r/Planetside • • May 08 '14

Could planetside be balanced in a better way?

http://stats.dasanfall.com/ps2/player/Malorn no stats on any esf weapon http://stats.dasanfall.com/ps2/player/Higby no stats on any esf weapon http://stats.dasanfall.com/ps2/player/ARClegger no stats on any esf weapon http://stats.dasanfall.com/ps2/player/Luperza no stats on any esf weapon http://stats.dasanfall.com/ps2/player/tayradactyl no stats on any esf weapon

I could keep on looking for SOE employer characters but i think you get where im going.. wouldn't it be better if there was a group of players, like on EVE, that would help with keeping the game balanced? if they make stupid suggestions that get raged on (more than normally) when they get implemented, they can just be replaced with other, more neutral thinking players.

personally i think this would really benefit the game in the long run.

2 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

3

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 08 '14

I'm pretty sure they balance based on performance statistics that we don't really have access to.

It would be nice if these stats were shared so that the community could see why these changes were occurring.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

If SOE keeps track of where and how much every single player honks, i somehow trust them in their balance decisions much more.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

stats don't say everything... the average kdr on saron laser cannon is 1.52 yet they still felt like they needed to nerf that vs infantry.. the average kdr on the prowler m12 kobalt is 21 yet that only got bullet spread (which is controllable by burst fire) and a headshot multiplier added to it.

1

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

kdr doesn't say everything either, a single tank can be worth almost 10 standard infantry in some cases, even more in the strategic side of things since they are resource-bound.

If a weapon is supposed to be weak against infantry for whatever reason (avoiding one-size-fits-all weapons, mainly, like the old lolpod/rotary combo) then it will be nerfed in that department until AI weapons are a genuine alternative to them.
Look at the Saron HRB nerf, now i see tons of magriders using the PPA to be able to attack infantry, while before the Saron was apparently good enough that you didn't need to pull something else. I think the Halberd will suffer a similar fate in the future (not necessarily losing its OHK, mind you) to make its AI effectiveness lower, since that is the main reason a lot use it over the Saron/Enforcer/Vulcan.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

exactly! how are they going to judge that correctly without actually using the weapons/vehicles themselves??

2

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 08 '14

I'm sure they have used the weapons, but the statistical information/data they are balancing against is far more important and revealing than basic first hand experience.

-1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

yet it really really isnt. for example i use dogfighter 1 airframe because i like the feel of it.. statistically the dogfighter 3 airframe should be better for me but my kdr goes down if i use that. if there is one thing i learned from marketing, it is that with a little creativity, every statistic can be used to your advantage.

2

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 08 '14

So you're saying everything should be balanced based on KDR alone?

-1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

if not from kdr, how would they balance the airframe? i mean its not like they actually use them ingame.

1

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 08 '14

So balance on KDR and personal experience? I feel like that won't paint a very good picture of weapon or slot performance. KDR alone can easily be skewed and personal experience is unreliable.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

..which is why they need the vieuw of a neutral experienced player that has used the weapon for a sufficient amount of time in the actual game:).

→ More replies (0)

0

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

By reading feedback and analyzing statistics.
Personal opinions are good and all, but don't necessarily represent the state of the balance because everyone's perspective is different. I wouldn't trust a skygod with air balance, because they have their own perspective and just the same i wouldn't trust a dedicated infantry player with infantry weapons balance, because they also have a certain view of the game that is most likely different from many many others.

A single guy's personal experience is too narrow to base balance upon it.

3

u/Burns_Cacti May 08 '14

Personal opinions are good and all, but don't necessarily represent the state of the balance because everyone's perspective is different.

Remember when they nerfed the mosquito because the striker was causing it to appear to be over performing when in reality it had very little to do with the aircraft?

Yeah, that's why stats lie.

0

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

Stats don't lie, people misunderstand what they imply because... well... they're people.

Also, i don't get your point. I was saying that a single guy's experience isn't enough to base a balance change, you need confirmation from different sources, which is why it doesn't matter that the devs don't play as much themselves, their view could be just as skewed as another random player.

2

u/Fimconte May 08 '14

Nobody is talking about a single guy.

Consulting with top-tier players would be much better for the longevity of the game, rather than relying on stats.

-1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14 edited May 08 '14

allright then let me paint you a picture: the first bolt action sniper rifles just got released into the game.. there are only a couple of players that actually like using them and they need alot of skill to pull off headshots.. the vocal majority however are complaining about the weapon because they lack the skill to use the weapon effectively and think it is overpowered.. So they add a bolt action sniper rifle that locks onto heads and thus makes sniping accesable to the vocal majority.. they have no problem with how it works as they can be effective with it but the snipers feel cheated. how would SOE know if that weapon is balanced?

(this is obviously extremified)

1

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

First thing, they'd try to understand why those bolt-actions were so difficult to use that only a few players can use them, because that's the first problem. They wouldn't add a new weapon that is easier do do but does the same exact thing, because it takes more development time and doesn't solve their first problem, so your example is already flawed... plus they don't cater blindly to the vocal majority like redditside seems to believe so firmly.

For the sake of your picture, let's assume they do:
They would find themselves with a weapon that is hard to use but, i assume, brings better results for the ones that can use it and with one that most can use with average results.
It wouldn't be a matter of one of the weapons being OP, still assuming there is a tradeoff, it would be a matter of having a mechanic that has likely a low skill ceiling and doesn't encourage getting better.
In any case where a new mechanic gets implemented there are thorough discussions about how it's going to impact the game; if in that phase something gets through and the devs realize it was an error putting it in they'll probably value what to do, but it's hard that a new mechanic does something like this.

Case in point, coyotes, aren't a bad mechanic. *cue people calling me scrub* The heatseeking mechanic is nice and the coyotes just need to be balanced, for example with a far longer reload time that encourages their use during nose cannon reloads. Same for all game mechanics we have, they aren't gamebreaking by themselves, there are always ways to tweak them to not be problematic anymore.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

allright.. we can talk about this for very long or very short with the same result so i will end my side of the argument here: there is no way they could know how something operates just from statistics alone.. not everything shows up in statistics, and as it stands, they seem to listen to (some, IMO, very incompetent) youtubers, streamers and other people that produce media about planetside instead of listening to some players that they select for being competent and being capable of making a neutral descision instead. heck they could even make them debate against each other on a secluded forum for game balance..

my point of vieuw is that it would really improve the game alot, your point of vieuw might be different and i accept that.. still thought i should share mine though.

1

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

there is no way they could know how something operates just from statistics alone.. not everything shows up in statistics

Did i ever even claim otherwise? My first response to the OP was "By reading feedback and analyzing statistics". Without user feedback they'd likely miss details that stats don't show, just like without using stats they'd miss details that user feedback doesn't show.

Having a small groups of players providing "deluxe" feedback would do nothing different beside adding useless complexity. Why are those players more important than the next 10? Because they are neutral? And what does neutral mean, that they are capable of seeing every potential issue from every point of view? If that's the case, posting a detailed thread is very likely to bring the same results, because SOE would read it and take it into consideration as they notice that it's well thought out, like they have been doing for a while.

I just don't see anything more than "the devs know nothing about their game, let the players balance it" in your suggestion, which is a really shortsighted way to look at their balancing process.

3

u/_DX3_ [AC] Dopey May 08 '14

I haven't looked at those stats, but I would imagine that they would compare the saron to the other ES weapons and balance it not just on KD rates.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

They said they nerfed it because it was performing better against infantry than the other 2 ESAV weapons.

1

u/Alkhemy May 09 '14

Why do so many planetside players seem to refer to EVE so much?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '14

because that game actually made it to last for a decade, which is what soe wants to achieve with planetside 2 :).

1

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

While devs don't have a whole lot of personal ESF experience (which could also just be bugged since they tend to switch factions), they have access to not only metrics and stats and that sort of things, but also to feedback from many many sources.
I personally trust them with the game's balance more than i would trust any member of this community... why? Because their main interest is have a good and fun game (good game = moneyz, if you want to be cynical about it) and they have access to the perspective of every kind of player from your BR4 newbie that just got skywhaled in his tank to the BR100 skygod in his flying chariot of farming awesomeness and anyone inbetween.

And if we gave these players access to SOE's tools... they'd just be like the game designers SOE already has, so what would be the point?

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

l about it) and they have access to the perspective of every kind of player from your B

OP weapon in first couple of months = good money.. *puts on tinfoil hat*

3

u/MrIDoK Cobalt ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ UNPRAISE MALORN ༼ ಠل͟ಠ༽ May 08 '14

*sigh*
I bet someone could write an essay on confirmation bias by looking at this subreddit.

2

u/MrMacgyverr Mattherson CML May 08 '14

I'm nominating this for best comment of all time. Thank you sir. #NerfReddit

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

Yes.

Balance should be based on gameplay not stats.

And gameplay isn't performance.

-1

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

I dont like balance.