r/GilmoreGirls • u/strawbbghost • Feb 27 '25
Character Discussion - General i asked ChatGPT to roast the characters
this is just for fun!!
r/GilmoreGirls • u/strawbbghost • Feb 27 '25
this is just for fun!!
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Living_Landscape_651 • Apr 10 '25
He shows up after like years and acts like he knows Rory and gives her a dumb speech on why she shouldn’t like Logan cause he’s rich???
r/GilmoreGirls • u/CiabattaBeKiddinMe • Mar 29 '26
Okay hear me out: As much as I loved Luke and Lorelai’s dynamic before they got together their relationship was always iffy. Butttt what if Lorelai had dated Luke’s ex, Rachel? They had a cute vibe. What other queer relationships can you imagine in the show?
r/GilmoreGirls • u/humanveryhuman • Aug 11 '26
i've seen the show 5 or 6 times and i hate her more with every rewatch. there were a couple good moments but for me she's mostly a toxic insufferable controlling classist racist snob and manipulator.
sometimes i'll see a post praising emily or smn saying maturing is realizing she was right and a good character and i go WHAT 🤯 can smn explain this support of emily?
p.s. i can't stand ayitl so i choose to pretend it doesn't exist and never rewatch it. let's ignore it for this post please
r/GilmoreGirls • u/not_a_gh0st_1996 • Sep 09 '25
EDIT: CLOSED DISCUSSION thanks so much to everyone contributing, I have learned a lot and I am glad I spoke about this 😊 I will now continue with my yearly rewatch because I've gained even more insight to why I love this show so much <3 I really appreciated your feedback!
As someone who went through something similar like lorelai it's really frustrating how she gets condemned for every mistake she makes. I've noticed this recently that it seems like everyone jumps on her, how she reacts wrongly when all i wanted in my childhood was a mother like her. Yes she makes mistakes and sometimes doesnt act accordingly yo her age (trauma will do that to you btw) but she does love rory unconditionally. That doesnt mean without consequences, even though she usually lets rory decide on her own, when she learnes to reciprocate, lorelai welcomes her again with open arms, no discussions, no judgement. She is allowed feelings as well. And yet she doesn't get the same grace like emily does and in my opinion people love to hate on lorelai just so they don't have to deal with Emily's behaviour and how much it hurt lorelai. Because for me that's obvious and the treatment of lorelai is so high standard like.
It reminds me of my therapy journey how my family likes to put me on a spotlight (and not a good one) that just because I am aware of my emotions means that I don't get to have any. I am not allowed to react whereas they get the benefit of the doubt. And yes, I know I’m projecting. But that’s kind of the point of art, isn’t it? It meets us where we are. It gives us mirrors, sometimes in uncomfortable ways. I just wish fandom could be a space where people like me — who saw themselves in Lorelai — didn’t feel silenced, judged, or dismissed.
this is the damage of therapy talk and I see it happening in the gilmore fandom as well. Lorelai CAN communicate - even if she rambles first and gets swept away because she has learned not to trust her reality or masks her pain with humor or deflection. But she isn't getting as much grace as Emily who simply reacts to everything infront of her, even if she's the one to gaslight and manipulate. And that imbalance is what I see reflected in how Lorelai is treated — both by other characters and sometimes by fans. She takes accountability, says sorry (something emily is incapable of) and even then people like to see it as "playing the victim". They have no idea how real gaslighting and manipulation feels.
To be clear: I’m not trying to villainize Emily. She’s a complicated character with deep wounds of her own, and I do see her humanity. But I wish that same level of nuance was extended to Lorelai more often. Both of them are flawed. And also people aren't perfect. Emily isn't, and lorelai certainly isn't. This is the whole point of the show. How they play off each other, not who's to blame.
If being honest about that gets me banned or pushed out, then maybe that space was never safe for me to begin with and it means sadly, even though it brings great joy, good riddance to the fandom. But I hope you can be a bit more understanding.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Willthegumysharkworm • Jul 11 '25
First off just LOOK at that total death glare look. He immediately had a plan. He knew what he was going to do. He totally RUINS rorys relationship with marty & kind of lucy because of the trust fund comment? This is like days after rory writing that essay about the rich people at the party like GOD this man can not handle anyone disliking rich people. (This is also just making me realize how many times he has issues because hes rich and he doesnt like people saying it) this is also like what? A month after rory was jealous bc he didnt mention bobby was a woman? Like she mentioned that marty wss back in her life but still he couldnt handle it so much that he ruins her friendships? That look is just so creepy and so evil dear god.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Bright-Butterfly8297 • Jan 27 '23
He is handsome and he (sort of) matures over the series. I actually feel like she was not honest about her feelings (for Luke) in S6 and S7 and she played him.
Ready for the downvotes!! 😬
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Interesting-Peach710 • Dec 16 '25
Watching for the 2nd time and he most definitely cheated. When he told Honor they broke up he told Rory it was just to get Honor to shut up, but then when he told Rory about the bridesmaids he said he thought they were separated. I don’t buy it. Shame, shame. I think I’m rethinking of joining team Jess again. I go back and forth. Dang it, Logan.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/hopeislikeabluebird • Aug 05 '26
I've been on a lot of TV show subreddits, but this one has one of the most hostile fan cultures I've seen.
The moment someone posts a thoughtful criticism of Rory or Lorelai, or points out their privilege, entitlement, or hypocrisy, a certain section of this subreddit immediately piles on with downvotes, dismissive comments, mocking comments, and personal attacks. It's not disagreement, that would be completely fine. It's the refusal to even engage with perspectives that don't fit the idealized image of these characters. It's really pathetic!
The worst experience I had was when I made a post discussing the racist jokes, stereotypes, and treatment of people from different cultures in Gilmore Girls. Instead of having an actual conversation, people rushed to excuse it with the same tired arguments: "It was a different time," "It's just a joke," "You're being too sensitive."
If people of colour are telling you that certain jokes, comments, or portrayals are offensive, the response shouldn't be to dismiss their experiences because you love a TV show. Acknowledging that a beloved series contains problematic elements isn't the same as saying it has no value.
What frustrates me isn't that people disagree, it's that there seems to be an almost fanatical unwillingness to accept that Rory and Lorelai are intentionally written as flawed characters. Any criticism is treated as an attack, while almost every other character is held to a completely different standard.
The irony is that Gilmore Girls itself often invites conversations about privilege, class, and flawed relationships. Yet parts of this fandom seem determined to shut those conversations down the moment they involve the two protagonists. You can enjoy Rory and Lorelai while recognizing that they're often privileged, entitled, or hypocritical. And you can appreciate Gilmore Girls while listening respectfully when viewers from different backgrounds explain why certain scenes or jokes haven't aged well.
A fandom shouldn't require blind admiration. It should be a place where people can discuss the show honestly, even when that discussion is uncomfortable.
PS Bunch on miserable losers proving the point in the comments even downvoting comments that simply says "exactly 💯" under another comment. How big of a pathetic loser you need to be to be that intolerant. Ugh!
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Next_Performance4330 • Aug 19 '25
Another edit because people aren’t seeming to understand: I’m not offended by her asking how he died it’s the fact that she asked if it was while he was sleeping with Paris.
EDIT: thank you for everyone’s point of view and those being nice! Now that I think about it Asher was known for being a player so makes sense just still doesn’t sit right with me.
I was just watching the episode written in the stars. When Paris tells Rory that Asher died Rory asks “it wasn’t during…. Was it.” I’m sorry but your good friend has just told you her partner died and that’s what you ask? Infuriates me every single time.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/ClassicArt3777 • Mar 01 '26
I know this is a controversial take and I am ready to get down-voted but I never saw the appeal in Paris' character through the show. Maybe the only time I liked her was when she stood up for Rory and told Logan to leave her alone. But any other time, I just find her selfish and demanding.
I know a lot of people love her and I won't say you shouldn't. But she was sometimes so overbearing in the show that I actually had to take a break. I only started to tolerate her when she was on the trip with Rory and was super flustered about her date with Jamie. I also felt sympathy for her when I realized her parents' absence in her life and how lonely she was.
But that still doesn't give her the right to treat people around her like that. She was very strong-headed, never compromised and always thought she was right. Me being a senior now may influence how I view her right now but if I had a classmate that made that big of a fuss not getting into Harvard when she still had such great options such as Yale.... I would find it extremely disrespectful.
She gets better in the later seasons but her in Chilton... whew... what a ride. I'm glad she went to Yale as it finally showed her that life doesn't always end up your way.
Edit: Based on what everyone said, I would like to explain a bit further. When I said "deserved, I meant it more of a she's not entitled to go to Harvard. Harvard isn't something that you just purchase and demand it. But her lashing out made it sound like that. I don't discredit all her efforts, and I do wish I was even as half dedicated as she was in some cases. But in the end, the way she reacted for her rejection was a massive turn of for me then. She gets much better in Yale!
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Virtual-Voice-6491 • Dec 26 '24
I might be slightly biased as I really didn’t like Dean’s character… I always found him irritating (might be a personal thing ahaha) but I think Tristan could’ve become a really great boyfriend, we never saw too much of him but what we did see he started to become softer and sweeter. Think it was a mistake they didn’t pursue this relationship very far.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Lumpy_Anxiety_3694 • Dec 14 '25
Emily and Richard treat GiGi almost the exact same way that Straub and Francine treat Rory. They never try to get to know her and view her existence as a mistake. I'm currently rewatching S7 (specifically The Great Stink) and it suddenly clicks that GiGi never attends FND's with her literal father. Every time Chr*stopher attends FND with Lorelai/Lorelai and Rory, it's just the three of them and GiGi is never mentioned or seen. Even Emily and Richard don't mention how strange this is, especially since Lorelai and Chris are married. Despite how Emily and Richard treat Luke, I think it's definitely interesting how Emily was willing to (attempt) get to know April, and Jess if you want to count him, but they never try to bond with GiGi.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/0nceUponATime0 • Jan 25 '24
r/GilmoreGirls • u/MotorTime3114 • Apr 22 '25
So basically I feel like logan is the whole reason she went downhill. If she was with someone else I doubt she would have stolen a boat or like drop out of yaleeee. So ya I feel like he messed her up and is the main reason she became the not so great person she is at the end of the show
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Weekly-Pangolin-6622 • Mar 09 '26
remind me so much of that scene in Breaking Bad when (spoilers!) Walt watches and lets Jesse's girlfriend OD and choke to death on her own vomit. It's so dark and eerie, watching a character whom you've known all along is flawed actively decide to slip into full-blown evil out of rank selfishness. This goes for Rory and Dean both, by the way. I kind of like them both and generally root for them through the first four seasons, but after that I cannot stand them and am actively rooting for their downfalls. Just like with Walter White in the last few seasons of Breaking Bad. What does this scene remind you of?
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Narrow_Celebration12 • Nov 04 '24
After Kyle’s party his dad calls Luke and makes him pay for damages or he’ll have Jess arrested. Dean goes to the house to also help damages.
Am I the only person who thinks if I were Luke or Deans parent I would tell Kyle’s dad to shove it? His kid was hosting a party without his parents consent and serving alcohol to underage kids. He is liable for damages that occurred under his roof and he is the one who’s lucky no one got hurt.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/InflationDry3749 • Jan 05 '23
I love Lorelai’s character I really do but she went a mile too far being rude to her dad in the episode where he visited her house after retirement. She made him feel so unwanted. He was only just being a dad telling her what fruits to eat in the morning dads are just protective like that. It’s just harsh to tell a person close to their deathbed that their opinion isn’t wanted and neither are they and that’s what she did
r/GilmoreGirls • u/antitheticalargument • Jun 04 '25
I need someone to explain why Logan’s proposal is treated like the ultimate red flag — because every time it gets brought up, y’all act like he asked Rory to hand over her passport, burn her degree, and become a Stepford wife.
Let’s get one thing very straight:
Logan’s proposal wasn’t toxic, manipulative, or regressive. It was a natural next step for someone who had been in a long-term, serious relationship with a woman he loved. He wasn’t love-bombing her. He wasn’t blindsiding her. He was saying: I choose you. Let’s build something real.
And what did he get in return? A weird, flustered, “I want to travel” speech from a girl who had never once demonstrated a real post-college plan.

edit - since y'all keep parroting the same thing: the public proposal thing? Logan was raised in that world. Fancy parties, formal gestures, big moments — that’s how he was taught to express seriousness. It wasn’t about pressure; it was about showing her he was ready to make it real, in front of people who mattered. Could it have been more personal? Sure. But manipulative? That’s a reach.
And he was trying to offer a future, not steal her thunder. If you felt threatened by it, that’s a you problem.
He wasn’t making it about him—he was trying to make it about them**.**
r/GilmoreGirls • u/Aggravating-Tea-9563 • Mar 08 '26
Genuinely - why is it so important to you? I promise not to negate your thoughts but genuinely want to know. My thoughts are genuinely - I think it’s ok to show this attempted assault on screen. It’s important for people to know you can be excited about sex and also withdraw consent and also that assault exists on a spectrum and does not need to look one way to be considered violating consent. I just don’t understand the vehement defense of this fictional character. I might regret this but oh well.
r/GilmoreGirls
•
u/KuriosLogos
•
Mar 20 '26
So I anticipate that this post might be downvoted to hell itself but I’m fine with that because I feel I can see things clearly and I’m more than willing to get to hell by dying on this hill:
Mitchum did nothing wrong when he interviewed Rory. He was absolutely right in his assessment.
The complaints I often see that’s commonly made against Mitchum is that he didn’t take Rory under his wing. He didn’t give her any guidance, didn’t give her any sort of instruction or a semblance of leadership in her internship to help her out to succeed and I’m constantly baffled that people forget Mitchum’s original statement to Rory when he convinced her to take the internship.
—
*Season 5 Episode 19 - “But I’m a Gilmore” :*
**RORY:** *Are you looking for Logan?*
**MITCHUM:** *No, I know better than to look for my son in the newsroom. I came to talk to you.*
**RORY:** *About what?*
**MITCHUM:** *I'm very sorry about what happened the other night.*
**RORY:** *It's okay.*
**MITCHUM:** *My family behaved atrociously, and, though Logan was a little naïve to walk into the lion's den without a chair like that, they were wrong and you deserve an apology.*
**RORY:** *Okay. Thank you.*
**MITCHUM:** *So, I hear you have some rather lofty journalistic aspirations.*
**RORY [nods]:** *I have plans.*
**MITCHUM:** *You know, my company just acquired a small newspaper. The Stamford Eagle Gazette. Decent circulation, pretty sorry writing, but definite potential. When we buy a new paper, I like to spend some time there. Take a couple of months, help turn it around, make sure we're getting our money's worth. Stamford isn't a bad train ride from here, is it?*
**RORY:** *Um, no.*
**MITCHUM:** *I have an internship available, if you're interested.*
**RORY:** *An internship?*
**MITCHUM:** *Be a good chance for you to get your feet wet. Experience how the real thing works.*
**RORY:** *No. Thank you.*
**MITCHUM [confused]:** *No, thank you?*
**RORY:** *I appreciate the offer. But no.*
**MITCHUM [stands up as if to leave, then turns back to Rory]:** *May I be so bold as to inquire, why the hell not?*
**RORY:** *Because I have a feeling that the only reason you're doing this is because you feel guilty about what happened the other night at dinner, and it's very nice, but very unnecessary.*
**MITCHUM:** *So what?*
**RORY:** *Excuse me?*
**MITCHUM:** *Say the only reason I offered this to you is because my family behaved badly and I wanted to make up for it. Say I have no interest in furthering your career. This is still an opportunity. Who cares why you got the opportunity? It's here, and life is about making the most of everything you're handed. Well, this is being handed to you. Now, what are you going to do about it?*
*[Rory looks thoughtful. Mitchum smiles in victory.]*
**MITCHUM:** *Monday. Ten o'clock. Call my office for the details. [He begins walking away.] And bring a pencil! You never know when you're going to need a pencil!*
—
Mitchum makes it crystal clear that he wants Rory to assume he has no interest in furthering her career here:
>**”Say the only reason I offered this to you is because my family behaved badly and I wanted to make up for it. Say I have no interest in furthering your career. This is still an opportunity. Who cares why you got the opportunity? It's here, and life is about making the most of everything you're handed. Well, this is being handed to you. Now, what are you going to do about it?”**
Notice that Mitchum doesn’t B.S. Rory. He literally only came to Rory to apologize for his family’s behavior and he’s offering her an internship as a way to make it up to her without being interested in helping her make a career. Everyone often complains that he didn’t help or instruct Rory during her internship and YES! That is completely true! And it’s because he wasn’t interested in doing so and he stated that in the first place. But here’s the kicker, the next few lines he says:
>**”Say I have no interest in furthering your career. This is still an opportunity. Who cares why you got the opportunity? It's here, and life is about making the most of everything you're handed. Well, this is being handed to you. Now, what are you going to do about it?”**
That statement is the ENTIRE reason for Mitchum’s review *against* Rory! Let’s take a look at his review:
—
*Season 5 Episode 21 - “Blame Booze and Melville”:*
**MITCHUM:** *You know, you and I haven't really sat down and talked about the situation, about how you're doing here, and all.*
**RORY:** *Well, you've been busy.*
**MITCHUM:** *I've meant to. Offered you the job, took you under my wing. It's part of the deal.*
**RORY:** *Great! I'd love your feedback.*
**MITCHUM:** *Go on and sit.*
*[They sit down, Rory with a notepad.]*
**MITCHUM:** *I've worked with a lot of young people over the years. Interns, new hires. I've got a pretty good gut sense for people's strengths and weaknesses. Whether they have that certain something to make it in journalism. It's a tough business. Lot of stress.*
**RORY [smiling]:** *Definitely.*
**MITCHUM:** *And I have to tell you. You don't got it.*
*[Rory is stunned.]*
**MITCHUM:** *Now, guts can be wrong. Mine's been wrong before. But not often.*
**RORY:** *I thought I was doing okay.*
**MITCHUM:** *I just don't really think that you have the drive to put yourself out there, to be honest. To get a story. To dig. I mean, just now in this meeting, I encouraged everyone to say whatever they wanted. You said nothing.*
**RORY:** *I wasn't sure if I should.*
**MITCHUM:** *Exactly. I mean, you saw Harry. He jumped right into the fire. You didn't.*
**RORY:** *But Harry's not an intern!*
**MITCHUM:** *Doesn't matter.*
**RORY [near tears]:** *I've always done what's asked of me.*
**MITCHUM:** *See, the thing is, in the real world, it's not always good enough to do just what's asked of you.*
**RORY:** *But I thought I was in a really good rhythm with everyone here.*
**MITCHUM:** *I'm not saying you're not competent. You're smart. You're terrific at anticipating needs. Actually, you'd make a great assistant.*
**RORY:** *Oh.*
**MITCHUM:** *I'm sorry. It's not my pleasure to disappoint someone like you. Especially you. What with the extenuating circumstances. But it's healthy. I don't know any other way. I don't B.S.*
**RORY:** *I should get back.*
*[She gets up and heads for the door. Mitchum stands up.]*
**MITCHUM:** *Hey, listen. I know this is rough, but, uh, I may have just done you a big favor.*
**RORY:** *Oh. Okay. Thanks.*
—
Notice that Mitchum wasn’t being unfair whatsoever. His primary criticism against Rory was this:
I just don't really think that you have the drive to put yourself out there, to be honest. To get a story. To dig. I mean, just now in this meeting, I encouraged everyone to say whatever they wanted. You said nothing.
Rory’s response was that she completely unsure if she had the authority to speak up in such a meeting and Mitchum’s response was absolutely right: Exactly.
My argument is that Rory completely misunderstood why she was Mitchum’s intern in the first place. She thought Mitchum was there to teach her things and to show her how to step, to be a good journalist, when he made it very clear in the beginning that he had no interest in helping her in her journalistic career BUT he did feel sorry and was handing her an opportunity because he felt sorry and he was interested to see what she would make of that opportunity. So what did Rory make of that opportunity? She played it way too safe. She stuck within her boundaries and she never stepped out of line once to grab more which was Mitchum’s main complaint against her.
I’m sure that a lot of us are fed up with the current administration and the leader of it. More so fed up with the Press who interviews them. How many times have we seen the media and press play by the current administration’s rules by asking safe questions and not pushing for the deeper story/truth of the matter regarding more controversial issues?
That’s EXACTLY what Rory was doing. She had no journalistic instincts at that time to break out of her assigned cage and go further and deeper than she was allowed to go to get more information and make a bigger splash in her community. Rory’s only defense to Mitchum’s complaints was essentially “I’m not allowed to… because I’m a lowly intern!” and that makes for a terrible journalist so I wholeheartedly agree with Mitchum at that time.
Mitchum wasn’t interested in tutoring Rory and making her into a great journalist in the first place. He stated as much when he gave her the job. His only interest was in seeing what Rory did with the opportunity that was given to her out of pity and she completely failed that test by being a typical intern and nothing more.
r/GilmoreGirls • u/LittleRedCatx • May 15 '25
Everyone talks about Jackson not telling Sookie he didn’t get a vasectomy (which is 100% wrong) But no one ever talks about how Sookie forced Jackson to get one. They are a couple and this should have been a discussion, they joke about how “they bought the big nurse” basically forcing him into it, and I personally think this is wrong.