r/Planetside • Miller • May 28 '14

Pilots: Do you use joystick or gamepad?

Perhaps it's stupid question, but I'm asking anyway. I'm a decent shooter player, and a decent game player overall. I played a lot of aircraft game with either console or joystick ( ahh X-Wing, Rouge Squadron, etc). Obviously these were single player, but I really felt comfortable with the controls. Thing is, flying with mouse and keyboard feels totally unnatural to me. I love mouse and keyboard for a shooter. But I can't fly like this. Is it worth getting a joystick / gamepad? Does it respond well? Thanks

3 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

8

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

I've not heard of anyone advocating anything but mouse+keyboard for flying in this game. I've not tried a joystick or gamepad myself, but from what I've heard the support isn't good enough for it to be worth it.

The mouse+keyboard aren't bad once you get used to them, they offer a lot of precision.

3

u/Jarcode [OO] RecursionPlayersAreBad May 28 '14

I use a Wii Remote with a Nunchuck for maximum precision.

2

u/Nlioc [AIM] May 28 '14

I would absolutely watch this

1

u/christianarg Miller May 28 '14

Alright thanks a lot. That's what I expected.

3

u/TollBoothW1lly [HNYB] May 28 '14

The biggest problem is not the way vehicles fly in PS2.. it is the HORRIBLE way that PS2 handles joystick input and there is no way to change it in game. Around the center the joystick is not very sensitive.. which is fine, but about half way through the range of motion on your stick, the sensitivity scale jumps dramatically. If SOE would make it a linear scale, or better yet, let you adjust the scale to your flying style, I would switch to joystick in a heartbeat.

4

u/Ausfall May 28 '14

The thing about using a joystick or gamepad is that aircraft in Planetside 2 don't handle the same way as other aircraft.

A typical air game will have controls for roll, pitch, thrust, brake, yaw and afterburners to control your aircraft.

Planetside 2 has all of that, in addition to vertical thrust and analog throttle, which means that roll, pitch, and yaw are used in completely different ways that frankly aren't conducive to a joystick setup. A reverse maneuver, for example, is much harder to pull off with a joystick while being much easier to master on a keyboard/mouse. You also lose out on the precision a mouse offers when you're trying to aim your weapons.

2

u/Sporadisk Jun 17 '14

..I get annoyed when people who clearly haven't been using a joystick for the kind of maneuvering they describe, repeat this particular bit of flimsy fiction. It's spreading like a meme, and when enough people parrot it it gets accepted as truth despite the obvious flaws in the reasoning.

1

u/Ausfall Jun 18 '14

I'll believe it when I see it. Video?

3

u/Sporadisk Jun 18 '14

PS2 has horrible joystick support, so that's out, but Here's a video from Diaspora, demonstrating a game with proper joystick support, wherein a joystick user easily controls the craft with precision.

Vehicles in diaspora can move along all axes of motion, including the use of sideways thrust, which a mouse user would struggle to be able to use without sacrificing one of the other axes. (like roll)

2

u/KarlisL [56RD] JoeSMokes May 28 '14

I haven't tried a game pad yet, but my X52 flight system did not play nice with PS2. Maybe a few days working with it I could have done something, but it did not go well. Mainly the problem is most PS2 aircraft behave nothing like a real aircraft, and the dog fights are nothing like an airplane dog fight.

2

u/X207Blitz TEST ACTUAL May 28 '14

I have a full flight simulator setup was well as a basic Xbox controller and neither of these got me anywhere close to being a good pilot. The core of the difficulty is that Planetside 2 does not appear to have the support necessary to use such a device coded into the game. Even after hours of play I still found myself going to my mouse in a panic to correct flat spins or uncontrolled barrel rolls due to being hit by something while piloting a galaxy.

My best recommendation is to find another player (if you're in an outfit start there) that has the piloting experience and can provide you with some training.

1

u/B4rr Bad Heavy on Twitch May 28 '14

Use mouse and keyboard. I have yet to meet a good pilot who will advise you otherwise.

The fly mechanics are pretty speciall anyway, so you have to get used to them anyway. Why not with the best if you ask most people possibility?

1

u/gimli217 [N] - Mattherson May 28 '14

I haven't met a single pilot that uses a joystick or gamepad...

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

I've used a joystick.

Don't. You can't do anything a2a, and it's only slightly better at a2g. Use a mouse

1

u/Skaner May 28 '14

I tried gamepad for a bit, ended up not liking it after a bit. Mouse and keyboard handle much better. The key is to set pitch up and pitch down to side mouse buttons so your not constantly pulling down or up on your mouse to make sharp turns.

1

u/andrei178 Eiji178 Oct 27 '14

I visited my parents' house over the weekend and then found this bad boy...

Imgur

"NOW USB COMPATIBLE" !! Welcome to the future.

15 years old and still solid!

I'm still a noob at piloting with KBM, and now I suck even more with this change in peripheral... but am totally enjoying the experience! I now spend an hour or two in VR to fly, and then try to farm points using my Engi before I log off...

Cheers to other pilots!