r/Planetside • It's still Waterson to me, dammit! • May 27 '14

What counters liberators?

8 Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

You don't counter Libs, Libs counter you... (aka Jackhammer Syndrome)

9

u/Marthalion [RMIS] - Cobalt May 28 '14

Hard counters:

  • ESF. You don't need any mad skills, you just need to not stay still in front of the lib and not fly below it. Long range sniping is easier than close range murder, but both are effective. Regardless of lib loadout, you have the upper hand in an ESF.

  • Another lib. Sneak up them, TB clip and let your gunner finish it.

  • Coordinated AA. ~3-4 simultaneous lock on sources will likely kill a lib before it can get away. Especially if combined with flak.

Soft counters:

  • AP round sniping. Remember to position yourself sneakily so you don't get spotted and taken down before you can do your stuff.

  • solo Flak. A lone flak source will drive a lib away, not kill it. Just remember to be in cover or the lib will kill you.

  • Dumb fire missiles. They do 50% dmg to a lib. But the lib needs to be reckless to be hit by one.

  • non-ap tanks. You need to position yourself to let your main gun point towards the sky. The lib will have the upper hand, but you'll be able to deal dmg and scare him off if he's caught unaware.

  • Battle gal. Bulldogs do nasty dmg to a lib and walkers will make it hard for the lib to run.

6

u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics May 28 '14

you have the upper hand in an ESF.

unless the lib has a dalton/shredder and the pilot is vaguely competent.

3

u/Marthalion [RMIS] - Cobalt May 28 '14

I can't say that I agree. Dalton shots are super hard to make. You will die to them but it won't happen often if you do as I wrote, don't fly under the lib.

As for shredder, it's powerless at mid+ distance because it's hard to aim vs a moving target at that distance.

I'll agree that it takes some getting used to to fight a lib. But it's not a matter of having to be über pro or even especially good. Of course the skill level needed also depends laregely on the lib crew. If they're über pro then you need to be at least good to take them down.

1

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

Shredder is definitely not hard to use at mid+ distance. This is coming from someone who just started to use the shredder because of how easily it melts Maxs, ESFs, tanks and really just about everything.

2

u/thelazyfool [VIPR] DropTheNaOH May 28 '14

At mid+ distance the dalton is largely luck, with skill helping to get shots close , then luck to make them hit.

Shredder is also very hard against anyone competent, as they will be moving around and you won't get more than a couple stray shots to hit.

1

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Yes, that is the ONLY thing when ESF get rekd. And I only know 1 lib crew on my/our server who can do that with a shredder - This is the deadliest thing I experienced so far in my ESF.. Nothing can be worse, comparing it to the dalton the dalton is a kobalt shooting at the lib.

3

u/B4rr Bad Heavy on Twitch May 28 '14

Dumb fire missiles. They do 50% dmg to a lib. But the lib needs to be reckless to be hit by one.

Since the lib update you need 3 Decis to kill it. The standard lauchers alwas were a 3 hit kill.

3

u/silentstormpt [🌈] eXist3nZ May 28 '14

yh if they run around with composite armor

2

u/squeaky4all Briggs May 28 '14

I like how you didn't even mention sky guards there, they are super useless unless 3 or more are in a group.

2

u/Marthalion [RMIS] - Cobalt May 28 '14

Skyguards are a power house and I do mention them. I just call it "flak" instead of saying "AA turret or Burster Max or Skyguard or Ranger". A lone skyguard in the open will be in trouble though. It can't kill you unless you're reckless/damaged so all you need to do is to get out, repair, sneak up on it and one clip it.

Do not underestimate the skyguard. It still does a lot of damage.

6

u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] May 28 '14

Personally I like to use the Air Hammer and Coyotes on my Reaver. I've been told it's super cheese-mode, but the versatility of the setup means I'm at least OK against anything I come across.

Air Hammer is hard to use when dogfighting an ESF but can almost one-clip them if you can catch them by surprise. It's made for farming infantry but works wonders against Liberators and Galaxies due to their large size. Considering all pellets hit and you're somewhat close, you can kill a Lib in ~2.5 magazines with AH alone.

Coyotes are great for ESFs but don't do a whole lot of damage to Libs. They are, however, exceptionally easy to get hits with on Libs, fire off fast, and reload quickly. During the 3 second AH reload I will usually fire off 1 or 2 volleys of Coyotes which helps my DPS.

If I get the jump on a farming Liberator from above and behind I will unload 7x AH shots, 2 volleys from Coyotes, then finish off with AH. All over in less than 8 seconds if you do it right.

Other setup are safer because they allow you to engage from long range. Mine is more for ambush and rapid ganking. Hope this helps.

4

u/Froyo_Baggins May 28 '14

AA nests do work, but it is all about location, timing, and awareness. If there is anything that obscures the AA nests vision it'll be used against them by any lib pilot that wants to go toe to toe with AA.

A2A battle Gals can work if they have decent aim and communication.

ESFs can work if it isn't an A2A lib crew.

Hiring your own A2A lib crew.

One thing I haven't seen is a MBT pack with AA secondary weapons manned. That could be quite effective if they stay mobile.

Sending misleadingly friendly /tells that bait responses to the pilot before you engage the Lib with two squads of walker/ranger/basilisk sundies.

Set down a spawn beacon and drop pod the wings. The super dense matter of drop pod debris is near impossible to correct for while flying. If you're lucky the trees, antennas, and rocks will take this time to shiv the Lib in the back to send a clear message to all aircraft.

3

u/Jmars04 [BRTD] MarseeeTR May 28 '14 edited May 28 '14

I mainly pilot libs and the most annoying thing for me is having 3 skygaurds and some MBTs in an area with AP rounds. If they stay fairly close and are in comms I don't want to mess with them unless there is some cover for my run up and easy cover to retreat into, south east of Indar is the easiest with all the canyons. If one MBT gets a shot on you with AP and 2-3 skygaurds start hitting you, you're in for a rough ride.

I've actually started seeing more MBTs with flak and walkers on Miller which can be annoying combined with a sundy with 2 walkers and skygaurds.

If I don't have any friendly ESFs around the area I will also be cautious when going to take skygaurds out as getting jumped by a ESF and getting hit by a skygaurd isn't fun.

If your flying an ESF, don't get close to my lib. I will always try and get close to you and finish you off quickly.

As for libs being balanced right now: If the proposed RPGs getting a faster bullet velocity comes true, it would be much easier to hit libs and would help alleviate the spawn camping with some skill on the RPG players side.

Just remember, there are usually 3 players working in a lib together. 3 players with skygaurds effectively puts a massive area out of bounds unless the skygaurds are not too good and can easily be flanked.

Skygaurd tip: Because I see a lot complaining about how OP libs are, most skygaurd players are completely useless. They sit in the same spot, with their ass in the same direction until they die. It only takes a good lib pilot a second to notice where you are shooting from, which direction your ass is in and they will flank and destroy you (If it's safe to do so and there aren't many ESFs about).

Move your skygaurd constantly. Fired at a lib or ESF? Move yourself 100m to a new location. When that lib/ESF comes back to shoot you in your ass, they have to adjust giving you more time and they will likely pull out. Even when your shooting at a lib, move constantly. A moving target can cause the tank buster to realign giving you more time to shoot.

Now imagine 2-3 skygaurds doing this, it's easy to counter a lib.

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

3 vehicles that are defenseless against anything but air are hardly a counter.

2

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

You have to realize the only thing a skyguard can kill is air while you can kill both air, vehicles and infantry. 3 skyguards can still not kill anything else and use a lot more resources than one liberator. The issue isn't how many people operate a liberator since then a harasser would be just as strong. The issue is how much resources are used to pull 3 skyguards each with their own cooldown.

It's easy to counter a lib but also very expensive. The liberator is incredibly cheap for the damage it can pull

1

u/Vaelkyri Redback Company. 1st Terran Valk Aurax - Exterminator May 28 '14

Any lib dieing to a battlegal has serious issues, Zephers will almost one clip a Whale due to weird resistance values. (7 shots will put on fire, 8 will kill), add in some glancing main gun rounds and you can drop a gal from full HP in under 4 seconds.

15

u/[deleted] May 27 '14 edited May 27 '14

m4d 5k1llz in an esf

there aren't many people who think libs are in a balanced spot right now, especially if you don't count lib pilots. Coordinating with several AA players helps, as does being very good in an esf, but other than that there's not a huge amount you can do short of staying indoors.

2

u/Daiwon May 28 '14

1/4 squad of lancers will see them off in a jiffy.

11

u/TaintedPaladin9 [OO] May 28 '14

Yea I'll break my lancer out right away.

3

u/Daiwon May 28 '14

How well does the phoenix handle? It seems like it'd make a decent AA weapon.

3

u/WarpTheWorld Miller May 28 '14

Phoenix is ok, but it only works vs hover/near hover air that's not too close and not too far away, a single hit will usually scare libs off though.

2

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

The phoenix missile travels about as fast as a thrown rock, and steers like a mule unless you have your ESF flight sensitivity up absurdly high. It packs a mean punch against aircraft if you can connect, but you're not going to connect unless the aircraft you're shooting at is braindead.

The 300m flight distance hardcap and limited field of view also means that you often can't even see the liberator if you're leading enough to actually hit it, and that your Phoenix will often fizzle out before even reaching them.

6

u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] May 28 '14

Phoenix is disgustingly slow, turns horribly, and has a max range of 300m. Unless they land near you for repairs you'll never get a hit. If you try to hit them a Phoenix while they're over-head you'll get some Shredder to the face and that will be the end of it.

3

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

Phoenix ought to have a single-use afterburner. The thing's already coded into the game as a reskinned ESF, it wouldn't even be hard.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

1

u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] May 28 '14

I'm not sure, either. If you're downvoting, try commenting on why you disagree with the post. The Phoenix is NOT an anti-air weapon. You can one-hit kill an ESF if you connect, but he's an idiot if he lets you. Phoenix is a decent weapon against close, stationary Sunderers out of line of sight, not for use on rapidly moving targets.

Lancer can be used against aircraft as long as they are in view and you have enough time to charge your shot for it to be effective. The projectile is fast enough that a skilled gunner can put the hurt on an ESF.

Striker is good for chasing off ESFs but doesn't normally do much to them. Each missile hits an ESF for ~15% IIRC. Against Liberators and Galaxies it seems to fair better as they have lower resistances to it.

2

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

I've let a phoenix land a hit on me. I felt so incredibly bad afterwards

1

u/Darchseraph May 28 '14

Prior to the Liberator Buff, the Phoenix was a credible threat to low flying liberators: being a 2-hit-kill meant that a squad of 4 could nuke Libs down with coordination.

Now I believe you need 3 rockets which is a little harder to coordinate as someone usually misses unless the Lib is literally hovering.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

They need to not move a lot, fly low and you need to have a decent position so yeah...not that great.

3

u/NocTempre Connery May 28 '14

Other libs. Equal skill and number ESFs have a 50/50, but the lib that gets the drop on another will kill it in under a second.

I find liberators are the most broken thing in the game right now, with the tankbuster and dalton being the primary offenders, the shredder is also too damn good at everything.

One non-nerf solution is to make AA Phalanx turrets with walkers and move the side cover to vertical cover. Adding a mana AA turret would also be a good move, especially with a shield that partially protects them from bombing.

6

u/Ausfall May 28 '14

ESFs engaging at long range. The default nosegun is very effective at landing hits on the liberator from ranges that are nearly impossible to respond to. At close range, ESFs with fuel tanks can literally fly circles around a liberator provided they can pull off their maneuvers properly. Use either long range or superior mobility to kill them off.

2-3 Heavy Assault troopers with lockons will make a liberator go away. Three rockets hitting it is a bit more than half of its health gone, and if the lib sticks around for another dosage it will be destroyed. If you abuse buildings and other cover that blocks air units, even one man can help deter a liberator. Same thing with MAX units equipped with burster cannons.

The thing to realize is (almost always) a liberator is at least two people working together. That means that you will also have to work together with someone else to take it down.

8

u/eriman [SGRD] Briggs May 28 '14

Whenever I'm in an ESF, I'll specifically stalk libs and engage with them using superior mobility to chip away at them from range.

TTK is so high that 95% of the time enemy air will show up to interfere or the lib will escape to ground AA or warpgate.

2

u/J50 Jaegarson May 28 '14 edited May 28 '14

Don't understand the downvotes here (I'll try to balance you out XD). If you're a good ESF pilot, it really isn't that hard to solo good lib crews. Being on waterson, there are tons of good pilots; libbing really isn't that OP because it's only a matter of time (short) before a PREY pilot takes you out..

I'm tired of these posts; there is nothing wrong with lib balance. Get decent in an ESF and start using it - they destroy libs. That being said, I really do think that the shredder is too powerful. It is ridiculous what it can do to skyguards.

6

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Don't understand the downvotes here (I'll try to balance you out XD). If you're a good ESF pilot, it really isn't that hard to solo good lib crews.

I 100% agree with you.

I'm tired of these posts; there is nothing wrong with lib balance. Get decent in an ESF and start using it

I can see where people are coming from, though. It's frustrating to feel like you need to spend dozens of hours, or scores of hours, or even hundreds of hours on something you don't really care about just to deal with a single kind of threat.

I really, really don't want libs to be easily counterable by every inexperienced solo player, and I don't want libs to fall back into the lull they were in for a while. One can see, however, where people get frustrated, where they think that "wasting as much of his time as he's wasting of mine" doesn't feel good enough and they want a kill.

Shooter players are trained to get kills, and when they die (10 second respawn) to deal heavy damage to a lib and scare it off (20-40 seconds to repair and come back, either landing or with NARS) they feel like they didn't really do anything.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

I can see where people are coming from, though. It's frustrating to feel like you need to spend dozens of hours, or scores of hours, or even hundreds of hours on something you don't really care about just to deal with a single kind of threat.

This is the biggest problem with lib balance right now. Even if ESFs are the best way to take them out, they are difficult to pilot and losing your ESF is too punishing. There needs to be more ways to respond to liberators.

3

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

they are difficult to pilot

Not really sure how to fix that, without adding a new anti-lib option that takes little skill. That wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing, but it brings more than a few issues.

losing your ESF is too punishing.

It's not so bad for someone with a maxed timer and/or membership. (I don't have the latter, for the record.)

That's one of the big problems with learning to fly, though. The more you need the practice, the less access you have to it. They really need to get the Resource Revamp (especially the stage that removes vehicle cooldowns) out as soon as possible.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Not really sure how to fix that, without adding a new anti-lib option that takes little skill. That wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing, but it brings more than a few issues.

I'm going to do as I have done very often in the past and draw from my experience in Enemy Territory: Quake Wars.

An important distinction between the aircraft in ET:QW compared to Planetside 2 is that in ET:QW, aircraft are able to yaw far, far faster, allowing a player to rotate the aircraft quickly without having to roll and pitch (rolling and pitching the aircraft, however, is still considerably faster and more accurate, so better pilots would continue to use that).

By default, in ET:QW, the game effectively gives you "training wheels" - you physically can't roll or pitch the aircraft beyond certain angles, allowing new pilots to get used to the vehicles' speed, handling and aiming without worrying too much about exact orientation in space and plummeting to the ground. This is acceptable in that game precisely because yawing is fast and a valid option.

The game also featured an option in the options menu called, "Advanced Flight Control", which effectively took the training wheels off and allowed you full control of the aircraft. More advanced pilots would turn this option on in order to pitch and roll faster than the aircraft can yaw and, among other things, improve their dogfighting performance by allowing them to perform more advanced manoeuvres.

This implementation certainly has its own issues - it does nothing to teach new players the advanced manoeuvres used in high-skill dogfighting - but it does lower the skill floor without buffing aircraft or lowering the skill ceiling, by removing some factors unique to aircraft and making them pilot more similarly to infantry or ground vehicles.

2

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

This implementation certainly has its own issues - it does nothing to teach new players the advanced manoeuvres used in high-skill dogfighting - but it does lower the skill floor without buffing aircraft or lowering the skill ceiling, by removing some factors unique to aircraft and making them pilot more similarly to infantry or ground vehicles.

If they can implement it, it sounds like as good a solution as any I've heard.

5

u/7303 [TIW] G7303H - Waterson May 28 '14

No it definitely is too powerful right now. Balance was great before the lib update, but they buffed too many resistances. I've been solo libbing a lot these past few months and even while solo it is quite obvious that libs are soaking up more damage than it should. It is way too hard for infantry to actually counter liberators right now and really easy to farm the crap out of infantry, especially at smaller fights.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Lib pilot here: If you lose/retreat from 6 people or less you are simply bad. True story.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Hell juat stay away from the tail and when it does the belly turn just reverse manuvere away

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '14 edited May 28 '14

A2A ESFs, flak, other libs, and lock on launchers to a certain extent.

The only thing that kills a lib easily is another lib. But the other things definitely "counters" them.

Also, AP Prowlers angled up.

Also, again, do the libs really suck that bad on Miller? I very often scare them away with just my ESF, keep your distance and theres not much they can do, if you are running low on health just run away for a bit. (Im not a very good pilot)

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

Deterrence != counter.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Sure, but it can be both, I would even go as far to say that to be an effective deterrence, it would also need to be a counter.

Well, just because they can avoid dying from something doesnt mean that thing doesnt counter them.

It would only be a deterrence if it was actually dangerous. The problem is flak and lock ons cant chase them down to kill them, and ESFs dont always do enough damage to kill them before they find friends.

4

u/AvatarOfErebus [ISK] Saskara - Miller May 28 '14

Q:What counters liberators? A:More liberators.

3

u/Jarcode [OO] RecursionPlayersAreBad May 27 '14

Burster MAXes, skygaurds, base AA turrets, lockon rockets, ESFs, other liberators, and AP tank rounds.

If you coordinate with the different counters, the same way a lib pilot coordinates with a gunner to attack ground targets, you're fully capable of killing liberators.

6

u/PKwolf [HIVE] May 28 '14

Double walker sundies, scary shit and as rare as a unicorn.

2

u/shockwave414 May 28 '14

And then a fury flash takes out the sunderer...

11

u/Kierlak NC at heart May 28 '14

the same way a lib pilot coordinates with a gunner to attack ground targets

lol

"Is it yellow in thermal without a tag the same color as our faction?"

"Yeah."

"Shoot it."

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

My favorite saying while libing, "Glowing and no tag showing, Charon will come rowing."

2

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] May 28 '14

Nice. I'm totally going to steal that.

2

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Maybe at a farm, sure, but some fights aren't cakewalks and the crew needs to make real decisions about who/how/when to shoot first. Drawing attention too early can mean the difference between a kill and getting shot down.

Besides that, sometimes the pilot can't give his gunners angle unless they tell him what they're shooting and where it is, he doesn't have omni-directional view.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

So, the way almost every vehicle has to play? Just telling someone to not shoot something for a few seconds?

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

So, the way almost every vehicle has to play?

Most don't directly depend on it for the entirety of their usefulness. Harrassers are in a similar boat, but for the rest you can get a good chunk of the value without even having a gunner at all.

Just telling someone to not shoot something for a few seconds?

That's most of what gets said between pubby crews, but folks who know each other can put the comms to a lot more use.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

Harassers.

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Liberators can't get maxed-engie-tool-strength repairs on the go like the old harrassers could, they're limited to FS and NARS. That's at least one big difference.

2

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

Harassers aren't immune to small arms fire and can't travel at 200+ miles an hour. That's at least one big difference.

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Harrassers can be spawned at any base, and cost fewer resources. That's another big difference.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker May 28 '14

Liberators cost less resources than an MBT despite being considerably more powerful.

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 27 '14

RLs are not op....oh wait... What stresses me out as a lib pilot are:

1.) Tanks obviously try to get a firing angles and secondary focused fire. 2.) Flak that obscures my belly gunner. 3.) G2a lockons on the perimeter of the fight. 4.) Enemy air.

2

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 28 '14

We generally deploy Air Canada.

0

u/fodollah [ECUS] Lead Waterson Penetrator May 28 '14

ahahahahahaha

1

u/ChipJiggins [Actual, Chip] May 28 '14

Basilisks

1

u/SpoonageVS May 28 '14

I discovered that shouting on /yell to piss off is a good way to have 5 libs suddenly above your base. So don't try that.

I do think that using my lock-on annihilator is helping somewhat as they usually fly away after the second rocket hits them.

1

u/Vaelkyri Redback Company. 1st Terran Valk Aurax - Exterminator May 28 '14

1/2 a squad with lock on AA.

"lock in 3, 2, 1,"

"lock","lock","lock","lock","lock".

"Fire."

5

u/Huller_BRTD TO THE CROOO- *slap* May 28 '14

"oooh wait, he flared"

"aaand he's coming this way, wonderfull"

2

u/Vaelkyri Redback Company. 1st Terran Valk Aurax - Exterminator May 28 '14

scatter, pop shields, wait 5 seconds and repeat.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Pop shields? lol

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Allow me to display my finest colors whilst moving at a very reduced speed. You're welcome.

1

u/Aetrion May 28 '14

The singular counter to Liberators is to get enough firepower in one place to make it impossible for them to stay there for longer than half a second, then watch them blow up because there is no way to realize this fact before the game renders the threat.

1

u/anmr May 28 '14

Ramming with gal

1

u/PurpleWolff FCLM May 28 '14

AA it may not seem like ur doing anything to it but when I'm soloing or piloting aa does so much damage and add a couple more aa and it's hell for pilots, you can also pull other libs and secs but it's 50/50 and depends on skill

1

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] May 28 '14

As TR i pull a double burster, extended mag, lockdown max with full flak. They will fly away for at least 45 seconds.

Thats IF I can hit them from the spawn room or some sort of cover. If you deploy lockdown you basically make yourself a huge target for dalton/ TB runs.

Lets assume I get him to run away. Now I'm stuck with a max unit and blew half my infantry resources. The lib merely goes to another base to farm.

I look forward to the resource revamp. That will do something to alleviate this problem.

The ability to deconstruct and reclaim some of those resources would do wonders too.

1

u/CobaltPhusion Game won't run. May 28 '14

ESFs, Skywhales, and other liberators.

Which still may not do it because all a lib needs is one second of visibility and a landed shot with the dalton (why not, from full health, to burning?) and all your work is gone.

1

u/SirGaz May 28 '14

When you're in a Lib camped spawn room, Phoenix.

The force field strip that makes part of the roof/floor for the fortifications, you can shoot through that. So find a angle that points through a hole in the canopy above the fortification and just steer it into a parked Lib. I don't know how much damage a Phoenix does to a Lib but it gives you 4 surface to air bounces for 1 hit so it's got to be a lot.

1

u/ILIEKDEERS DEEEEEEEEERS May 28 '14

Cswic.

In all seriousness, positioning. Which counters nearly every thing in the game. From air to armor to infantry.

1

u/Wtfisthisgamebtw NotProOrion May 28 '14

No one mentioned this but, get 3 ESFs who have Hornets and 6 missiles should do the job.

1

u/Jerthy [MCY]AbneyPark from Miller May 28 '14

All you need is 2 ESFs with default noseguns (eventually lockons) attacking from a distance (and KEEPING the distance). There is nothing lib can do about it except for bringing a lot of lube.

NC can also go with airhammer up close but that is quite a loterry.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

That only leads to a kill if the lib is deep in enemy territory. Outside of that the lib just smiles and moves on. What are you gonna do? Tickle him to death with six magazines? By that time he is already so deep in his territory that multiple ESFs will engage you.

1

u/Jerthy [MCY]AbneyPark from Miller May 28 '14

So you want to be able to snipe libs surrounded by allies? If he's got an escape plan he should be able to escape no?

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

No the question was "what counters a lib" and what you describes doesn't counter a lib for said reasons. It only works if the lib is very deep into enemy territory.

-1

u/TGangsti may contain traces of irony or sarcasm May 28 '14

yawn coordinated, multi-source and type aa-fire - can't repeat that often enough

If you can't lock on it, it can't kill you simply for the fact that G2A is 400m, while infantry rendering is 300. With a lib that high you want your vehicle to keep moving to be a less predictable target. A dalton round takes up to 3s to impact depending on altitude, a shredder simply doesn't deal that much of a damage anymore.

I'm getting tired of these daily based nerf libs/buff aa topics. AA is pretty damn fine right now, most of the players just simply can't use it properly.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

^ libplayer

0

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

^ can't even fly a lib or what?

-1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Jobes

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

my 3/3 lib yesterday got nearly insta-gibbed by three burster maxes. So Teamwork is my answer. ESFs, other libs, tanks can hit libs pretty easy, burster maxes. A couple lock ons will do it if the group works together. I feel most people complaining about libs is because they expect to be able to take pot shots at them like they do a tank without working with other people around them. Because a lib is agile and can outdistance quickly you have to do burst damage to the lib and hit it as a group.

1

u/Tibuski May 28 '14

So because you came with a lib, 3 randoms needs to spend resources in a max (if they have the resource), buy a second AA because they only have one by default and either : die because you will at least kill one while leaving or succeed but are now left with a useless Max... Of course, dedicated lib farmer is back in the next 2 minutes because he has low cool down or another team member pulled a lib for him.

The problem is that, even if some people find the lib nice because it require 3 people etc etc etc ... it generates so much frustration to infantry people that just want to play the game and try to defend/attack a base on the ground !

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14 edited May 28 '14

So because I had to spawn a lib, and dump certs in it for high g 3, buy a dalton, dump certs into that for zoom/thermal,reload, ammo capacity, buy a bulldog, dump certs into that for ammo cap, thermal, mag capacity, buy a tank buster, dump certs into ammo cap, mag cap, zoom, dump certs into afterburners, and dump certs into nanites you think you should be able to kill that with 1-2 people? Oh not to mention that WE ACTUALLY are working as a team and have trained to get good together. But your pubbies should just be able to wreck us without even speaking to one another huh.

edit: Libs are a little to tanky right now and need their resistances looked at maybe. My problem is everyone is crying nerf, which SOE has proven they don't do very well. Non-TR air had a very dark period when the striker was OP and I don't want the lib to become useless again. We do not need a 3 manned high skill ceiling vehicle to become what Zoe has.

1

u/Tibuski May 28 '14

you didn't get my point.

It is a credit to you that you spent so much cert in the actual best farming method in the game, I don't argue against that, you are following the actual game rules.

The problem, is that the fun of 1, 2 or 3 people ruins the fun of PLENTY of people on the ground :)

-1

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Just for you because it seems like you are too lazy to search in the SOE forum for the stupid liberator complain... What counters liberator who either fly or spawncamp hover:

FLAK-turrets, AV-Turrets, AV-Mana Turrets, Decimator, Standart Rocker Launcher, Lock-On Launcher, dumbfire from AA launcher, burster MAX, AV-MAX, MBT tank rounds, light tank rounds, skyguards(!!), more skyguards, other liberator: tankbuster, dalton, shredder, bulldog, walker; ESF, other ESF, friendlies, galaxy ramming, galaxy weapons, sunderer basilisks, sundy walker, sundy ranger (in mass), some MBT secondarys, trees and terrain.

Need more or are you happy now? Do not argue with me that the lib is not uncounterable or super OP, the discussion will hurt and I have the experience in libs, but also on their counters and what CAN counter them..

2

u/CobaltPhusion Game won't run. May 28 '14

Now how does that work for a small fight?

Libs are notorious for ruining small skirmishes by obliterating anything that moves.

Or when the lib is directly over you?

The planetside 1 liberator was a bomber done right. Not this "lol hover over you until you die cause you can't hit me" BS they are now.

0

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

That is the time where I pull an ESF if it is 1 lib, and 99% the time the lib camping small fights will die.

And in big fights libs get smashed so hard that they can't even live flying 1 round above..

And libs in Planetside 1 were something totally different, so I am not going into this.

1

u/CobaltPhusion Game won't run. May 28 '14

planetside 1 libs were completely different

That's the idea. They were better skill based bombers.

0

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

If you do want Planetside 1 libs, the whole ps2 game needs an overhaul. Every weapon for AA or that damages Air would need to be rebalanced. The whole airgame was different in ps1, that just does not work.

If you give libs this mechanic right now, they are more useless shit than Flashes. I tried flying the last days and it just got worse.. You can not FLY, even if you are experienced, because every bigger fight is being spammed with skyguards @ every corner, lock-ons from ground and other tank shooting you + FLAK turrets/MAXes everywhere. Try to fly somewhere else? OK, the only place would be the really small fights you called where libs only spawncamp. But they do it because nothing else is possible. And even then, ESF will be your hardest counter to beat and they are everywhere and can be spawned by everyone and learned how to fly.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

We are talking about at least average skilled libs. Sure, bad pilots like you think decis or av mana turrets are a counter but that doesn't matter at higher skilllevels.

1

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Yea, bad pilots like me.. Not like I spend hunderds of hours in a lib and in a Mossy that I should know it.. Totally not... Sorry but it is getting ridiculous with these complains about the lib. Fly it yourself in prime time and freaking show me how you do it as good as people say it is. Uncut, maybe more sessions after that. Then I show you how to kill libs with an ESF, if you really need one. Only thing that makes the lib dangerous is and ever was the Shredder! And everyone complained about the Dalton, which was NEVER a problem, but the Shredder...

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

If you think an AV mana turret is a counter to a lib you are a bad pilot. There is no way around it.

1

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Well as you can see I wrote "hoverlibs" meaning the spawncamp libs. They are the PROBLEM so many people talk about in the forums.. aren't they? I talked about the general things that can counter the lib, inclouding these stupid spawncampers.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

No, those are mostly unskilled players like you and not the problem

1

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Sorry, but later this day I'll make quotes from SOE forum where I prove you that ppl complain about hoverlibs. And if you say unskilled -> Yes, but also people complaining about them are unskilled players. Sorry but I can't see any good arguments rather than "he's a lib pilot"; "only unskilled...." from you, show me your character stats and prove me otherwise that you can fly lib yourself, otherwise these are only stupid theses that come out of a stupid player. Prove me wrong, but the argument "you are unskilled and a bad pilot" is not even true, because I CAN PROVE you otherwise.

-1

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

Liberators are overpowered and you think AV turrets can counter them. That shows that you are unskilled. Simple as that.

Wathever you find on the forum doesn't matter, that has nothing to do with the topic.

2

u/Danielpxp Ceres May 28 '14

Wow, simple as that, you are dumb.. Sorry but did you even read my posts? Get serious, please. You are the unskilled here.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

I'm not the one claim that an AV turret can counter a lib so no, I'm afraid you are the dumb & unskilled one.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ May 28 '14

I have known Daniel for over a year now. He is one of the best pilots on ceres and he can hold his own on other servers too. Don't be fooled by the anti-tank natur of the turrets:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tpiUI7niRU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fq9_0A8tVx4

(disclaimer: vids by the glorious InFlamess not Danielpxp)

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14 edited May 28 '14

The only thing that is a COUNTER to liberators is multiple ESFs.

Yeah. If they're alone in the sky, I'm often capable of taking a lib solo, but if I have even a single capable wingman I know we're getting the kill.

Everything else - lock ons, skyguards, burster maxes, etc, are a deterrent, not a counter.

I'm not necessarily sure that's a problem. Bursters can easily swap loadouts, and lockon users don't have to swap loadouts. Skyguards have a little more of a base to argue from, but they seem to have the overall most flexible ground-based AA weapon, and their mobility means they'd be a huge problem if they were made much stronger.

2

u/squeaky4all Briggs May 28 '14

Skyguards would be in a good place if their flak exploded on impact, not just in proximity of an aircraft, being able to suppress infantry or other tanks would be worth it.

3

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Skyguards would be in a good place if their flak exploded on impact, not just in proximity of an aircraft

They'd be anti-everything, then.

1

u/squeaky4all Briggs May 28 '14

They are mediocre at best against air. Giving them some potential would at least make it worth while pulling one even if the air decides to fuck off.

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

They are mediocre at best against air.

That adds up, if everyone were pulling them. No-fly zones would get pretty ubiquitous if Skyguards were as good at killing ground vehicles as they were at killing air. That's just assuming that they wouldn't be better at AV than the designated AV cannons.

2

u/squeaky4all Briggs May 28 '14

I didnt say to make them good at ground, just mediocre but with the flak exploding on hit with ground or other vics they could be very good at suppressing targets.

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

just mediocre but with the flak exploding on hit with ground or other vics they could be very good at suppressing targets.

Are you saying the explosions would do a lot less damage to ground targets than they do to air?

Maybe that'd work, then. We'd have to see how it plays out.

0

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

He means suppressing fire with flinch.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

When the most almost anything can do to a vehicle in this game is damage it enough to make it take a short time to go repair, it's overpowered.

If I'm being honest, something feels a little . . . off about the current state of Composite Armor. I think that if there's a real issue it lies there.

Skyguard buffs aren't really the way to fix that, I don't think.

4

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

The problem imo is that Liberators have high damage and high health right now. If you lower the health, you will never see a liberator over a big battle just like before. If you lower damage, then what is the point of a liberator. Why not just make it a galaxy.

2

u/davegod May 28 '14

The problem imo is that Liberators have high damage and high health right now.

and high mobility

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

2

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

It takes them like 21 seconds to kill one.

Depends on how close they are, how many shots land, and what they have equipped. Under "ideal" conditions, a skyguard can kill a liberator in under fifteen seconds. Under more realistic conditions, though, it might be 30+.

That said, giving more killing power than that to the fastest tank in the game (a tank which only requires one crew member to operate at 100% strength) could be an issue. If Libs don't have enough counters, we should look somewhere other than the vanguard when trying to fix that. It has its niche, due to its mobility.

5

u/silentstormpt [🌈] eXist3nZ May 28 '14

For a vehicle that cant do almost anything else besides AA once it pulls a skyguard turret (and is stuck with it) seems reasonable.

4

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

One crew to operate doesn't really mean much. The harasser requires 2 crews to operate and 3 crews at max strength. Should they be equivalent to a liberator? Should I be able to swat it out of the sky.

A liberator has the option to kill everything. A skyguard is laughable at killing anything but air and even air now is pretty laughable to try to kill. The liberator doesn't have a niche. It just kills everything.

It already has been proven that after the recent buff, skyguards require at least 20s.

0

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Should I be able to swat it out of the sky.

Why should the harasser be the one to easily win? That's not "equivalent" at all.

It already has been proven that after the recent buff, skyguards require at least 20s.

The recent buff to composite armor, you mean?

If there's a problem with a specific equippable, that equippable should probably be the thing addressed.

3

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

Why should the harasser be the one to easily win? That's not "equivalent" at all.

You made a point that the tank only requires one crew member to operate. That doesn't really mean much. The question is, are there appropriate enough counters to a liberator to justify the high firepower and high durability that it has.

You aren't taking into also that it is cheaper to pull a liberator than the counters for the liberator. So resource cost is also very important.

IMO the simple solution is the following:

  1. Make the skyguard more powerful up close. Liberators should be taking a very large risk in getting close to a skyguard. This still allows them to stay in battle since they can maintain high altitude over a skyguard.

0

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

That doesn't really mean much.

It means something, though. People won't use a vehicle that requires two or three people to be effective if they can get even the same effectiveness from a one-man vehicle. Likewise, people aren't likely to pull a vehicle that requires two or three people to be effective if it dies easily and reliably to one-man vehicles.

You aren't taking into also that it is cheaper to pull a liberator than the counters for the liberator. So resource cost is also very important.

"Per person", sure, but total? A lib costs more than a skyguard. If three people pulled skyguards, that'd cost more, but I'm not arguing a lib should survive hovering near three skyguards. If they're doing that now, I agree, that's a problem.

2

u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) May 28 '14

It means something, though. People won't use a vehicle that requires two or three people to be effective if they can get even the same effectiveness from a one-man vehicle. Likewise, people aren't likely to pull a vehicle that requires two or three people to be effective if it dies easily and reliably to one-man vehicles.

Yet a Galaxy still exists and is useful. What matters isn't how many ppl the vehicle carries but the role the vehicle serves. Conclusion: How many people are in a vehicle to make it 100% effective doesn't matter.

"Per person", sure, but total? A lib costs more than a skyguard. If three people pulled skyguards, that'd cost more, but I'm not arguing a lib should survive hovering near three skyguards. If they're doing that now, I agree, that's a problem.

There are so many perks a Liberator gets that it is absurd to think that the equivalent should be 3 skyguards. And that is why I had a solution I added. Make the skyguard do more damage up close. It will balance the fight in the air by quite a bit since you won't remove the Lib but you won't make the skyguard so weak.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

21 seconds is the maximum fastest ttk against a certless lib, when the skyguard has maxed reload speed.

Have you timed it yourself? Go try it in VR right now. Within the maximum damage range, landing every shot, you can do it in just under 15 seconds.

If you add composite armor and fire suppression that shoots up to over 25 seconds to kill the lib. If you have 100% accuracy.

I acknowledged that.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

That's exactly what I did, and I got 21 seconds.

Are you sure you didn't miss? Are you sure you had all the upgrades on the lightning? Are you sure you didn't take any unnecessary pauses?

You must have been shooting a damaged lib.

I made sure it was freshly respawning each time.

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '14

[deleted]

1

u/Suradner [TEST] Adner (Mathemerald) May 28 '14

Yep. You're making me doubt myself now.

Legitimately sorry about that.

Maybe I'm mixing it up with a dual burster max..?

I don't know the time on a burster MAX, so I can't say if that makes sense. I only tested the skyguard because someone was making a claim a week or so back that seemed fishy.

Were you using an actual stop watch?

Didn't have one on hand, I used a timer and recorded how many seconds had elapsed. That's I've been saying "near fifteen" or "just under fifteen" instead of exact times. Maybe I messed it up, but I'll have to kick myself if I was off by six or seven seconds every time.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Syfoon memeralds penis king May 28 '14

Skyguards are pack animals.

Get a couple of pals, focus fire and watch 'em fall out of the sky.