r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Feb 01 '26

We’re working on a new edition

82 Upvotes

This is mostly as a way for us to hold ourselves accountable. After a 4.5 year break, we’re back on the old game design horse again.

The goal is to address many of the complaints of the original while updating it to more accurately reflect the current state of both the 5e and the OSR community. Additionally we want to incorporate a lot of tweaks from our supplements line.

Right now the working title is Fifty Torches Deep, as a play on the fiftieth year anniversary edition of D&D.

We have no timeline or even proper commitment, but figured no better place to post about it than here.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Jun 22 '21

A rude awakening for my 5e players with Five Torches Deep...in a good way.

59 Upvotes

TL;DR at bottom

Coerced, begged, bribed, and blackmailed my 5e players to try Five Torches Deep and it was delightful. Right away they learned it takes a different play style when they came across an obviously raided and deserted camp.

They stealth scouted some goblins along a ridge line and got an ambush off! "They are naturals" I thought. 7 goblins in total, 1 dies from an arrow to the throat. Then the zealot charges in...One shot from a goblin drops him. The players are stunned. A series of bad choices and poor rolls the whole party is down. These goblins are slavers so they take them captive.

What follows next was described as the most intense D&D they had ever played. They awoke in a crude jail cell in a ruin with no weapons, no armor, and 2 HP.

"This isn't what is supposed to happen to heroes."

"You are not heroes. You are adventurers who are about to become slaves. Are you just going to let that happen? What do you do?"

The players ended up busting out, killing a guard, scavenging a single bone spear and a crude bow with only 2 arrows. They found out the real slavers were dwarves, there was some failed negotiations that ended in the entire goblin hoard chasing them down. They could have escaped right away but they wanted to recover their gear. Which I allowed at the cost of the escape DC being higher. They accepted.

2 players failed and one succeeded. I described the other 2 being surrounded by gobbos about to be cut down. The escaped players says "wait, can I go back and try to help?" Sure, pretty dangerous. They don't care. Rush back and cast Illuminate with the intent to scare the goblins away. I tell him to roll a spell check just to see how effective and bright the cantrip is...

Nat 20.

Goblins flee in terror! The players make it back to town with their gear and low HP. Even though they "lost" they still had fun! They were rapid talking about it for a while. They escaped with their lives and a ton of information and experience. They now plan on getting as many henchman as they can and going back to fully clear it.

TL;DR - 5e players learn 5TD world is dangerous and they aren't superheros at level 1. Get beat up. Get captured. Jailbreak. assassinate. alert screaming goblin hoard. Nat 20 saves the day. Players are hella jazzed up to play again.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 19 '22

Time to head out!

41 Upvotes

Hey all!

Two years ago I created this subreddit to allow us to discuss the game Five Torches Deep. About two months later, I started experiencing symptoms of what we would come to find was stage 4 Liver disease. It seems I had (have) a genetic deficiency called AAT that caused this, and I needed a transplant "near future".

A year later, I asked /u/samurguybri (a regular contributor here, then and now) if he would be interested in helping me moderate, and he agreed!

Later that year, in December (last year) I had my Liver transplant surgery! The surgery went really well, and my recovery has been great these last five months.

Having said all that, I need to step away as an Admin here because... well, put simply, I have been occupied more with other things, especially since surgery those five months back. I'm not the kind of guy to remain an Admin/Moderator on Reddit if I am not actively involved with the community, posts, etc. As such, today I step down/out as an Admin (or even as a Moderator) passing the Administrative reins over to /u/samurguybri who I previously spoke to about this.

Thank you Samurguy, everyone else as well, and to you /u/hadouken_bd for Five Torches Deep and your activity here helping answer questions about your game ;)

Have fun everyone!


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Mar 17 '21

Resource My FTD Monster Stats site is live - fivemonstersdeep.com

39 Upvotes

I created a site for Five Torches Deep monster stats - fivemonstersdeep.com

The monsters on the site are converted from OSR content using the monster rules in the FTD rulebook. At the moment the site contains monsters from:

  • Basic Fantasy

  • Keep on the Borderlands

  • Stonehell (levels 1-2)

I plan to add more monsters to this database over time.

Some of you may have seen this tool already, I have made a few enhancements:

  • Export the stats to an image file

  • Change the monster's category (brute, sniper etc.)

  • Make it clearer that stats are modifiers

  • Each monster has its own URL

  • Can search by hit dice

  • Number appearing

  • Alternative speeds in brackets

Please check it out and let me know if you have any feedback.

Happy delving!


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Oct 25 '20

Resource Dislike the standard character sheet? here's my hack

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Jul 16 '26

Resource Five Torches Deep - Duels (Anyone Checked This Out?)

Post image
34 Upvotes

I saw this was on sale, so I figured some folks might want to give it a look if you haven't checked it out yet. Direct link for those interested: Five Torches Deep - Duels


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Feb 26 '21

Welcome to the 5 Torches Deep Arts and Crafts Inventory System!

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Aug 31 '26

Why is 50TD so long?

32 Upvotes

In an earlier post I mentioned that the second edition of Five Torches Deep, Fifty Torches Deep (50TD), is almost ten times as long. I think some people found that disconcerting.

So why is it so long?

The design goal of 50TD was to be a “comprehensive” version of FTD, which in short means that it includes all of the optional and supplemental rules from previous releases.

The actual core rules are only slightly longer, and that’s mostly due to expanded clarifications and better procedures. The longest extended rule section is the procedure around adventure turns, which could be completely disregarded without much issue.

Even with all of the supplemental information, it is of a comparable word count to OSE and Shadowdark.

So what are all of these extra and optional rules?

Expanded ancestries and lineages, similar to the Origins book (though some tweaks and clarifications, and trimmed down).

Significantly expanded spell lists for all casters.

Significantly expanded example monster and monster building rules.

Potions, alchemy, and crafting rules.

Down time and extended haven rules, significantly expanded beyond the Homesteads supplement for FTD.

Training, leadership buildings, and other domain management rules (even for lower level PCs).

Duels and advanced combat rules.

Simplified “one roll combat encounters” rules.

Significantly expanded options around retainers, mounts, animals, vehicles, and large scale battles.

Expanded corruptions, including rules for crafting poisons or similarly corrupting components.

A more fleshed out GM section, as well as more rules around hex crawling, procedures, and adventuring.

Expanded class functions and more details around features and talents.

If you just want to play the simple streamlined version of the rules, we plan on organizing and tagging the content in such a way that that becomes quite easy to do. Limiting ancestries, one roll combat, no adventure procedures, etc.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Aug 16 '26

50TD dev update: moving to editing and layout

32 Upvotes

Hi folks, we’ve finished the first draft of 50TD. It’s coming in at over 10x the word count of FTD, which is honestly probably too much.

Our editing and layout process is to set a template of page layout and then edit the page content to fit appropriately with the right fonts and spacing. This is what led to such “clean” layout and uniformity in other FTD works.

That technique is quite easy with a 5-6k word manuscript but dealing with something of this size is quite an undertaking. I’m anticipating that as we get into layout some sections will simply have to be completely rewritten to work.

Normally this stage takes a month or two, but here I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s 6+. Writing began in January so it was about eight months, I was shooting for an end of year completion of layout but I don’t think so.

In other update news we’ve made a tentative agreement with an artist who works fully in analog (real paint and ink) with a very distinct style. It’s not the typical of modern OSR, but it’s quite different from historic FTD and other D&D alike games.

More news to come and previews once we’re getting under way.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • 20d ago

About 50% done with first layout and editing pass

30 Upvotes

We’re roughly on schedule with completing the first “proper” draft of 50TD. Our goal is to get something done and out from our small alpha group to closed beta groups before the end of the year.

One large challenge of this run has been writing in traditional two column 8.5x11” paper. It’s not a size we’ve EVER written or laid out for, always instead preferring landscape orientation or smaller single column foot prints.

A lot of our raw draft has had to be almost completely rewritten in order to fit with our “every spread a complete idea” concept. Our preliminary layout method is to use Google Docs which obviously limits flexibility from more advanced tools like indesign.

We use Google Docs because of the ability to easily comment and edit and have version control from any browser on any device. So far I would say this round has been very illuminating in terms of our approach to writing completely without a layout constraint.

A lot of benefits but a lot of challenges too.

Thanks for following along and we’re excited to share it with some groups in the next month or two!


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Apr 14 '22

GMing Finally got the customizable DM Screen!

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 08 '21

GMing It's here...

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Apr 30 '21

Resource fivemonstersdeep.com now includes monsters for Barrowmaze

28 Upvotes

I added the monsters from Barrowmaze to my FTD monster stats site https://fivemonstersdeep.com

Also chucked in the monsters for Hole in the Oak.

Enjoy!


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Mar 11 '21

Look what came in the mail today.....

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Apr 21 '23

Resource Things that 5 Torches Deep does better than "the world's greatest roleplaying game."

25 Upvotes

WARNING THIS MIGHT BE LONG

Whenever I'm asked "what's a game that's 5E but better?" My answer is always, by default, Five Torches Deep.

But why? What does 5TD do better than 5E? Well a lot of things dear reader. Here's my own personal list of things that Five Torches Deep does better than D&D 5E. I made my list based off of things that 5E players themselves don't like about 5E and wish WoTC would fix.

Monster Math Table: This is probably the most useful thing in the whole book. For those of you who have played 5E, you know that the CR system is fundamentally broken, and doesn't work. Changing ANYTHING about a monster drastically changes the way it functions in combat.

But with the Monster Math Table? Want to scale up a low level bandit to HD 18 and make it a bandit warlord? You got it. Want to scale a dragon down to HD 5, and have your party fight a dragon at low level? You got it. There's no way to do this in 5E without making a fight too hard or too easy. There is rarely an in-between.

Additionally you can steal monsters from other systems and use them in 5TD. You can't do this in 5E without doing all the work yourself, but 5TD saves you tons of time and drastically lightens the workload.

The Three Pillars: The 3 main pillars of D&D are combat, roleplay, and exploration. 5TD does all 3 of these better. Admittedly it's all off the back of the tenets of the OSR, but I felt it necessary to list it anyways.

  1. Combat: We all know combat takes FOREVER in 5E. Monsters need hundreds of hit points because the players do so much damage, if you don't give them hundreds of hit points, they pose no significant threat to the party and those goblins can kiss their asses goodbye.

But in 5TD health is low, damage is high, and health regain is slow. Even with retainers combat still goes by quickly. You actually have to avoid combat, and think your way out of it, rather than pressing an automatic "I win button" whether that be a "strategy," or spell. And I use the word strategy very loosely because there's no strategy involved in 5E. There's no thinking. There's no planning ahead. The game is designed for you to win 90% of the time.

It is ironic how 5E, a super heroic fantasy game, does worse combat compared to a lot of games like it, and it's supposed to be good at it.

2. Roleplay: You don't roleplay in 5E. You say you want to look for traps. The DM tells you to roll Perception, and your Ranger with expertise in Perception, and the Dungeon Delver feat, will automatically find every trap, every single time. You didn't interact with the dungeon to find the trapdoor. You didn't do anything clever to find the trapdoor. You looked at what your highest bonus was, and were given it automatically. It's a very video game esque way of doing it that way, and it's boring.

Now of course 5TD does have a perception skill, but the difference is you can actually fail as your bonus might not even get that high (though DC 11 isn't that high either but the DM can do what they want), and there are no feats, and Thieves don't get Expertise until level 9. Rogues get the ability to find traps easier which makes sense because they're the trap finding guy. But in 5E ANYONE can be the trap finding guy.

A houserule I've seen used in 5E is using one attribute for a skill in place of another attribute. For example using Strength for intimidation instead of Charisma because you're being physically imposing.

In 5TD if you were proficient in Intimidation you could use any stat you want as long as you can justify it just by RAW.

3. Exploration: This just simply doesn't exist in 5E so really I've got nothing to rag on, because there's nothing to even compare it too.

In 5TD because gold is XP and how the players level up, and pay for more supply, and retainers, going into the dungeon and actually exploring is something they should really consider doing. It's how they're going to acquire magic items, and more wealth to stay alive.

No Dump Stats: In 5E there are 3 undisputed stat kings. Con, Dex, and Wis. If your character is not good at these 3, they are a worse character compared to someone who is, and your character is ruined forever. It almost considered rude to even show up to the table with such a character.

In 5TD, admittedly Str, Con, and Int are really good as they literally keep you alive, but the other stats have uses too beyond being your casting stat. Your fighter with 12 Str and 16 Int? Sounds fun, you'll do amazing things with that character.

Martial/Caster Divide: There's no point in playing a martial in 5E because you will get outpaced by the Wizard eventually. You're still making your 4 attacks (once a short/long rest) and the Wizard is flying, summoning, teleporting etc. It's immersion breaking, as what's the point of swords anymore? Magic is overpowered as hell and the only way to keep mages in check is with other mages.

In 5TD... Do I even need to explain? Wizards can do awesome stuff. HOWEVER, they are balanced by the fact that their magic is dangerous to themselves, thus swords can still be relevant in your fantasy world, as the fighters can actually stand a chance.

Conclusion: This is getting way too long so I'm gonna end it. But if anyone ever asks for a game that's "5E but better," direct them over to this post.

There's more I'd love to add, so a part 2 might have to be in order.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 18 '22

Resource I made a Five Torches Deep Discord since I couldn't find an existing one and would love for you to join!

25 Upvotes

Link to Discord: https://discord.gg/dTrKFHbesz

Not much else to say really. I've set up a discord before that's got a couple hundred people now so I decided to do it for this system that I love. I've added some useful bots, made channels that highlight different aspects of play and tried to make everything as clear as possible.There's a bot that automatically posts a link to a reddit post from this sub so that everyone can view and discuss it and I made channels so you can find a DM or players.

While I still have some things left to do I would love for people to get in and let me know what they think. I'll also give you your own private channels if you want to host your games in this server with existing players or players you meet through the server.Right now I'll be putting this server on Disboard and other sites to advertise it's presence and hopefully I can make it so that I'm friendly with other OSR discords.

Hopefully I'll see you on the server :)


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 18 '22

Resource Made a monster sheet form-fillable version in the comments

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Feb 06 '21

5e Monsters Bestiary & Random Map Generator

25 Upvotes

Greetings! I've recently started playing Five Torches Deep and I decided to make a few rpg tools to simplify my work as a GM.

Random Map Generator

The first is a simple map creator using the puzzle cube technique.


Fifth Edition Bestiary

This is a Bestiary based on the 5e SRD Monsters. This one is still a work in progress as I convert the abilities found for each monster.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Feb 03 '21

Delve Report: 5TD + Barrowmaze (~7 sessions so far)

25 Upvotes

I've got six or seven Five Torches Deep sessions under my belt now... We've been crawling through the Barrowmaze, an undead themed megadungeon. Been sticking very close to the Rules As Written. It's been a blast! For the benefit of others that might run Barrowmaze, this thread is about the little adjustments and tweaks I'm making to both the rules and the adventure.

  • Mainly, I want to adjust the level-up pace. This adventure is incredibly lethal, and the treasure is very spread out. Each character has only been getting 200-500 xp per session. Dying resets your xp. Consequently, only a handful of characters have made it to level 2 @ 2500xp. People don't mind playing a low-powered game, and they are being incredibly good sports about losing 3 sessions worth of XP in one unlucky moment, but the ice is getting thin. I'm going to begin letting new characters start with 1/2 the XP of the old character. They need to feel like they're making progress.

  • A few players mentioned that they enjoy the lethality (it's a great change of pace from the extremely survivable 5e) but the drawback is that they're not getting attached to their characters because they expect them to die in 20 minutes. Personally, I think this will solve itself over time... after you get past the first few levels, D&D characters get way more survivable. If you reach that plateau, you'll feel like you came through the crucible to get there.

  • On that note, ability scores have such a huge impact on survivability... you can really sense a player's disappointment if they get stuck with shit stats. It's always fun to roleplay a character with low scores, but the reality is that failing checks all session gets old. I dunno if this needs attention or not.

  • After three sessions, one warrior reached level 2, rolled his d10 for hit points... got a 1. He was a great sport about it, but it actually annoyed ME that he worked so hard to level up but barely gained any survivability. I want them to get a little bit more confident over time, and that requires hit points. I implemented a houserule that if you don't like your HP roll, you can choose to reroll once, but you're stuck with what you've got.

  • Spending so long at levels 1 & 2 is tough for the casters, who sometimes lose their ability to cast spells for the day after their first die roll. And because of the super low ability scores, it can be really easy to fail that check. Moving forward, I want to use the houserule is that when you fail a spellcasting check, you only lose access to that spell, not the full level.

  • It takes half a day to hike from the village to the barrowmaze, and the adventurers know that traveling at night is risky. If they leave town at sunrise, and want to get back to the inn at sunset, they only have about two hours to explore the dungeon without having a risky trip home. They are looking to blaze a faster route to the dungeon, so I'm setting up a sidequest which will let them shave off some travel time. Letting them worry less about sunset will make the attrition mechanics work better - with a two hour delve, nobody ever gets exhausted or runs out of supplies.

  • Equipment Breakage is the attrition mechanic which sees the most play at our table. I've houseruled that the Mending cantrip doesn't work instantly, it follows the same rules as regular Repair. Fixing equipment in the dungeon is always going to take time and be noisy. You get advantage on the check if you are using a specific tool kit, but you save inventory space by just using Mending.

  • This is a classic D&D problem -- that the treasure the party earns greatly outpaces the cost of goods and services. It seems like a waste of time to tabulate little 1gp and 4sp expenditures when you have 7000 gold in the bank. The main cost they incur each session is henchmen. I implemented a plot clock (using a mechanic from Blades in the Dark) to track Guildmaster Osen's mood. I drew a circle and divided it into 8 slices. Every time the PCs come back, if multiple henchmen have died, I fill in 2 slices. If the PCs did anything to comfort the families of the dead, sweet talk the guildmaster, or do other damage control, I only fill in one slice instead of two. Once the clock fills up, the Guildmaster designates the party "higher risk" and all their henchmen recruitment costs go up x10. (this really isn't an issue at first... paying 1gp vs 10gp doesn't matter, but once each henchmen costs 100gp, they'll get worried about it increasing to 1000gp.)

  • I've been real inconsistent with the cost of healing services and healing potions in town. 1d4 healing potions are available per session, and they cost anywhere between 50 and 200 gold, depending on my mood. Currently, curing a disease costs 500gp, restoring a limb costs 2000, and raising the dead costs 10,000. I told them that if they recover Diamonds or Holy Writs, the church can use them as components for that casting.

  • I made up a henchmen deck. It started with about 25 cards, and is probably down to 10 or 15 now. The deck is about 40% torchbearers (who are willing to carry 5 load), 40% men at arms, and 20% classed adventurers (who want a 1/2 share of treasure). On each day, the party can recruit up to 1d6 henchmen if they visit the merc guild. But if they pay the town crier his fee of 10 gold, he will go knock on doors and wake up potential recruits. In this case, you find (the higher of 2d6) henchmen. This has been a fun way to do it - players have developed relationships with the henchmen over time. When a henchman dies in the Barrowmaze, I put their index card aside and include "undead henchmen" in random encounter tables.

  • In the rules as written, there's basically no way to get bright light into a dungeon, meaning ranged attacks and sight-based checks are always gonna have disadvantage. I have a houserule that two sources of dim light creates bright light, which creates a tiny problem solving / gear management puzzle. When they can only hire one torchbearer, when combat starts, they order the torchbearer to put his torch / lantern on the ground and light a new one.

  • In the Barrowmaze, you can find a few weapons that permanently radiate light. This kinda breaks the game of managing torches and dim light, since a glowing sword will illuminate the room even if it's hanging off your belt. Moving forward, I think I'm gonna let glowing weapons work like this: they have 3 charges per day. You can say a powerword to spend a charge and the weapon will shed dim light for an hour. If you chant the power word three times, it uses all three charges, but your weapon sheds bright light for 1 hour.

  • You can also find Bags of Holding, but I'm going to houserule that they're pretty small (because then what is the point of using a game with streamlined encumberance rules?). A bag of holding will let you carry 3-5 extra load.

  • Another classic D&D problem, which is a little harder to solve, is that a long dungeon crawl is kind of about developing an effective standard procedure. Once the players have figured out how this dungeon tends to work, every encounter is addressed by applying the same set of problem solving tools. I don't want to play the gotcha-punishment game where I'm killing their characters because they forgot to say "I look at the ceiling" the one time an ooze was up there. Because then the game just becomes this repetitive grind of them describing how they search a wall or door over and over again.

Overall, we're loving Five Torches Deep! It took some adjustment for the people who have only known 4e and 5e, and are used to very detailed rules with lots of room for build+equipment theorycrafting. A few players mentioned that it felt very sparse, with very few options... but grew to appreciate the vibe that your character is not so much based on stats & abilities as it's based on your RP and treasure.

Every few sessions I ask, "Are these rules working well? anything you want to change?" and everybody has given me the thumbs up. Our group has a mix of people that have been playing D&D for 20 years and 3 years. And they love a challenge - in 5e, they tend to play very survivable, optimized characters. They are thrilled by the game's high lethality and challenge.


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Jan 25 '23

Solace of Stone - Cover (draft)

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Jun 18 '22

Ready to play 5TD. Just need pizza and people.

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 09 '22

Homebrew Slightly expanded armor options that I plan on using

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/FiveTorchesDeep • • Oct 12 '21

Resource NEW FTD Kickstarter: Highfane Peaks!

24 Upvotes

" Highfane Peaks is a setting toolkit designed to help you build evocative adventures in a mythological mountain range

  • A 70+ page setting guide for Five Torches Deep

  • Detailed mountaineering rules

  • New lineages, classes, spells, monsters, and equipment

  • Guidelines on adventuring in an arcanely-drenched mountain range

  • High concept: what if dungeons were on mountain peaks instead of underground?

Five Torches Deep: Highfane Peaks is a compact compendium of rugged climbs and ancient magic. Here's a quick summary of its key elements:

Old-school plus 5e. Highfane Peaks is built for Five Torches Deep, the best selling OSR minded 5e hack. As such it works with just about any fantasy adventure game that uses a d20. While there are a few widgets that specifically cater to FTD, the majority of the book is a collection of tools and tables to help create adventures in a sorcerous mountain range. 

A setting of aberrant temples carved atop magically-birthed mountains. A long-dead progenitor people known as the Shapers created the eponymous range at the edge of the world. Some say that these peaks are where all life began; others that it is a foul place haunted by the sins of careless mages. Dig into dozens of pages of spells, monsters, loot, adventure hooks, and people in our typical concise style all designed to fit within an evocative setting.

New rules for mountain-based adventures. New lineages, classes, equipment, and subsystems to make ascents feel like a hazardous trial of mountaineering rather than a quick montage of exposition. Play as the bizarre clayfolk constructs left behind by the Shapers, tame an infamously agile rockgoat to be your loyal steed, and try to avoid being conscripted into the ghost armies of the aurorawyrms that rule the night skies.  "

...more on the Kickstarter page:

http://kck.st/3BzrnHH

I'm stoked for this. I've got a hexcrawl going and the PC's are still in the hills. I love the idea of making the Mountains a mythic place.

...and what's an advanced class? Squee!


r/FiveTorchesDeep • • May 07 '21

Today is the two year anniversary of the original Five Torches Deep Kickstarter! All products 50% off!

24 Upvotes