/r/Minecraft Moderation Guidelines
Introduction
Except for severe offenses, one or multiple warnings should be given first.
Repeated offenses raise the punishment where applicable.
Assume positive intent where possible.
Try to de-escalate instead of just giving stern/bot warnings. Calm people break fewer rules than angry people.
Ban messages should always contain the ban reason and a link to our ban appeals process
Removed content should have a removal reason
Remove only what goes against the spirit of the rules, apply common sense and ignore the letter of the rules in other cases
Post and comment removals
Removal reason/comment should be given when posts and comments are removed
Do not consider removal comments a punishment, use them only to explain removals
Removal comments in response to removed comments can clutter up comment sections when there are many comments to be removed. In these cases:
Remove comments without notification
Do not hold the removed comment against the person because they have no way to know
Give warnings for repeat offenders
Send a removal reason via modmail if removing a rule-breaking comment does need to be communicated without commenting inline
Bans
Except for severe offences, bans should only happen after a prior warning (in the form of explicit warnings or removal comments)
Bans are only given for severe offences, or for repeated offences against either the same rule or more than three different rules
The first time someone is banned, it should be a temporary ban of a few weeks
If someone is banned again, it should be a ban which does not expire permanently (reddit calls them "permanent")
Ban messages should include the ban reason and a link to the ban appeals process
Ban appeals on temporary bans can be accepted after a few days
Ban appeals on "permanent" bans
Can be accepted after a few weeks
Should be sincere and convincing, especially for more severe ban reasons or repeated bans - depending on the offence, repeated bans may not be appealable
Modmail
Every modmail should receive a response within a day or so
Modmail responses should be sent without the username hidden
If something needs to be discussed with other mods before responding, a short answer indicating we'll need a bit longer to respond properly should be given instead
Muting is reserved for people who become belligerent
Rough categorization of our rules into where offences are more or less severe
Minor offences (typically not intentionally rule-breaking)
Follow our standards for quality
No memes
Don't post images of text
Stay on topic
Avoid chain posting
Use more specific pages when possible
Speak English only
Medium offences
Don't advertise servers or communities
Be civil
Keep self-promotion to a minimum
Major offences (typically intentionally rule-breaking)
Respect the Minecraft EULA