r/neutrinos • • Sep 30 '21

When this post is 24h old (Fri, 4PM US central) MicroBooNE will announce on sterile neutrinos - the most highly anticipated neutrino result in years

36 Upvotes

Edit: Results are in! See the bottom!

Overview: Mark Ross-Lonergan will announce MicroBooNE's first test of the LSND and MiniBooNE anomalies at 4PM Chicago time at Fermilab's "Joint Experimental-Theoretical Physics Seminar" (aka the "wine and cheese" seminar). More information, including a zoom link, can be found here. The title of his talk is: "Search for anomalous single-photon production in MicroBooNE as a first test of the MiniBooNE low-energy excess" and is the first of four analyses that MicroBooNE has developed to test the low-energy excess.

LSND/MiniBooNE: In the late 90s the notion of neutrino oscillations was finally starting to be taken seriously with the first discovery in 1998 by Kajita at SuperK followed up by confirmation at SNO in 2001, 2002. But the oscillation parameters were completely unknown so people were trying to measure oscillations at a wide range of baselines and energies just to figure out what is going on. In 2001 LSND at Los Alamos looked for electron neutrino appearance in a muon neutrino beam and saw 88 more events than expected from backgrounds with a significance of about 3.8sig: arXiv paper. Anything over 3sig is considered "very interesting" but certainly not a discovery which generally requires 5sig. This excess could be explained by another oscillation frequency that is incompatible with those measured by atmospheric neutrinos (SuperK, and later confirmed by MINOS, Daya Bay, RENO, NOvA, T2K, and IceCube) or the solar frequency (SNO, SuperK, Borexino, and really confirmed by KamLand). If true, this would indicate a fourth neutrino which, based on measurements by LEP of the Z boson's decay width, would have to be "sterile" which means that it doesn't experience the weak interaction. Such a sterile neutrino would be a right-handed fermion gauge singlet of the Standard Model only accessible through mixing with the active neutrinos.

To better understand this, Fermilab decided to do the BooNE experiment but only ever ended up doing a smaller version called MiniBooNE. The idea was to do another nu_mu to nu_e appearance experiment and keep the ratio of distance to energy the same so that if this were a sterile neutrino the oscillation effect would be the same, but at higher energy (and thus higher baseline) which ensures that any issues with the prediction, any issues with the cross section, any issues with the backgrounds, or any issues with any new physics scenarios other than sterile neutrinos would appear differently. After some confusing data, in 2018 they eventually reported 4.7sig generally compatible with that from LSND in the context of a sterile neutrino: arXiv paper. This can be nominally combined with LSND to reach 6sig evidence for oscillations.

tldr: older experiments see an excess consistent with sterile oscillations at high significance

Other hints: If you see nu_mu to nu_e oscillations at a given frequency associated with the sterile neutrino mass, you must also see oscillations at the same frequency in both nu_mu to nu_mu and nu_e to nu_e. A number of nu_e to nu_e experiments have shown some hints that are possibly consistent with the LSND and MiniBooNE signals when expressed in terms of a sterile neutrino. One is an overall deficit in the total reactor neutrino flux compared to theory prediction, although there are some hints that this deficit is due to a problem with the nuclear physics in the flux prediction. Another one is an overall deficit is calibration source measurements used to calibrate pp solar neutrino experiments, although again, there are hints that this is due to a nuclear physics problem. That said, neither of these have known explanations either.

Constraints: The nu_mu to nu_mu channel is extremely powerful as it is, in many ways, easier to probe. Thus there are strong constraints on these oscillations. Notably MINOS+ at Fermilab seems to rule out essentially all of the parameter space by comparing possible sterile neutrino oscillation signatures that could appear in either their near detector or their far detector. In addition, atmospheric neutrinos at much higher energy would experience a resonant effect through the Earth and IceCube places very strong constraints on this as well. Finally, a sterile neutrino would provide a fairly significant modification to early universe measurements of big bang nucleosynthesis and the cosmic microwave background.

Note that all of the hints require a comparison to a theory prediction and all of the constraints involve measurements at multiple baselines. Put another way, it is known that predicting the energy spectrum of the flux is extremely hard, the neutrino cross sections at these energies are extraordinarily hard, and backgrounds are all over the place. On the other hand, measuring distances (or zenith angles for atmospheric neutrinos) is far easier and unlikely to be subject to systematic uncertainties.

Possible explanations: If the excess isn't a sterile neutrino, what else could it be? For LSND there was an analysis that suggested that much of the excess was on the edge of the detector and that perhaps there were misidentified particles escaping the detector which would mess up the background analysis. For the nu_e to nu_e hints, there are hints of nuclear physics. None of these explanations have been confirmed, but they don't seem implausible. For MiniBooNE you still have to do something. It's possible that the backgrounds aren't properly predicted. It's possible that there are misreconstructed particles, although because of the different energies it would be rather different than the effect for LSND (and obviously everyone both in the experiments and not have checked these things to death). If it is new physics people aren't that keen on sterile neutrinos. Something that people have looked into (including me) is if maybe there is a sterile neutrino but there is extra new physics (a new interaction) this can significantly weaken the constraints from MINOS+ and IceCube and possibly alleviate early universe problems - but the parameters don't work well for all experiments simultaneously. MiniBooNE could also be due to a heavier sterile neutrino that decays in the detector. This was pointed out awhile back and then a few years ago three papers on this appeared all at once revitalizing this idea. This is plausible but a bit more involved from a model building point of view than just a sterile neutrino which has a benefit in its simplicity.

Present: To address this problem, Fermilab began the short baseline program: a collection of three state-of-the-art liquid Ar detectors in the same beam at different distances. Thus if there are oscillations the close detector basically measures the backgrounds, the middle detector sees an excess of electron neutrinos, and the far detector the signal is back closer to the near detector. This provides an unambiguous signal of oscillations. The first detector constructed is called MicroBooNE (now micro refers to the fact that the spatial resolution is really tiny). The other two have been coming online in the last few years. MicroBooNE has been taking data for a number of years now and have been putting out ancillary results (performance of the detector, cross section measurements in different regions of parameter space, and so on). After a few set backs they are finally prepared to report their initial results relevant for oscillations. The key is to know if a) they have seen an excess and b) if so, if they believe they can reconstruct all the final states correctly (liquid Ar should be amazing for this). In addition, this short baseline program is an important realistic detector technology test for the US flagship experiment, DUNE, under construction now.

Conclusion: There are some compelling hints for a sterile neutrino that have lingered for 20 years and appear to be over 5sig. There are more compelling constraints. New physics explanations are a bit complicated. Standard model explanations are unclear. An ambitious program is getting started and the first results will be presented tomorrow.

NEW Results: Mark gave an amazing talk! They saw a Delta rate consistent with theory expectation, but slightly below the theory expectation actually. This means that the new physics evidence that MiniBooNE has seen is probably not due to a misidentified Delta decays (one of the most likely standard physics explanations) at about 2sig. See here. That is, the theory prediction for the background rate is confirmed at modest significance. In addition, there are some translation issues between Ar and C which would actually increase this significance at which a Delta explanation of the excess is disfavored. Results can be found here.


r/neutrinos • • Oct 26 '21

Tomorrow (Wednesday) at 10 AM central time MicroBooNE will announce their first real oscillation results

16 Upvotes

Edit: Results are in! See below!

The talk is open to the public, the zoom link and more information are here.

For background, first go read my other post from a month ago. Quick summary: hints of extra neutrino oscillations at Delta m2 ~1 eV2 was seen by LSND and MiniBooNE, somewhat incompatible with MINOS+, IceCube, and cosmological measurements. MicroBooNE was built to test this and a month ago they announced that the most likely background to explain MiniBooNE (extra Delta's compared to the prediction) is likely not the answer.

Now that we have an indication that backgrounds probably aren't the answer to MiniBooNE's result, the next question is if MicroBooNE sees the same electron neutrino appearance events consistent with what MiniBooNE saw. Note that while they have accumulated decent statistics at this point, they have probably only analyzed a relatively small set of it, so the statistical significance of the results may not be that significant. That said, this should be the biggest single jump in our knowledge of 1 eV steriles in many years.

If they see nothing then this was likely an analysis problem in MiniBooNE and the story is likely over. There would still be some lingering details like how did both LSND and MiniBooNE get it wrong it different ways that happened to look like a consistent signal? What about the other weak hints (reactors, sources, etc.) which have possible non-oscillation explanations but have not been fully explained? That is, the work would go on, but it would not be driven by searches for new physics, rather for better understanding our experiments and nuclear physics.

If they see something then the game is on. The first thing to check is if it is consistent with sterile neutrino oscillations and if the relevant parameters are consistent with those from LSND and MiniBooNE. Next, it will be important to check sidebands with kinematic distributions. That is, there are a number of explanations of MiniBooNE that do not involve neutrino oscillations and that predict specific distributions in the kinematics; while some of these have been ruled out by MiniBooNE, MicroBooNE should be much better at probing these.

Results: According to this FNAL article they see no oscillations! This means that MiniBooNE and LSND sitting with 4.8 sigma and 3.7 sigma evidence for something still need to be explained.


r/neutrinos • • Apr 24 '23

The 2023 High Energy Particle Physics Division Prize is awarded by the European Physics Society to Cecilia Jarlskog, Daya Bay, and RENO

Thumbnail eps-hepp.web.cern.ch
9 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Aug 17 '24

Underground event marks excavation completion on colossal caverns for underground neutrino laboratory, DUNE

Thumbnail
news.fnal.gov
8 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Jan 11 '23

STEREO experiment confirms anomalous neutrino measurements and rules out hypothesis of a light sterile neutrino

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
8 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Oct 21 '21

MicroBooNE's appearance results are finally coming next Wednesday!

Thumbnail theory.fnal.gov
8 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Aug 02 '21

The International Neutrino Summer School, hosted virtually at CERN, starts today!

Thumbnail
indico.cern.ch
7 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Mar 04 '24

Tour a particle accelerator, ask real scientists questions and more at Jefferson Lab.

5 Upvotes

The Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility in Newport News, VA is having its biennial open house on Saturday June 8 from 9am-3pm, admission and parking is free. Learn about superconducting materials, supercomputers, particle accelerators, particle detectors, nuclear physics research and much more. See our web page for more information.


r/neutrinos • • May 11 '23

Is this correct? Meon number is not conserved as I think

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Dec 01 '22

The Short Baseline Neutrino Detector at Fermilab is moving across site right now, follow in real time on twitter

Thumbnail
twitter.com
5 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Oct 23 '21

Funny and informative debate style news report on the status of sterile neutrinos

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Sep 03 '21

[arXiv] Sterile Neutrinos as Dark Matter Candidates by Joachim Kopp

Thumbnail
arxiv.org
5 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Feb 20 '21

Farewell Daya Bay, hello JUNO

Thumbnail
cerncourier.com
5 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Apr 07 '25

If the sun exploded as a supernova, you'd die from the neutrinos first.

4 Upvotes

Learnt a cool factoid today. Please take with a grain of salt, although this was spoken and confirmed by astro-particle physicists.


r/neutrinos • • Nov 30 '23

Question: how did we confirm experimentally that there are there flavors of neutrinos?

4 Upvotes

Lepton flavor is conserved at the weak vertex, I assume this gives us a way to tune an experiment to one of the neutrino flavors, but I since there are more electrons around than muons or tau, doesn't this mean that the vast majority of what we detect will be electron neutrinos? How did we confirm the existence of muon or tau neutrinos?


r/neutrinos • • Jan 24 '23

Ways to weigh a neutrino

Thumbnail
symmetrymagazine.org
4 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Nov 11 '22

OC: Galactic Neutrinos discovered in IceCube for the first time!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Jul 15 '22

The history of the limit on the number of light active neutrinos on the electroweak side: from N<6000 to N=2.98+-0.01 [twitter thread]

Thumbnail
twitter.com
4 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Feb 22 '22

Where we are with supernova neutrino burst detecting and alerting

Thumbnail
nature.com
4 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Nov 14 '21

Can Your Eyes See Ghost Particles? | Neutrino Physics

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/neutrinos • • Oct 27 '21

Neutrino questions and discussion weekly thread

4 Upvotes

Ask your neutrino related questions and discuss recent neuws in this thread.

Please read the sidebar and remember to follow reddiquette.


r/neutrinos • • Aug 25 '21

Neutrino questions and discussion weekly thread

4 Upvotes

Ask your neutrino related questions and discuss recent neuws in this thread.

Please read the sidebar and remember to follow reddiquette.


r/neutrinos • • Aug 18 '21

Neutrino questions and discussion weekly thread

4 Upvotes

Ask your neutrino related questions and discuss recent neuws in this thread.

Please read the sidebar and remember to follow reddiquette.


r/neutrinos • • Feb 17 '21

Basic neutrino questions weekly thread

4 Upvotes

Ask your cosmology related questions in this thread.

Please read the sidebar and remember to follow reddiquette.


r/neutrinos • • Dec 22 '25

Could there be more neutrino mass states than flavor states?

3 Upvotes

Basically I want to know if there's any reason it'd be impossible for there be 3 neutrino flavor states and 4 (or more) mass states? I know this is similar to sterile neutrinos, but the sterile theory still suggests there exists some "sterile" flavor.

The standard mathematical formulation of neutrino oscillation requires that mass states and flavor states be related by some square unitary matrix. The matrix's square-ness requires that for each flavor state there's a mass state. But do we KNOW that this is the only way to represent neutrino mixing?

From some quick google-ing it's not possible to have a unitary matrix that isn't square, but you can have a non-square semi-unitary matrix (where it's unitary only when applied one way e.g. AA† =I≠A† A). Perhaps that'd be good enough for plausible formulation of neutrino mixing/oscillation?

I'd guess that phenomenologically speaking a 3-flavor 4-mass theory or neutrino oscillation would look pretty much identical to the standard sterile neutrino formulation. So there's probably not much real motivation for a 3-flavor 4-mass theory. Nevertheless though, I'm curious if the idea passes the sniff test (so to speak).

Anyways, if anyone's familiar with a paper/book where this sort of thing is discussed, and/or if you know why this idea wouldn't work, please let me know.