I said :p. They're hard to GET the kill with but easy TO kill with.
0
u/MarkZwei May 29 '14
Why? How? You have more outgoing damage with the nosegun for the duration of the lock. A group of ESFs with noseguns will take out ESFs sooner than a group of ESFs with Tomcats.
1
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
Yes but with a nosegun you need to manuever like crazy and aim accurately the entire time. With A2A, you just need to be generally looking at the pilot. Not to mention, I can have one bait pilot or galaxy that makes you aggro him, while the rest of my squad uses A2A to wipe you out. Of course the counter is flares, but then you miss out on other utilities.
2
u/_Equinox_ [QRY]>[BAX] May 29 '14
What you're saying is asinine.
You need to stand still and be non-evasive to get the lock. You then need to not do any damage while you're getting the lock...
Coyotes are objectively superior to tomcats. Fuck, you can use them effectively in third person.
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
Yes but i'm not talking about a 1v1 situation. My god are A2A useless in that. They are useful when its a group fight.
0
u/MarkZwei May 29 '14
Not convincing; it is hard to do manoeuvres and maintain a tomcat lock, so Tomcat users tend to be easier to hit (or otherwise find few opportunities to fire). Because they are trying to line up the missile instead of using their noseguns, there is a period with no incoming fire that can be exploited for maximum aggression. It takes as little as 3 ESFs to finish one of you off before you can get a shot off. Your effectiveness drastically decreases from there.
A bait galaxy is a moot point; would YOU shoot at a Galaxy rather than ESFs? If so, then I can also use one to bait you, and if not, I would also not shoot at it.
2
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
I'm just pointing out that the A2AM is effective. Not that it is OP or that there is no counter to them. There is. But I can always run from you, increase my distance, (baiting you into friendly air if you chase me), then start over again. A2AM are useful. Even more so when you are engaged with another target.
A bait galaxy is a moot point; would YOU shoot at a Galaxy rather than ESFs? If so, then I can also use one to bait you, and if not, I would also not shoot at it.
Would I? No. But that's because I know better. But you can't just ignore me. I have two gunners on my gal plinking at you. What does happen then is other ESFs get baited. Usually those are not the skilled pilots (Recurssion many times managed to counter-bait my galaxy into an ambush :l ) but it does happen.
1
u/DrunkCommy DAKKA DAKKA DAKKA May 29 '14
Tomcats are good weapons to keep your distance. See the cloud of mossies and reavers, stay out of it and send missiles. See an enemy peel off to repair, chase that mofo
2
u/_Equinox_ [QRY]>[BAX] May 29 '14
Tomcats require you to:
Point your nose at an enemy for a relatively long period of time while doing no damage.
Maneuver your reticule over an enemy ESF while staying relatively still/non-evasive so as not to throw off your aim while you attempt to lock.
Attack enemies that have: Flown away, landed, or otherwise attempted to disengage or are too large to be more maneuverable than you.
Tomcats are great at fat targets, but terrible against ESFs. ESFs that are competent will just eat the locks, fire suppress and shred you with a nosegun.
If you get the jump on them, tomcats will frequently win. If it's an even fight, you will frequently lose.
Coyotes you will frequently win whichever fight. Get coyotes if you need to get better at flying. It will make a better pilot fight you more cautiously.