r/FateTheGame
•
u/travisbaldree
•
Oct 17 '24
Some quick notes from the guy who made the original game.
Hi, I'm Travis. I was the sole engineer and designer of the original Fate (also did some art, sound, and animation on it).
Am I going to regret this? Probably.
Do I benefit in any way? No.
But it still bothers me enough that I apparently can't help myself.
Just out of idle curiosity I downloaded the demo. IMHO from a purely gameplay perspective (and often a visual perspective) this is a big step back from the original. I don't mean that in a sour-grapes way, and I don't have anything against remasters. It vexes me how many ways this is a step backward for something touted as an improvement.
Part of me wrestles with making this list. Why am I offering a list of ways to improve this when I don't have control of the IP I made, and will never benefit from it, and can only watch it get tortured into new shapes by people who don't really care about it? I guess I don't know. Maybe I'm just salty that the work that went into these elements will disappear down the line in favor of a remaster.
Anyway, just from playing 5 minutes, here's a list of stuff that really should be fixed at a basic level.
This is an alpha, but I would expect these things to be in place in an alpha, especially given that the original game still exists.
The original game is nearly 20 years old and could be improved in a multitude of ways. It's hardly some perfect artifact, and is absolutely riddled with flaws - but I made it in like two or three months, TOTAL. I'm sure this remaster will have been in development for far, far longer than the original game.
It's rough to see a bunch of egregious new flaws introduced.
Again, this is 5 minutes of play. I could create a much more exhaustive list with time - but I don't have the time, and it probably doesn't matter anyway.
CONTROLS
* Player orientation doesn't tween between directions, so it snaps when you path in a new way. Looks janky.
* Pathing is a big step backward from a technical standpoint. Object avoidance is poor, and presumably objects are not writing to the obstruction map dynamically, and repathing is not happening when the obstruction map is changed, because there's a lot of sliding around/getting stuck on things. Try to walk between the vendor near the large building toward the gate and the crates beside him and see what happens. You constantly slide-walk beside a target you approach and any other minor obstructions
*Clicking a single time on an object does not approach and attack. You have to attack again once you arrive. It has no target memory.
*Breakable objects do not highlight - which in combination with no click-memory, makes it a pain in the butt to break stuff.
*Holding the mouse button down when a target dies does not automatically reacquire a new target if it is under the mouse.
*MOST EGREGIOUSLY - Holding the mouse button down on a target should LOCK THE TARGET - moving your mouse off the target should not lose it until the LMB is released. This is awful.
GAMEPLAY
*Swing animations are not varied and don't have an early breakout for reattack, which makes them feel sluggish to boot.
*No Fog of War
*Door animations are far too slow
*Monsters are also terrible at pathing and get stuck on things
*Attack ranges are weird - sometimes excessively far
*Item flips from drops are really blah and unsatisfying
*Pet teleports around weirdly
*Enemy AI is a downgrade - they flee forever
*Character runs slower. Feels sluggish.
GRAPHICS
*Floors are no longer multi-textured heightfields. This makes them incredibly monotonous. Fate had a system which splatted multiple texture blends for more organic and varied floors. This is a big step back visually.
*PBR materials are over the top and too shiny/plasticky - not harmonious with texture style
*Water actually manages to look worse
*Breakable animations are limp and unsatisfying
*walk animation is super weird and awkward
*Wall tiles don't have their normals joined across seams so they light badly
*Gels have pretty unattractive faux-reflections
*Shadow projector is set too high so chandeliers project
SOUND
*No footstep sounds
*No swing sounds
*Ambient sounds mostly missing?
*Music is all stacked up and strange
INTERFACE
*Being unable to play with one half-pane open is a big step back.
*Overall the new interface art is pretty characterless. That's subjective, but -
*Characters don't highlight when you mouse over them so it's hard to track targets
*No indicators when characters are behind objects
*You can't rotate or zoom the camera any more - which is even more important when you can't see behind-wall indicators
*Health bars over the characters in scene are redundant and cluttery.
*Can't shift-click to have your pet pick up things
*Why remove all the hotbar slots?
*No hotkey mapping for spells?
Anyway, to sum up, the original just feels vastly superior to play. I realize how that sounds coming from the guy who made it, but most of these are objective functional observations that have to do with how straightforward it is to accomplish the things you want with appropriate feedback and satisfying motion and combat. I don't think they're particularly arguable.
le sigh!