r/nanowrimo • • Jan 23 '24

NO MORE NANOWRIMO

1.3k Upvotes

NaNoWriMo and its staff have recently come under fire for their numerous unethical and predatory practices. These include, though are not limited to:

  • Hostility and inaction after numerous members raised child grooming allegations against a volunteer moderator who was in charge of teens within the NaNoWriMo forums.

  • Headquarters took nearly 2 months to quietly remove the accused moderator's leadership powers, and over 5 months to remove their account... which they only did after this former moderator threatened to damage NaNoWriMo's contract with an affiliate.

  • Refusal to protect kids in the Young Writer’s Program from predators. Kids were instead bullied and silenced by the staff.

  • Ivan the Icy, a scavenger hunt game that featured a terrorist-styled “supervillain” (which they admitted was a mistake).

  • Local organizers (called MLs) not being background checked, yet required to host in-person events with kids present.

  • Harboring volunteer MLs who were reported as racist, homophobic, transphobic, and/or abusive.

  • Ignoring and silencing MLs who begged for help regarding serious issues within the volunteer program. This resulted in at least one participant suffering an event-related assault.

  • Inaction when MLs abused fellow MLs with bullying and ableist discrimination.

  • Promoting multiple Vanity Presses (predatory, scam-like publishers), including Inkitt, even after outside sources confirmed and announced they were predatory.

  • Solicitation via email for donations from kids in the Young Writer's Program.

WHAT CAN YOU DO?

  • Do you know of a school or classroom participating in NaNoWriMo through the Young Writers Program website? Please bring these issues to their attention.

  • If you donate to the NaNoWriMo organization, stop. There are plenty of other charitable organizations far more worthy of your monetary support.

  • Continue enjoying the November writing challenge WITHOUT the NaNoWriMo organization. Many authors and writing groups have written 50k words in 30 days without even being aware that the organization exists.


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 02 '24

In an official statement, NaNoWriMo calls critics of AI ableist and classist.

777 Upvotes

NaNoWriMo has issued an official statement via their new favorite communication channel... the FAQs. In this statement, NaNoWriMo claims that critics of AI are classist and ableist

I recommend reading this with your own eyes: https://nanowrimo.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/29933455931412-What-is-NaNoWriMo-s-position-on-Artificial-Intelligence-AI

This very accusation is classist and ableist, because it suggests that, according to NaNoWriMo, AI is necessary to make the written works of the lower classes palatable enough for the gentry to read.

Also, NaNoWriMo failed to be specific in their statement. To what type of AI are they referring? There are numerous forms of AI available to writers. Some forms are ethical (though not recommended if you're still developing your own unique writing voice). Some forms sit in a grey area. And others are fueled by the blatant theft of authors' original works. NaNoWriMo could have offered guidance for finding the ethical options, but instead they issued a blanket statement of support for all AI writing "tools."

Even if I hadn't already witnessed last year's scandal with the alleged child grooming moderator, and NaNoWriMo's subsequent community mismanagement... Even if the organization hadn't already dropped me along with their entire force of over 800 volunteers... this would be my exit point.

Edit #1: NaNoWriMo just edited their statement to include acknowledgement of "bad actors in the AI space." However, they are standing firm behind their claims that disabled and poor writers need AI in order to write well and be successful. For reference, here is the original (unedited) version of their statement: https://web.archive.org/web/20240902144333/https://nanowrimo.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/29933455931412-What-is-NaNoWriMo-s-position-on-Artificial-Intelligence-AI

Edit #2: NaNoWriMo's (interim) Executive Director is author Kilby Blades. She is the person who regularly updates the FAQs, and is likely the person who wrote this AI statement (at the very least, it was posted under her watch as an official statement). NaNoWriMo's summary of recent events and changes at NaNoWriMo (including more information about Kilby's current role) can be read here: https://nanowrimo.org/changes-at-nanowrimo-may-2024


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 25 '24

NaNo HQ Discussion I was doxxed by nanowrimo

756 Upvotes

the title really says it all tbh

I was the original ‘whistleblower’ last year as I was apparently the first person to reach out to the board of directors about the issues regarding the groomer mod and HQ’s mishandling of the whole situation.  Well, last week the official nanowrimo facebook account sent an unedited screenshot of my original email to a random participant through messenger.  The screenshot included my email address which is my full name.  

Screenshot (editing done by me): https://imgur.com/a/2loKUab

The ‘random participant’ immediately shared the unedited screenshot online.  And while that is super gross behavior on their part as well, I only shared my confidential information with the board of directors, so I hold the org responsible for this violation and breach of trust.  

“We are so committed to transparency’ nanowriomo doesn’t actually identify themselves in messages, so it’s unclear which staff member has done this, but I can only assume this was done by Kilby herself since, who else is left? 

I wrote to the board of directors on Monday November 18th, immediately after this happened.  As of the time of posting this, I have not received a response.  No acknowledgement, not apology, no ‘we’re looking into this’; nothing.  So in addition to being doxxed, I am also being ghosted.  Yay me! 

As it’s unclear who is even on the board of directors anymore (seriously guys, is it just Kilby?), I don’t have anyone else I can reach out to at this point.  Apparently the executive director is allowed to commit gross misconduct and there is zero recourse to be had because there’s no oversight or governing body she has to answer to.  I tried to do things ‘the right way’ and I tried to resolve this directly but nanowrimo refuses to engage with me.  So I am escalating this here, to a public space.  Because what else can I do? 


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 03 '24

The new ML agreement Nano doesn't want you to see (yet)

524 Upvotes

In a normal organization a volunteer agreement would not be shocking. It would be boring.

It would not come with a confidentiality clause holding the volunteer liable if they speak out, and forbidding them to talk to other volunteers.

It would not come with a mandate that these volunteers report anyone in their communities that break any kind of supposed rule to HQ (including, literally, use of profanity).

It would not come with an obligation that these volunteers report other volunteers and participants for violations of the literal written letter of local laws (including places where being queer or speaking against the government is a crime).

It would not make those volunteers swear to listen first to Nano HQ for directions in case of a public health emergency (instead of, you know, government health agencies).

It would not hold volunteers legally liable for everything that happens in their regions, giving the HQ that's telling them what to do and when to do it a free pass.

And yet, that is exactly what this agreement does. Less a step forward and more a happy leap into a ditch.

I'm sharing this now to raise awareness in case you do want to get involved in the future. Know what they will be asking you to do. Know what your liability will be if you agree. And ask yourself if doing a writing thing is really worth all that when you can just do it yourself, or with, like, any other group.


r/nanowrimo • • Apr 01 '24

Guys, Nano's not getting better.

522 Upvotes

I guess Inkitt being a scam wasn't enough for them. One of the sponsors for this year's Camp (such as it is, with the website being a buggy mess) is ... yet another scam! This one is "Ninja Writers," which uses the style of other "guru" life-advisors. For the low, low price of the "24 hour limited discount" of $599 (down from $750, of course) for the lifetime membership, you too can learn all the secrets of being the absolute bestest writer ever!

I'm tired.

Please don't give these shady "sponsors," or NaNoWriMo, your money.


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 06 '24

AI is not writing

519 Upvotes

Writing is not meant to be easy, nor to have an easy fix-all. Allowing the support of AI stripes writers who have worked days, months, years to create their own voice. Never again will I use this service. I will be openly denouncing NANOWRIMO to all my writer friends, and any who say they use it.

Edit: cheers to the coward that reported me for suicidal behavior. Glad to see to have the courage to post your thoughts.


r/nanowrimo • • Jan 18 '24

Don't Vote for Nanowrimo for P4A

491 Upvotes

Every year, Nanowrimo participates in Project4Awesome and asks people to vote for them so they can get money. It hurts to say this, but after everything that's come out this past year, the organization doesn't deserve the help. P4A is a great program and definitely still vote in it, just please vote for other organizations that actually deserve the money. The link below has all the details about what's been happening with Nano:

https://www.tumblr.com/the-nanowrimo-chronicles/739884889561808896/dont-vote-for-nanowrimo-for-p4a?source=share


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 28 '24

UPDATE: Kilby has forcibly removed EVERY SINGLE ML.

475 Upvotes

Kilby has removed ALL MLs, even those who have said they were staying. No more ML forum access, no more site access, no more discord links -- everything has been revoked.

The new ML agreement leaked and it's even worse than the first one. AFAIK, only MLs who agree to sign it will be given back their site access.

Make no mistake - this is a clear intimidation tactic. "Fall in line, or else." It's also meant to keep MLs from organizing/communicating via the ML forum.

I'll be shocked if even 10% of the MLs subject themselves to this nightmare. To everyone affected - I'm so, so sorry, You deserved to be treated so much better. This organization has failed you at every single juncture.

(For the curious, here's the new leaked ML agreement: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NQ6hMEpFfhrBTCcxV_8tgRChBX8Zxsco/view )


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 05 '19

Tip Hey you, BROWSING REDDIT instead of writing...close this and GO WRITE. Yes YOU.

470 Upvotes

and by "you" I mean me.


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 29 '24

WoNoWriMo

450 Upvotes

Y'all, I just seized WoNoWriMo.com, who is with me to start World Novel Writing Month? Do we want to keep it in November? Or put it in a less hectic month? Votes?


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 15 '24

We did it…. We all stepped down.

426 Upvotes

All of the mls from my region are done.


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 13 '24

It's over.

413 Upvotes

Apart from the issues with the ML contract...
People cannot be stewards for an organization that has enabled harm against minors then attempted to suppress information about it. That's like a baseline human rule. Many people have gone above and beyond to prove that harm, and many other users corroborated that. There's more than enough information to satisfy the burden of proof, and since the board has adapted yet another information suppression campaign... it's over.

My sympathy is gone.

People had to wade through some truly vile shit to even bring this to anyone's attention, and that not being enough for some people has done so much damage to my faith in people to be responsible enough to be community leaders.

I feel like some genuinely don't really realize how bad this is, but like... there's no excuse anymore.

There's no reason to still cling to supporting an organization that has repeatedly demonstrated it only values its own self-preservation at the cost of everyone's safety.

It's time to leave.

Divorce from the organization, transition towards being independent writing groups, because NaNo is no longer a safe refuge.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSYcdosGLoPFI_Dc--vuC9Bl4-OUFGcmHgBRt2aHSRVWBPc6su4AMFY5iDgZGyC379Zm8C7zhBd2zuf/pub


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 07 '25

Is anyone else really just grieving right now?

406 Upvotes

I understand everyone was mad at the non-profit for some legitimate reasons. I understand that there was a lot of anger and resentment, and I think it was justified. But is anyone else just sad? Like just heartbroken that they won't be able to do it this year? Or is it just me?

ETA: " JUST DO IT YOURSELF" wow, I hadn't thought of that. That isn't possible for everyone.


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 09 '24

NaNoWriMo’s Hypocrisy

396 Upvotes

Hating AI is "ableist and classist?" The fact that they have the gall to say that is incredibly ableist and classist.

My hand tremors at least once a week to the point that I can't feed myself. I have ADHD. I am a dirt poor college student. But I would never use a cheap, soulless machine to generate sentences (not using the term writing, because it's not) stolen from others, but strips away the soul and meaning the original authors gave it.

NaNo's acting like being working class or disabled means you can't write by yourself to justify their shitty AI agenda.

Writing is art. Writing is from the heart. Writing has been with humanity for thousands of years. Millions of those writers were disabled and/or poor. Saying that they, or anyone else needs AI is belittling and infantizing.

Writing will never be AI. Writing is human. Writing needs emotion. You should write because you love writing. You should write because you love capturing the essence of the human soul in letters. You should never call yourself a writer if all you do is use AI for a get rich quick scheme. Those who do are lower than dirt.


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 14 '20

Tip Terrible discovery

395 Upvotes

I have just learned that if I want to have a riddle contest in my novel, I have to write a riddle contest???

I would like to speak to a manager.


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 30 '20

Nine years ago I lost NaNoWriMo for the first time. Since then I've lost five more times and didn't even try three times. Today I just wrote my 50023rd of the month.

385 Upvotes

I hit 50,000!!!! This is gonna be emotional, but boy does it feel good to get to say that. I'm not even done with it yet, but I just wanted to bask for a moment in hitting the mark that's felt out of reach for a decade now.

The book is so bad. SO so bad you guys There are probably 20,000 words that need to go, and easily another 30,000 that need to be added in somewhere to make anything make sense, but I don't care right now. Because I've got 50,000 words in one word document.


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 07 '24

Authors, please remember this moment when you start thinking about your book cover

366 Upvotes

… because AI images are theft, too (and visual artists are just as furious as you are).

Thanks for coming to my TED talk.

EDIT: fwiw, I’ve done NaNo three times and won twice. I can’t believe this bullshit. But I have also seen writers using AI for book covers and publishers doing the same. I don’t think that we can protest one without condemning the other.

EDIT 2: changed “real artists” to “visual artists” to avoid ambiguity.


r/nanowrimo • • Apr 09 '24

Just spotted this job listing for Executive Director of nanowrimo

350 Upvotes

I actually have never participated in nanowrimo, but this sub has been popping up on my feed and I’ve been loosely following what’s going on.

I spotted this job listing and thought you all might find it interesting.

I really admire and appreciate all of you for fighting back and doing the right thing. It’s super inspiring!


r/nanowrimo • • Dec 01 '20

I LOST!

339 Upvotes

I see so many "I won" posts, and I am super happy for everyone who won...but those of us who tried and lost should not be ignored. Don't be quiet about your missing the deadline, fellow losers!

We tried, and that effort was not wasted, we got some words, and that's better than no words!

For me, I have set a new deadline (September 30th, 2021) to hit the 50k. That way I will have 'finished' this project, and can feel good about entering into October and planning my next NaNo Novel. Don't let your loss become a demotivator! <3


r/nanowrimo • • Oct 12 '24

Scrivener's statement on the NaNoWriMo AI thing

337 Upvotes

https://forum.literatureandlatte.com/t/nanowrimo-2024-ai-statement/142534/42

For those who don't want to click:

  1. They found the AI statement "bizarre."

  2. They hope to use their influence as a sponsor to guide NaNoWriMo (the organization) to "do better."

  3. They have "serious concerns" about generative AI.

  4. Scrivener does not and will not have AI features, though if an operating system imposes AI, they won't "actively disable" it.

  5. They have been asked to withdraw their sponsorship, but do not intend to at this time.

  6. While they're not exactly thrilled with NaNoWriMo as an organization, they do support NaNoWriMo as an event and wish to continue to do so.

  7. They feel that NaNoWriMo (the organization) may not last much longer, and they don't want to accelerate its death by withdrawing their sponsorship and thus destroying NaNoWriMo the event, given that Scrivener itself is rooted in it.

  8. They plan to review their ties to NaNoWriMo (the organization) periodically and will cut those ties if the organization does something that is, in their mind, a step too far.

  9. There's a vague reference to "other problems with NaNo recently", but nothing overtly stated about the grooming allegations.

  10. They accept that they will be boycotted by some, and suggest those individuals should also be "boycotting companies that are truly threatening writers with their positions on AI, such as Meta and Amazon."

tl;dr - No, they're not withdrawing their sponsorship, but they don't support generative AI, either.


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 07 '19

This makes me irrationally happy, but I just closed down for the day at 12345 words.

335 Upvotes

r/nanowrimo • • Oct 06 '24

Nobody will do 50k in a day anymore

328 Upvotes

And be taken seriously I mean.

Even before AI, there were questions about quality, accusations of pre-writing or lying etc.

I used to admire it (despite wondering at quality, how these people slept etc). Writing- actual writing through pen/pencil/typing/dictation- 50k in a day is impressive regardless of how good or bad that 50k is. It's an astounding human feat some people managed because of the nanowrimo incentive.

I kinda dreamt of doing it one day, as someone who usually crossed the "finishing line" in 3 weeks.

Now? If I saw it, I'd just assume AI. I'd be another one assuming cheating. Because it's so statistically rare a human can do that vs AI doing it.

That's sad to me.


r/nanowrimo • • Mar 15 '20

Writing / Focus Site Could we start a "National Novel Writers Quarantine Challenge"?

324 Upvotes

That would sure motivate me to make use of this crazy season we're in.


r/nanowrimo • • Sep 03 '24

Shut Down Nanowrimo: It's AI stance is bad, its grooming of kids is worse

318 Upvotes

It's time to pull the plug on Nanowrimo. When an organization designed to help make writing fun for people ends up actively hurting huge numbers of creatives and insulting countless more people, it's time. I made a petition:

https://chng.it/H4gKdqg6vP

I've shied away from deleting my account because even with everything going on I was trying to remain optimistic and thought our criticism might change things but nope, this goose is a nice and even 165 Fahrenheit the whole way through. Still gonna do the challenge on my own when I can, and luckily there are plenty of groups out there for writers who just want to actually write.


r/nanowrimo • • Nov 02 '12

A NaNoWriMo cynic showed up on my Twitter feed. I fired back.

Post image
318 Upvotes