r/Planetside • u/NocTempre Connery • May 29 '14
A Permanent, Scaling Solution For A2G and G2A
Air terrain. It's been suggested plenty before, I'm just interested in reminding people an elegant solution exists, as well as throw in a few of my ideas on a specific implementation.
A cloud layer ~50m thick at around 500m altitude, that aircraft thermals/NV and all lockons can't see through. Only the highest elevation bases would be in or above, and this would actually have some G2G lockon implications as well for variety.
Above this layer you would have billowing clouds acting as three dimensional cover. Bullets could still penetrate but you'd be shooting blind. Even higher up you can have wispy clouds that just break lockons and thermals without being opaque. This "air terrain" moving would be beautiful but ultimately unnecessary (although highly odd looking) for early iterations.
Below this layer, aircraft are operating at "sea level". This is a massive condensation and simplification of the real physics of flight, but cutting speed and maneuverability in half below the cloud layer would be perfectly fair and solve the #1 problem with AvsG - their ability to disengage before what are supposed to be hard counters can respond.
Bonus:
Add phalanx walker turrets to the gun deck of higher tech facilities (where you find the rare specialized AI turrets already, or by some new factor). Especially if you give these turrets walls above like the tech plants instead of the buckets like the towers, these will actually be a way to respond to high altitude hovering.
4
u/rj88631 [DOG]RobMichael May 29 '14
A 10% decrease in Lib Survivability would be more than enough to make everyone happy. And Lib crews need to accept that to participate in large fights they need to fight in groups like everyone else in the large fight. Solo tanks and infantry don't last long in a big fight, why should Air fair any better.
2
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
No it wouldn't. Now lib crews are more limited where they can go, their weapons are still obscene, and options are just more limited. It is a very quick, and extremely dirty short-term fix to the blatantly overpowered liberator platform for the time being. However I think it is important to remember that just puts them back into the unused pile they were before the buff. It doesn't fix the issue so much as remove the issue from mattering (aside from the angry people who spent money and/or actually like liberators but desire better balance and gameplay).
2
u/rj88631 [DOG]RobMichael May 29 '14
I doubt a 10% decrease in survivability would remove Lib gameplay entirely. It would make G2A in small fights a real option again. I don't mind their weapon damage too much. They just currently can tank too much damage in a small fight. A lib should be a force multiplier, not a force in and of itself.
2
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I think they are broken in damage and health, and making them slightly glassier doesn't truly fix the cannon part. It doesn't matter if it dies to a light sneeze if it can (and regularly does) wipe out entire squads in the blink of an eye.
2
May 29 '14
Air doesn't either
2
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Air has to fight everyone with LOS even if they want to engage just a small group. This is the root of the very questionable health and ttk attributes balance. Air terrain gives them the cover to look into this issue deeper.
7
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics May 29 '14
very cool and nice idea, all those particals could decimate framerates though
i do like the idea though
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I'm okay with fairly simple clouds on low and medium settings. The only sticky situation is when an opaque cloud is outside of terrain render range but a vehicle behind it is within vehicle render.
Considering this is a) already a problem with ground terrain as well that doesn't seem to result in game breaking issues and b) something that can be solved by changing aircraft render rules without a performance hit I am mildly optimistic SOE could pull this off with minimal fuss, should they so choose.
2
u/MrBubbleSS Emerald - Flash with Benefits May 29 '14
Why walkers? The aspis phalanx turrets do just fine...
0
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Not to derail too much, but even a cluster of 4 of them can do nothing to respond to long range (>300m) air that is even mildly interested in self preservation.
1
2
u/PenguinPerson May 29 '14
Sounds like a situation where libs lower from the cloud layer and blow the shit out of their targets then simply ascend again when they take fire.
This idea seems like it would hurt the ground game and benefit the air game. Sure aircrafts move slower below clowd range but with afterburner getting up to cloud range will be no issue. Thermal only works at 300m anyway.
Just seems like an inbuilt stealth system in favor of A2G.
2
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
If they are "terrain peeking" they are playing smart and kiting, not farming which is the problem behavior. It also takes more skill to land the shots at further range, but getting closer (which is the effortless solution currently) is now a lot riskier because you are committing wihtout an instant escape. Furthermore, A2A predators are moving around the map faster than their A2G prey, supporting distinct roles in the air meta.
2
u/PenguinPerson May 29 '14
Yes but this cloud cover also can conceal enemy air approach which in many cases can make the ground powerless to respond. It will cause a lot of angry infantry and tankers who will claim there is no way to see the aircraft coming.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
The cloud layer itself is not supposed to be presented as an opaque sheet hiding everything air is doing above. I only intended to suggest some clouds at or above that layer become opaque, and there should be such cover to make low observation approaches feasible at high altitude.
2
u/PenguinPerson May 29 '14
If the cloud layer isn't visible then the design is a direct nerf to air in general.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Not opaque does not automatically mean invisible. I don't want to get bogged down in the technical details of something that is just a concept, but think of it more like the thin bushes for infantry; you can see through but they are obscuring.
1
u/PenguinPerson May 29 '14
Ok I think I can visualize what your saying. Its hard to say then if it would be a help or hinderence dependant on how it would be implemented.
2
u/FourthFactioner May 29 '14
One can dream.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Weather has been on the radar (hah!) for a long time as a "someday" feature. Air terrain (not necessarily anything like I envisioned in this thread) is a necessary part of weather being more than cosmetic.
I would love to see this happen, but am under no illusions that I am doing anything other than promoting an idea that has been circulating since beta, and is over a year out even if they started working today for some crazy reason.
2
May 29 '14
How would you explain a cloud layer above the desert continent Indar?
0
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
It could be thinner and more sparse. Similar variety to Esamir's flatter ground terrain in the air.
7
May 29 '14
Honestly we need to go for small changes that can be tweaked, we're more likely to get an improvement this way. Your proposed changes are big and would drastically affect the game.
1) Increase flak DMG at close range, drop the velocity / DMG at range. This would ensure A2G is punished whereas A2A is not. Skyguards can chase too, so should not be too bad.
2) Lower lockon range, but decrease lockon time. A2G will then have to deal with this, but A2A will not.
3) Remove most base AA from larger facilities. We don't need 10-15 turrets in large fights in addition to all the MAXes, skyguards, etc.
9
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 29 '14
I honestly disagree with point 3. And I do fly a Galaxy a lot. AA at large facilities is another strategic layer that a large facility has. While I fight at the satalite bases, I send 3 - 4 people to destroy the AA at a large facility. It is currently a strategic metagame that is important since AA is easily destroyed by tanks and other vehicles which allows air to participate in the fight.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Haters gonna hate. All /u/dostoyevskain is asking for is a second helping of changes that have already gone live, which is exactly all I was pointing out. Not everyone is up to date with the recent changes.
3
u/Autoxidation [TIW] May 29 '14
I'm not sure mechanics exist in the game to lower velocity past a certain point. Lowering the velocity of flak would make it feel worse and make it worse against ESFs. I think a higher damage falloff in exchange for higher damage up close would be a good trade though.
If you think Skyguards can effectively chase aircraft you're delusional, sorry. The lack of stabilization on turrets plus the speed of aircraft means you'll never chase one down.
The lock on idea is interesting, but removing all the flak turrets is a bad move. That's one of the only effective AA for many new players.
1
May 29 '14
If you think Skyguards can effectively chase aircraft you're delusional, sorry. The lack of stabilization on turrets plus the speed of aircraft means you'll never chase one down.
I've got a Racer 3 skyguard and I can tell you I most definitely can chase libs and gals over short to medium ranges. It is absolutely far from ideal but you absolutely can
2
u/Autoxidation [TIW] May 29 '14
Maybe in certain areas on Indar where you don't have trees or hills, but in general this is impossible, if not extremely unfeasible.
1
u/Crownie Connery May 29 '14
drop the velocity / DMG at range
Flak already mostly just tickles, and the velocity is embarrassingly slow.
-5
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I'm not sure how much experience you have with the game, but aside from the velocity dropoff, all of that already is how the game works... o.O
6
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt May 29 '14
Not really. The Range of Flak is still pretty good and as someone who likes flying Galaxy's I feel that even at a fair distance (A hex or two away) from the base as somewhat decent gunner can still hit you.
For point 3 amp stations and tech plants are covered in AA turrets and it makes providing any form of air support over these fights a pain.
-1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Flak is definitely stronger at close range. It seems the real issue people have when talking about flak is that aa ground can engage from a huge area which means you can realistically have 10 people shooting at a single plane, each at over 200m away. Death by 1000x papercuts is an issue for all vehicles, but cloud cover would actually restrict some of those attack angles so you only are being engaged by the fight you are engaging. Flak from two bases away would then be your fault for not using terrain, not an unmanageable risk. Buffing flak at extreme close range only really changes the skyguard vs tankbuster dynamic, which is something I have strong feelings on but isn't actually a meta issue so much as a balance peeve.
They did exactly this already as part of the ESF updates. It worked pretty well but I'm not sure if you could actually lower it any further without simply eliminating lock/flare counterplay.
They are, point in fact, on average removing AA turrets as they do balance passes on the amp stations, the only bases that were downright unapproachable (ironically) for air before. On the whole, SOE is getting better at this with every patch, and is not a real issue as far as I can tell.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt May 29 '14
1)Its stronger at close range because it can generally get more shots on target, at the very least a velocity reduction may be necessary.
2)I agree that they did this.
3) For the Amp stations they are simply moving the Turrets to the inside wall rather than the outside, theres still a lot of Flak turrets and they're actually giving smaller bases Flak turrets as well, look at Amerish with places like Lithcorp Central and NC Arsenal.
I do like your idea of clouds and stuff though.
0
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
They are removing some (some moved, but a few are simply gone), but more importantly, removing easy access for instant repairs, especially with the 3 point redesign (which I am not a fan of as a change for all bases, only some).
Adding a few turrets to bases that had none is necessary, and is only a problem if those turrets contribute to other bases air defense significantly, which they actually have done an admiral job of limiting; air terrain would solve that with much less headaches on the base designers, since air angle restrictions would become decoupled from ground flow.
1
u/Axle_Grease PS1 Vet: SaigoTakamori May 29 '14
Very cool ideas, but like most suggestions here it just seems like a coding nightmare.
3
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Well, I've seen a lot of floating trees lately, so SOE already proved it's not impossible :P
1
u/TheMoogy Moogy [MAP - Woodman 4 lyf] May 29 '14
So basically separate air from ground even more.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I don't believe that would be the effect. The purpose is to make features that vary engagement distances depending on the "air terrain" without adding all sort of funky walls (the pulled air shield feature) and super tall terrain that takes away ground content without doing a whole lot for the problem that air is too exposed. Buffing health more and more so they can deal with taking hits from 9 different hexes leads to scaling issues when there are NOT attacks coming in from every conceivable angle. Hence the title; the most important change air terrain brings is it finally lets combat scale by partitioning combat in a soft way. Air dominance becomes a much more localized fight that is not binary for entire regions of the continent.
1
May 29 '14
As a pilit if I struggle to fight at lower altitudes I will simply not fly there. You are also taking away cover for air craft from other air craft like mountains and making a2a hover fights.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Then you are choosing to avoid risk and giving up the reward. The ground cover still exists, in fact I explicitly described several levels of soft and "hard" cover in the air (a puffy cloud to hide in will not save you from the bullet striking you, but it will give large advantages in dodging, losing a tail, turning the tables, and other nifty ideas that are impossible with the perfectly clear skies of the moment). Flying "slow" at ground level is still outrunning everything that is not an aircraft by an insurmountable margin.
1
May 29 '14
So would you change manuvering speed at ground level?
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Top speed and acceleration for sure. Yaw pitch and roll I really don't know what would be best but I'm guess some but not as severe.
1
u/Ketadine Upgrade NOW the control console May 29 '14
"Air terrain" would only make the air game even more detached from the rest of us. What is needed imo is to make A2G and A2A aircraft setups mutually exclusive or at least make them very inefficient at the other role.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I disagree. I think it would make the AvsG interplay more localized, which would improve the "attachment" air feels to a particular fight. The speed difference between A2G and A2A would hugely favor air combat as a multilayered dynamic where even if the same loudout can engage both, takes time to transition between.
1
u/Zcuron May 29 '14
Wouldn't this be somewhat similar in effect to hossin trees?
I'm a bit concerned about peeking in and out of this layer to fire off a few shots, then going just above it, but if we ignore that, I think the largest impact this will have will be on A2A fights as long as the idea is "clouds", and one can use said clouds as an LOS block in a dogfight.
I don't fly, but that strikes me as quite a liberating thing in terms of what you can do maneuverability-wise.
2
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14 edited May 29 '14
I am confident that would be a good change that would give much more exciting dog fights. When you watch a movie do planes endless circle in place until one gets a gun shot off? Only sometimes, and not as the end-all-be-all. Usually there are exciting chases and dodging locks and weaving in and out to break tailing wingmen off. In PS2 running is suicide because it is just open air with clear line of sight in every direction.
Edit: Also yes, hossin trees will have this effect, however this is coupling ground terrain with air terrain. It is one way to implement the air layer aspect (but not the details above that improve A2A). Some of the bases on the nexus have this effect as well. I would like to see these improvements added to more map area.
1
u/Zcuron May 29 '14
I'm just thinking that; if they share the effect, it'd be interesting to see it in action before anything's added.
So, a look at the hossin air game might give a better idea as to the numbers you'd want for cloud thickness & hight; the specifics in other words.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I would love to see that chain of events become reality. Even if the devs suddenly decided to idolize this idea and begin work immediately clouds would be a year out, so maybe, just maybe, threads like this with comments like yours connecting the concepts will, in fact, eventually lead to real improvements to the state of the air game.
1
May 29 '14
Then air craft would get very little flight space and when in a dog fight one could bail in to the cloud never to be seen again
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I argue it would expand the flight space by letting fights play out horizontally, where there is much more room. It gives obstacles that make running not suicide and gives tactical thought to maneuvers that trade altitude for other advantages, since diving into the canyons carries its own set of downsides.
1
May 29 '14
So lower the skill cealing? If you are going to run away you need to be good, not just hit the afterburner and go away in to the cloud were I can't see you and you don't have to dodge trees and bridges
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Do you really believe the current skydance as the only "legit" way to engage is particularly interesting? It doesn't take this away, and obviously fleeing puts you at a disadvantage. But now you can maneuver and attempt to turn the tables, instead of simply a death sentence. That heightens the skill ceiling and the floor considerably as well as broadens the gameplay as a whole.
1
u/snafucit [MERC] May 29 '14
So we are to be blind at high altitudes and go slower once we attempt to engage the ground, so deterrent based weaponry become hard counters? I hope you are aware that ground bases AA is just that, a deterrent. Not to mention ESF are already getting torn to pieces by this supposed deterrent and that is with it going as fast as they do. Your ideas are far to imbalanced in favor of ground and would do nothing but separate the two play styles reducing the Combined arms aspect of this game. Though I would be all for some cloud cover to be in the game it needs to stay a concealment option and nothing else.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
I hope you are aware that ground bases AA is just that, a deterrent.
Which is wrong. If it's up, it should go one to one with what it is specialized for.
Your ideas are far to imbalanced in favor of ground and would do nothing but separate the two play styles reducing the Combined arms aspect of this game.
Air can't have everything. Right now, it does (a galaxy is even better than a sunderer for base assault even).
I believe there is a lot of evidence that you can't balance aircraft for a large range of fights without making them the dominating factor. Air terrain would change that, but cosmetic only is not good enough.
1
u/snafucit [MERC] May 29 '14
Devs have stated multiple times that AA is a deterrent, it already scales to well in numbers so to buff it further in a 1vs1 breaks the air game completely. And if you think a galaxy is better then a sundy at base assaults then you are simply delusional man, last I checked a gal cannot allow non squad mates to deploy in it. Your idea is simply unrealistic and embraces separating combined arms, not to mention SOE would never in a thousand years waste time and resources on such a thing, still waiting on beta bugs to be fixed myself.
1
May 29 '14
This would make Liberators even more OP than they are now. All you would have to do is have someone on the ground spotting targets and directing fire. It would be like large scale orbital bombardment.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
That is not as easy feat as you are implying. Even with perfect gunners, your dps is now significantly reduced from sheer falloff on the tail (only a drake or walker will have the range) and losing the ability to contribute with the nose gun. Definitely not a buff, even for the kiter, and the hovering low altitude Lib becomes suicide as it always should have been.
2
May 29 '14
Most Libs don't use the nose gun from my experience. Some do but it's rare. Same thing for the tail gunner unless it's a bulldog. Most just circle and Dalton/Zephyr. Which have to be low to the ground if they are using Thermals so most go magnification and have spotters on the ground or inlarge the mini map and Q spot for the gunner. They would do the same thing in the "cloud" cover but now you wouldn't be able to lock on or shoot them.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
You already can't lock onto a lib at that far of a range. Long range shelling is frustrating, yes, but it is not the behavior that breaks gameplay people would like to see stopped first.
2
May 29 '14
Standing on Tech towers and Scared Mesa anything can be locked on too. What really breaks the game though is Liberators ability to eat flak damage like a bowl of Frosted Flakes and just keep on hammering you into your spawn. Even if you try to ESF and kill them they will just belly up with a shredder and waste you in less than a second.
1
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC May 29 '14
How is this anything but a nerf to air? There needs to be a possibility for Libs and ESFs to participate in big fights.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Because it means air can participate in a part of the fight without facing the AA wrath of the entire fight.
1
u/AmbyValkrine May 29 '14
Perfection.
0
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Too strong for a repost of a common idea. But I am somewhat proud of what I consider my novel contribution of the "sea level" limiting flight performance.
0
u/Fazblood779 Someone PLEASE Revive this game May 29 '14
shoots G2A rocket at ESF running hornet missiles ESF flies above clouds and breaks lock on Shoots missiles while above, then descends below to aim at target
Besides that, I'd love to see it happen!
2
u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver May 29 '14
>shooting hornets from cloud layer that is at 500m
>hornets have a range of 450m
1
u/Vaelkyri Redback Company. 1st Terran Valk Aurax - Exterminator May 29 '14
ground level is at 200m.
1
u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver May 29 '14
Unless OP wants the southern half of indar to in fact be entirely above the clouds, it would probably do well to have the cloud layer by 500m above the ground by relative altitude.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
500m is an example stand-in, not a suggested design goal. Rule of thumb I guess is somewhere between 1/3 and 2/3 of the total range (lowest point to flight ceiling). It does not have to be flat, featureless, uniform thickness, or unchanging height.
3
u/CobaltPhusion Game won't run. May 29 '14
Imagine the clouds rolling off the edge of the crown and TI-Alloys and such, tumbling down into j-908 creating a bowl of fog.
1
1
u/Fazblood779 Someone PLEASE Revive this game May 30 '14
Sorry, I was not aware of that. Thanks for correcting me :p
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Sounds like a fair use of terrain. If they are hoping in and out of the cloud layer then they are fairly high up for most bases. That different bases would be impacted differently is entirely intentional. 500 is not a hard number, just an anchor for conceptualization.
1
u/Fazblood779 Someone PLEASE Revive this game May 30 '14
Had another thought about it, and the idea actually seems fine :)
1
1
u/sockeye101 [RCN6] May 29 '14
Maybe this will pave the way to bring the flight ceiling back up to original values, or even extending it as high as 1500m, with 1000m of play for the aircraft. Make it come and go, so weather forcasts become an important part of gameplay, and things such as cloud cover, rain and fog become a major factor in strategy, both in the air and on the ground.
Then maybe we'll see those massive carriers come into play, and even a few floating bases as well... (Capturing the low-altitude AWACS facility???)
1
u/Harv3ster [QRY] | DA RINGER #WorldChamp May 29 '14
While i see your angle from where your comming from your solotions create more problems than fixing the scaling.
Below this layer, aircraft are operating at "sea level". This is a massive condensation and simplification of the real physics of flight, but cutting speed and maneuverability in half below the cloud layer would be perfectly fair and solve the #1 problem with AvsG - their ability to disengage before what are supposed to be hard counters can respond.
Lets actually think that through: My reaver goes with racer frame 265 while i slightly point my nose down and use up thrusters. The lib reaches while on his back using his thrusters around 250 and the gal goes around 200 i think.
So cut the speed in half , that means ESF max speed is 133 , libs reach 125 and galaxies 100 kph. That combined with half maneuverability every single aircraft will instally die. Why? Right now it takes around 4 sec. for a skyguard to TTK an ESF if it doesnt move . The only way i can survive that is by diving for cover and flying zick zack . Mostly i have like 50 % health left , with those speed and maneuverability cuts every esf pilot will die if he is below the cloud line. So the skilled pilots who fly for killing esfs will never be below the line , and just fly over it to gank other players. Libs will be waporized as soon as they get to low and galaxies well , they wont make it either. So the only place where pilots can be stay without dying in a second is above the 500m line. That would decrase the amount of players in the air cause there is no point in flying at all , Except to be ganked and the ground and air game will be complety seperated.
For those changes to happend there needs to be a complety revamp of the current AA scale but even than there will never be a perfect balanced because the unblance in this game happens due to players zerging and spamming vehicles which cannot be limited becaues there is of limiting player to play vehicles. The more players are involved the more harder it is to contain a balance. As soon as you reach a certain number of player doing a certain job , like playing AA in skyguard , a hex becomes a giant red sign of air. But if you dont have enough players doing it the hex becomes a giant red sign for ground players. Thats the problem of an open world FPS
0
May 29 '14
Go above cloud cover
Set waypoint
ez xp ez life
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
You know that doesn't work, right? If you are outside of render range, you can't hurt infantry, even if you theoretically manage to land a shell where they are standing.
1
May 29 '14
The cloud cover would be horizontal across the continent, right? If people are on a hill that put them in render range, ez xp ez life.
1
u/NocTempre Connery May 29 '14
Different terrain has different vulnerabilities. And if that terrain was especially high, there wouldn't be enough flight ceiling to escape up, it would be above the barrier and able to engage them unless they dived into the thicker atmosphere that would slow them down. It can go both ways.
-3
u/hejyhej VANU IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCT. WAKE UP SHEEPLE May 29 '14
Damn, I really wanted the only text in the body of this post to be:
"STFU"
16
u/Aozi May 29 '14
Soooo....What does this solve?
You're essentially creating an aircraft only zone that simply prevent ground from eliminating aircraft. While letting the air just bomb the ground forces. I mean even if you're shooting blind, with some coordination with ground forces, or simply hit markers and waypoints, you can still keep shooting down with no issues and you can still keep farming.
And you still keep peeking out, landing few shots down and then go back up before you take too much damage. NAR fixes you right up.
Does ground actually have any way to counter aircraft bombing them from above the cloud layer? Or would ESF's be the only possible option to counter that behavior?