r/ICoveredASong • • Mar 07 '13

Welcome to r/Icoveredasong. Here are your 3 automatic downvotes

44 Upvotes

I thought about really letting loose and venting with this post but that would make me no better than those I am bitching about. Instead I submit to everyone here a suggestion- Require a reason for a downvote. Simple yet effective. If you don't like the song being covered, don't vote at all.

I have only been subscribed for a few weeks but I have seen such good covers get down-ed to oblivion for no apparent reason. This should be a welcoming and supportive environment for musicians, not a place for a select few to show off and downvote everyone else. If you want that, make this sub private.

EDIT: I want to clarify this is not about lost karma. It's about someone sharing a GOOD cover and getting downvoted to oblivion resulting in denial the exposure they deserve.


r/ICoveredASong • • Jun 20 '13

"Radioactive" and "Pumped Up Kicks" Acoustic Cover

Thumbnail
youtube.com
38 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Jun 12 '13

"Take On Me" as covered by my band on the streets of Toronto (I'm playing keytar/high kicks)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
36 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Sep 23 '12

Gangnam Style - 8 string metal cover

Thumbnail
youtube.com
32 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Feb 25 '13

I Covered a Song - But I'm looking for criticism, not downvotes.

30 Upvotes

Hello /r/ICoveredASong

I think this is a great subreddit. It's awesome that we're able to share music we've worked on with eachother.

But personally I've seen somewhat of a growing trend in this subreddit. Just take a look at the front page of this and the upvote/downvote ratio on posts. And quite often these posts with several downvotes have no comments on them.

I have absolutely no issue with someone downvoting a song cover I post. In fact, if you don't like it, downvote it! However, please tell me why you downvoted it. Constructive criticism is absolutely amazing and can help us all improve. There have been times I've been unaware of a mistake I've made in some of my music (too much reverb, improper compression, etc) and people pointing that out to me has helped so much.

I'd much rather have someone comment and tell me what they didn't like about my song, rather than just saying "Great job, sounds good." Of course I appreciate that too, just saying.

tl;dr - Instead of downvoting, give constructive criticism.


r/ICoveredASong • • May 24 '12

Adele's "Someone Like You" for solo fingerstyle guitar

Thumbnail
youtube.com
29 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Oct 28 '13

We recorded a cover of Royals by Lorde in our garage using "homemade instruments" (Studio Quality)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
28 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • May 16 '13

I covered "Get Lucky" by Daft Punk (With three other Redditors)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
28 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Nov 03 '19

Ever noticed how you can replace the lyrics of Hallelujah with the lyrics of Jolene?

26 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Aug 14 '12

Cartoon Network 90s Theme Song Rock Medley!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
26 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • May 16 '12

My Cover of Kids by mgmt

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
25 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • May 17 '12

Congrats /r/ICoveredASong. You are today's micro feature for /r/subredditoftheday!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
24 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Mar 14 '14

Happy - Pharrell Williams (I'm the one singing and playing bass)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
23 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Feb 23 '26

January 28th Verse

22 Upvotes

I ain't gon lie guys I just wanted to share a lil song I made and I want someone to talk about it cause friends or people on Discord servers haven't responded to me at all. Mainly just focus on the lyrics as English ain't my mother tongue, I did it on 100$ mic on a 50$ sound interface on FL studio trying to mix it myself as well. Nowhere near a professional level and it might genuinely be my bad English accent why it doesn't sound professional.

Nonetheless Id love to talk about the song with anyone that actually wants to give it a shot.


r/ICoveredASong • • Sep 25 '25

Trying to make an acoustic and fingerstyle of When you Sleep by My Bloody Valentine (shoegaze)

21 Upvotes

I'm a Brazilian musician and I have an EP and an album. If you're interested to know my music and if you like instrumental music, folk, ambient and of course, shoegaze, one of my biggest influences and passion, here are some links below

https://nycolle-f.bandcamp.com/

https://youtube.com/@Nyco_lee

https://open.spotify.com/artist/1gyuEDeY7guxPygrdiVr0R

https://www.deezer.com/en/artist/14576931

https://soundcloud.com/nycolle_f

https://www.instagram.com/nycolle.musica

https://www.tiktok.com/@nycolle.musica?_t=ZM-8uzJk6spzjZ&_r=1

https://www.last.fm/user/nycolle_f


r/ICoveredASong • • May 02 '18

Pixel Mixers: Final Fantasy VI - World's Requiem [We covered every song and the album is free!]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • May 15 '14

My cover of Mr. Blue Sky by E.L.O.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Aug 17 '22

Hail to the king (my attempt at suspicious minds by Elvis)

20 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Sep 15 '16

I Covered Pure Imagination sung by Gene Wilder in Willy Wonka

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Apr 25 '12

My little Sister (11) singing Drops of Jupiter by Train. She is very shy. Can we give her cover some views and Reddit love?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Apr 11 '14

I changed the chords to Pharrell's "Happy" and made it a minor blues song - Feedback appreciated!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
19 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Dec 03 '12

I have a feeling that this subreddit is littered with downvote bots

19 Upvotes

Every time I come across a submission on this subreddit, no matter the content or quality, it always seems to be downvoted to 0. The lot of you have talent spilling out of the URL's and your posts are being pushed down without reason given. Either there's a bot or two on the loose, or we're not abiding by the two rules of the subreddit.

I dunno, it just feels as though a bigger sense of community would help everybody out. :)


r/ICoveredASong • • Jun 17 '22

a folk waltz version of the theme from Howl's Moving Castle 💙

18 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Sep 15 '21

Short ukulele post of Fly Me to the Moon

18 Upvotes

r/ICoveredASong • • Apr 29 '15

I covered "Mad World" by Gary Jules and played the piano part on guitar

Thumbnail
youtube.com
18 Upvotes