r/Planetside • u/Kaomet • May 29 '14
THE REAL PROBLEM WITH AIR & GROUND
I'm fed up by "buff this, nerf that" threads about air & ground. None of those adress the real issues, nor help to raise awareness about it.
The problem is about the number of players, and their position on the map.
During a ground fight, there is something like a front line, and covers. A single ground unit can position itself in a way she can shoot/be shot by only a fraction of the enemy force.
When you are flying, you can be shot by EVERYONE in the area. There is no "front line", and no cover (except maybe some mountain on amerish).
To sum it up : on the ground you fight against a line, in the air you fight against a whole area.
Up to now, the only mechanism to adress the one against many nature of air versus ground, is flares. It provides lock-on imunity for 5 seconds, ie against any number of lock on.
As long as ground force is able to stack or as long as the map doesn't provide decent cover for air, or untill the dev include some "1 versus many" defense mechanism, the balance of Air versus Ground will be as is : Air is OP against a small population, and unable to participate significantly in a big fight.
Tweaking endlessly speed, agility, damage, health or resist, will not solve the problem, just give it a different flavor.
1
u/DrunkCommy DAKKA DAKKA DAKKA May 29 '14
We need Galaxy AWOCS units. A pure air support gal variant that's extra beefy, provides radar sensing/radar jamming, Increase/decrease lock-on times.
With this we could beef of ground AA a bit, to help small fights, but still allow air to stay in big fights.
1
u/Kaomet May 29 '14
I don't understand how an extra gal is going to help against an area full of busters and skyguards.
1
u/DrunkCommy DAKKA DAKKA DAKKA May 29 '14
If the gal is made extra beefy (im talking like 3 composite armors, and remove ALL weapons) it helps this way:
A) its radar/lock on benefit is high enough that it will attract a lot of fire, this will allow more nimble craft more space (if the flak is shooting the gal its not shooting the esf)
B) Gals area already fairly big, if they are extra beefy, aircraft can use them as cover in the air, putting something between them and the source of the flak. Wont be nearly enough to avoid it all together, but enough to buy some time for the flak shooter to shift attention or for auto repair to kick in a bit
I was debating having the support gal works as a repair sundy as well, but I think that would be way to op
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
Server Clash begs to differ. We maintained a huge air-force on the test server and dominated Woodman with it.
1
u/SpaceIco (Connery) [EXƎ] A son of Helios May 29 '14
I don't think that's what he means, though. Sure, you can maintain a giant mosquito ball of death and rain hellfire upon everything on the ground well enough to contain it, especially if most of the pilots are of at least moderate skill. What I took OP to mean, and it's a great sentiment, is that he'd like to see air be able to exist above a massive ground battle while not dominating it, or vice versa, for the airspace to be just as contestable as the ground space is simultaneously. Right now, it's fairly exclusive-- either mosquito ball of death or ground has the area too locked down for any air to speak of. There's usually some middle ground, but I like the idea of more separation between the two so you can have a 48 v 48 air battle taking place above a 48 v 48 ground battle without all the pilots and good a2a fights dying to lockons and flak.
0
u/Herby20 [903] May 29 '14
Miller did the same to Mattherson.... Except Mattherson just pulled a bit of flak and kept several squads of air from being able to meaningfully contribute for large periods of time.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
Yes but the airgame has changed since then. Flak can be easily contained with a Galaxy drop of troops or skilled liberators.
1
u/Herby20 [903] May 29 '14
"Since then?" This was two weeks ago!
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
I thought you meant an older match. I didn't know they had a more recent match.
Hmmm well I guess we just need a Connery vs Mattherson match up to see what works best.
1
0
u/Wyvrrn [SOCA] May 29 '14
Maybe a smoke grenade that sprays smoke around the immediate area for x amount of distance or something like that? I realize this could be spammed but it seems like an easy band-aid solution for now.
I definitely agree about the flight ceiling being way higher because it really is a no fly zone on big engagements because you become priority target number 1
9
u/Semajal Aeleva [ABTF] Miller May 29 '14
I would very much like a big boost to flight ceiling and maybe even "clouds" that block air visibility. I dream of large scale air battles occurring above a large fight for dominance. Right now a large fight is mostly a huge nope for most air unless you move very very very fast. If air could fight well out of range of ground (and be unable to hit ground at that height anyway) it would be awesome.