r/heidegger • • Jul 23 '26

My Heideggerian critique cost me my job at McDonald's

345 Upvotes

So there I was, cleaning the floors and considering the nature of Dasein, always recognizing the mop to be ready-at-hand. My manager comes in and starts rambling about some kinda present-at-hand blasphemy, including a recapitulation of the Cartesian sense of subject/object distinction with my mop having been used by me to ruin a child's meal (I wiped it clean using hermeneutics).

I immediately begin to counter that her ontological relationship with the mop does not consider the existential nature of being, conflating it with being. I take her to task that my part-time work reflects my McNugget-flavored being-toward-death, which is also the name of my metalcore band (find us on YouTube). She enters into some dangerous ground, accusing me of insubordination. Uh oh, she's activated my trap card.

I begin citing at length the "Question Concerning Tech Stuff" and how she is reducing me to standing-reserve by having me abide by the requirements of the job. I desire to be like a wooden Rhine bridge, placid and structurally unsound. She fires me on the spot, as this is a right-to-work state that does not recognize the clearing we operate in.

Truly only a god can save us


r/heidegger • • Dec 28 '25

Guys what’s stopping you from dressing like this???

Post image
244 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Jul 18 '26

Heidegger featured prominently in latest Rick and Morty episode

Post image
150 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Mar 19 '26

How has Heidegger's Being and Time changed your life?

Post image
115 Upvotes

World-renowned philosopher Simon Critchley is getting ready for something exciting coming soon for the centenary of Being and Time. To help build hype and foster community, we want to know: how has reading Heidegger's Being and Time changed your life?


r/heidegger • • May 11 '26

Heidegger’s Phenomenological Interpretations of Aristotle has been the most enjoyable and complex study for me; this book is truly excellent.

Post image
110 Upvotes

Life as care (Sorgen) lives in a world and cares for itself in the most diverse modes of corresponding relations and enactments, and in the modes of temporalization, in accordance with the objects encountered in experience and with the encounters themselves. The object of care is not significance as a categorial character, but rather the ever-worldly, which finds its corresponding objective expression, formulated by life itself. Significance as such is not expressly experienced; yet it can be experienced. The “can” has its own specific categorial sense; the transition from expressivity to inexpressivity is “categorial” in an eminent sense (interpretation of categories!). But significance becomes explicit in life’s own (eigene) interpretation of itself, and only from there can one fully understand what it “is” and means to live factically “in” significance. An abbreviated formulation: “to live in significance” means to live in and from objects within the categorial character of the content of the significant.

In caring, life at each moment experiences its world, and this fundamental sense of experienced being provides in advance the sense, according to its full meaning, for every interpretation of objectuality — even and including the logical-formal (interpretation).

[The mobility of factical life can be interpreted, preliminarily described, as unrest (Unruhe). The how of this unrest, as a full phenomenon, determines facticity. Regarding life and unrest, cf. Pascal, Pensées I–VII; the description is valid, but not the theory and its fore-conception (Vorhabe); above all: soul–body, le Voyage éternel, thus not accessible to existential philosophy. The clarification of unrest, unrest clarified; un-rest and problematicity (Fraglichkeit); powers of temporalization; unrest and the toward-what. The unsettling aspect of unrest. The non-emphasized, undecided between of the aspect of factical life: between surrounding world (Um), shared world (Mit), own world (Selbst), prior (Vor), and posterior (Nach); something positive. The seeping-through (Durchsickern) everywhere of unrest, its figures and masks. Rest (Ruhe) — unrest; phenomenon and movement (cf. the phenomenon of movement in Aristotle).]


r/heidegger • • Dec 30 '25

Heidegger Museum, Messkirch

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

Pocket watch was a gift from Husserl.


r/heidegger • • Aug 26 '25

Was Heidegger almost a satirist with this?

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Jun 27 '25

Heideggerian Scholarschip really is something else man

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

for anyone wondering: κινησις = kinesis Its from Aristotle’s Physics


r/heidegger • • Aug 20 '26

Heidegger Hell Beer

Post image
82 Upvotes

Very ready-to-hand.


r/heidegger • • Mar 11 '26

Heidegger And Aquinas

Post image
76 Upvotes

Many believe that Heidegger was an atheist — at certain periods of his life he did in fact indirectly assume an atheistic position — however, Heidegger contributed significantly to Catholic philosophy. In fact, I think Catholics, especially Thomists, should make use of Heidegger in certain discussions.


r/heidegger • • Apr 11 '26

Heidegger walks into a bar

66 Upvotes

...and orders a drink.

The bartender asks, "What'll it be?"

Heidegger pauses.

"I don’t know yet," he says. "I must first understand the Being of the drink… not merely the drink as a being."

The bartender blinks.

"So… beer?"

Heidegger sighs.

"You have already fallen into average everydayness."

The bartender asks: "A drink or a drink in the world?"

Heidegger stares for a moment.

"…A drink," he says slowly, "insofar as it reveals itself within the clearing of Being."

The bartender nods.

“So… draft or bottled?”


r/heidegger • • Dec 29 '25

Photos

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Dec 29 '22

Heidegger Photos

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Mar 01 '26

Favorite Heidegger look?

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

In my case, I love his style in the photos with the beret


r/heidegger • • May 07 '21

Question on Being and Time

56 Upvotes

Can anyone give me a summary of Heidegger's chapter in Being and Time on The Attestation of Dasein of an Authentic Potentiality of Being, and Resoluteness? For some reason, my copy is bound incorrectly and left most of it out.


r/heidegger • • Jul 21 '26

Passage from Heidegger in Mark Z Danielewski’s House of Leaves

Post image
55 Upvotes

Stumbled upon this while reading this and thought that it might be of interest here


r/heidegger • • Aug 05 '26

What is so hard about reading Being and Time?

53 Upvotes

I am reading the book for the first time. Before starting, I was flooded with advice to start with second-hand literature, Husserl's work, etc, etc. Absolutely no one warned me how straightforward the book was and I am surprised that I even picked it up, but I am glad I did. I have one year background in philosophy and I haven't read anything dense but Being and Time opened my horizon for the German idealism and hermeneutics.

I want to know, what in the name of God, do people find hard about this book? It is certainly not the length, for most german magna opera are way longer than 600 pages and readers do not complain harshly. It's also not the ideas Heidegger presents in it because he is arguing something earthly and lively, unlike the writers he criticises. Nor is it the language, because you literally cant mistake what "thrownness" means or what "being in the world" could stand for. I suppose that the original text has gone too far in creating words but the three prominent english translations make it not just understandable but also inevitable.


r/heidegger • • Aug 17 '26

Heidegger on How Modern Thinking has Reduced Mystery to Mastery

52 Upvotes

According to Heidegger, modern thinking has reduced intellectual mystery to intellectual mastery.

Modern thinking is conceptual, and a concept is, essentially, a form of grasping — from the Latin root conceptus, “to take in” or “to contain.” In our time, we speak of “grasping the material,” “retaining information,” “gaining knowledge,” and so on.

“In the modern age, through calculative thinking, we have long become accustomed to seeing in thinking, and demanding from thinking, grip [Zugriff], grasp [Griff], and concept [Begriff], i.e., we understand the “concept” on the basis of a grasping: conceptus — no longer ὁρισμóς. — The Event

Symbolically, grip [Zugriff], grasp [Griff], and concept [Begriff] evoke the gesture of seizing something in a clenched fist. Heidegger suggests that when thinking has been reduced to conceptus, it is no longer ὁρισμός (horismos) — the Greek word from which we derive “horizon.”

It is impossible to look at a horizon in a grasping way. The only way to truly see the horizon is to allow it to be what it is and to let it reveal itself. The moment we snatch something out of the horizon and trap it in a definition, we no longer see the horizon. It is gone. To see it, we must let it be.

Symbolically, Heidegger associates this with the opposite gesture: the open hand. He calls it Gelassenheit — releasement, or letting-be. Modern thinking becomes reductionistic because it has turned mystery into mastery. We see bits — broken pieces — but never the horizon.

For something to reveal itself, it must be released. We must open our hand and allow the horizon to open itself to us in a reciprocal gesture. If I listen to a melody or a song, for example, I cannot possess or seize any of its notes. To continue hearing and enjoying the song, I must allow each note to come and go so that the next one can appear.

If I try to grab, retain, or make use of a single note, the horizon of the song is lost. I may “grasp” the individual elements — I may learn the note’s position on the scale, its frequency, its intervals — but I will not hear or enjoy the song. I will never see the horizon.

I remember going to music school as a child — which I hated — and thinking: “I thought music was about playing songs, but it’s about scales, solfeggio, and learning about the lives of composers.” The only reason I went was because my mom insisted.

But one day, I saw a classmate sit down at the pianoforte and play a popular song. I was speechless. I loved the song. Suddenly, it occurred to me that what I had been doing at music school for two years had little to do with Music. It was a bitter-sweet discovery.

I realized that music was something entirely different from what I had been taught. It was a mystery.

And mystery never begins with mastery. Mastery always follows mystery.

Eventually, I dropped out of music school, and a few years later I taught myself to play the guitar — this time, driven by a sense of mystery.

Surprisingly, mastery came too, over time — as a side effect. I learned the scales, the notes, the intervals, the solfeggio. But this time, my interest was nourished by the mystery of music.

Unless we first embrace the horizon, we won’t know the meaning of the elements that fill it. The first gesture is never to grasp conceptually. The first gesture is always to become super attentive to what the horizon wants to reveal.

There is no need to attack, seize, grasp, or retain.

Reality will yield itself willingly to the one who is willing to wait for the revelation of its hidden beauties.


r/heidegger • • Jul 04 '25

Humor: Heidegger Abandons Division III

Post image
51 Upvotes

Note: I'm not making an argument nor is this my position. I just find it humorous/amusing & thought I'd share.


r/heidegger • • Sep 07 '24

Heidegger, Kostas Axelos, Jacques Lacan, Jean Beaufret, Elfriede Heidegger, and Sylvia Bataille

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • Jun 26 '26

What would Heidegger say about modern technology?

46 Upvotes

Often, we fail to recognize the extent to which our language shapes our thinking. For example, what happens when we habitually call people human resources?

Heidegger writes in The Question Concerning Technology:

“...he [man] comes to the brink of a precipitous fall; that is, he comes to the point where he himself will have to be taken as standing-reserve.”

Those who work in HR habitually refer to people as “resources.” Yet the moment someone views us as a resource, we immediately cringe. We instinctively sense that we are being degraded.

Heidegger argues that in our age, being reduced to mere standing-reserve is almost inescapable. Whether we recognize it or not, this reduction is embedded in the very language we use. But where does this language – and the thinking behind it – come from?

In his exploration of technology, Heidegger concludes that modern technology is no longer a tool, even though it is presented as one.

“The essence of technology is by no means anything technological.”

Modern technology is a Gestell – Enframing – a conceptual framework that we cast upon reality. Technology is a way of thinking. It reveals how we see everything. Heidegger illustrates this with the example of the Rhine.

Before the twentieth century, numerous watermills stood along the river, each built into the natural flow. In the twentieth century, however, a power plant was constructed at that very site, and the river was locked into it. Now the river is built into the power plant.

This illustrates what has happened to technology. In the past, technology was built into nature. Today, nature is built into technology. In fact, almost everything is built into technology. The question is: Who serves whom?

Gradually, we have shifted from using tools to being used by them. According to Heidegger, one consequence of such a shift is that we tend to view everything as standing-reserve. Humanity stands “on the brink of a precipitous fall” because we are unconsciously turning ourselves into fuel for the Machine.

No one likes being reduced to standing-reserve, yet we continue to use the very language that produces such reductionist thinking.

As a translator, I see more and more agencies replacing personal communication with automated systems. In the past, project managers contacted me directly to offer work. Now I simply receive a notification that a job has appeared on an online platform, and I have to claim it immediately because hundreds of other translators are competing for the same assignment.

I understand why agencies do this. They have built a vast Machine, and everything – including people – must serve it. Yet there are still companies, usually smaller ones, that prefer talking to people. Those are the companies I prefer to work with.

They may sacrifice some profit, but they refuse to treat people as standing-reserve, and they refuse to become it themselves.

Modern technology enframes us to think of everything as a resource. It gives us a language that reduces both nature and humans to fuel for the Machine. We use this language almost unconsciously, yet we still recoil when a boss treats us as an expendable resource.

What is the alternative? Refuse to build our lives into technology! We must have a full and rich life without it. Only then can we build technology into the mainstream of our lives. When we use it less, we can use it some. When we use it all the time, it uses us.

When we build our life and work into technology, it invariably reduces us to standing-reserve. When we build technology into OUR life and work, we reduce it back to a tool. Ultimately, there is only one state of mind that is powerful enough to turn technology back into a tool.

Heidegger concludes,

“Essential reflection upon technology and decisive confrontation with it must happen in a realm that is, on the one hand, akin to the essence of technology and, on the other, fundamentally different from it. Such a realm is art.”


r/heidegger • • Apr 02 '26

The Cover for Heidegger Thinking has been revealed!

Post image
45 Upvotes

Simon Critchley’s Heidegger Thinking: Being and Time Explained is a comprehensive, long-form deep dive into what is arguably the most significant philosophical work of the last century. The book, edited by Ben Olson, is structured into 18 chapters, each presenting a key concept such as Dasein, World, Space, Others, Anxiety, Death, Conscience, and Finitude. Critchley avoids the “bazaar of pop philosophy,” opting instead for a slow, intimate journey through Heidegger’s notoriously difficult architecture without sacrificing depth. Heidegger Thinking is the essential guide for serious readers who intuit the importance of Heidegger’s thought but desire a clear path through its legendary complexity.

Have questions or comments about the book? We'd love to hear them below! You can check out the book here!


r/heidegger • • Aug 10 '20

~Dwell~

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • May 31 '25

Is Heidegger’s Philosophy Tainted by Nazism?

44 Upvotes

I’m currently reading through Heidegger in Ruins and Unterwegs in Sein und Zeit.

The former is written by an intellectual historian who has written several books on Heidegger, while the latter is authored by an actual Heidegger scholar who has held several high-ranking positions in the field.

Richard Wolin (the historian) posits that Heidegger’s philosophy, specifically after ’the turn’ is unequivocally tainted by his “spiritual racism” & the Bodenständigkeit (based on Blut und Boden). He puts the emphasis specifically on the black notebooks.

Alfred Denker, however, in the first half of Chapter 3, essentially minimizes the antisemitic remarks found in the black notebooks, stating that whatever was found in them was nothing new, as those sentiments were already expressed in Heidegger’s private letters.

What I found remarkable is that Denker mentions the exact same issues that Wolin emphasizes and studies in depth, but does so casually, almost in passing, since according to him, Heidegger no longer held these positions after the end of the war. He does, however, affirm that Heidegger posited a kind of “German exceptionalism” (to use Wolin’s term) as a necessity within his metapolitical framework when he began the history of being project. But again, this is mentioned in an almost wavering tone, as Heidegger “failed” to realize this project anyway & since politics held little importance in his later philosophy, Denker implies we can more or less disregard it.

I don’t know what to think tbh. On one hand, the antisemitism in the notebooks seem like the paranoid remarks of an irrational 20th century German (there are many irrational statements in the notebooks). On the other hand, there’s clearly a pivot in his philosophy toward “German Dasein,” in contrast to the supposedly inferior Bodenlosigkeit (rootlessness) he attributes to Jews or “semitic nomads”

There’s also a more alarming detail I noticed in his ‘33–34 seminar Nature, History, State, where he claimed that nomads became nomadic not merely due to the desolation of the steppes and wastelands, but that they themselves often created wastelands wherever they encountered “fruitful and cultivated land.” In contrast, the bodenständige Menschen (people rooted in soil) were, according to him, capable of establishing a home even in the wilderness.

Anyone who’s read Mein Kampf can immediately see the disturbing parallels: Hitler divided humanity into three categories; civilization builders (Aryans), civilization bearers (East Asians), and civilization destroyers (Jews).

What do y’all think?


r/heidegger • • Dec 29 '25

Photos

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes