r/DestructiveReaders • • 9d ago

Science fiction with cyberpunk vibes [2925] LIM SEOK JIN

Hi, this is the first story I’m posting here.

Here are some of my critiques:

3181_how_to_make_a_hundred_thousand_dollars

2309_go_cry_to_your_money

1515_watching_the_comet_strike_them

2990_ethiopia

1832_leave_only_ash

1379_chapter_2_horror_urban_fantasy_paranormal

2900_gothic_horror_dark_paranormal_romance

2377_number_42

1095_bus_gods

2058_come_home_family_drama

2278_the_beacon_hotel_total_rewrite

2558_untitled_novel_chapter_1

 

Link to the file LIM_SEOK_JIN.pdf

The file is in PDF format, hosted on my own server, and proudly free-notarized by NotarizeMy.com (Code: NM-KH5Z9EZ3YDPKY285)

 

Any comments and/or criticism are welcome.

Thank you.

1 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/jcoupshosh 9d ago

Thanks for sharing your work!

My first impression is that you seem like a seasoned writer and you are quite familiar with this genre. It is quite action based giving clues to interiority but the interiority is not the priority which is I think what I would expect from this genre, tbh I am not that familiar yet with genre writing.

The beats seem well thought out, the flow works, the pace is also very consistent. Personally, I really like it when writers do not end dialogue with "he said", "she said". The tone/stylistic choices and emotion if clear and well thought out enough can do that, which it does here. It's quite clear who is speaking when so great job on that!

The writing is very tight and I do not feel I read any superfluous sentences! Great line about privacy and security. The utility knife tie ins are a nice detail.

The two separate streams of time or space is interesting but again I could not figure out their connection. I could not understand what it is he was trying to do, something related to memory perhaps? It is not clear to me what Mnemosyan's fourth level is or why certain things could happen there or couldn't. Why is the whole operation considered high risk? What is the risk?

Is he trying to break into the fourth level or is he already in it? He seems to know a lot about it but the second half of the story makes me think he is trying to breach it.

Something the Fourth Level will never be able to conceive. As a reader I do not feel that familiar with the Fourth Level so I can not tell why it would never be able to conceive something. Are these layers of this consciousness around which he is building a security system?

In the beginning, you note the apartment is filthy but when he enters it, the description does not indicate filth, maybe messy. The fact that you mention the apartment is filthy before Seok Jin has entered it means he has been here before?

He takes off his soft black leather gloves, folds them, and places them beside the briefcase. This can be a lot more particular and precise since Seok Jin is described as precise later on.

Make up in improbable colors. This is more telling than it is showing, sounds vague.

It seems like Seok Jin can feel the girl, that her body is real but when you mentioned the glitch, it became confusing for me.

A beam of tart pear mustard - What this is referring to

If you had not told me Seok Jin is 51, I would not be able to guess from the story that he was older. I wonder if that detail is important. Does anything happen to the three armed guards standing behind him in the beginning of the story? Are they there throughout the whole thing?

I hope this isn't too much! your writing is skilled. It is the plot that confuses me :)

1

u/mianaai_c 7d ago edited 7d ago

The main issue with this piece is lack of clarity. On my first read I didn't understand what happened, what were the stakes, what were the character's end goals. On the second read, I remain confused. Maybe I'm dense. Alas, I will focus on the places where you trickle information and fail to build coherence.

The more I reread this piece, the less I feel I understand.

The omission of dialogue quotations is something I also like to do a lot, even through I need someone to slap my hand and tell me it doesn't work, it doesn't add the desired feeling of uninterrupted flow, but only adds to the confusion.


I'm left stumped at the choice of verb at the beginning: "afford". You are trying to build a juxtaposition, he is excited for this meeting in a run-down apartment, which is congruent with him going to a sex worker once a month. On the first read, it was a good hook; you manage to raise a lot of question in a small space. On subsequent reads it became frustrating, as these questions were not answered. I still don't know what this "Mnemosyan's Fourth Level" is, other that it seems to have a function in security detail?

She knows the owner of the house personally.

Is the woman in these excerpts Samina or someone else? In any case, who is the owner of the house? Not Lim, surely, since he arrives at the run-down apartment with full security and all that.

she works as a runner, but she isn't fast enough.

What is a runner, in this context?

What does "85%" danger level mean? What is it a probability of? Of something bad happening? Of him dying? Of the knife having been placed there with malicious intent? What I'm getting at is that this paragraph does not tell me anything. Okay, the two guys inspecting will be fired for having missed the knife, fair enough. "Won't ruin his day or month" is an odd enumeration. If this mishap or whatever it is, security breach, won't ruin his day, then it's implied that it won't ruin his month. It's like me saying I don't have 3 apples and I don't even have 100 apples. The second one is redundant.

The system he wanted and built is telling him he has been surpassed. He can afford that, too. Especially now that it's too late.

What is the nature and purpose of this system? What is Lin's relationship with it? He seems fine with "the system" going on without him in the loop. There is the same problem here, you don't give me enough concrete information to understand anything.

Every individual is called upon to fulfill their duty to the very end.

This and phrases like it keep telling me that the girl was hired to do "something". What? I've no clue. If you keep gesturing vaguely at this something without giving additional information to build up to a coherent thing, you are not building mystery.

The girl's gaze on his body is a pleasure that no longer touches him

You want to say here that he's indifferent of being admired? Because of old age and responsibilities and all that? But, why would the girl's gaze be a pleasure? I mean, I don't see her admiring him or looking at this old man who hired her to use her body with anything other than contempt, disgust, or, in the best case scenario, indifference.

When she reaches the fourth display case, she always has to make an effort not to pick up the doll in the blue lace dress right away.

Why?


I'm trying to reconstruct the plot as best I can.

Lim goes to an apartment, where he meets with a sex worker/something more than a sex worker. Before that, he sends people to secure the apartment. He seems like a big-shot corpo/government guy. He finds a knife, a breach in security. He decides to continue, despite the warnings of his system (?), because he is cocky.

Then there's the parallel plot of the girl examining the objects. My best guess at what's happening is that this guy, Lim, is using the girl to experience some emotions, renewed by the fact that she sees the dolls for the first time. I guess they connect their neurolinks up (or some other cyberpunk-esque jargon), and he uses her mind to percieve for the first time some items precious to him.

And, in the end, while he indulges himself so, someone takes the opportunity to "hack" him. And the moral of the story is that humans are the weakest point in any cybersecurity system, a well known fact in real life. Am I close? Also, what is that he is doing by pressing the buttons in the molars? It's okay, you can tell me.

It is not clear to me whether the two interwoven plot lines are different perspective of the same scene or whole different scenes. If yes, there is a contradiction in the ownership of the apartment/house, in his perspective, it is the woman's house (where she lives with her boyfriend or where at least the boyfriend visits), while in her perspective, the man is explicitly the owner.


There is a trope in writing, the "as you know, bob" type of exposition; this is where two characters who both know something explain that thing to one another for the benefit of the reader. It's a trope to be avoided. I bring this up because in this story, I see the opposite problem. The two talk about this job and this process they are doing, and the dialogue is believable as far as I can tell, but I as the reader am not clued in. I am a witness to things happening and I have no context to understand their importance, the stakes, and even what changed at the end of the story. In other words, there is too little exposition, or clear exposition.

But, if I am right in my interpretation of the plot, there is the seed of a good story here. There is the titular character that has agency, he is cocky, he is important but he indulges in pleasure (he "affords" to) which end up being his undoing. There is the girl, a mercenary selling her body and mind. There is a theme worth exploring here, how the powerful can in the present world buy the use of bodies of desperate people, what if in the future they can also buy the use of their minds?

But, you need to put more meat on the story. What is exactly the nature of Lim's indulgence? Reliving a memory from the past? What is the nature of that memory? A lost child, or memories when he himself was a child. The specifics of the episode/memory he wants to relive doesn't necessarily need to be unique, but it does need to be clear by the end of the story. The crux of the story is how he is reliving the episode, not its contents, and the cost he ends up paying. Also, what is his job? Why does it matter if he is "compromised"?

What is "Mnemosyan's Fourth Level"??

Overall, this felt like a puzzle that I failed to solve.

Anyways, thanks for sharing.

2

u/St3fanoFabbri 7d ago

Thank you so much for your feedback. I'm flattered that you took the time to read the story several times, making a genuine effort to understand and decipher it.

Your interpretation of the plot is correct.

I take the sense of urgency and passion I detect beneath the surface of your comments as a huge compliment.

You're right to have questions, since the text doesn't provide enough information to draw many conclusions, and I agree that too much is left out. I'll keep that in mind as I work on the rewrite.

1

u/Opposite_Chain_1362 2d ago

Great analysis

1

u/sketch165 8d ago

Hi there! Just some opening thoughts:

So, a lot of world-info isn't recoverable from this text. I cannot find out what Fourth Level is - I can only see what Lim thinks about, perhaps infer feeling, and guess at the environment. This seems more or less the right thing to do, if my interpretation of your work is correct. I don't think the reader is meant to understand the world, so much as 'feel' or 'live' along with Lim and his distorted narration; to kind of inhabit him. I love that!

So, it seems to be a story that enters into a slice of Lim's life. What do we find in this slice? The narration is unreliable, in the sense that I can only see what Lim sees, essentially. So, the focus is more on his subjective experience, as opposed to an external report of events in chronological order. What to find in this? Well, we see a man who thinks in terms of systems, rules, achievements, and events; he either doesn't acknowledge his state as a human with a messy array of feelings and a history, or he systematizes it. At his heart, he wants to be seen. Probably because of a childhood spent in isolation (I assume the utility knife belonged to his father, who he recollects in his flashback as just walking by), where he could only connect with objects, feeling estranged from - and, in the future, estranging himself from - the social, messy, unordered, sometimes-warm-sometimes-painful aspects of life. 

He tries to make technology that allows him to access this part, to connect with people in a safe way, although - and he probably doesn't believe it himself, at least not fully - people are supposedly unable to connect because of the immense distance between them. 

I liked this one:

His childhood and being are found in the stones and drawings Samia can't understand and dismisses as useless, something Lim doesn't care about; but, the object he displaced his need for an attachment is what Samia finds intriguing, and which she thinks he cares about. That's pretty much his philosophy getting enacted in real time. 

Overall, I think it's a great character study! The choice not to give information forces me to live with him and think in his terms. The prose is clipped and dialogue is entirely reported, which fits his experience: people are distant and can only hear reports; he thinks in term of what can be controlled and done, so short statements better choices than long and lyrical. Lim is believable as a felt state of being, but not entirely as a person. That's your choice to make. Samia is hollow, which is appropriate. My critiques:

  1. "That is our limit and our fate as human beings." I get that it's probably him repeating a mantra to convince himself. So, it's appropriate - but, we could already recover this as his worldview without it; as it stands, right here, on the page, reading it, it looks like you announcing your story's idea, which somewhat weakens the prior craft (showing me what he attends to and allowing me to infer). Lim can experience it, absolutely, but the reader doesn't need to hear it. It can be appropriate in the fictional world, but inappropriate when you translate that to the page. 

  2. The ending lines seem quite vague; they leave an effect, not a discursive message. Your choice about that.

  3. "The message SYSTEM COMPROMISED...," seems ungrammatical. Think of changing to:

The message, 'SYSTEM COMPROMISED,'...

Or you can report his direct experience by cutting, "The message," and just allocating the whole line to the actual message and maybe try something with alignment. Maybe like so:

Across his on-retina:

SYSTEM COMPROMISED

Or anything you like, but it seems ungrammatical right now, which disrupts my experience of Lim's interior world because I become aware that I'm reading a text

4. Some of the more explicit descriptions of the clothes on Samia, or lack thereof, and how the two relate seem odd. For this story, I treat this as Lim's attention  dwelling on her, which seems at odds with the kind of person who's been established so far. I'd think, based on how I understand it, that he may not like to consciously dwell like that. Maybe just give it a line and leave it? 

Overall, fantastic work though! Sorry if I misunderstood the work.