r/machiavelli • u/[deleted] • Mar 22 '24
r/machiavelli • u/KanamaraMatsuri • May 31 '25
Discourses on Livy
I just picked up a copy of “Discourses on Livy,” which is Machiavelli’s analysis of Roman history, are there interesting parts I should read?
r/machiavelli • u/whoamisri • Dec 05 '24
Machiavelli: Why we must overcome our obsession with the new
r/machiavelli • u/Fickle-Buy6009 • Jul 11 '26
"No Good Deed Goes Unpunished" (The Prince, Chapter 19)
r/machiavelli • u/Fickle-Buy6009 • Apr 04 '26
Clizia is a comedy by Machiavelli about a father and son competing for the love of an orphaned girl
en.wikipedia.orgr/machiavelli • u/Fickle-Buy6009 • Feb 06 '26
No, Machiavelli wasn't just "describing reality" or "telling it how it is": Refuting the most FLAWED talking point
You may have heard either of the following before:
"Machiavelli is just misunderstood, all he was trying to do is describe reality as it was in his day"
or
"Machiavelli was just being honest, telling how it is, and he was blamed for it"
These, in all fairness, are mindlessly moronic talking points.
I would also state that anyone uttering these not only has never read Machiavelli, but has close to zero knowledge of philosophy and has probably been living under a rock.
How can I say something this bold, you ask?
Well, my reasoning is shockingly simple:
Machiavelli deliberately sprinkled audacious lies, blatant misquotations, misspellings, and not to mention hilarious ironies within his works, mainly to encourage his readers to think and ironically to distrust authority. If you read him tone-deaf (which is inevitable if you don't do your research/due diligence with secondary sources) you will no doubt be lost. Machiavelli distorts Livy so much that I couldn't even count on my fingers or toes the amount of times he does so.
Machiavelli's reputation is not due to any truth telling but because he defended the good old fashioned, iron and poison-laced politics with his own name on the titles of his works. Saying otherwise is grotesquely misleading and is ignoring the big skyscraper sized elephant in the studio apartment room.
"Describing reality" is something pretty much everyone that has ever picked up a writing utensil has done. This interpretation is basically an insult to every philosopher and every recorder of history.
I can guarantee I know what you will say next:
"But Machiavelli exposed the evils of human nature and how brutal politics can be"
Thomas Aquinas would like a word with you.
In fact, Plato, Aristotle, Thucydides, Polybius, and Epicurus would also like a word as well.
Even more interestingly Socrates called me (on his IPhone of course) from his prison cell before he was condemned to death by the Thirty. He asked "do these guys think I am chopped liver?" (that's a joke, btw. So much utter bs on the internet that I think many people will think this is real)
The biblical theorists also put in the good word.
You get my point.
Not only is the idea of inherent human immorality not new ("original sin" anyone?) but even Machiavelli's infamous promotion of force and fraud is also not new, even by Machiavelli's own estimation (see his comments on Chiron in P 18). The ancients simply uttered these political sentiments covertly, Machiavelli does so openly.
Did Aristotle not "describe reality" or "tell it like it is" when he discusses how tyranny ruins a civil state? Did biblical theorists refrain from the truth when they decried human cowardice, avarice, and predilection to lustful, sinful behavior?
In order to tell the unadulterated truth, one must not engage in omissions, so off the bat Machiavelli wouldn't qualify. Examples include describing Nabis as a popular ruler (Prince 9) without mentioning that he was killed as a result of a conspiracy (like he does in the Discourses) or describing popular but outrageously criminal rulers like Agathocles and Oliverotto as "princes" in The Prince, yet "tyrants" in the Discourses. (P 8, cf. D I 10)
One must also obviously not use misquotations either when telling said truth, which disqualifies Machiavelli even more in this regard. Though as I said above, Machiavelli sprinkles in the deliberate mistakes and lies in so that attentive readers can understand what he is actually trying to get at, not because he likes misleading people. This in my view makes his works more endearing, as it makes him more enigmatic. An example of this is almost certainly in the Discourses book 1 chap 26, where a Bible verse which is attributed to David actions is actually said of god "he filled the hungry with good things and sent the rich away empty".
Eh, but who knows? Maybe I am wrong.
In fact, I know of another person (a businessman actually) who was wrongly persecuted (but by the FBI) of describing reality too:
I killed a lot of guys – you're not talking about four, five, six, ten..... Today, you can't have a body no more ... It's better to take that half-an-hour, an hour, to get rid of the body than it is to leave the body on the street.
As to this kindhearted (definitely NOT evil, but realist :) ) method, he continued:
If Fatato were called on to take part in a hit, Sonny said "he should wear a hairnet to avoid leaving DNA evidence," the prosecutors wrote. He also offered grisly cooking lessons. Disposal of a body, Franzese advised Fatato, could be accomplished "by dismembering the corpse in a kiddie pool and drying the severed body parts in a microwave before stuffing the parts in a commercial-grade garbage disposal." Source here https://web.archive.org/web/20100225221814/http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jerry-capeci/feds-want-jury-to-hear-so_b_470557.html
Arrivederci.
r/machiavelli • u/Fickle-Buy6009 • Feb 03 '26
"Machiavelli never praised democracy. The only time he refers to democracy, it is to stress that Athens’ democratic constitution inspired by Solon had a brief life."
r/machiavelli • u/Fickle-Buy6009 • Jan 30 '26
What are your personal theories on Machiavelli's work?
reddit.comr/machiavelli • u/ZBellen7 • Oct 08 '24
Which version of The Prince should I choose?
I have the option of the shorter paperback with George Bull and Anthony Grafton 144 pages or the hardcover 240 pages with Tim Parks, which would you recommend?
r/machiavelli • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '24
What’s the distinction between mercenaries and auxiliaries?
r/machiavelli • u/slicksouthpaw • Sep 08 '26
How good of a Statesman/Diplomat was Machiavelli really?
For those who know Machiavelli, it is quite common knowledge that Nick was appointed Second Chancellor for the Florentine Republic, where he primarily dealt with foreign, diplomatic and military matters in and revolving Florence for nearly 15 years before his position was nullified by the return of Medici rule. He liaised with many famous figures with that time from Pope Julius II and Caterina Sforza to Cesare Borgia. No doubt he was very astute and effective in his observation of how Power and Human nature operates within the political and philosophical sphere as shown in his works such as The Prince. One question I have for people was how effective do you think Machiavelli was in that role, what positive changes did he make to Florence as a republic state and what credible feats did he manage to attain in his quite long and prolific career of diplomacy and statecraft?