r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 22 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread Star Guardian 2022 Misc PBE Thread - ONE TIME EXCEPTION

1.5k Upvotes

Hey all, This subreddit's rules are pretty clear about keeping feedback on-topic and on PBE content. As a one-time exception to the rules, we're opening a general 2022 Star Guardian feedback thread.

If you have feedback about, say, Star Guardian Helmet Bro, keep it in the Star Guardian Helmet Bro thread. If there isn't a dedicated thread for your topic, use this one. Please keep feedback related to League of Legends and the content of the Star Guardian 2022 events (counting official videos, other games, PBE, etc.)As always, please keep general PBE feedback guidance in mind - you can read more here: https://www.reddit.com/r/LeaguePBE/comments/k7gg0i/best_practices_skins_pbe_feedback_guidelines/ Specificity and being scope-conscious are key!

I look forward to reading your feedback, even if there's no direct response it is being read and considered. Thank you for playing and being the most amazing community in the world. <3 Riot Tiny Bun and all of us at Riot!

EDIT: Thank you so much for taking time to leave feedback here. I've seen some frustration that there's been no response yet. I wanted to keep this thread open for both PBE cycles, which it's why it's been up a while. Additionally, I tried to set the expectation that while I was actively reading and passing on the feedback here, that there wouldn't be a direct response from me, because I felt any response would be dissatisfying without an explicit commitment. It's not appropriate for me personally to commit to anything I am not 100% in control of, there would be a potential for me to break that commitment for factors out of my control. No one human is in charge of every decision related to an event, making a skin, etc. But having no response at all it seems felt like it wasn't even being read. Even within this thread which has a lot of similar notes there are conflicts - some folks would want Redeemed Xayah/Rakan as Mythic Chromas, others as their own Legendaries. So I at least wanted to come back to let you know truly, it is being read and discussed. Thanks for taking the time to type it up and thank you for participating in the event in the ways that suit you best.


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 11 '21

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread PBE Bugs and Feedback Thread: Ultimate Spellbook

1.2k Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm HBBONG, Product Lead on the Modes team.

A brand new game mode, Ultimate Spellbook, will be available for extended testing on PBE starting today! This mode asks the question "What dream plays could you pull off with another champion's ultimate?" It won't be releasing right away; look for more information on our release date in the future.

Here's how the mode works:

  • The queue is blind pick, so play all your favorite League of Legends champions! However, you only get one normal Summoner Spell plus one Ultimate Placeholder where your second Summoner Spell usually goes.

  • Once you load into the game, you’ll have 30 seconds to pick from one of three ults randomly chosen from the pool below. You can't get your own ult, and the ult pool consists of the following:

    • Ahri

    • Amumu

    • Ashe

    • Azir

    • Bard

    • Cho’Gath`

    • Ezreal

    • Fiddlesticks

    • Gragas

    • Gwen

    • Janna

    • Jarvan IV

    • Jhin

    • Karthus

    • Kayle

    • Kayn

    • Kha’Zix

    • Lee Sin

    • Lissandra

    • Lucian

    • Lux

    • Malzahar

    • Maokai

    • Miss Fortune

    • Mordekaiser

    • Morgana

    • Nocturne

    • Nunu

    • Olaf

    • Rell

    • Rengar

    • Shen

    • Skarner

    • Soraka

    • Talon

    • Tryndamere

    • Xerath

    • Yone

    • Zoe

  • The ult you pick takes the place of your Ultimate Placeholder for the rest of the game, and you can't change it. You can use your Ult-ernate Summoner Spell after its initial 135 second cooldown, even before hitting level 6.

  • Ult-ernate Summoner Spells level up as your Champion’s ultimate levels up to rank 2 and 3 (levels 11 and 16) and benefit from Summoner Spell haste.

    • Ults that only scale with AD now also scale with AP.

    • Ults that only scale with AP now also scale with AD.

    • Ults that only scale with Health now also scale with AD and AP.

    • Ults that scale with nothing continue to scale with nothing.

  • You can see everyone’s chosen Ult-ernate Summoner Spells on both the scoreboard and next to their healthbar. Pay attention for a teal indicator above champions’ heads that indicate when their Ult-ernate Summoner Spell is off cooldown.

  • Ultimate Spellbook has accelerated pacing similar to that of One for All. You start at level 3 and with more starting gold, so level up and spend your money! Passive XP and gold are increased, you share some minion gold with teammates in lane, and objectives work differently.

  • Rather than four Elemental Drakes, Ultimate Spellbook has Mordekaiser's old drake.

    • A drake will spawn every 3 and a half minutes.

    • Stacks grant a buff that makes auto attacks on towers apply a DOT that deals percent health magic damage to towers.

    • The Soul grants the ability to reanimate on death with rapidly decaying Health. This ability has a 5 minute cooldown.

  • The map looks different. For some reason.

Please give Ultimate Spellbook a spin, and share your feedback on the mode and reports of any bugs you encounter here in the thread!

Thanks,

HBBONG


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 06 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine hairs - follow up

815 Upvotes

UPDATE

Here are the final edits (with comparison to how it looked on Day1 of PBE for 12.11 cycle) for Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine hair, based on requests in this thread:

https://imgur.com/a/Dz4bzkz
https://imgur.com/a/xJqBlVd

These changes should be visible on PBE in few hours (after next deploy) or (in worst case scenario) after Monday's deploy .

As always - thanks for all constructive comments!

---------------------------------------------------
Hello everyone,

I want to address the recent situation with Prestige OS Seraphine as many of you seem to be dissatisfied with changes made to her hairs.

The thread gathered a record number of comments we ever seen, ever before the changes we made. By the time I gathered the sentiment, it was already 10 times bigger than average we have and most of requests about the hairs was to make them orange/darker & longer. Only few commenters mentioned that they actually like the shorter hairs.

However, after making those changes the thread doubled in size, with an opposite feedback. We were not even able to act upon before the branch was closed for 12.11 release.

As a rare exception, we decided to open this new thread for this specific case. I want to hear your opinions on following aspects of Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine hairs:

1) should we keep them longer or revert to shorter?

2) should we also revert the color, keep current one or change it to something else (staying in similar color region that is) ?


r/LeaguePBE • • Jan 09 '21

General [Suggestion] Viego CTRL+5 model swap from unmasked to masked.

633 Upvotes

Basically just swapping between normal model and the one in his recall would be really neat. It changes him to this rad iron/ghost lord which is very neat. In his recall, it could have the same animation but swapping to the unmasked model.

I'm not just doing this because I like the idea, but I see a lot of other people who like the model in the recall and wanted this exact change. I SPEAK FOR THE PEOPLE YO


Update: See mod comment, this request is unlikely due to requiring a transition animation (he does have an idle/laugh animation where he grabs his face tbf), transition vfx, toggle, discussing if helmet design is fitting, and testing. The only hope we got is being an exception.

Update 2: https://twitter.com/Spideraxe30/status/1348672488822218760 Oh well, his regular form isn't that bad I just thought armoured form was cool. I wouldn't bother arguing on Twitter, as that would never change their mind even if the reasoning is scuffed (also it wasn't Spideraxe that decided this).


r/LeaguePBE • • Nov 26 '24 Diamonds are Forever Helpful Bless Up Take My Silver Heart of Silver

General Revert Viktor's redesign.

608 Upvotes

Plain and simple. No Viktor players asked for this complete 180 on a character beloved by a group of players. Arcane Viktor and LoL Viktor are two completely different beings and it would have been fine had Arcane Viktor been a skin, but removing the old lore for no reason does not sit right with me.


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 07 '22

General Ashen Knight Pantheon looks anything but a knight..

567 Upvotes

Like, such a cool concept, such a great idea to choose Pantheon, and you guys decided to make a purple ruined chroma? again the leather panths? again shirtless? again a weird valkyrie helm with a strange beard? such a downgrade from Pyke.. i really had hope, but i wont grind unless this changes drastically, enough is enough! listen to our feedback from Ruined Pantheon! Also, the splashart, how do you guys approve that? the background feels so empty compared to Pyke, so much purple...


r/LeaguePBE • • Apr 14 '22

General it feels like riot didn't actually think we'd give a fuck about the eclipse skins

507 Upvotes

So the Eclipse skins have been announced yesterday and the reaction has been... interesting. Accross both Reddit and Twitter multiple different criticisms have been leveled - the biggest one by far being the frustration for Kayle not getting a Legendary after years of tease and hype, but there are others as well: Sivir mains were left with a very underwhelming skin for the standards of a Legendary, especially when it comes to her splash art; Senna players complain that the VFX are bland and that the Prestige version is completely disconnected from the Eclipse thematic, All while Diana players are up in arms they didn't get a skin a all and they just want to date Leona, for God's sake. Sejuani mains are more positive, but they've also pointed out that the recolored ice effects look kinda janky. Aatrox mains seem to be the only ones out of the batch who are unabashedly happy (and I agree with you guys - simping for Kayle is a W indeed). Even seemingly trivial topics, like the skin being called "Solar Eclipse" instead of "Sun Eater" Kayle and a shared splash art have turned into big pain points for multiple people

Beyond champion-specific complaints, there's also been a puch to add borders and other cosmetic choices to the event, which currently is only planned to have two icons (one for Prestige Senna) and one emote (also for Prestige Senna). It is honestly baffling that the community has come to ask for so many different things all in one event, and to me it all points towards Riot own expectations towards this event were completely different than the community's. In fact, the very decision to make it a mini-event shows that they were never planning to go big on it, and so it makes sense that other things like additional cosmetics or the Diana skin would be left out as well. It also wouldn't be such a glaring issue for Riot to not perfectly nail down every single skin choice if they expected the players to just treat it as a nice batch to fill the gap between the real events.

What doesn't make sense is why would Riot ever assume that when planning for Eclipse. The entire Coven/Eclipse setting is by far one of the most popular of the entire game, easily on par with Star Guardian and Project, and Eclipse Leona and Coven Camille, Lissandra, Morgana and Evelynn are widely regarded as some of the best available. The lore for the alternate universe has also been consistently built up year after year since way long ago, with player expectations only ever getting higher. It's bizarre how Riot managed to set themselves for what could easily be one of the highlights of the years only to waste it all way not doing the bare minimum to live up to it. TL;DR is honestly the best course of action would be to just postpone the event and actually make it worthwhile.


r/LeaguePBE • • Aug 21 '20

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread Nocturne, Viktor, Malzahar and Ignite - Visual Effects Updates

460 Upvotes

Hello Everyone!

Riot Beardilocks here to bring you another round of visual effect updates. Similar to the previous VFX updates we’ve made in the past (Ziggs, Thresh, Lux, etc), we're working on updates to the Visual Effects (VFX) of more champions whose spell effects are in need of some love. In Patch 10.18, we'll be releasing a VFX Update for Malzahar, Nocturne, Viktor and Ignite!

Our goals for these sorts of smaller scope updates is to improve the overall gameplay clarity of vfx whilst bringing them up to modern League of Legends standards. This means that our efforts are primarily aimed at spells which do not clearly communicate the hitbox. Our goals are not to change the art direction for these skins or champions - those kinds of changes are reserved for full Visual + Gameplay updates (VGUs).

Just like the previous ones, since these are smaller updates geared toward sprucing up some of the oldest members of the roster, they aren't in the same prioritization conversation as to how we decide who gets a VGU (where we take model, gameplay, and thematic into account too!): they do not affect any other timeline, and are simply dev passion projects.

We're looking for feedback on their VFX changes, which should be up on the PBE soon-ish. Please try them out there —especially if you're a main— and leave us your feedback once the changes are up!


MALZAHAR

VFX Update aimed at modernizing this old champion's feel while improving his gameplay readability. We also took this opportunity to get a better look at the Void thematic's VFXs to better illustrate its modern representation in the Lore.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H_cCTAkNvNQ

Base Kit:

P - Reduced some of the noise from the shield. Made it a bit brighter to match other spell shields (this one also negates 99% of damage, so yeah it needs to be visible).

BA - New missiles and hit effects.

Q - New quickcast indicator to better represent its actual hitbox (yes, it's always been that large). Completely revamped the whole effect. Void spikes grow from the ground, revealing Void portals in their heart. These then dissolve into missiles towards each other, damaging enemies. Also new hit effect. Fixed a bug where the hit effect would proc once per missile, even though the damage only applied once.

W - New spawn effects. Voidlings now follow the natural Void evolution, going from white/bone color to their usual appearance, as they spawn in. Also added an idle glow on their eyes. They also have new basic attack impacts.

E - Added a beam from Malzahar to his target on cast. Completely new debuff effect, much less noisy, but still chaotic. When it propagates, a beam links the dead target to the new one. It also now spawns a little hit effect on each damage proc. Also fixed a bug where his E would go on cooldown when Malzahar's target would die during the cast time.

R - New beam, hit and AOE effects. The pool should feel more appropriate to the current Void aesthetic in the lore, rather than just "space stuff".


SKINS:

Our approach when updating skins is to respect skin pricing tiers. Unless a skin is a 1350, we will not add any custom VFX. The exception to this is for older skins who already had unique visual effects. In this case, we allow these unique VFX to be updated to modern standard, regardless of tier.

Overlord Malzahar: Overall recolored effects, since this is a 975. Went for a shadow-y feel.


Snow Day Malzahar:

P - Cleaned up and glowier.

Q - Completely revamped, with different ground indicators. Big snowballs!

W - New voidling impacts. Summon effects were good, so we left them alone.

E - Recolored beams from base, and new snowy E debuff.

R - Some more snow, and new edge on the pool. Overall cleaned up.


Battle Boss Malzahar:

Q - New ground indicator. Ships and their shot have been turned horizontally, so they match the actual hitbox.


Hextech Malzahar:

P - Cleaned up and glowier.

Q - New ground indicators. Gems are slightly bigger. Cleaned up the missiles. Added some more animation to the whole spell.

W - New voidling impacts. Summon effects were good, so we left them alone.

E - New hextech-y beams, with cleaned up debuff effect.

R - Slight cleanup and timing adjustment on the pool. Added some more hextech-y waves.


Worldbreaker Malzahar:

P - A bit glowier.

Q - New ground indicators. Made the wave shot horizontal to match the hitbox.

(Malzahar updates by RiotSirhaian)



NOCTURNE

https://imgur.com/EqGFcHQ

*VFX Update aimed at modernizing this old champion's feel while improving his gameplay readability. The primary improvements were around making sure his Q is visible and that the passive clearly communicates the area of effect. Nocturne had too many colours on his kit previously, so we made the decision to unify to just two colours - red and blue.

https://youtu.be/8c3G_-pU94U

Base Kit:

P - Added a circular effect that communicates the area that Nocturne slashes targets. The passive ready effect has been moved from Nocturne's hands to be a glow on his blades. This way it is clearer when the effect is ready, and it does not compete with the attack speed buff for space.

BA - New swipes and target effects

Q - New animated claw that should be easier to see in a busy teamfight. The darkness trail has been balanced so it isn't so overwhelming for its low gameplay impact.

W - New shield effect, with thematic darkness elements.

E - New beam and shadow effects. The timing better illustrates when the target will be feared.

R - New dash and trail VFX. The hit effect on the target does not look like it should do area of effect damage anymore.


SKINS


Our approach when updating skins is to respect skin pricing tiers. Unless a skin is a 1350, we will not add any custom VFX. The exception to this is for older skins who already had unique visual effects. In this case, we allow these unique VFX to be updated to modern standard, regardless of tier.


All skins had updates to move the Passive glow from Nocturne's hands to his blades.


Frozen Terror Nocturne:

All of Frozen Terror Nocturne's VFX were updated with the same approach as base, but keeping their winter theme.


Haunting Nocturne:

All of Haunting Nocturne's VFX were updated with the same approach as base, but keeping their spooky theme.


Eternum Nocturne:

P - Changed the glow to the blades, and gave it some high-tech lens flare effects

BA - New swipes and target effects

Q - Updated to include a shadowy claw in the centre of the ball, to help improve recognisability. Reduced overall noise

W - Reduced noise with a high tech galaxy effect.

E - Unchanged

R - New dash, trail and hit VFX. Nocturne gets an upgraded shadow tornado effect on his body when he activates his ultimate.



VIKTOR

https://imgur.com/eY4ZaRS

*VFX Update aimed at clarifying this champion's gameplay, whilst also updating visual fidelity. The primary improvements were around making sure his E clearly communicated the width of the affected area. The other changes on Viktor were kept very small scope in order to deliver this in time for Worlds.

https://youtu.be/u7NKdjTxGIg

Base Kit:

BA - New trails and target effects

Q - Updated shield and beam VFX to feel more Hextech

W - Made the edges of the gravity zone slightly clearer, and unified the colour palette.

E - New VFX to clarify the hitbox, and better communicate the damage zone when Viktor has upgraded his E. Yes, it really has always been that wide.

R - Added an initial impact effect to communicate the burst of damage on initial cast.


Creator Viktor:

W - Made the edges of the gravity zone slightly clearer, and unified the colour palette.

E - New VFX to clarify the hitbox, and better communicate the damage zone when Viktor has upgraded his E. Yes, it really has always been that wide.

R - Added an initial impact effect to communicate the burst of damage on initial cast.


Deathsworn Viktor:

E - Made effect wider to clarify the damage zone



IGNITE

Updated the visuals for ignite to reduce the overall noise whilst making it clearer when targets were affected by this powerful debuff, as well as more clearly communicate when the individual ticks of damage occur.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AeiLzNQxYp8


These changes should go to the PBE over the next few days, please test them out and leave your feedback here!

Many thanks


r/LeaguePBE • • Feb 23 '23

General Rakan & Xayah don’t get a joint recall again? ;-;

457 Upvotes

UPDATE: Riot Games are officially not going to be giving Rakan and Xayah a joint recall on skins anymore.

Making this post because no one has set up feedback threads for the upcoming Broken Covenant Rakan - Xayah skins.

But weren’t we promised last time that Rakan - Xayah would get a special joint recall next time?

Arcana skins got massive backlash and we were told that two weeks wasn’t enough time to make a recall.

They had almost a year now. What’s the reason (not calling it an excuse) for not giving one to us?

This skin was the easiest to give a recall by literally using elements from their recalls like the wall in Rakan’s and the bird in Xayah’s.

It’s sad that they don’t seem to care about us and what we want just because we aren’t as popular as Ekko because his Firelight skin was recalled, worked on and released after backlash.

Rakan - Xayah were created as lovers to be a duo bot lane. It’s the very essence of these champions. If they don’t get played together often, fix and balance them to be stronger together than cutting corners on skins. Clearly the focus has been on Xayah, Xayah, Xayah for the past few years.

What about Rakan? He’s only getting a buff because of this skin. Really sad honestly ;-;


r/LeaguePBE • • Nov 26 '24

General Lux's Ultimate is better than Jinx's Exalted

449 Upvotes

After watching the skin spotlight and listening to all the voicelines, the skin is supposed to feature Jinx in all her "forms", which means: schizophrenic and depressive Jinx (the Jinx with graffitis on her), the Heroic Jinx, and Powder.

However, despite those forms being all different they all share the same animations, recalls, and guns. (And schizophrenic and hero Jinx are just chromas from each other, so you really just gave us two forms.)

First, "Menace" Jinx:

  • She's the Jinx who blew up the council, the Jinx who lost Isha. Why didn't we get barefeet hobo long haired Jinx from when she was in the cell? If long hair can't be done, then chopped hair from before she met Ekko. She should have slower running animation, more depressed, and her recall should absolutely feature her in her cell.

  • So knowing that it's this Jinx, why is she wearing the HERO outfit?? It's ridiculous. She can't be unredeemed Jinx while wearing the redeemed outfit.

This whole form needs to be scrapped. It does not fit.

Then, "Hero" Jinx:

  • She's missing her iconic X on her shirt.

  • She's missing her mechanical finger.

  • She's missing her FUCKING HOOD.

Did you guys even watch Arcane?? How do you overlook such important points? Did you not know she lost her finger? Did you not see her wearing her hood? Did you guys forget you literally released an icon with her hood on in

Lastly, Powder:

  • Give her different quns, man. What the fuck? Is this exalted or not? Even ultimate MF has different guns.

  • She also needs her own animations and recalls. She shouldn't move the same way as Jinx, she's Powder.

  • The shared recall even more painful on this one too. Why is she lighting that smoke? Man.

Conclusion:

This time, simply editing the textures or adding a toggle wouldn't cut it in my opinion because you need to change her animations and recalls to all be unique, and her "Menace" form needs to be changed altogether. For the love of god, she can't be a menace AND wear the hero outfit.

This is seriously a huge joke. It's underwhelming, disappointing and lazy. You all hyped this up and for what? Also apparently the Nexus finisher is not even included???

Why is Lux's ultimate better? This Jinx costs 250$, it's a whole new tier. It's supposed to be ABOVE the ultimate skins that are worth 30$. So why is it worse??

Please I beg, delay the release to redo this skin. It's ridiculous. This is not exclusive, this is not next tier.

Either redo it or drop it as Ultimate, because that's not Exalted.


r/LeaguePBE • • Nov 13 '20

General SG Soraka Prestige Icon is not giving what y'all think it would give...

418 Upvotes

I do not want to be mean, but that icon is unacceptable. We know, SG Soraka's original icon was her familiar, like the other 2017 gang but it's been 3 years, prestige skins have portrait-like icons. We all were so excited to have a golden star guardian soraka portrait (like xayah & rakan) but they really painted her pet's icon golden. It's cute but when they even made a new icon for Senna prestige, this is just lazy. The backlash in Twitter is also real about this. We don't want this to be another drama like K/DA skins, just please listen to the majority and paint a new portrait for her prestige. if not, please make a icon of the splash art like immortal journey talon and irelia. it's ridiculous to have that rat as SORAKA's one and only prestige skin's icon.

The context: https://twitter.com/JumaraloHexCore/status/1327059655076564992


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 16 '22

General Whats the point of feedback threads?

406 Upvotes

Recently, both Ashen knight pantheon and Prestige seraphine got hundreds of constructive comments to change the skins to fit better and in the end you guys decide not to listen any of that and just do whatever you want, idk why you people at riot think we were born yesterday. Keep doing that and you’ll lose players. Lets put ashen knight panth as an example, mythic skin locked behind a big paywall, releases with such a low quality it gets one of the most negative receptions a skin had in the last years, a skin that literally feels like a copycat of an older one, but you guys decide to not do anything with pathetic excuses over and over. Let that sink in.


r/LeaguePBE • • Mar 13 '25 Love

General We want changes or delay for Battle Academia skins

389 Upvotes

•New animations for Xayah, she is not legendary

•Duo-recall for R&X (This has been the feedback of Rakan-Xayah mains for years, and you don't give it despite legendary skin)

•Icons + Borders for all members

•New recall animations (It should be like Battle Academia)

•Qiyana should more prestige looks


r/LeaguePBE • • Jul 20 '22

General Feedback regarding PBE Feedback Threads

389 Upvotes

(I hope this doesn’t read off as a rant, I’ve tried to reword it 4 times and this is what I could say about this.)

I don’t personally see the appeal in feedback threads anymore, since to me and a lot of people it seems the feedback just falls on deaf ears.

I won’t even mention AK Pantheon because everyone has been clowning on riot already about that skin.

Rioters told us we weren’t supposed to get Purified x/r because of lore reasons back in 2019 then this year Purified Xr becomes the canon in SG Universe, therefore the lore won’t be an issue, and WR gets them. This only gets addressed as ‘giving space for wild rift to grow’ as if it’s a completely different ip and not mobile league of legends except for the exclusive skins.

Star Guardian Sona’s vfx was visibly lacking and it still is after the hundreds of the same feedback because “it is out of scope”.

Star Guardian Syndra had reverse update, and now Morgana receiving 0 visual updates because of “lore” and I highly doubt we will learn the actual lore regarding this (after the vfx artist told us that they would try it out without mentioning any lore whatsoever mind you) I really doubt anyone after this event would go “Oh but Morgana is not supposed to have chessboard imagery on her ult because of the Star Guardian lore!”, rather, they would go “Zoe and Fiddle has it, why not Morgana?”

Riot doesn’t make changes on some skins for ‘consistency’ then give us bare minimum with each year. 2017 Guardians had different idle poses, included their familiars a lot more and in 2019 epic skins (zoe and neeko) got their familiars dancing with them. It’s like we’re taking 2 steps forward then 3 steps backwards.

This is the big summer event yet that does not translate to us, the players who care about Star Guardians or normal skins in that case. We keep hearing out of scope this, out of scope that. (even a texture change is apparently out of scope)

My solution to this is: just tell us what is in-scope before asking for feedback so both us and rioters don’t get fed up with this issue every time.


r/LeaguePBE • • Jan 25 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread Vel'Koz VFX Update

387 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Similar to the previous VFX updates we’ve made in the past (Syndra, Zilean, Malzahar, etc), we're working on updates to the Visual Effects (VFX) of champions whose spell effects are in need of some love. Our aim is to get their VFXs to current League standards and improve gameplay clarity. This time, it's Vel'Koz's turn, for 12.3's PBE Patch!

This VFX Update was mainly focused on making Vel'Koz a bit more in-line with the rest of the Void champions VFX-wise, and (especially) adjust some of his less accurate hitbox indicators.

Just like all the previous ones, and since these are smaller updates geared toward sprucing up some of the oldest members of the roster, they aren't in the same prioritization conversation as to how we decide who gets a VGU (where we take model, gameplay, and thematic into account too!): they do not affect any other timeline, and are simply dev passion projects.

Here's a video preview of the changes for his new VFXs. Infernal and Blackfrost only received minor tweaks since they are more modern.

All affected skins: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aR-Ejndx0hc

Thumbnail for those interested: https://imgur.com/YXPNT8k

------------------------

We're looking for feedback on his changes, which should be up on the PBE now. Please try him out there —especially if you're a main— and leave us your feedback!

------------------------

EDIT 1: Made the E projectile a little more visible, and tweaked the respawn portal on base to be a bit more modern-void.

EDIT 2: Adjusted both Infernal and Blackfrost E AOE indicators to make them a little more interesting, and adjusted Q missile width a little bit.

EDIT 3: Adjusted Base's R beam to have a more intense center and lower intensity edges, to reduce that feeling of a solid rectangle and bring back some of the original feel. Also made the hit point at the end of the beam a bit more intense.

EDIT 4: Color-shifted his base Taunt's math screen to a more voidy color.

EDIT 5 (12.4!): Re-added the color shift on Battlecast Vel'Koz' model when ulting.


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 21 '23

General Skin delays should be more normalized.

359 Upvotes

This subreddit has been created so that we players have a platform to give our feedback.

However, several skins feedback threads have shown that the changes we ask for, even when unanimous and high-volume are "out of scope" for the two weeks allowed on PBE.

If that's the case, then in the most extreme cases like SG Seraphine currently, the skin should be delayed, it's happened with Firelight Ekko, it should happen again, and if the skins quality remains as it is, it should happen on a regular basis in order to ensure all skins are of proper quality.

Star Guardian Seraphine is currently a lackluster skin, it's missing a transition animation for the homeguard, has very blocky hair, has one of the two pets entirely absent, the wrong star sign and no transformation in the back animation, reused VFX, lackluster SFX, a strange auto-attack animation, and that horrible stage in the homeguard. It's clearly unfinished, and it would be beneficial for it to be delayed, and any skin with this level of quality in the future should be too.


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 03 '22

General Opinion: What's the point of implementing feedback if the changes made are worse than they were before and cannot be changed?

345 Upvotes

Just go look at the Seraphine Prestige thread. Initially there was 400ish comments just asking for two minor things, hair slightly more orange and a bit longer. Then, they took this feedback, absolutely butchered it and didn't even do what people asked, and locked in the result. Now the thread has over 1500+ comments, all the new ones are people BEGGING for them to revert it. Riot's already said they won't be changing it and won't be giving any refunds to those who did the passes for Mythic Essence. Very disappointing.

EDIT: Thanks to all who commented and to Riot for allowing changes in post!


r/LeaguePBE • • Oct 24 '23

General Enough with the $200 Chromas

344 Upvotes

Like i don't care if it's been discussed I'll say it again, the nerve to charge $15 for a skin then say oh here's a recolor for $200 is insane. I don't care if it's optional it's predatory, you know there's people out there who have maintained full collections for their mains and you're hoping you can get them to snap and dish out money. You say it's only for the whales but we all know how gatcha works, your biggest budget ever has done nothing better than the previous years yet you keep sucking players dry and pocketing it. Gambling is a serious issue and bringing it into this game is enough to make people quit or dig themselves into a hole.


r/LeaguePBE • • May 25 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine

342 Upvotes

Post PBE cycle update:

  • She now has a prestige themed tattoo under her left eye, to keep it aligned with other skins.

  • More VFX has been added to the Heal from Surround Sound (W) heal

  • Passive aura on allies is no longer yellow. It has been changed to turquoise/aquamarine

  • Hairs are made slightly darker/orang-y

  • VFX on the platform are now better visible when the Echo part of the passive is ready.

  • (ed2) hair are now longer, more in line with other skins. This change was not confirmed by the time I prepared the changelog, but apparently it was in by the time I posted it.

Thanks for all constructive feedback!

--------------------------------------------------------------------

https://imgur.com/a/YmeG40X

Some songs start with a rhyme, some with a rhythm... Mine starts with the crowd.

Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine comes with:

  • New models and textures!

  • New VFX!

Prestige Ocean Song Seraphine should be already available on PBE! Feel free to leave any feedback or questions you have so far down below!

Riot DW Platypus


r/LeaguePBE • • Jun 11 '25

General Skin Quality Concerns

340 Upvotes

Skin quality has obviously been degraded massively since the lay offs, but it’s to the point where each and every skin added to PBE recently is either feature incomplete or massively missing the mark, especially in the animation department.

‪Where’s our transition animations and attack variations in legendary skins? All new legendary skins have incredibly disconnected animations. Some don’t even have new rigs (shaco) and some are the same as previous legendary skins (karma) ‬

‪Where are the model details? Most epic skins don’t even have new mesh pieces, and look incredibly Flat ‬(Spirit Blossom Akali versus Spirit Blossom Eve: the quality difference in the amount of new mesh is night and day) https://imgur.com/a/tENXvlV

‪Why are exalted skins reusing animations and assets of skins that have come before it. These are not exalted, they 👏 are 👏LEGENDARY👏‬

‪Why don’t chromas have different pattern variations? You guys literally have a article explaining how some chromas would have different patterns https://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/featured/skins/chromas

‪I have spent roughly 10 grand since I started playing, I have yet to buy a single skin this year with how bad the quality has been. I probably am one of the “whales” you are targeting, but you aren’t going to deliver skins way below expectations and expect us to buy them.‬

U/riotmeddler u/Tryndamere

‪BRING👏BACK👏SKIN👏QUALITY👏‬


r/LeaguePBE • • Jul 10 '22

General The difference of attention we get depending on which champ is amazing.

323 Upvotes

We always get the same excuses, that they can't make it to the deadline, that they have limited resources and time to make changes, but depending on the popularity of the champion these false arguments get debunked, why are they so biased?

This is an example, Star Guardian Kaisa vs Ashen Knight Pantheon.

Hopefully i won't get mods blocking me again, or posting biased comments.

https://i.imgur.com/ljJV3X4.png


r/LeaguePBE • • Nov 26 '24

General Why isn't one of the forms of Arcane Fractured Jinx with her hood on?

321 Upvotes

While everyone and their mother is angry over the Viktor VGU, I'm just sitting here thinking that Arcane Fractured Jinx has 3 forms, all of which are pretty cool, but the first neon blue and the last chemtech form feels too similar and the neon blue one needs a hoodie on to differentiate it. I don't have much to add about the gacha practice and it's pricing everyone already hasn't added but at least give her the hoodie.


r/LeaguePBE • • Apr 12 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread [12.8] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Solar Eclipse Kayle

318 Upvotes

Hello All!

"Grant me the strength to forge by flame, a world beyond worlds."

https://imgur.com/a/CGhmNpV

Solar Eclipse Kayle is heading onto the Rift with:

  • New models and textures!

  • New VFX!

  • New SFX!

  • New recall Animation!

Solar Eclipse Kayle is set to be 1350 RP.

Solar Eclipse Kayle is available on PBE! As players who get a first-hand look at this upcoming content, we want to hear your thoughts. Drop your feedback in the thread below.

----

update 4/20/22 in response to player feedback:

Hello, all! Thank you for taking the time to leave feedback on Kayle. For those of you who shared your excitement, we're glad to hear it! For those of you who took the time to write constructive feedback, we're grateful - even if we couldn't address all of it.

Changes we did make:

  • Changed name to Sun-Eater Kayle

  • Changed wing eye VFX from green to maroon-pink

  • Bug fixes, including to the VO filter


r/LeaguePBE • • Jul 13 '22

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Star Guardian Taliyah

303 Upvotes

Post PBE Cycle update:

  • We added a transparency on her tassels and reduced yellow color intensity (this should also make it more coherent with the Splash art)

  • Her familiar now appears at the same time as Taliyah jumps on the wall created by her ultimate

For the future update (tentatively aimed at 12.15)

  • Homeguard animation should be prioritized over passive if both are active at the same time. As this is her only skin that features Homeguard animation, we were not able to resolve all technical difficulties around this.

    Let me provide a bit of context for the some of the suggestions that didn't make it:
    - Stone field of Unraveled Earth (E): model change for the stones would be outside of scope for the PBE cycle and cause some readability concerns. Visual distraction and noise would only increase if we made stones brighter (eg rose quartz) so we opted to not make this change.
    - Weaver’s Wall (R) shape was kept for similar reasons. In our internal exploration we found it to be barely recognizable when Taliyah slides on the wall as it is created.

Thank you for all of the constructive comments!

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://imgur.com/a/zVzF73W

"The earth calls, and I must answer."

Star Guardian Taliyah comes with:

  • New models and textures!

  • New VFX!

  • New SFX!

  • New Recall!

Star Guardian Taliyah should be already available on PBE! Feel free to leave any feedback or questions you have so far down below!

Riot DW Platypus