r/musiccognition • • Jul 14 '26

Pop Publication Are you a lyric person or a music person? by Unexplainable

Thumbnail
megaphone.link
68 Upvotes

30 minute podcast on recent research on what people are paying attention to when they're listening to music.


r/musiccognition • • Jun 26 '16

Why do I like 'evil' themed music?

32 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Nov 03 '20

For those who want to learn how to play music by ear: A ear-training tool to speed up your learning journey! (Currently still in development!)

31 Upvotes

Hey people!

My name is zlliu, and I am an information systems student (I study coding and stuff) with some free time and a passion for playing music by ear (learning new songs just by listening without need for music sheets)

I’ve made a ear-training tool to help those who wish to learn how to play by ear speed up their learning journey and drastically reduce the time needed to learn this skill! You can find the tool here:

https://pitchgarden.com

Features:

  1. Practice identifying notes and intervals just by listening

  2. Practice identifying sequences of notes and chords just by listening

I originally made this tool for a few of my friends, but figured why not share it with more people, get more feedback and make it even better? (And have fun while doing it!)

Any feedback is appreciated! Whether the UI is ok/whether anything is broken or buggy/quality of life changes y’all would love to see etc

Note: this is currently deployed in Singapore, and might take a little longer to load for those outside of the Asia pacific - do let me know if it is unbearably slow!

Cheers!


r/musiccognition • • Sep 10 '26

Music is an Intersubjective Reality

Thumbnail blog.thinkinghard.com
28 Upvotes

Is music objective or subjective? Music does not correspond to any other aspect of objective reality, and the mechanisms of music perception exist only inside our brains. And yet there is a substantial amount of agreement between different people as to what counts as music. Hypothesis: Evolution wants music to be an objective reality, or as close to objective as it possibly can be. That is, evolution wants us to agree on what counts as music.


r/musiccognition • • Nov 04 '15

Evolution of tonal organization in music

27 Upvotes

Hello. I would like to bring to your attention my article in the Frontiers in Psychology Journal, where I put forth a new comprehensive theory that draws a psychological perspective on the evolution of tonal organization of music from the Stone Age to the rise of Babylonian music theory. Its time-line is hypothesized using the available data from ethnomusicology, anthropology, plotted against the data coming from psychoacoustics - also making a whole range of valuable research from the countries of former Soviet Union available to Western reader for the first time. I’d be interested to hear your thoughts on it. http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01405


r/musiccognition • • Oct 09 '20

unusual books about music theory?

26 Upvotes

Hey there,

i have basic understanding of music theory and i want to learn more.

I'm looking for books that are coming from a different perspectives.

For examples books that combine math, geometry and music or books about the historic development of music theory. The weirder and more esoteric the better!


r/musiccognition • • Feb 06 '26

Is the "unlearnability" of absolute pitch just a case study in historical circular logic?

25 Upvotes

I’ve spent a lot of time digging into the primary literature surrounding absolute pitch acquisition, specifically looking at the origins of the concept of "unlearnability". I wanted to share a quick timeline of what I found most important.

Does anyone think there were other important logical inflection points?

1955 Bachem published the famous "1 in 10,000" statistic and labeled absolute pitch "spontaneous" and "not acquired through practice"

1993 Takeuchi and Hulse published meta-analysis concluding "no documented cases of adults learning absolute pitch"

2013 Van Hedger challenges the idea that absolute pitch is immutable with his "boil the frog" experiment showing perception in lifelong absolute pitch possessors can be influenced by stimulus. (I think this is important because it provides a scientific basis to attempt training contrary to the widespread belief that absolute pitch was "unlearnable")

2019 Van Hedger published the first "black swans" showing that absolute pitch perception can be successfully trained in adults to levels indistinguishable from "naturals," falsifying the "impossible" dogma.

There were of course other follow-up studies that confirmed Van Hedger's findings and other relevant stuff since. Here's the full article I wrote for anyone who's interested.

I left out Levitin in 1994 because it didn't seem to directly influence the perception of "learnability" though I do know from talking to researchers that it was a big influence for later work like Matt Evans' 2024 study on ear worms.

I also left out the Gervain 2013 because even though I see it referenced sometimes as an adult training study, when I read the study it really seems like a study on the drug valporate, which was using learning absolute pitch in adults as a proxy for child-like neuroplasticity.

To reiterate, I'd love to know whether anyone knows of notable milestones or studies in this exact conversation that I missed. I left out the fMRI in 1991 because it's about neuroplasticity and not exactly about learning perfect pitch.

I’d also love to hear whether the "No True Scotsman" defense, redefining absolute pitch to exclude successful adult learners, is still hindering progress in phenotyping. I know it's a problem in the general public, so I guess I'm more wondering how pervasive it is in the scientific community.


r/musiccognition • • Jan 15 '26

Music and Neurodivergence

22 Upvotes

I have autism and ADHD, and I'm interested if there are any studies on the relationship between neurodivergence and music cognition. From what I can tell, diagnosed neurodivergence is disproportionately common in professional musicians, and while it's perhaps inappropriate to speculate about neurodivergence in public figures who are undiagnosed or choose not to reveal it, there are countless musicians out there whom I suspect are neurodivergent. This applies for all levels of success and musical ability in my experience, from musicians I've met or jammed with in my city up to world famous musicians. For that reason, it seems like it would be easy to find a population of neurodivergent musicians for a study.

While I don't think that neurodivergent people are necessarily going to be more musical, it must have some effect on how we interact with music. Plenty of autistic/ADHD people have no interest whatsoever in music, but for some of us it's a fixation. I'm aware any study would therefore predominantly look at those outliers, but that group seems large enough and over-represented enough that it would be worth looking at. In particular, my personal experience is that autistic musicians have much better pitch recognition and musicians with ADHD have a much better internal sense of rhythm than average. That's purely anecdotal of course, but I'd be fascinated to find out if there's something to it. Beyond that, there could be implications for how neurodivergent musicians practice their instruments or compose.

If any work has been done on this I'd love to read it, and I'd love to hear other people's thoughts on the relationship as well.


r/musiccognition • • Aug 17 '20

We’re conducting a study into musical timbre perception and we need your help!

22 Upvotes

Hello /r/musiccognition!

I’m working on some research into the way our brains encode timbre, and we’re currently seeking study participants to help us build a better picture of the way we perceive abstract and synthetic sounds. I’d love to invite members of this subreddit to take part.

The study involves two sections — you may see either or both depending on your cultural and musical background. The first is a pairwise dissimilarity listening test, in which you assign a score to how different you think two timbres are. The second is a semantic rating test, in which you rate a number of sounds along descriptive scales.

Participation takes between 20 and 50 minutes, depending on which parts of the study you end up doing, and requires only a computer (running a recent version of Google Chrome) and a pair of headphones.

As a thank you for participating, you have the option (at the end of the study) to be entered into a prize draw for one of two £25 Amazon vouchers.

You can participate at this link: http://qm-fm-study-2.herokuapp.com/

If you’re interested to know more about the study or how your responses will be analysed, please do ask questions in the comments and I will happily answer :)

Thanks!


r/musiccognition • • Feb 11 '12

Why Adele's 'Someone Like You' Makes Everyone Cry - WSJ.com

Thumbnail
online.wsj.com
22 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Jun 09 '20

Applied Harmony - An Approach for Performers & Composers: new video series on the learning & practical use of harmony via fundamental principles of psychology (by Dr. Andrew Schartmann & Dr. Alan Belkin)

21 Upvotes

Intro:

Applied Harmony - Introduction

First Episode:

Applied Harmony - Basic Principles, Part 1

Official Website

I thought that this was too good not to share. It's not often that I find perceptually-based content that's also readily-applicable for musicians, especially of all breeds!


r/musiccognition • • Feb 04 '22

How do vibrations in the air become music and emotion in your mind? Follow a sound signal as it travels through your ears, and up the different nuclei and pathways in your brain to become music. Watch How We Process Music in our Brains (Neuroscience for Musicians).

Thumbnail
youtu.be
20 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Nov 28 '20

Music Therapy Informed Techniques for Anxiety Management & Wellness

Thumbnail
youtu.be
20 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Oct 23 '15

The neuroscience of bass, and why it's fundamental to music

Thumbnail
openculture.com
20 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Jan 11 '26

How to study music cognition?

19 Upvotes

How do you go into researching/studying music cognition/neuroscience? I really want to go into the field, however I don’t know how to go about it. What degrees do I need? And how would I go about it from there?


r/musiccognition • • Dec 15 '20

Update 5: for those who want to learn how to play music by ear - a platform built to accelerate your ear-training journey! (Still in development)

19 Upvotes

Hey redditors!

Quickly summary of my previous posts:

I built a ear-training platform originally for some of my friends, but figured why not share it with more people and gather more feedback, and posted it online and have since received lots of valuable feedback and advice from the community (thanks to all, really appreciate it!)

Currently, ear-training exercises inside include identification of notes, intervals, sequences of notes, chords and so on.

Where you can find it: https://pitchgarden.com

I’m excited to share some new updates!

  1. Persistent log in has been enabled - issue where users get automatically logged out after refreshing or leaving has been fixed

  2. Improvement for mobile UI - fixed issues where some content is cut off in mobile version

  3. Layout improvements and minor bug fixes in ear-trainer page

  4. 13 more songs added to song-trainer

  5. Minor change in layout

Any feedback/advice/suggestions are greatly appreciated - Thank you all once again for all the support, feedback and suggestions y’all have given me so far - really appreciate it!

If you’re interested in updates about Pitch Garden, feel free to follow us on the following platforms!

Youtube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvx8Wmv9RT6NbhhnMAt5DSA

Telegram channel: https://t.me/pitchgarden

Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Pitchgarden

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/10453...

Twitter: https://twitter.com/pitchgarden

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/pitchgarden_/

Cheers!


r/musiccognition • • Jun 30 '15

A cockatiel can reproduce music accurately, by rhythm and melody

Thumbnail
youtube.com
19 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Jan 28 '15

Music in Our Ears: The Biological Bases of Musical Timbre Perception

Thumbnail
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
19 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Apr 29 '26

Why does all 8-bit-era chiptune music sound like it's pitched higher than we remember?

18 Upvotes

First off, apologies if this is the wrong subreddit to ask about this; getting to the bottom of this has been a long and ongoing saga that has led us to search in several places, so far in vain.

So, background: We (as in, plural system, "me + all my other personalities/voices in my head," apologies for any confusion caused) are currently in our 40s and heavily into gaming. As children, we were practically raised on the old Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) and Game Boy. We have very strong and vivid memories not just of the games we played back then, but of their incredible music. There's something about 8-bit chiptune music that really stirs something in us, you know?

Recently, we were dismayed to discover a disconnect between memory and reality: Specifically, every time we went to go look up a song, it sounded off to us--specifically, it sounded weirdly pitched up compared to what we remember. The first time this happened, I honestly assumed we'd just found some YouTube video that sped the playback up to avoid automatic copyright detection or something. But... no. It's consistent. Not just every video that had that song, but even sites like Zophar's Domain (which have the actual original .nsf files, or, essentially, the exact instructions from the game code to the sound chip for what to play.)

It's not just that we were remembering songs in the wrong key, but it was how consistent we were about remembering everything in that key. After a long time spent grappling with how to explain what we were hearing, we finally realized that you could take any given 8-bit song, slow the playback down to 0.95x or 95% speed (making sure you're not using some advanced speed control that preserves the pitch; you want that reverse-Alvin and the Chipmunks effect to happen,) and you get exactly, and I mean exactly what we remember.

We assembled a link with a selection of songs that particularly stand out to us for one reason or another; you can see what we mean here. For every one of these, the (100) version is standard 100% speed playback--that is, these are the original versions. These are what the songs actually sound like. The (95) versions are what I could have sworn on my very life was what the songs sounded like until I started looking into all of this. Even now, they're what we remember. They're what the music is "supposed" to sound like to our ears and our memories. The (100) versions feel weird to us; they're too sped up, too high pitched. They're wrong. But they're not. We are.

(Side note: If this discussion has made you curious about any songs you remember from that era, the easiest way to recreate this experiment at home is to look up whatever game you'd like in the music collection on Zophar's Domain and download the track you're thinking of; there's your 100 version. Then, we use the Slow and Reverb Studio website to get the 95 version; upload your track, turn the speed to 0.95x and the reverb to 0, and the pitch should automatically be 0.95x as well.)

From the research we've done since then, it's clear differences in music perception aren't exactly uncommon. However, our particular case has some peculiarities that we weren't able to find answers for:

First off, the sheer consistency of the extent to which our memory is off. We've read that the way a song sounds versus how you remember it sounding can be affected by anything from stress levels to your current heart rate--a song you listened to while working out sounds a lot different when listening to it in bed--but that's not the case here. Everything always sounds exactly 5% faster than it's "supposed" to. Nothing ever sounds slower than it's supposed to, but neither does it sound more than 5% faster. Every song from the era always sounds pitched too high at 100% speed and then sounds perfect when set to 95%. Not 90% or below; exactly 95%. Across multiple games, across every time we've sat down to listen and check again while working on this mystery.

It's almost like we have some sort of weirdly perfect and set in stone absolute pitch memory (apologies if that's the wrong term; not exactly an expert in music theory.) We can listen to a song we heard almost 40 years ago with an exact memory of the key it's supposed to be in and an ability to hear the difference when it's even 5% off... except that the unfailing and immovable rock to which our memory's compass points is itself exactly 5% off.

That alone was enough to make me suspect we grew up with an NES that itself played music 5% too slow, and thus we remember what we grew up with. However, that theory has been disproved at this point. We asked about this topic in NES hardware communities where people who know a lot more about the actual circuitry were quick to explain how that's just physically not possible; the entire game would fail to render if the processor were off by that much. Furthermore, we actually still have our old original NES and I recently hooked it up again to test; it now plays music at 100% speed. (That doesn't rule out something about the speakers of the TV we had at the time or the outlet it was plugged into or things like that when we were children, of course, but clearly the system itself is fine.)

Furthermore, this is bigger than our NES itself. Of all of the above examples, Final Fantasy III (whose original NES version was never released outside of Japan) we only played later, as young adults or so, on an emulator, once the fan translation was made. Dragon Warrior IV we played on our original hardware since we still had and still have it, but not until young adulthood when we snagged a copy on eBay. Everything else in this list was original hardware that we played on the NES as children... except for Solar Striker and Tetris, which aren't even NES games at all. Those are Game Boy games. But across all of these cases, across the hardware/emulation gap and even across two different consoles entirely, all of them somehow have the exact same issue of the 95% speed versions being the ones that sound correct to us. What are the odds that all of these systems were affected in exactly the same way? No, that has to be our memory. It has to be.

But... again, why is our memory so consistent about how 8-bit music "should" sound?

And also, why only 8-bit games, specifically? It's not only NES games (again, Game Boy games are affected, too,) but it is only that kind of 8-bit chiptune music. Once you get to the advent of the 16-bit SNES era and beyond, everything returns to normal.

Also, unsure if these tidbits are actually relevant to solving the mystery, but just in case this info we uncovered seems interesting to anyone:

  • We have had at least one or two others in our friend circle confirm the same experience, down to remembering things at the same playback speed. This is far from universal; several friends do in fact hear the 100% versions as correct and as what they remember. But we had, for example, one friend have a very animated emotional reaction to the Dragon Warrior IV Chapter 5 Overworld 1 theme in particular. This song plays after the hero escapes as the sole survivor from a doomed hometown. To them (and to us,) not only is the 95% version "correct" and exactly what we remember, but the 100% version just sounds jarringly off by comparison. It's way too upbeat for the sense of desolation and loneliness you're feeling at that moment. To us, it's ruining the moment to hear the music in that key. No, it's definitely supposed to sound like the 95% version to hit the proper mood, we each could have sworn. (Said friend also backs us up on the 95% version of the Crystalis Mt. Saber theme being the one they remember, too, but without quite as much of an animated defense of the emotional impact in that one's case.)

  • For what it's worth, the one we personally tie that much of an emotional defense to is Mega Man 3's Wily Castle 2 theme. There's something about the lower key that makes it feel so much more melancholic... the 95% version damn near makes me cry when it gets to the "chorus." Something about the chord that resolves to...?

  • Back when we still thought this was a hardware issue and not a memory one, we had a hypothesis that people would identify with whichever one they actually grew up with. That is, people who remember the 100% versions as correct would consider the 95% versions cursed and wrong, just like how people who remember the 95% versions feel about the 100% versions. Surprisingly, this proved not to be the case. Even people we asked in our friend group who remember the 100% versions as correct still liked and sometimes even preferred the way the 95% versions sound, too. (This appreciation emphatically does not hold for the other way around; everyone we asked who remembered 95% hated 100%.)

  • For younger friends who actually hadn't heard these songs before at all and thus had no nostalgia or memory bias or anything going in, who were hearing these songs for the first time, we observed a notable preference for the 95% versions.

Sorry for the post length, here. As you hopefully can see, we've been working on this case for a long time and have quite a few notes racked up by now. Any insight you all might have would be greatly appreciated. Thank you so much for your time, either way!


r/musiccognition • • May 05 '21

Much more difficult to analytically hear vocal harmonies than any other musical texture, feel like they're processed in a very different way than other sound

18 Upvotes

I don't know why, but my brain has this problem actually hearing the distinct notes in vocal harmonies, unlike piano or guitar where if I play a chord and focus on each note I can actually distinctly hear it. With human voices the notes all block together like a thick mesh where overtone and separate voice are difficult to distinguish, and when I'm transcribing I'm doing it by feeling it out and checking until it sounds right, I can't clearly and distinctly hear each individual voice the way I can with other instruments. I get by ok, but I write a lot of vocal harmonies and I think it would vastly improve my writing to be able to really hear them analytically like I do other instruments. Anybody else have a problem where human voices or other timbres sound fundamentally different from others and it's much harder to hear them analytically? Any ideas about why this might be?

Also if those of you who are musicians could recommend some good material to practice transcription of vocal harmonies, I would really appreciate it. Ideally I'd want something a capella with 2-4 voices, slower tempo, good recording quality and either sheet music or some sort of reference like isolated stems I could use to check my work.


r/musiccognition • • Jun 27 '12

Odd article in Slate on "the problem with scientific studies of music..."

Thumbnail
slate.com
18 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Aug 27 '11

Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic Scale (oldie but goodie!)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
18 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Mar 14 '14

Jazz, Guitar and Neurosurgery: the Pat Martino Case Report.

Thumbnail
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
17 Upvotes

r/musiccognition • • Jan 12 '26

Is the future offline for artists when it comes to releasing and promoting records and shows?

16 Upvotes

I'm interested to see what music fans think about the increasing number of musical acts leaving digital platforms - Spotify, social media sites, etc - and choosing more analogue and traditional means to release and promote their records and shows.

Is this something we're going to see much more of as people look to balance their digital lifestyles? Could it eventually spell disaster for streaming, especially if some of the big established names desert them? What does it say about us as fans? Are we longing for real-life experiences?


r/musiccognition • • Aug 11 '21

How Bob Moog brought usability heuristics to the electronic synthesizer

Thumbnail
uxdesign.cc
16 Upvotes