r/marxistreadingclub • • Sep 03 '18

Capital Vol. I - Week One - Part VIII: So-called Primitive Accumulation

32 Upvotes

Alright everyone, let's begin! To start off we're going to be following this study guide to Capital Vol. I which begins with the last part first at the author's recommendation. Reading begins today and we're going to try to do a chapter-a-week pace that can totally be extended in case some of us need more time.

This thread is the discussion thread for the first part we'll be reading, Part VIII. Spark discussion, ask for clarification, critique, and anything else related to So-called Primitive Accumulation here!

Edit: The study guide has essay questions at the end of each section. Feel free to post your q&a's here!


r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 23 '12

Lenin's "Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism" (IHSC): Introduction

21 Upvotes

As I'm sure most of you know the next book we're reading is Lenin's "Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism" but we're going to be doing the discussion a bit different this time in response to the feedback we received. So this post will function as an introduction to IHSC and to explain the new discussion method we're trying.

The 5 Discussion Plan:

  • We will be splitting IHSC into 5 separate discussions, discussing two chapters each.

  • Tomorrow, I will post all 5 discussion threads at once, that way people will have an opportunity to post as soon as they're done with the section.

  • There will still be specific discussion dates, but commenting before or after is fine. Our First discussion will be on chapters 1 and 2 and the official discussion date will be next Wednesday 8/29. The next 4 discussions, also on two chapters each, will be every Wednesday. This is subject to change if people think that's too long of a time or something.

  • Discussion prompts or extra material will be added by me on or before the discussion date. I will be making shorter and simpler posts than the ones you saw in TSAR discussions.

  • Give us feedback on this discussion method. There are certain aspects I think will work, and certain ones I think won't, but the only way to know is try it and to see what people think!

  • Let me know if you'd like to "host" one of the 5 discussions. Basically, you can write discussion prompts and link to certain things etc, message it to me, and I will edit it into the appropriate discussion. I will give you credit of course (and I receive no karma, if that even matters to anyone here).

  • The community will vote on the next book we discuss. I will be posting a thread to vote for the next book in the next few days. We'll also decide if we want to have multiple discussions at once or not.

Okay, now that that's out of the way.

Introduction to Lenin's IHSC:

Here's an introduction written by Phil Gaspar for "Socialist Worker". I suggest reading that. There's also a short article about IHSC by Brian Jones in the ISR that I think will be helpful. Also, here's the wikipedia page on IHSC

Hopefully those will show you why this work is still important today. Also, I want to include two important points made in the introduction of my paper version of the book:

  • Lenin wrote this while exiled in Switzerland in early 1916. It didn't appear in Russia until late 1917. He wrote if for open, legal presentation in Russia, and because of this he had to phrase things in a particular way to avoid censorship. He says in his preface:

It is painful, in these days of liberty, to re-read the passages of the pamphlet which have been distorted, cramped, compressed in an iron vice on account of the censor. That the period of imperialism is the eve of the socialist revolution; that social-chauvinism (socialism in words, chauvinism in deeds) is the utter betrayal of socialism, complete desertion to the side of the bourgeoisie; that this split in the working-class movement is bound up with the objective conditions of imperialism, etc.—on these matters I had to speak in a “slavish” tongue, and I must refer the reader who is interested in the subject to the articles I wrote abroad in 1914-17, a new edition of which is soon to appear. In order to show the reader, in a guise acceptable to the censors, how shamelessly untruthful the capitalists and the social-chauvinists who have deserted to their side (and whom Kautsky opposes so inconsistently) are on the question of annexations; in order to show how shamelessly they screen the annexations of their capitalists, I was forced to quote as an example—Japan! The careful reader will easily substitute Russia for Japan, and Finland, Poland, Courland, the Ukraine, Khiva, Bokhara, Estonia or other regions peopled by non-Great Russians, for Korea. (Emphasis mine)

  • Lenin specifically does not draw upon Marx or Marxist economists to substantiate his claims. He instead chooses to utilize bourgeois economists to emphasize his point.

  • The book's title as it appeared originally was apparently "Imperialism the Latest Stage of Capitalism".

Please let me know what you think of anything I've talked about or linked to here, and feel free to post any other resources you think would serve as good introductory aids.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 02 '19

We're summarising every chapter of Das Kapital, here's Chapter 1.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 18 '18

Revival for Marxist reading club - ?

18 Upvotes

Can we go through Capital Vol. 1 for those like myself who haven't read it yet? Maybe set it up to start August 1st or sometime around there? Would love to have discussion threads in real time with other folks reading it too.

UPDATE: Join me over at this thread for the next move: https://www.reddit.com/r/marxistreadingclub/comments/93018v/polling_for_capital_vol_i_chapter_by_chapter_w/


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 24 '12

The State and Revolution: Discussion of Parts I-III

15 Upvotes

Edit: I just wanted to say that anyone viewing this hours or even a few days after the discussion shouldn't let that stop them from contributing. We're still in the process of reading this book and will be for at least the next week or so, and this discussion will be on the front page of this subreddit for quite some time.

Also we'll be having our next discussion, about parts IV-VI, on 8/1 at around 5pm US Eastern Time.

Hello everyone, it's finally time for Marxist Reading Club's first discussion. The topic is parts I, II and II of Lenin's State and Revolution.

I was going to try to explain a lot of the historical background but I see that I'm already late in posting this so I'll instead just say what I personally think this first discussion should be about, list some questions I think should be answered in order to understand the context in which this was written, and provide some supplemental resources.

Firstly, I think it's important for everyone to remember that we're just discussing the first 3 chapters of the work. It's not forbidden to mention later sections, but I do think this means that we should keep in mind that proper "judgement" of the work as a whole will make more sense in our next discussion. This doesn't mean you can't present issues with a point Lenin made in a particular chapter we read. I just think this discussion should focus more on understanding the historical context of the work, who Lenin was writing for and responding to, and basically asking questions more than answering them. I think at this juncture there is more value in understanding the history preceding and surrounding the publication of the work than there is in discussing how things went after... feel free to contradict me though. I, at least, am trying to put myself in the shoes of someone reading this at the very start of the revolution, for now.

A few points of interest/questions:

Lenin wrote TSAR (I realized that that was the acronym the other day and it amuses me to no end) during his exile in Finland, just a few months before the revolution. It was not published until just after the revolution. How does this affect the lens through which we view the work?

Lenin frequently references and addresses the ideas of Karl Kautsky, a very influential Marxist at the time. Kautsky's work Dictatorship of the Proletariat is mentioned heavily. Lenin wrote his own response to it called The Renegade Kautsky. What were the main disagreements between Kautsky and Lenin?

One major theme so far is the concept of recuperation. Lenin attempts to restore Marx's radicalism. This, of course is very relevant as Marx and other revolutionaries are still being "emasculated", as Lenin says, today. How does the recuperation of revolutionary figures, in relation to the issues discussed by Lenin in TSAR, differ between then and now?

I had more questions/concepts I wanted to bring up but I'll just have to get into them during the discussion as I'm out of time.

Video Resources:

The Paris Commune is mentioned a lot. Here are two lecture on the subject I've enjoyed in the past:

The Paris Commune and its Legacy: this is part of a series of lectures on the history of France and it's especially interesting for all the bizarre and amusing details about the commune the speaker provides.

Paris Commune 1871: This is a talk by a Marxist so it deals more with the significance of the commune in ways probably more relevant to our interests. Don't get intimidated by the giant "STALIN" banner... regardless of what you think of him Stalin has nothing to do with this excellent lecture.

Here is a fairly decent biography of Lenin obviously its not free of bias by any means, but it seems less biased than some of the other ones I've seen.

Here's a talk on TSAR that I found pretty interesting although the questions/statements by the audience at the end were a little less useful to me.

This is the first of another series of videos about TSAR, but I haven't watched it yet.

I'm at work for the next few hours so I probably won't be able to make in-depth contributions until later.

Okay, let's discuss!


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 20 '12

Reading State and Revolution: When, How, Why?

15 Upvotes

When?

Okay, I figured we should probably discuss setting up a schedule for reading and discussion. I'm open for whatever people want but I was going to suggest we have our first discussion on chapters 1-3 on 7/24 at around 6pm UTC.

I know this may be annoying to some of you who already started reading, but I hope to link to this subreddit in r/communism and /r/socialism to get some more people interested in reading to join us. This longer time will give them time to get a copy or prepare time to read etc.

In my copy chapters 1-3 is only 40 pages, and it's just slightly less than half the whole work, so I figure we can read 4-8 faster once we have people on board, but what does everyone else think?

How?

What version are you reading?

Here is an online copy of the book.

I'm reading the version in this Essential works of Marxism collection.

It seems that this is one of the more popular editions, and I wanted to bring it up because it is translated by the anti-communist historian Robert Service who has been criticized for his biased work in the past.

This doesn't mean it's a bad translation, but people reading that version might keep this in mind, you might even try comparing a couple sections to the online version or something. I don't want to discourage reading this version, but it will be interesting to see if the translator's bias makes a difference.

Also, does anyone have any suggestions for complimentary essays, articles, documentaries or other resources? This could not only add depth to our understanding of the work, but could give people who finished reading the section first some extra material to discuss.

Why?

This is optional, of course, but I thought some of you might be interested in stating why you're interested in reading "State and Revolution" in addition to voicing your opinion on this other stuff.

I read it about a year ago, but not thoroughly enough. I think I just read through the words but didn't think about it enough at the time, and I wasn't very familiar with Lenin or the history of the Russian Revolution then. I kind of had a dismissive view of Lenin at the time which I now see as unjustified and it led me not to get very much out of the work.

Having grown more familiar with the history and Lenin as a person, having read some of his other writings, and having moved more toward traditional Marxism and seeing value in Marxist Leninism, I've decided it would be very helpful for me to reread this and to read more works by Lenin who really was the first person to put Marx's theory into practice on a large scale.

How about you?


r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 16 '12

Our next book discussion on Lenin's "Imperialism", thoughts about this subreddit so far, and where we'd like to go next.

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone, sorry for dropping off the face of the earth. Back to action!

I'd like to talk about the next discussion, possible other book discussions, and what all of you think of this subreddit so far and want to see in it.

First, the next discussion I host will be about Lenin's "Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism" which you can read online here. I'll probably post a separate thread about it but feel free to comment on that selection here.I'd like to hear any thoughts on the timeframe for reading this and if we should split it in two etc.

I think it will be a great follow up to TSAR and is also pretty relevant today. It's considered one of Lenin's most important works and it's focus on economic imperialism, concentration of capital, banks, and the formation of monopolies (even the the "freest" markets) make it something that I think we can pretty easily relate to the state of affairs today. Its subject matter will also open the doors to discussions on plenty of other interesting subjects as well. I'm also looking for a more modern work that continues Lenin's line of thought on this.

Some questions for everyone here:

  • What do you think about this subreddit so far, and what did you think about our discussion on TSAR? Is there anything we could do to create better discussions and get more people involved? Were my prompts/resources valuable or could I have created a more lively discussion?

  • Did you like the format of two separate discussions for TSAR or would it be better to have a single discussion for shorter works like that?

  • Does anyone else want to lead discussions on other works? As I said in another thread, I'm happy to post discussion dates and times for other works as long as someone is willing to host it and there is interest in the work.

  • Does anyone have any other suggestions to make this subreddit more engaging, interesting etc?

  • Where should we go from here? Philosophy? Economics? Political theory? History? Marxism combines all of these things of course but it's obvious that there are works that focus most heavily on one or the other.

I'd like to see what direction everyone would like to go after we finish our "unit" on Lenin (we'll see if people are still interested in reading something else by him after ITHS).

I've had a few ideas. It really depends on what everyone here is familiar with. I'm starting to think that it would be useful to cover some of the basics. For instance, we could read the "The Early Marx" section of The Marx-Engels Reader.

I also don't know where everyone stands on Marxist economics. Has everyone read Capital? Is Marxist economics something people would like to focus on because that rabbit hole goes pretty deep, but interests me greatly.

I'd also like to move onto things like the later works of Marx and Engels, the Grundrisse, and the works of other major Marxists like Trotsky, Luxemburg, Gramsci, Mao, etc. We could also throw in some more recent works of Marxism, from the likes of Bertell Ollman, Andrew Kliman, Richard Wolff, Louis Althusser, David Harvey, Slavoj Zizek etc etc.

Lastly, we could even include a fiction book here and there. I have tons of suggestions for that but I've already rambled enough.

Okay, so let me know what you think. All thoughts and suggestions are welcome!


r/marxistreadingclub • • May 11 '14

Session 1: Bukharin's 'Economic Theory of the Leisure Class' - Prefaces, Introduction and Chapter 1

13 Upvotes

For those unfamiliar with the structure/plan of this reading group, please check this post for details.

This session, we'll be reading the Russian and English Prefaces, the introduction and chapter 1 of Nikolai Bukharin's work, 'Economic Theory of the Leisure Class' [Here's a PDF version of the book!]

I would also suggest consulting Screpanti and Zamagni's book, 'An Outline of the History of Economic Thought' [PDF] for a brief academic overview of some of the economists referenced in Bukharin's book. I will provide a list of names referenced in each section of my notes in order to aid in this task.

Feel free to discuss the book, add questions or comments or share your notes below! Mine will be posted shortly.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 30 '12

IHSC: Chapters I and II

13 Upvotes

Sorry to be late in posting this. This is the first free time I've had to sit at a computer and type stuff in awhile.

A few thoughts/questions:

Chapter I: "Concentration of Production and Monopolies"

In this chapter Lenin explains how capitalist production tends toward centralization which leads to monopoly. He uses statistics and writings from bourgeois economists to demonstrate how most production in various countries is accounted for by a very small proportion of the actual businesses.

There has been plenty of writing on this subject since, but to put it into modern terms I'll mimic Lenin by pointing you to Forbes' article on the Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich's database showing the "147 companies that control everything" which in turn links to the actual paper. I'd love to hear some thoughts on this or other similar studies that bring this up to date.

Lenin also argues against the "free trade/regulation stops monopolies" ideas, both of which we still hear a lot of today. He says:

The facts show that differences between capitalist countries, e.g., in the matter of protection or free trade, only give rise to insignificant variations in the form of monopolies or in the moment of their appearance; and that the rise of monopolies, as the result of the concentration of production, is a general and fundamental law of the present stage of development of capitalism.

Lenin sums this idea of necessary monopoly formation here:

[...]the development of capitalism has arrived at a stage when, although commodity production still “reigns” and continues to be regarded as the basis of economic life, it has in reality been undermined and the bulk of the profits go to the “geniuses” of financial manipulation. At the basis of these manipulations and swindles lies socialised production; but the immense progress of mankind, which achieved this socialisation, goes to benefit . . . the speculators. We shall see later how “on these grounds” reactionary, petty-bourgeois critics of capitalist imperialism dream of going back to “free”, “peaceful”, and “honest” competition.

Has he demonstrated satisfactorily that both government regulation and a "free market" either aid or at least do not hinder the formation of monopoly? How has thought on this progressed over the last 100 years?

Chapter II: "The Banks and Their New Role"

Here Lenin describes how banks have come into a position of great importance controlling virtually all of capitalist's money capital. He uses Germany as an example, which had an unusually strong banking industry for the time.

Here's an article from Worker's World about the banks role in the modern crisis.

How has Lenin's idea of the banks' importance measured up? Was Lenin making an overstatement when he talked about the "domination of finance capital"? I think Brenden McCooney's video on the falling rate of profit could be a helpful resource here.

A Few More Resources:

Lenin’s Theory of Imperialism and its Rivals : This is an excellent lecture on Lenin's theory of Imperialism and other theories before and since.

Imperialism Lenin and Bukharin this is a 2008 video lecture I really enjoyed. It provides some excellent background on the events preceding/surrounding the publication of IHSC. It not only goes over Lenin and Bukharin's ideas of imperialism and how it relates to today but he makes some criticisms as well.

Complementary writings:

Imperialism and World Economy by Nikolai Bukharin: Lenin based much of his work on this longer work and some have argued that Bukharin's work presented a more comprehensive theory.

The Marxist Theory of Imperialism and its Critics by Ernerst Mandel: this is a pretty short work that does what it says on the tin, the biggest downside is that it's kind of dated, having been written in 1955.

Also, as I discussed in the introduction, I posted all the other discussion threads at once. Feel free to go to those relevant threads and post if you'd like... we'll see how this works out.

III and IV, V and VI, VII and VIII, IX and X.

Should I make an announcement on the official discussion dates or something?


r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 03 '12

The State and Revolution: Discussion of Parts IV-VI

13 Upvotes

Hello everyone and welcome to our discussion of Parts IV-VI of TSAR! I apologize for the delay, I lost access to my computer and had to reformulate everything I'd prepared.

I think I went a little overboard on the references/links and probably didn't spend enough time formulating good discussion prompts, but let's see where this takes us:

A few questions and talking points: (Feel free to ignore these and talk about whatever you want --ask your own questions too!)

  • Lenin has been accused by some (as referenced in this essay and as shown in this oft-posted Chomsky clip) of greatly changing his tone in TSAR, and not fitting with it in his previous or later writings. How much truth is there to this? This essay seems to argue against the aforementioned point of view that point of view, but I don't have access to the whole article so I can't be sure of the author's intent. (My own feelings on this are summed up pretty well in this series of comments I made some time ago, but I'm definitely open to discussion on the matter). This is something that comes up a lot, so what are your thoughts?

  • Rather than speaking directly Lenin seems to act as a guide, showing us the true nature of M&E's views. Is this really all he is doing? If he is making a substantial contribution, is his style of writing simply him strongly crediting his influences, an attempt to veil his own contributions, or was this necessary due to his opponents placing M&E on a pedestal and at the very same time diluting them?

  • Much is said of the question "has the oppressed class arms?". What are your thoughts on this considering the development of technology and the increasing divide between the power of the state (in the form of smart bombs, drones etc) vs. what an armed proletariat (with just guns) could accomplish? Is "has the oppressed class drones?" going to be a question to ask in future revolutions?

  • In part IV section 5 Lenin is pretty blatant about his views of personal privacy of religion as opposed to party "privacy" of religion which he speaks of in this earlier work and this one as well. Are any of you religious? How do you feel about this?

  • What were your thoughts on Lenin's discussion of "Equal Right?" as this comes up frequently in discussion?

Also, this isn't a question or a prompt but I just wanted to say that I feel the section "The Economic Basis for the Withering Away of the State" could've served to answer about half of the questions posted to r/debateacommunist... I exaggerate, but I seriously felt like he was addressing the Hypotheti-pals of DAC there.

Thoughts on The State and Revolution in Practice:

  • Why did revolutions form in less industrialized areas instead of areas with a stronger proletariat, and M&E supposed they would? (or, to put it another way, why did the revolutions in more industrialized countries fail?)

  • What makes a truly "premature" revolution and what, in your opinion, is an example of one?

  • If the type of worker's government, or DoP put in place vary depending on the conditions it's established in, just what kind of variance can there be, and how can we apply lessons from different ways of approaching it decades or over a century ago to conditions now?

TSAR discusses how the ideas laid out apply to the Paris Commune, and I'm sure we've all thought about how they may have been put in practice (or not) in the USSR, PRC, Cuba, etc, which is obviously fine to discuss, but I thought it might be interesting to bring up some other situations to think about in this way:

  • Could revolutionary governments like The Bavarian Soviet Republic or the Hungarian Soviet Republic have possibly been saved by proper action before/during their formations? How did they attempt to implement/implement DoP?

  • Anarchist Catalonia and the Ukranian Free Territory: Were these governments still attempting to put DOP in place but "imagining that by changing the names they change the things themselves" as Lenin says?

  • What about Socialist Yugoslavia?? They formed under occupation of the Nazis and disintegrated, after pressure from the Imperialist west. How can we compare them to real attempts at building socialism as well as the abstract ideas presented in TSAR?

  • Chile: Was Allende's Chile a victim of attempting to co-opt the state instead of smashing it as this article suggests?

  • What about the failure of communist movements in other South American countries, or in Mexico, Asia etc? I'd love to some discussion about other countries in addition to the usual USSR/China that I'm sure the reading of this book always brings about.

Relevant shorter writings by Lenin:

Plan for an Article “On the Question of the Role of the State” a short draft written in 1916 for what would eventually become TSAR.

The Tasks of the Proletariat in Our Revolution

The Immediate Tasks of the Soviet Government

The State: A Lecture Delivered at the Sverdlov University: I think this is an especially useful companion to TSAR an could probably act as a short introduction.

Fourth Anniversary of the October Revolution

Better, Fewer but Better

Relevant Audio

All of these are taken from the wonderful collection of lectures at wearemany.org which I can't recommend highly enough:

Marxism and the State (this specifically focuses on TSAR)

Lenin's Theory of the Party

Lenin and the Vanguard Party

Base and Superstructure

We Must Dream: Echoes of What is To Be Done? in Lenin's Later Career

Lenin and Rights of Nations to Self Determination

Relevant Videos:

I couldn't find quite as much video specifically relevant to TSAR, but if you look in the previous discussion I posted some great videos. These are still pretty interesting and relevant in some way:

Lenin's Speech: What is Soviet Power?

Lenin and Kautsky (Part 2, Summary) (Discussion on Kautsky's support of the war) - Lars T Lih

Imperialism Lenin and Bukharin by Phil Gasper

Lessons of the Comitern Series:

Rebuilding the International: Rosa Luxemburg and the Comintern by Helen Scott: This lecture attempts to dispel some misconceptions about Rosa Luxemburg's views of Lenin and the Bolsheviks, as well as misconceptions about her in general.

The Workers' Government: Fiction, Pseudonym or Transition by John Riddell: Discussion of the worker's government and the debate surrounding what it actually means.

'Party of an Old Type' to 'Party of a New Type' by Lars Lih: On changes of the role of "the party" in the Comitern.

Further Essays/Writings relevant to TSAR:

Dictatorship of the Proletariat and Socialist Democracy : I haven't read all of this but the first section "What is the dictatorship of the proletariat?" is an excellent TLDR of what the term means. I have a user of r/communism to thank for posting this some time ago.

Introduction to TSAR from a socialist website that contains a list of other recommended major works.

Relevant Essays/Writings about Lenin:

Lenin For Beginners this is a "documentary comic book" done in the same vein as "Marx For Beginners" that you may be familiar with. It's actually very well done in my opinion and is a quick read that covers a lot of history/information.

Lenin by Trotsky

Foundations of Leninism by Stalin

Long Live Leninism! 1960 article by the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party

Works by Marx/Engels Mentioned in TSAR:


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jan 08 '21

I made a video arguing, that Marx and Smith really aren't opposite- thought this would be appropriate to link here

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • May 09 '14

Starting up a new reading group on Bukharin's 'Economic Theory of the Leisure Class' beginning on Sunday [11th, May, 2014]

12 Upvotes

Greetings everyone!

I figured we'd start off a new reading group this weekend. We'll be reading Nikolai Bukharin's work, 'Economic Theory of the Leisure Class'. This is one of his most well known works directly attacking Subjectivist/Marginalist economic theory from the standpoint of Marxian theory.

The reading group will begin this Sunday (11/5/2014) and we'll be discussing the prefaces, introduction, and the first chapter.

The posts for the reading group will be divided into four parts:

Session 1: (11/05/2014) Prefaces, Introduction, and Chapter 1.

Session 2: (15/05/2014) Chapters 2 and 3

Session 3: (18/05/2014) Chapters 4 and 5

Session 4: (22/05/2014) Chapter 6 and the Appendix

While I'll maintain this structure throughout the reading, readers are welcome and encouraged to read ahead and reread sections they have trouble with along the way. However, please keep your comments relevant to the session we're discussing. If you wish to discuss further sections, you're welcome to do so, but please mark exactly which parts you're talking about so those ahead or behind you know exactly what you're talking about.

Any and all ideologies are welcome to participate, provided they follow general reddit guidelines and the rules of the sub.

This is my second time leading a reading group so I encourage any and all suggestions and questions so we can clarify any ambiguities before the reading group begins. I apologize in advance for any last-minute changes or adjustments in the plan or discussion group as I learn exactly how to conduct such projects.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 28 '21

Let’s take on Capital together

11 Upvotes

So I finally feel that I am starting to get the hang of actually doing the readings of Marxist literature but there’s one that I’ve been avoiding since the jump. You already know it, Capital itself by Marx.

I have tried this book alone multiple times over the past past year and a half since I became a Marxist but I just struggle to keep going. Soo I thought I’d see who here is willing to go the distance with me on this one.

I know for a fact I can’t be the ONLY one here whose been avoiding this so let’s brave it together.

I want to start a discord chat and meet at minimum on a weekly basis at a designated time to discuss this one. Sunday works the best for me but I’d be willing to work around others schedules.

If you’re interested leave your discord tag below and we can get moving on this. It’s time to get down to business comrades.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Dec 25 '19

Marxist - leninist

11 Upvotes

Looking for Marxist Leninist stuff written by people of color! Any recommendations?


r/marxistreadingclub • • Apr 12 '14

Anyone down to read The Dialectics of Nature with me? We've got 4 people from /r/socialism who would like to.

11 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 13 '12

First International

11 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I want to discuss what this subreddit should be like, gauge interest, and discuss a time for our first book discussion. Which will be State and Revolution by Lenin as brought up here

Is this an idea people are interested in? What should the rules be? Any suggestions for anything in general? Anyone want to be a mod?


r/marxistreadingclub • • Sep 25 '20

The USSR as an example of socialist success

10 Upvotes

the USSR's official ideology was Marxism-Leninism.

im not going to address things like holodomor or the purges but on what the soviet union achieved. but if you want, ill make a post on them based purely on historical consensus and archival data.

Russia was an impoverished, mostly illiterate society before 1917 but after the soviet union was established and planning was started things began to take off. yes there was issues including famines, but consider the conditions, grain was being destroyed, livestock killed and machinery given during the NEP was being destroyed. a brutal but sadly necessary "dekulakization" occured collectivizing industry. the soviet union was also invaded several times, had to educate, industrialize, fight a war, organize, and shut down counter revolutionaries.

What happened after the soviet union was founded:

only after after socialist industrialization did Russia grow faster than the rest of the world: https://wid.world/document/soviets-oligarchs-inequality-property-russia-1905-2016/ https://wid.world/document/appendix-soviets-oligarchs-inequality-property-russia-1905-2016-wid-world-working-paper-201710/

they made all education free http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/PubEdUSSR.htm http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/anglosov.htm http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0000/000013/001300eo.pdf

literacy rose from 33% to 99.9% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Likbez

they doubled life expectancy in just 20 years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Soviet_Union After the October revolution, the life expectancy for all age groups went up. A newborn child in 1926-27 had a life expectancy of 44.4 years, up from 32.3 years thirty years before. In 1958-59 the life expectancy for newborns went up to 68.6 years. the Semashko system of the USSR increased lifespan by 50% in 20 years (by the 1960's, lifespans in the USSR were comparable to those in the USA): <https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/RB5054/index1.html>

the last famine of the USSR was in the 1940s. after the wars ended socialism proved it could feed everyone and CIA data even suggests they ate just as much as americans https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP84B00274R000300150009-5.pdf it also was not till the soviet revolution that nutrition quality went up https://artir.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/compar1.png?w=640

between 1913 and 1960, workers in Russia moved from 58.5-hour workweeks to 41.6 hour workweeks (-0.36 h/yr): https://books.google.com/books?id=x8JYjwEACAAJ https://b-ok.cc/book/2669908/77497f

the USSR averaged 22 days of paid leave in 1986: https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.pdf (the USA averaged 7.6 in 1996 https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ebs.t05.htm))

in 1987, people in the USSR could retire with pension at 55 (female) and 60 (male) and received, at minimum, 50% of their wages: https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.pdf For comparison, in 2016, people in the USA can retire at 62-67 and the average (not median) retiree household in the USA get inflows of $48k/yr, 65% of the 74k average (not median) household income: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-you-get-by-on-the-average-americans-retirement-income/

it was not till socialism was established that GDP took off https://i.imgur.com/JiZapPz.jpg and then collapsed with the reintroduction of capitalism.

The Soviet Union had the highest physician-patient ratio in the world, my notes say 42 per 10,000 population, vs 24 in Denmark and Sweden, 19 in US. In this document: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0735675784900482 You can open it without paying with sci-hub.cc

the soviets kept up with agricultural output worldwide until they bought grain instead of grow it https://khvostik.files.wordpress.com/2018/10/agricultural-production-world-vs-ussr.jpg?w=640

  •  1957: Launch of the first intercontinental ballistic missile R-7 Semyorka.

  •  1957: First orbiting satellite, Sputnik 1.

  •  1957: First living in orbit, the dog Laika on Sputnik 2.

  •  1959: Launch of a missile, the first man-made object to leave the Earth's orbit, Luna 1

  •  1959: Telemetry – First communication to and from the ground, Luna 1.

  •  1959: First object to pass near the moon, and the first object in orbit around the Moon, Luna 1.

  •  1959: First satellite hit the moon, Luna 2.

  •  1959: First images of the dark side of the moon, Luna 3.

  •  1960: First satellite to be launched to Mars, the Marsnik 1.

  •  1961: First satellite to Venus, Venera 1.

  •  1961: The first person to enter orbit around the Earth, Yuri Gagarin in Vostok 1.

  •  1961: The first person to spend a day in orbit, Gherman Titov – Vostok 2.

  •  1962: First flight of two astronauts (estimate), Vostok 3 and Vostok 4.

  •  1963: First woman in space, Valentina Tereshkova, Vostok 6.

  •  1964: First flight of several astronauts (3), Voskhod 1.

  •  1965: First spacewalk, Aleksei Leonov, Voskhod 2.

  •  1965: First probe to another planet Venus, Venera 3.

  •  1966: First probe to descend on the moon and send from there, Luna 9.

  •  1966: First probe in lunar orbit, Luna 10.

  •  1967: First meeting of unmanned Cosmos 186/Cosmos 188 (until 2006 this feat was not imitated by the United States).

  •  1969: First docking and crew exchange in orbit, Soyuz 4 and Soyuz 5

  • 1970:. First signals sent to the moon by Luna 16.

  •  1970: First mobile robot, Lunokhod 1.

  •  1970: The first data sent by a probe from another planet (Venus), Venera 7.

  •  1971: First space station, Salyut 1.

  •  1971: First satellite in orbit around Mars and landing on Mars 2.

  •  1975: First satellite in orbit around Venus and sending data to earth, Venera 9.

  •  1984: First woman to walk in space, Svetlana Savitskaja (Salyut 7)

  •  1986: First team to visit two space stations Salyut and Mir (7).

  •  1986: First permanent space station in Earth orbit, the MIR orbit from 1986 to 2001.

  •  1987: First team to spend more than a year aboard Mir, Vladimir Titov and Musa Manarov.

It seems impossible: whereas in Tsarist Russia, people traveled by carriage, 40 years later it was possible to reach space. The Soviets also developed the largest thermonuclear experimental system in the world, 10 Tokamak, a prototype fusion reactor. Tokamak heats the hydrogen at the temperature of the bowels of the sun (tens of millions of degrees) and keep the heated substance for a long time. They also created the first nuclear icebreaker "Lenin", the first in the world, another feat of Soviet engineering, consisting of a giant 19,240 tons of steel, driven by three nuclear reactors using pressurized water.

These were the largest industrial and social achievements of the Soviet Union, not to mention the country's reconstruction, destroyed by World War II. this is just a taste of its achievments.

academic studies on the USSR

Professor of Economic History, Robert C. Allen, concludes in his study without the 1917 revolution the russia would not have achieved nearly as much as socialist russia. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.507.8966&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Study demonstrating the steady increase in quality of life during the Soviet period (including under Stalin). Includes the fact that Soviet life expectancy grew faster than any other nation recorded at the time. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2672986?seq=1

A large study using world bank data analyzing the quality of life in Capitalist vs Socialist countries and finds overwhelmingly at similar levels of development socialism brings a better quality of life by Shirley Ceresto, PHD, and Howard Waitzkin, MD, PHD https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1646771/pdf/amjph00269-0055.pdf

Ask Somebody Who Lived Under Communism!"

Studies consistently find that people in most ex-socialist countries feel that life was better under socialism than it is under capitalism:

What the Soviets accomplished in the immediate aftermath of Stalin's death was nothing short of an economic miracle. They suffered 30 million deaths and a 25% capital loss in the second world war. Of all the Allied powers, the USSR took the brunt of the death toll, and Berlin ultimately fell to Soviet forces. Then there was a famine until 1947. Stalin died relatively shortly after, in 1953, and it was only four years between Stalin's death and Khrushchev's USSR beating the USA to outer-fucking-space.

to get a look into soviet life look at these images https://imgur.com/a/HRAZZ99#fZOGNEm

this was a short post. but i hope it opens the eyes of some people. realize the USSR was still in infancy. there is literally so much more i could add but this is already a good bit.

some youtubers to browse and things to read

Masterpost on the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (Soviet Union)

Masterpost on Workers' Control and Democracy in the Soviet Union

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qeYeYeLN7uKxfMdoe7TAmOMD2fmgyZdU_urvW6eAsRg/edit#bookmark=id.ie987hvbw24t

https://www.youtube.com/c/SpookyScarySocialist/videos

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCReRffTpdfRgDsNVLAKBH0g

https://www.youtube.com/c/ComradeLenin/videos

https://www.northstarcompass.org/nsc1212/ussr.htm

https://writetorebel.com/2016/11/25/the-successes-of-socialism-in-the-ussr/

http://www.idcommunism.com/2016/09/why-socialism-is-superior-to-capitalism.html

and to finish it off a little montage of soviet achievments https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5axVunzQSA

there is so much more i can add. this is just a taste.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 30 '18

Polling for Capital Vol. I chapter by chapter w/ discussion about study guide

10 Upvotes

I lost my job recently and so the start date for this has to be pushed back until no earlier than September 1st or until I get that figured out. I'd also like to poll for ideal start time for everyone still interested. I figured we'd read Capital chapter by chapter and have a discussion thread dedicated to each chapter.

There is also a study guide someone from UT College of Liberal Arts made that seems like it could be useful to those who'd want to use it. The thing about it is that is starts with the last part (Part VIII: So-Called Primitive Accumulation) first. The author explains:

We begin with Part VIII of Capital instead of Part I for two reasons. In the first place, Part VIII is a lot easier to read, being less abstract and richer with historical detail. The chapters of Part I, which deal with "value" and money, tend to be very abstract and terse. In the second place, the study of Part VIII, which shows how the capitalist system originated, i.e., how capital originally created the working class and imposed its system on it, provides a very useful point of reference for the careful dissection of value in Part I.

What does everyone think? Can those interested please post your ideal start date (sometime after September 1st) and if you think we should or shouldn't begin in the order the guide suggests.


r/marxistreadingclub • • Nov 16 '20

How Marx can help us navigate the 21st Century

Thumbnail
through.blog
9 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 31 '18

Capital Vol I - Sept. 3rd start date - GET READY!

9 Upvotes

Alright everyone! Sept. 3rd is the start date unless objected to. Comment in this thread if this is good for you and let's-a'go!


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 14 '21

Stalin Beyond Western Propaganda

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Aug 19 '19

We're still summarizing every chapter of Das Kapital by Karl Marx. Here's chapter 4.

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 21 '19

Capital's Golden Shackles, as Described by Marx

Thumbnail
marxianmatrix.com
8 Upvotes

r/marxistreadingclub • • Sep 13 '12

IHSC: Chapters III to VI

8 Upvotes

Due to no one, including me, commenting on the date that was supposed to be the III/IV discussion I've decided to combine that and the discussion for today. As a side note, I think that posting all the discussions at once and expecting people to comment before the discussion date was a good idea but will not really work in practice, so while I will keep up the part VII-X posts for now but will simply make new posts when the discussion time actually comes.

I'm going to forgo my usual summaries/questions/resources etc. I finished the book awhile ago and I'd rather just post this now than take more time going through my notes and remembering what each chapter was specifically about etc. I'll just comment like a normal person!

Here are the titles of the chapters we're discussing though:

Chapter III: Finance Capital and the Financial Oligarchy

Chapter IV: The Export of Capital

Chapter V: The Division of the World among Capitalist Combines

Chapter VI: The Division of the World among the Great Powers

Speak, comrades!


r/marxistreadingclub • • Jul 15 '12

Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right

8 Upvotes

I think this book is absolutely crucial to understanding the philosophical basis for Marx's politics. Written in 1843, it's one of his earliest works, which grapples with the limits of the political philosophy of one of the most influential philosopher's of that century: GRW Hegel.

Optimally, we would read Hegel's PR first, then Marx. Hegel can be a bit daunting for those not trained in philosophy, but if you put the work into understanding his philosophy and how Marx broke with it, the latter's thinking really opens up, IMO.

I'm currently writing a dissertation on Hegel, so I might be able to help with some of the more confusing terminology/obscure arguments. This would be a long project that would take some time commitment, be warned.