Posts
Wiki

Comparison with other extensions/userscripts

I decided to make this page to give a detailed comparison of Image Max URL (will be referred to as IMU for brevity) vs other extensions or userscripts that provide similar functionality. Since I am the developer of IMU, although I've tried to write this as unbiased as possible, there definitely may be inaccuracies with regards to the other extensions. If you spot any issues, please let me (/u/MaxImageBot) know! :)

In general, I'd personally recommend for you to try them all and see which one you like best.

General

In general, these are the main advantages of IMU:

  • It can find larger/original images for literally thousands of hardcoded websites (currently >9000), ~20-30 times more websites than any of the extensions listed below

    • There are also many generic rules (such as for WordPress, Drupal, and MediaWiki), which means that any website not explicitly supported by the script may still be supported through the generic rules.

    • Almost every rule is URL-based, not host-based. This means any website that hosts the image is supported (or even if the image is opened by itself in a new tab)

  • The popup functionality is supported on pretty much any website, with pretty much any image. There are very few host-specific rules, as they are almost never needed in order for it to work on any specific website.

  • It's highly configurable (currently ~300 options), which means that you can customize it to work exactly as you'd like

    • Nearly every keyboard shortcut can be fully customized via recording a keysequence, and can even include mouse buttons.

  • It's updated frequently, and each update is often relatively significant (you can check the changelog)

  • Fully open-source! :)

And these are the main disadvantages (most of which are planned to be addressed in future updates):

  • No support for custom rules (issue). If you want to add a new rule, you have to add it directly to the script (or contact me)

  • Unless they are complex, I almost always add new rules within a day, often within the hour if I'm available at the time. PRs are also accepted!

  • Some popup features found in other extensions/userscripts are missing (see the comparisons below for more information)

  • The configurability is a double-edged sword. Since there are quite a few options, it can be hard to navigate through. (issue)

  • Currently there is very little for localization (issue). If you want to help, please do! :)

  • No chrome extension (issue)

I want to make IMU as powerful as possible, so pretty much none of these features (or the ones missing in the comparison tables below) are out of scope, they're just not yet implemented. If there's any specific feature you'd like to see, please let me know! It helps for me to know which features to prioritize implementing :)

Table

Below is a mapping of IMU options and features to other extensions. Note that only popup-related features are included (features like replacing images and redirection are not included in the table as they are not present in any of the other addons).

Please let me know of any inaccuracies! Though I have tried to make this as fair as possible, I haven't done in-depth research on any of the addons, so it's absolutely possible that there are mistakes.

This table is still unfinished

Image Max URLImagusHover Zoom+Mouseover Popup Image Viewer
Enable/disable toggle+Popup enable/disable keyEnabled when holding...Activate Hover Zoom+N/A
Enable/disable toggle+Popup enable/disable keyDisabled when holding...Disable Hover Zoom+N/A
Popup trigger delayDisplay delayDelay before displaying a picture/videoN/A
N/AReset delay on mouse-moveN/AN/A
Popup action??N/A
Allow showing partially loadedN/A (always enabled)?N/A (always enabled)
Use not-allowed cursor when unsupported / unable to loadN/AN/AN/A
Minimum image sizeN/AN/AN/A
Use mouseover eventN/A (always enabled)N/A (always enabled)N/A (always enabled)
Exclude background-imagesN/AN/AN/A
Exclude page backgroundN/A (always enabled)N/A (always enabled)N/A (always enabled)
Exclude image maps??N/A
Only popup for linked imagesN/AN/AN/A
Exclude if image URL is unchangedN/AN/AN/A
Exclude image tabs???
Pop out of frames (beta)(always enabled, stable)?N/A
Popup default zoom: Fit to screenN/A (always enabled)??
Popup default zoom: Fill screenN/AN/AN/A
Popup default zoom: Full sizeN/AN/AN/A
Popup default zoom: Custom sizeN/AEnlarge zoomed images by this factorN/A
Popup position: Cursor middlePop-up placement (?)??
Popup position: Beside cursorPop-up placement (?)??
Popup position: Page middlePop-up placement (?)Center images?
Popup for plain hyperlinksN/A (always enabled)??
... Only for links that look validN/A (always enabled)??
Popup for <canvas>???
Popup for <svg>???
(Blacklist functionality)GrantSitesN/A
Don't popup video for imageN/AN/AN/A
Support pointer-events:none??N/A
Keep popup open untilN/AN/AN/A
Don't close until mouse leaves???
Threshold to leave imageN/AN/AN/A
Leaving thumbnail cancels loadingN/A (always enabled)??
ESC cancels loadingN/A (always enabled)??
Automatically close after timeoutN/AN/AN/A
Use hold key+Center popup on hold+Close popup on unhold+Enable pointer events on holdFull zoomN/AN/A
Close when leaving: ThumbnailN/A (always enabled)N/A (always enabled)?
Close when leaving: Popup???
Close when leaving: Both???
Clicking outside the popup closesN/A??
Zoom out fully to close??N/A (always enabled)
Popup panning methodFull zoom default mode??
... Invert movementN/A??
Minimum drag amountN/A??
Horizontal/Vertical scroll action: GalleryScroll through an album with mouse wheelUse mousewheel to navigate albumsN/A (Horizontal zooming scrolls through an album)
Horizontal/Vertical scroll action: ZoomN/A (default)N/A (default)N/A (always enabled)
Horizontal/Vertical scroll action: PanN/AN/AN/A
Override scroll outside of popupN/A (always enabled)??
Zoom originN/A (always set to Cursor)??
Zoom behaviorN/A (always set to Incremental)??
Incremental zoom multiplierN/AN/AN/A
Move with cursorMove pop-up with cursor??
Move within pageN/A (always enabled)??
Link imageN/A??
Link videoN/A??
Clicking link downloadsN/A??
Hide cursor over popup + Hide cursor afterHide idle cursor over popup??
Disable pointer events???
Download keySave pop-up contentSave imageD key
Open in new tab key... Open image in new tab?T key
Open in background tab keyShift+... Open image in new tab?N/A
Open options key... Preferences?N/A
Rotate left/right key... Rotate left/right?N/A
TODOTODOTODOTODO

Imagus

This section (and below sections) are kept while the Table section is still under development

Below is a mapping of Imagus options to IMU options. Note that while Imagus has many options that IMU doesn't have, IMU also has many options Imagus doesn't have. It depends which options you find more useful :)

Preferences:

ImagusIMU
Enabled/Disabled when holding ...Popup trigger/prevention key
Display delayPopup trigger delay
Reset delay on mouse-moveN/A (always enabled)
Wait before start another zoomN/A
Mark zoom-able elementsAutomatically highlight images -> Hover, modify Highlight CSS to change the style
Minimum size difference to zoomN/A
Preload imagesN/A (issue)
Prefer images with higher resolutionN/A (always enabled)
Load higher resolution when entering full-zoomN/A (always enabled)
Add hovered links to the browser historyAdd popup link to history
Default media volumeDefault volume
Scroll delay?
Scroll through an album with mouse wheelVertical/Horizontal scroll action -> Gallery
Cyclical scrolling in albumsCycle gallery
Caption styleButton CSS style
Caption placementButton CSS style
Wrap by defaultWrap caption text
Show caption textCaption (in UI)
Consider link-text as caption?
Show image/video dimensionsImage size (in UI)
Prevent tooltips?
Default modePopup panning method
Activation with right mouse buttonHold key -> Right click
Pop-up placementPopup position
Use all available spacePrevent cursor overlap
Move pop-up with cursorMove with cursor
Follow the cursor while hidingN/A (no option to hide the popup)
Minimum distance between the pop-up and the cursorN/A
Hide idle cursor over the pop-upHide cursor over popup, Hide cursor after
Use the thumbnail as the background of the pop-upPopup CSS Style -> background-image: url(%thumburl%)
Mask color and opacity?
Custom style (CSS)Popup CSS style
Send image to ...N/A

Shortcuts:

ImagusIMU
Disable shortcuts while editing textDisable keybindings when editing text
Ctrl+Right click on an image puts it into a pop-upPopup trigger key (Record, Ctrl+Right click)
... suspend for the current session and domainN/A
... manually preload imagesN/A
... Enter full-zoom modeFull zoom key
... toggle using all available space?
... wrap captionN/A, but hovering over the caption will display the full caption
hide caption when Shift is heldUI toggle key
... open image in new tabOpen in new tab key, Open in background tab key
... add or remove to/from historyN/A (always added when 'Add popup link to history' is enabled)
Save pop-up contentDownload key
Copy URLCopy link key
... copy caption textN/A (but selecting and copying the caption text will work as expected)
Esc hide the popup and stop loading its contentSame behavior
... zoom in/outZoom in/out key
... PreferencesOpen options key
... Flip horizontal/verticalHorizontal/Vertical flip key
... Rotate left/rightRotate left/right key
... Natural size?
... Auto fit?
... Fit to widthN/A
... Fit to heightN/A
... Send image to...N/A
... Step forward/backwardNext/previous gallery item
... Step 5 foward/backwardN/A (modify the current item # directly in the UI)
... Jump to start/endN/A (modify the current item # directly in the UI)
... Jump to numberNo keyboard shortcut (yet), but you can modify the current item # directly in the UI
... Search for captionsN/A (done automatically, if I understand this option correctly)
... Play/pausePlay/pause key
... Show/Hide controlsToggle video controls
... Speed up/downSpeed down/down key
... Frame-step for videoPrevious/Next frame key + Frame Rate

As mentioned above, no custom rule support for IMU, so the Sieve section is ignored.

Grants are supported through the Blacklist option (albeit in a more basic manner)

Hover Zoom+

General:

HZ+IMU
Enlarge zoomed images by this factorPopup default zoom -> Custom size, Custom zoom percent
Caption positionButton CSS style
Extend zoomed images below the mouse cursor?
Show icon in address barN/A (always visible)
Show zoomed images while loadingAllow showing partially loaded
Show high resolution pictures when availableN/A (always shows the highest resolution)
Use mousewheel to navigate albumsVertical/Horizontal scroll action -> Gallery
Enable ambient light behind imagesKind of, this could theoretically be done through modifying Popup CSS style + Background CSS style. It might be a bit of a pain to do this though
Center imagesPopup position -> Page middle
Frame background colorPopup CSS style (border: 5px solid [color])
Zoom videosEnable Videos
Use prev/next action keys (or mousewheel) to change video position bySeek amount
Don't use mousewheel to navigate within video (action keys will still work)Vertical/horizontal scroll seeks -> No
Mute zoomed videosMute video
Show timestamp on videosN/A
Audio volume for unmuted videosDefault volume
Delay before displaying a picturePopup trigger delay
Delay before displaying a videoPopup trigger delay
Fading animation durationPopup fade, Background fade

The Sites tab is supported through the Blacklist option

Action keys:

HZ+IMU
Activate Hover Zoom+Popup trigger key
Disable Hover Zoom+Popup prevention key
Open image in a new windowN/A
Open image in a new tabOpen in new tab key
Save imageDownload key
Activate full zoomFull zoom key
View previous image in a galleryPrevious gallery item
View next image in a galleryNext gallery item

Advanced:

HZ+IMU
Show update notificationsNotify when update is available
Add viewed pictures to the browser's historyAdd popup link to history
Exclude NSFW imagesN/A
Automatically preload zoomed imagesN/A (issue)
Enable albums supportEnable gallery
Zoomed pictures opacityPopup CSS style

Mouseover Popup Image Viewer

All features are supported except for:

  • Custom rules

  • Force popup ignoring size threshold