r/Minecraft • u/CR0SBO • Jun 26 '12
Farmers of /r/minecraft, just to make sure you do know this.
624
u/TheWyo Jun 26 '12
Doing it the first way gives you almost double the efficiency/growth rate. There's a reason people do this. If a wheat is adjacent to wheat on more than 1 axis, it's growth rate gets cut in half. See the wiki page 'Wheat Farming' under the header 'Growth rate'.
261
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
If you cut the growth rate in half, but more than double the output of wheat, aren't you getting more wheat for your time?
169
u/Orobin Jun 26 '12
just build a bigger farm!
→ More replies (2)11
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
My farms resemble CR0SBO's, but with 8 rows of wheat and water down the middle for aesthetic purposes. I get insane amounts of wheat.
edit: I bungled that sentence a bit. My farms have 8 wide rows of wheat, with water dividing each side, for aesthetic reasons.
→ More replies (17)40
u/LessieHippopotamus Jun 26 '12
But most people prefer getting wheat faster. That way you always have wheat.
→ More replies (3)24
u/firepelt Jun 26 '12
That's why you build up a stockpile of excess wheat by more than doubling your output.
→ More replies (22)26
u/HazzyPls Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Time to harvest has always been the deal-breaker for me. Building in rows lets you run down the aisles spam clicking to harvest very quickly.
As opposed to waddling around, holding crouch, in a giant square.So things have changed a bit, apparently. But Holding W and spam clicking is still faster than moving around in a square.58
u/Trahas Jun 26 '12
you no longer have to crouch however, that was removed a while back too. as long as you don't sprint or jump you should be fine.
29
→ More replies (1)10
26
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
Well, if that's really the deal-breaker for you, there are solutions to it. Walking no longer tramples wheat; only jumping. So that takes that out. If you've been crouching still, you don't need to anymore. If you like the feel for aisles, you could use this http://i.imgur.com/Uy5Ve.png. That's what I do, as I'm partial to the layout myself. Lilypads/half steps on the water will stop anything from going down there. You could also add a lily pad to the OP's design and get this http://i.imgur.com/xAbZc.png. Let's you walk straight up and down the rows, and the only thing is that every 9th row, you have a block with no wheat on it. every 9th block.
With those, you never even have to trudge through the water if you don't want to.
→ More replies (10)9
u/Pointy130 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
The problem I have with this is that you can't sprint. Last summer I perfected an underground design that was the fastest possible way to plant and collect wheat without pistons (I was playing on a server with a Jobs plugin, and getting xp for the Farmer job required you to manually break crops).
The design in question:
The glass would prevent you from treading on the crops, the stone next to the crops and over the water would prevent the broken crops from falling out of reach, and the torches would keep everything lit. In order to harvest, I used an Autohotkey script that would spam the left mouse button as fast as possible, and sprinted up a row looking at an angle, breaking the crops, then down the row planting using a script that would spam the right mouse button. (This was unnecessary, I could have easily just used two fingers to rapidly click, but I figured as long as I was going to overengineer things I'd go all the way.)
I'd do this from row to row and aisle to aisle, placing one wheat in each inventory slot but one, used to hold the seeds I'd collect and use for replanting. This would ensure that when my inventory became full, I wouldn't have to sort out the seeds, which I couldn't profit off of in the server's market.
Relative efficiency wasn't an issue, as each row was around 50 blocks long (I didn't come up with the original measurements, I'd probably have gone with 64 blocks if it were an option to me) and it was long enough that by the time I'd finished a full harvest from one wide to the other, the first couple of chunks' distance of rows would have already surpassed the > 80% ready to be harvested stage. If I remember correctly, it held some 8000 wheat and quickly made my faction the richest on the server.
If anyone's actually read all the way through this, I commend you on your perseverance.
→ More replies (3)41
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.→ More replies (3)10
u/iplaygaem Jun 26 '12
One piston, a lever, and a block of water.
Proper positioning will ensure the entire thing gets harvested in one flip of the switch!9
Jun 26 '12
If you load a water bucket into a dispenser it does the same thing now. So basically you connect a dispenser with a water bucket in it to redstone wiring + a button which has the signal run through a pulse generator which turs the dispensers on and off and is completely tunable.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (4)3
Jun 26 '12
You could just run water over them to harvest immediately. My farm for example, is semiautomatic and runs water across the field using redstone circuitry + dispensers. The only problem is replanting but harvesting is pretty much instantaneous.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (32)3
Jun 26 '12
Less than double, at most. That 9x9 block could have 45 wheat blocks at twice the growth speed, vs 80 blocks. 90 wheat in the same time as 80.
7
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
OP's design is half the max growth rate, ignoring the few around the water block. This setup http://i.imgur.com/DeUR9.png, provides twice the growth speed, to hit the maximum. For every row, there's an empty one next to it that can be filled at the cost of cutting the growth rate in half. You can double the amount in the field and then some. Only 28 at max speed can fit in that field. 36 if you just throw them on the ends too, which wouldn't hurt now that I look at it. Either way, it's less than half of the 80 OP's would provide.
What way are you thinking to place them to get over half of OP's harvest and maintain max growth?
→ More replies (4)28
u/renegade770 Jun 26 '12
Straight from the wiki:
Planting in rows on a layer of hydrated farmland produces the wheat the fastest for a given number of seeds. However, planting a solid area of hydrated farmland packs about twice as many individual crops into the same space, each taking a little less than twice as long to mature (see the section on Growth Rates above). Thus, planting an area solid will actually produce slightly more wheat than planting it in rows, and will need to be harvested much less often. This may suit some players who do not like to monitor their farms too closely.
http://www.minecraftwiki.net/wiki/Wheat_Farming#Tips_for_efficient.2Fautomated_farming
Basically, it will grow faster in rows, but its more efficient in the solid square
→ More replies (1)13
9
u/FlyingSagittarius Jun 26 '12
Getting the growth rate cut in half does sound bad, but it's from 30% to 15%. Even though the first method doesn't get its growth rate cut in half, it only gets 16.5% to start with because each wheat only has two adjacent farmlands. Doubling your crop of wheat is definitely worth sacrificing 1.5% of growth rate.
10
u/Captain_Sparky Jun 26 '12
According to the wiki page, the most efficient method is actually to have a solid hydrated field with alternating rows of wheat, putting tilled dirt blocks on either side of the rows instead of water. Which is truly something I don't commonly see. OP's suggestion I see quite often, on the other hand.
→ More replies (5)4
u/superherowithnopower Jun 26 '12
a solid hydrated field with alternating rows of wheat, putting tilled dirt blocks on either side of the rows instead of water
That's how I do my wheat farming, actually.
I wonder if many people don't do the wheat/water/wheat farms partly because that's what the villages have.
6
u/Captain_Sparky Jun 26 '12
That's probably part of the reason. It could also be because most people start their first wheat farm in the easiest possible location - right next to a river or body of water. Having the water all along the side of the tilled soil works, when they eventually make their own inland farm, they carry only that information with them and create rows of water alongside tilled soil.
3
u/fligan Jun 26 '12
Do you mind taking a picture? I may just be being stupid, but I don't understand the layout described.
7
2
u/cxkis Jun 26 '12
Thanks for pointing that out. http://www.minecraftwiki.net/wiki/Wheat_Farming#Growth_rate
2
u/pat5168 Jun 26 '12
Doesn't the wiki say that this is the best way to grow wheat though? I don't like having to check the water canals every time I harvest, so I just use that technique and use 6 lilypads to cover the water.
2
u/Vectoor Jun 26 '12
You rarely harvest stuff as soon as it is ready though. Wheat grows fast enough anyways.
2
u/Herr_Reese Jun 26 '12
Which makes method one better when you're starting out and need wheat fast, but when you have a set up like I do on my friend's server with 10 farms like number 2, it's annoying enough to harvest, and produces enough wheat in one harvest, that it becomes more efficient.
Which is better depends on what point you're at in your settlement.2
u/TheWyo Jun 26 '12
I think that reply makes you the first person to truly have read my comment how I intended it and not try to bring up the relative amount you get compared to full fields. I never disputed that fact. Well done.
2
u/PKfireice Jun 26 '12
actually, the most efficient way is a 3x3 block of dirt with two 1x3 "railings" of water source blocks. Ex:
WDDDW
WDDDW
WDDDW
I remember a while ago hearing that they grow fastest in that configuration, so repeat that as much as you need to. It may have changed since then, but I'm pretty sure its still that way.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.→ More replies (2)1
u/shine_on Jun 26 '12
I use the second method, and after a few in-game days I still have more wheat than I know what to do with.
1
u/UhCrunch Jun 26 '12
Does this include the Y axis? Serious question.
2
u/pineapplol Jun 26 '12
Two wheat cannot be placed next to each other on the Y axis. The dirt it is planted on would get in the way.
→ More replies (1)1
u/DirtyDanil Jun 26 '12
I just like how it looks, not going to start getting out my spreadsheets any time soon ;D
→ More replies (10)1
u/ShadowRam Jun 26 '12
Not to mention you can walk through the water (or lily pads) to harvest, and not risk ruining the ground.
282
u/homesarstar Jun 26 '12
Sometimes, it's not about the efficiency, it's about the aesthetics.
73
u/Ausmerica Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
I think the more efficient way is also the more attractive way, personally.
59
u/CrazyJoe91 Jun 26 '12
And, in my opinion, a field of wheat looks much better than rows of it.
19
u/fapmonad Jun 26 '12
Perhaps you haven't seen a wheat field up close? It looks like this.
I think Minecraft farms are just so small that you immediately notice the rows, unlike the huge fields we have in real life.
13
u/mischab1 Jun 26 '12
And if you look at that picture, you will see there is more than one row within a square meter and that rows are not planted a meter apart. As someone who grew up across the road from a wheat field, I think the square field with one water block looks more accurate.
0
→ More replies (5)4
u/zmilla93 Jun 26 '12
Using the second method in an auto farm likewise looks much better than the first. It is more redstone intensive, but has a very nice effect when harvesting.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (6)1
u/Mindelan Jun 26 '12
Also for me, ease of use. I plant my wheat in a building on a block above ground level, with a glass block above it, and a block behind it covering the water. Then I turn towards the wheat and auto-punch while walking down the line, picking up the wheat as I go. To replant I just hold down the plant button and walk the opposite way.
I get a pretty and modern looking what farm that is also highly functional and very easy to build.
29
u/Talonz Jun 26 '12
This is the way I, personally, have been doing it for a long time now. For those arguing about growth rate... While not having as many adjacent water source blocks will make the wheat grow at about half the speed, one must remember that you now also have about twice as much wheat each time you harvest. The end result is that per unit of time, you will be getting about the same amount of wheat, but only need to harvest it half as much. Less work, same output, in other words.
9
u/gukeums1 Jun 26 '12
I'm replying to this because it's right. And I agree. And this is my rationale: more wheat means more bread. If it takes a little more time but less space for more wheat - what do I care?
It ultimately depends on the situation. Early game SSP? Kill a pig and eat it while the wheat grows. A hardcore deathban server? Probably going to try to make my farm efficient.
Not every strategy makes sense in every situation
46
u/nebetsu Jun 26 '12
I know this isn't the most efficient setup, but I don't mind and I like having wooden planks to walk on while I harvest. I pretend that they're floating on the water.
2
u/hazwoof Jun 26 '12
This is more or less the setup I use. I think it just looks nice.
2
u/igotwaaaybaked Jun 26 '12
Yeah, my setup is pretty similar, too. It's a greenhouse!
3
u/POULTRY_PLACENTA Jun 26 '12
That looks cool, I'll have to make me one of those.
→ More replies (1)1
Jun 26 '12
I do the same but with four tilled blocks on either side and cement half blocks. I think it looks nice and with the size of my wheat field I never run out of wheat anyway so who cares about efficiency.
1
1
u/Zellgadiss Jun 26 '12
I do it the same except I build a large deck in front to make it look like its an extension of the deck.
0
Jun 26 '12
[deleted]
8
Jun 26 '12
Wood is easier to use, especially when you have no access to a swamp. Even if you do have access to a swamp, you still have to gather the lilly pads.
→ More replies (5)
62
u/RosesRicket Jun 26 '12
You're messing up the growth rate with your method.
19
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
The above one won't get maximum growth rate either, as each block with wheat only has two hydrated farmland neighbors. They would need to have tilled and hydrated land on each side of those rows to reach maximum growth rate. If it hasn't changed.
However, his design would be more efficient, just slower to grow. By having wheat on a diagonal, or by having them not in straight line basically, you cut the growth rate in half. But by filling the 2 rows adjacent to the fast growing row, you triple your output at the cost of only half the speed.
Either way, your farming habits also matter a lot. If you like to leave it and come back way later, a packed field is better. If farming is your game, then the quicker one.
0
Jun 26 '12
[deleted]
11
u/VastCloudiness Jun 26 '12
This provides the fastest growth rate: http://i.imgur.com/6ytWI.png
Each wheat has 8 neighboring blocks that are tilled and hydrated farmland. They have a north and south neighbor, but not an east or west neighbor at the same time(can either way, just not a mix). They have no diagonal neighbors.
→ More replies (5)4
2
u/sje46 Jun 26 '12
Growth rate is hardly an issue. You should be getting a huge surplus of wheat even with a small-medium farm. What is an issue is time spent harvesting it. Going up and down and collecting wheat and seeds from rows is a huge time waste. Whereas the block method allows very quick harvesting, and relatively quick planting as well. Takes longer to grow, yes, but if the farm is sufficiently large enough (which isn't large at all) it simply isn't an issue. Just visit the farm once every few minecraft days and you're set for quite a while.
2
u/CR0SBO Jun 26 '12
I think confusion must have arisen because of sugar cane requiring to be grown on a block adjacent to water.
1
Jun 26 '12
I haven't farmed much.. so forgive my ignorance. Is water required for the crops to grow? If not does it help them grow faster? What is the significance?
6
u/mrthirsty15 Jun 26 '12
This is how I do my farms. Just run through the circle smashing plants, run back through replanting.
You can also make the crops two wide.
→ More replies (4)
6
2
u/Fostire Jun 26 '12
Would a block of water under a block of dirt keep it watered?
4
→ More replies (1)0
u/drewsdunne Jun 26 '12
Yes that is what I do. I fill the underneath of my field with water
→ More replies (1)1
u/CR0SBO Jun 26 '12
Interesting, last time I tried that it didn't work. That was a good while back now.... still, cool.
4
u/Mopar_Madness Jun 26 '12
That suggested way to do it "works" but not as fast as the 1st way, its programmed into the farming code that wheat grows fastest in that original configuration. However, according to the minecraft wiki, this is the "optimal" farming method: http://www.minecraftwiki.net/images/b/b6/WheatFarmPatternAR8x81W2T.png
1
u/Tattered Jun 26 '12
I have no idea why someone didn't post this immediately instead of each comment just posting a specific element that affects one aspect of farming
1
u/LitCactus Jun 26 '12
This is my farm setup. Most of the time, it takes 30 minutes and all of my wheat is fully grown.
25
u/kentuckydango Jun 26 '12
It's easier to collect the wheat if you plant it the first way.
→ More replies (1)32
u/Krenston Jun 26 '12
The second way has the same straight lines without having to jump into the water for lost wheat. The second way is easier.
27
u/venividiikarma Jun 26 '12
Lily pads can solve that if you do rows of water
13
u/Ninjasmooshr Jun 26 '12
but you could save on lily pads by only having to use 1 in the more efficient manner.
→ More replies (1)6
u/Herp27 Jun 26 '12
Instead of lily pads, I put a block with a torch on it above the water to save space.
→ More replies (5)
3
3
7
5
4
u/FlyingSagittarius Jun 26 '12
With regards to growth rates, there are two factors why the second method is still better than the first.
For one, the growth rates on the two methods are almost equal. While the first method doesn't get halved growth rates because of crowding, each wheat only has two hydrated farmlands beside it instead of eight. Each wheat gets 2.25 * 2 + 12 growth, for a total of 16.5% growth rate. For the crowded method, each wheat gets (2.25 * 8 + 12)/2 growth, for a total of 15 growth rate. It's definitely not much better.
Second, the increased amount of wheat you can grow at one time vastly outweighs the paltry increase in growth rate. 1.5% extra growth rate isn't worth halving your potential wheat crop.
If you like fast growing wheat, till your soil in the second pattern and plant your wheat in the first pattern. You still have half of the maximum wheat crop, but your growth rates are doubled to 30% because each wheat still has 8 surrounding farmlands without being crowded. This method will produce the same amount of wheat as the second method, and twice as much as the first method.
Source: Wheat Farming page on the Minecraft Wiki.
2
u/AytrusTekis Jun 26 '12
I totally understand this. However, I think another standpoint needs to be considered.
If I am playing a game SSP or SMP where I am not terribly worried about food for survival, I will generally go with the rows because it is aesthetically pleasing.
My rows are generally 2:1 though (2 soil, 1 water) to be a little more efficient with space without losing the general aesthetics.
Now, if I am playing on a server where survival is a much more serious concern, and space saving efficiency is necessary, then I absolutely build the square cell farm.
So, put simply, and I know this is just my method and does not account for everyone, it all depends on the circumstances which farm I use.
Also, I think the row farms are a little easier to manage if you use the automated flushing system for harvesting.
2
u/SageOfSkyrim Jun 26 '12
Here is my farm.
Legend: W - Wheat, H - Water hole, L - Ladder hole, C - Cobble
WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWHWWWCWWWHWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW CCCCCCCLCCCCCCC WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWHWWWCWWWHWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW WWWWWWWCWWWWWWW
Goes in a 15x15 square, cut into 4 7x7 squares with Cobblestone lines. In the very center is a ladder hole that goes down or up, either one. In the center of each 7x7 wheat square is a block of water, which, if you place it from the very top, will go down. You can easily extend this farm up or down, and it is very efficient. Only need 3 blocks of height. I place torches along the cobble pathways and on the top row of the wall in the farm.
And you know what, I don't care if it looks weird in the post. It's too stubborn to fix.
6
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool. Also, end a line with two spaces to get a linebreak.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.2
2
2
u/SirBraneDamuj Jun 26 '12
I think the first method just looks nicer. I don't do one layer of water in between each row of crops, but I still like having a stream run down the crop line instead of just one tiny little square hydrating everything.
2
u/evercharmer Jun 26 '12
Nah man, I'll do what's aesthetically pleasing. I'm generally set up enough in the first few days that the most efficient output simply isn't necessary.
1
u/hackisucker Jun 26 '12
I don't know about you but i think a field of wheat looks better than rows.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/Take42 Jun 26 '12
Orrrrr, make it the first way, but put the water underground under every other row and keep it pleasing to look at and effective. (I make it this way for auto farms)
2
u/Muezza Jun 26 '12
I prefer the first option. It looks a bit better IMO and it isn't like space in MC is at a premium. Different strokes for different folks.
2
u/atomicoption Jun 26 '12
OR use this pattern for maximum growth rate:
~#%#
~#%#
~#%#~ = water
= tilled earth (nothing planted)
% = wheat
3
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.
2
u/KeytarVillain Jun 26 '12
TIL other people don't look up optimal farms on the wiki (mining patterns too, for that matter)
2
2
2
2
u/Valendr0s Jun 26 '12
I usually do 6x7 squares on a slope with a capped water source on either side.
Then I hook a switch up to a water source and let is harvest itself.
2
Jun 26 '12
I prefer automated wheat farms. Flip a switch, collect seeds and wheat. Planting isn't too annoying as the water doesn't destroy the farmland and one harvest lasts quite a while.
2
2
2
2
u/Thyrial Jun 26 '12
I'd just like to point out that people are missing a major point when it comes to efficiency. Yes the OPs method grows slower, but it produces almost twice the amount of wheat so even if it grows at half the speed it's pretty much just as efficient. However the key thing here is that the OPs setup would only need to be harvested once while the optimal setup requires harvesting twice in that same time period. So for most things the OPs setup is actually far more practical for an extremely minor loss in production.
3
u/RamsesA Jun 26 '12
How do you collect the wheat without trampling the tilled soil?
12
Jun 26 '12
You can walk on tiled dirt with out trampling it. Now, you only trample fields by jumping on them. I don't recall what patch changed it.
→ More replies (1)1
→ More replies (9)1
2
Jun 26 '12
In minecraft you have infinite space...
1
u/ZeroError Jun 26 '12
Not if you play factions or are trying to fit your farm into a small area underground or in a valley near your home.
2
Jun 26 '12
The old way also keeps you from having to walk on your soil.
8
u/FancySkunk Jun 26 '12
But there's no longer a downside to walking on tilled land.
→ More replies (6)
1
u/Sta-au Jun 26 '12
Hmm... I'll try your method. I've just been making them in the style that I've witnessed in the Testificate villages. A huge field of wheat does sound really appealing.
1
u/conitation Jun 26 '12
i personally use water on either side to push anything to one spot to be picked up just to make my life easier :p
1
1
u/Reesch Jun 26 '12
I prefer the first way because I keep my water flowing all to one spot. That way I can just walk by where the water ends and collect anything that fell in.
1
u/Lothrazar Jun 26 '12
As a bonus, I like to hold water back with pistons, so it washes the wheat down to me so i do not have to punch it.
1
u/FaithyDoodles Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I do it the way OP suggested, only I have a piece of dirt above the water spot, and a piston a few blocks above that dirt block which is blocking water from flowing, so, I just have to press a button or a lever and water will pour on the entire plot and harvest it for me. I don't mind how long it takes since I make a couple of them and the wheat adds up anyway.
Edited to add pic.
1
u/jonezen7 Jun 26 '12
This is exactly what I was thinking when I was watching DW20's LP this morning.
1
u/InvalidZod Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Ok now make yours so it auto collects all of the wheat into one spot with the push of one button
1
u/BasslineRaver Jun 26 '12
Sometimes I just like having things like the first rows. It looks nicer. :)
1
1
u/five_hammers_hamming Jun 26 '12
I do this:
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-w
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-w
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-w
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-w
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-w
w-ww~ww-ww-ww~ww-ww = wheat on farmland
~ = water (typically flowing from an overhead source that can be shut off for harvest)
-- = walking pathway one block below the wheat-growing level:
W WW WW WW WW WW W
F FF~FF FF FF~FF F
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXx = whatever
2
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.→ More replies (5)
1
u/Alt0173 Jun 26 '12
Am I the only one who builds an underground lake below my crops for them to have water?
1
Jun 26 '12
I personally don't know much about farming but I just think the first way looks a lot better....
1
u/TwistedD85 Jun 26 '12
Also, although I'm not entirely sure if it's changed since I last played, if you build an auto harvester don't forget any wheat caught directly beneath falling water is destroyed.
1
u/The_Hammer_Q Jun 26 '12
yeah, this is the best way to efficiently farm, but the other way just looks better.
1
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 26 '12
I'd just say that I like a more constant, steady stream of income than a larger more sudden one.
1
u/MaverickTopGun Jun 26 '12
A lot of my farms are the first picture because old habits die hard. Back when you you had to crouch on crops, the first way was much easier to harvest.
1
1
u/getintheVandell Jun 26 '12
I do it like this..
Wheat | Water | Wheat | Nothing | Wheat | Water | Wheat
W~W W~W
Lets you walk between the rows and knock anything you don't collect into the waterstream to collect at the base. I'm sure this is very simple and basic advice, though. :V
2
u/Helzibah Forever Team Nork Jun 26 '12
By the way, this subreddit has comment sprites as linked in the sidebar, so you can make pretty pictures:
(The only downside is that there isn't a water sprite, so I've used blue wool.)
By the way, if clicking on this comment causes it to explode madly with numbers in Reddit Enhancement Suite, you can disable the option in the settings console
UI > Keyboard Navigation > commentsLinkNumbers > offor disable the entire keyboard navigation module. See this comment for an explanation.
1
1
u/staticrift Jun 26 '12
I did it the first way before even knowing it helped the crops, purely because it looks good.
1
u/Squishpoke Jun 26 '12
You can even put half-blocks above the water, making little sidewalks to make harvesting even easier.
1
u/moonblade89 Jun 26 '12
I make automated farms to save myself the trouble of farming it all by hand.
I make 3 lanes, 3 wide. The middle one is water, the side ones are dirt. Place it in a tiered fashion so that every 7 blocks or so it raises up 1 level. The middle row will have a walking platform over it to access the switch (getting to it). Right at the very top, I have a simple lever connected to pistons on either side that hold back water. Release the water to wash all the wheat down to a central collection bin. Put the lever back to stop the water. Collect. Reseed.
For me, this has always been the easiest way, but obviously only viable once you get the resource for pistons.
1
u/Jigglymilksack Jun 26 '12
I think a lot of people just arrange theirs like the top photo because it's more aesthetically pleasing. Most of the farms I've made have been more for show than anything else.
1
u/Juxta25 Jun 26 '12
Did anyone think to place the soil on top of a water pool? That way you can have a 10x10 area of wheat in which every block's directly adjacent to a water source, keeping the growth rate and and also maximising the planting area.
1
1
u/Persianseven Jun 26 '12
oh i know, its just that its ugly as fuck and not realistic in the slightest xD
1
u/stone111111 Jun 26 '12
both water and space are (virtually) infinite, so i don't see why its a big deal.
1
1
1
u/Gravyness Jun 26 '12
Here's why the top representation (rows) works better than the other
I particular use the second one tho, it is slower but I'm too lazy to be planting it so often.
1
1
1
1
1
u/BLO0DBATHnBEOND Jun 26 '12
also the other way looks a ton nicer and for me minecraft is all about making stuff look nice
1
u/Kirixis Jun 26 '12
Personally, I use this fact to locate my water source far enough away to hide it for looks and utility. The advantage is that you never fall in water again and you can create paths. My standard arrangement is to make two rows of two wheat with a two block dividing path and two block paths on either adjacent row. Then I hide the water and boom, no more getting wet and with the paths harvest wheat without stepping on tilled soil.
1
1
1
u/Fuguzors Jun 26 '12
Reads comments about growth rates...
I don't think the growth rates matters unless you're sitting there watching and waiting for the wheat to grow... Personally, when I grow wheat, I plant the seeds then go off and do something else. By the time I come back all the wheat have grown, so I harvest and replant it then go off, etc...
1
1
u/HansDaFonz Jun 26 '12
Too lazy to read all the comments, but I'm sure you've noticed you can put the water underneath? Then you can have a 100% efficiency farm.
1
1
u/MrXBob Jun 26 '12
I personally like to build things that look nice. Whether it's more efficient the other way or not, I just think the first way makes for better scenery and is more realistic.
1
1
1
u/CloneDeath Jun 26 '12
It also looks a lot worse, and you can't build an automatic farm the 2nd way.
2
Jun 26 '12
That's not true - I've managed to do it before.
Takes a bit of unique piston placement but it is possible.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
Jun 26 '12
Here'e my personal arguement about farming and the growth rate. I dare you to tell me that you always look at your crops and wait for it to grow. I think that most people just wait around for their crops and come to harvest every once in a while.
I have a design that yields 90 wheat. It uses pistons, so it isn't annoying to break and replant. I check it about once a day, and I have about a chest full of wheat.
1
1
u/cheesyguy278 Jun 26 '12
I think I know why people do the traditional method: Back when wheat could be trampled when walking, people had to use the older method so they could harvest without trampling by walking in the water.
1
u/Shyshaeia Jun 26 '12
Thanks for the reminder. I tend not to maximize crops too much and go more for asthetics instead. This will work great for my "Amber Waves of Grain" project. I'm going to turn my nieghboring grassland into a savanah!
1
u/feanturi Jun 26 '12
Who needs to save that much space? Well I guess on a small server, but... I prefer to have my farm plots two blocks wide and several blocks long, with a trough of water completely surrounding the whole thing. Then I cover the water with half blocks making it a nice trim. Looks great and you're not falling in the water all the time.
1
1
1
u/Darth_Kyofu Jun 26 '12
But the first one is more beautiful. Unless it's a really big farm. Besides, how can water be something we can waste? It's almost infinte. Oh, wait, it IS infinite.
1
u/PublicToast Jun 26 '12
I hate when people do this. If they want it to grow faster, why don't they just do this?
1
1
u/captainf Jun 26 '12
I haven't played in a while, but can't you just put the water underneath a block of dirt and it still works the same? Wouldn't doing it that way give 100% efficiency?
1
u/xlirate Jun 26 '12
what about the hole thing were if you make more then 2 rows of weet, they grow much slower?
1
u/sweett2015 Jun 27 '12
Has anyone tried to put water underneath the block of dirt? Would it work this way? Because that would solve everyone problems....
1
1
1
1
u/Captain_Sugar Jun 26 '12
But... it's just so ugly man. I'm sure if we needed to grow real wheat to feed our starving families, and option B was a valid way to do so, we'd do it. But when farming virtual wheat, appearance is half of it.
1
9
u/CR0SBO Jun 26 '12
Well that sparked a lot more discussion than I imagined it would...