r/Planetside • • May 26 '14

When will the air portion of the game improve?

When will AA get a nerf? Burster maxs and sky guard can destroy an esf in 2-3 seconds. When will soe make air game better? I feel like I am flying paper in the sky.

The amount of time and effort we put in to be decent pilots, is all countered by weapons, that require 1/100th of the skill to use. Mattiace did a good job of explaining why there should be a balance for skill, not just weapons. http://youtu.be/F7AxfS3FHTQ

What are your opinions on AA as pilots, and what are your opinions on AA when playing the role of AA?

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

13

u/Jarcode [OO] RecursionPlayersAreBad May 26 '14 edited May 26 '14

When will AA get a nerf?

Flak isn't as bad as some people complain it is. It definitely needs a damage dropoff (so flak stops interfering so much with A2A fights at high altitudes), but that's about it. And you'd have to be careful about nerfing any type of flak too, since liberators don't need an easier time squashing small and medium sized fights on the ground.

Mattiace did a good job of explaining why there should be a balance for skill, not just weapons.

I wouldn't reference Mattiace's discussions. While he has some really good points, he has an extremely biased and elitist view on ESF pilots that has gotten the majority of this subreddit to dislike him.

What are your opinions on AA as pilots

  • G2A tracking was changed so that you can use terrain to dodge locks, which I absolutely love. It's a skill based counter that actually lets me enjoy dealing with G2A locks.

  • Flares were fixed (not sure when) so that they are reliable at dodging locks now, so if I am going after ground targets in an ESF, not only do I have a skill based counter in my arsenal, but also a button that throws the lock off for me.

  • Flak costs resources to pull and is easily avoidable. The only exceptions to this are base AA turrets, which can be countered by pretty much anything on the ground (infiltrators, C4, tanks, dumbfires).

If you're going to ask me what's wrong with the air game in Planetside 2, it's going to be the horribly frustrating air-to-air combat that has turned into a Coyote and A2AM fest on most servers. And I could rant on about those, but other pilots and myself have already expressed their concerns with air-to-air balance with no response from SOE. But flak and G2As, in my opinion, isn't overpowered at all.

1

u/Spazmonkey1949 Apocalith-Briggs- May 26 '14

If Coyote has wrecked air so much, do you think the game would just be better without them?

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Wont happen. Coyotes haven't wrecked the game, they changed it. Still really sucks for newbie flyers but nosegun flyers are pretty bad to them as well.

3

u/Spazmonkey1949 Apocalith-Briggs- May 26 '14

Yeah it makes it pretty inaccessible to new players. I have tried to go into the Air a few times, but normally within 30 seconds Im locked on and dead. No idea where its coming from or how to evade.

4

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

A2a lockons are more frustrating for me than coyotes (any weapon fusillqde is deadly) because a pilot cannot learn to dodge/shoot the missile. I almost never break a lockon attempt w/o using cover. My favorite thing is to turn on the lockon user and afterburner within no lock range but them suckers are quick.

5

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

AA does what it is supposed to which is ward off flyers and destroy clumsy ones.

6

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

So what kills the good ones?

"LOL OTHER AIRCRAFT"

If the counter to a thing is itself, the thing is broken. I'm tired of "deterring" flyers with my expensive, dedicated tank.

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Depends on what good means. Just because a pilot flies high out of reach/sight doesn't make them aces. Just mindful of groundfire.

At a certain height only air can counter air. Arguably g2g lockons are more a deterrent than killer of tanks as well. They make me pop smoke and back off all the time. Air has a lot of freedom of movement so competent pilots use it to their advantage.

Re: skyguards, I suck with mine so I can't argue it but as an esf flyer they are not something to take lightly. I think the main problem is fighters can be nasty almost stock while not everyone can pull skyguards.

3

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

The big issue is that air can kill ground at those ranges (cough cough Libs) so ground needs to be able to counter air at those ranges.

Devs have stated multiple times that they don't like "Couldn't do anything about that" deaths. Well, that's how every single death to aircraft is right now for me. I'm in a Magrider, Lib flies over, might as well hop out and redeploy.

Hell, even in my Skyguard, a Lib flies by at 800 meters and I pretty much have to nope out. There's nothing I can do but prolong the death, no way to avoid it. It WILL kill me, and I can't do anything about it.

1

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Imagine if all those dead tankers rage pulled fighters and attacked. An ace pilot may be able to fight off a half dozen (seen it) wobbly pilots but a lib would have to get lucky and is a big target.

1

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

I got a rage tell from EvilBert (you may not know of him, big farmer'pilot on Mattherson TR) when I rammed his Lib to death with my Scythe yesterday.

The problem is that if I die in my tank and go back to the spot where I got killed, the Lib won't be there. That famous air vehicle maneuverability, and he's long gone.

1

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Libs don't go that far unless they get shot up.

2

u/SentienceIssues Not affiliated with SentientOne May 26 '14

Why are you assuming that AA is the hard counter to air when, generally speaking, air hard counters itself.

2

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

Because something besides air has to counter air. That's the whole point. Otherwise, whoever wins the fight in the air enjoys complete superiority and farms to his heart's content. Kinda like Liberators are doing right at this very second.

This isn't a MOBA. When there are no other Champions (aircraft) around, you should still have to fear the minions (ground units) that you're trying to farm.

2

u/SentienceIssues Not affiliated with SentientOne May 26 '14

The soft counters act as a deterrent. The hard counter is not acting in isolation because of the softer counters on the ground.

If your air is still getting killed with all the lock on options available (air and ground) then I'm not sure what to suggest.

3+ skyguards will stop almost all air entering an area. 5 or more and you've completely stopped them functioning.

That's right. 5 guys can stop any number of liberators functioning in an area as long as they don't ignore their flanks.

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Air superiority is a goal that needs to be achieved for exactly that reason. There should be a constant struggle for superiority and if there isn't what can be done to fix that.

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

Air superiority currently trumps all other types of superiority. That should not be the case.

1

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

That's how modern warfare is. So more people need to fly.

1

u/rj88631 [DOG]RobMichael May 26 '14

AA is a hard counter up close. I pull AA a lot of the time and I find this fair. An ESF or Lib flying far away, I can usually use a Skyguard to keep him away. If he comes straight at me or my friends? I make him eat dirt.

I feel AA is pretty balanced ATM. Air shouldn't be able to fly directly at AA.

1

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

Except that air CAN fly straight at AA. It's the easiest way to take out a Skyguard with a Lib or a Gal.

A Lib can face-tank a Skyguard long enough to TB it into oblivion, even from the front. That's not balance.

1

u/ILIEKDEERS DEEEEEEEEERS May 26 '14

Good pilots know when to engage bases. Too many G2A lock ons? Better hit shift and find a different base to lolpod.

4

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] May 26 '14

Until you have spent time as both a skyguard driver and a pilot I think your opinions will remain biased towards one direction.

I think that the skyguard is in a pretty good place right now honestly.

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Maybe before lightning availability buff it could have used some more magazine size.

2

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] May 26 '14

Ehhh, maybe but it's enough to gib a careless ESF and drive a liberator away if you pick your battles. Two or more tend to do terrible things.

2

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

I still have to L2Skyguard. I guess you have to lead a lot.

2

u/HaemoglobinUK [QRY Me An Airgame]HaemoglobinVS [Mattherson] May 26 '14

You have to lead a lot more than you expect honestly, there's also a lot of potential for ass-hattery in where you position yourself and who you are flying with.

If you have friendly ESF that can be bait for a trap it's fantastic.

4

u/PWNBUCKETS May 26 '14

Published on May 26, 2013

Lock-ons and flak have been changed several times this year along with lib resistances.

3

u/Huller_BRTD TO THE CROOO- *slap* May 26 '14

TIL: anything that can hurt pilots in any way whatsoever is OP.

The skyguard is pathethic at it's role against liberators and even worse at anything else despite requiring a highly specialised weapon and a lot more skill than most pilots display. If you get killed by flak in a liberator you aren't a good pilot. And it is ridiculously easy to take out skyguards with air if you know what you are doing.

Not a single person who ever used a skyguard would claim flak to be OP, only pilots claim it is OP and that is because they alone feel entitled to be invincible and farm ground with impunity.

The skyguard needs buffs in pretty much everything to become viable because spawning a skyguard leaves you with a laughable reward for a giant cert investment and hard to aim weapon, you get a kill once in a blue moon, you are left with one of the most useless vehicle weapons against ground targets and liberators rarely to never have any issues taking you out in a direct 1v1 even when they make plenty of mistakes that would get infantry and ground vehicles killed ten times over if they did the equivalent actions. And even when they are scared of your flak, they just fly to the nearest piece of terrain to go farm somewhere else, leaving you with a useless skyguard which you can dump for all the good it'll do you then.

Realy, the only thing that makes flak scary is the big explosions going off all around you. The liberator outclasses the skyguard by a vast amount in mobility, survivability, health, versatility, staying power and especialy firepower. And even a rocketpod ESF can tackle skyguards if they play it smart, but at least they have to play it smart and there is a real risk involved in facing a skyguard instead of just overpowering the skyguard in a direct 1v1.

Flak-air ballance is FUBAR, pilots don't even try to deny it. They even go as far as claiming this is how it's supposed to be.

#bufftheskyguard2014

1

u/rj88631 [DOG]RobMichael May 26 '14

only pilots claim it is OP and that is because they alone feel entitled to be invincible and farm ground with impunity.

I agree with this part. I feel AA and Air in respect to one another are balanced though. Skyguard with some certs invested into it is pretty decent at area denial and chews up any idiot who flies in a straight line.

0

u/SentienceIssues Not affiliated with SentientOne May 26 '14

And you have extensive experience playing both roles right?

2

u/fredrikpedersen CSG OutlawTorn May 26 '14

I fly a lot and I feel Ground vs ESF is in a good place right now. You're not supposed to be the king of the skies by yourself, flak and locks keep you on your toes. If not you are stuck with a A2G game like at launch, which I believe was incredibly broken.

Good pilots can dodge flak and locks, bad pilots need to learn.

Most of the time I'm more afraid of the tankbustin'/ramhappy/AA-Daltoning libs out there

2

u/Ubad00d [BIG][SVA] Cobalt May 26 '14

G2A is alright IMO, A2A is another matter with the introduction of win missiles.

2

u/rj88631 [DOG]RobMichael May 26 '14

I am tired of solo pilots complaining that AA is OP and involves no skill. Leading and guessing where the Air is going to be at a certain range and how tight the pilot is turning takes a good deal of time to learn. Finding good spots to position your free points skyguard to fight air and avoid enemy armor/AV/water pistols is skill.

What Pilots Say:

"AA is OP and takes no skill and ruins the Air Game in PS2"

What Pilots Mean:

"This is fucking bullshit that I can't fly directly at an AA battery consisting of 3 skyguards, 2 AA Burster MAXes and a Repair and Ammo Sundy. How am I supposed to get easy kills with my lolpods otherwise. Fuck targets of opportunity. Anything on the ground should easily die to my elite flight skills and I should never have to think about where I am relation to the enemy except when I want easy ground kills."

2

u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun May 26 '14

When I fly, I am usually supporting my platoon of friendlies on the ground with scout radar and killing the ground stuff as expected. Ground players hate me, and for good reasons, so they deserve the ability to fight back. It is much more of a problem for them with Libs and battle Gals, but I feel as an experienced A2G pilot that the weaponry balance for ESFs is in a decent place. The times where they instant kill me are all times where I deserved it. What often happens is that several players work together to form AA groups and that makes a no fly zone for A2G pilots.

2

u/Vass654 May 26 '14

And an ESF knowing what they are doing can screw over a Skyguard in seconds. If the ESF is stupid enough to go straight at a Skyguard, all fat, dumb and happy, they deserve to get shot out of the sky in a hail of flak.

Personally, I hate how the CoF is on the Skyguard. I think it should be tightened up, but then again, I don't fly. I also believe the Lightning should have a G2A missile system turret.

As for Skyguards or flak "interfering" with dog fights at high altitudes? Uhm. That's what it's there for. You shouldn't be able to just sit way above and ignore flak. I have to be careful shooting into any kind of dog fight because I might end up hitting friendlies. I normally wait until the enemy ESF or Lib has done their stupid flippy maneuver they always do and start going to town on them.

0

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

Yeah flak should be an anti security blanket. I like that it can hit things up high.

1

u/waaxz May 26 '14

Good pilots can dodge Lock ons pretty well (I have been using one for like a week and I can tell really fast if a pilot knows how to dodge them). As for flack I think ESF should resist a little bit more but keep it the same vs other aircraft.

-1

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

No it's impossible to dodge lock ons.

1

u/waaxz May 26 '14

Using terrain yes you can (Not dodge, make it crash into it, just didn't know what word to use)

1

u/AngerMacFadden May 26 '14

I wish you could trick em into hitting other targets (preferably enemies).

1

u/Jarcode [OO] RecursionPlayersAreBad May 26 '14

They can. It's rare, but I've seen it happen before.

1

u/Rangerdanvers (PTMC) Grumpy Vetran May 26 '14 edited May 26 '14

As a pilot, Flack is almost perfect it just needs it's max range cutting slightly. It's a real pain being hit by flack from two bases across.

If you're getting up close and personal with a burster max or skyguard You're a moron. You don't get close to your hard counter.

You either try to pick it off at a distance ask for help or bugger off elsewhere

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '14

Alright my opinion as a learning pilot.

Anyone can be great with flack. Anyone. That's because there's no skill involved in it really.

My fix is to give it a damage drop at range, change the skyguard to the point where it does massive damage, but make it harder to hit. IE reducing the blast radius

DON'T LET PEOPLE PULL SKYGUARDS AT EVERY FUCKING BASE. TACTICAL RETREAT TO THE NEXT ONE

And reducing composite libs resistance to it. That's a big reason why there's so much of it, along with the point above

4

u/ILIEKDEERS DEEEEEEEEERS May 26 '14

You have to lead with flak.

Getting hit by a bunch of flak? Pull out. That's a ground fight. Go find armor to bomb or other air to chase down.

Not like there are a lack of libs ripe for shooting.