r/DelphiDocs • u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator • Oct 24 '24
🏛️ TRIAL RA Trial Day 6 24th Oct Part 3
‼️‼️Please watch Bob's live from about 1.05, describing the "stabilised" video‼️‼️ ✨️Defense Diaries live https://www.youtube.com/live/JndLLL7kius?si=Ub9uEAq-npHmd42M
And then, can someone please explain to me how TF are we supposed to believe that this "stabilising" and "enhancing" can fill in the parts of the video where the camera was pointing down, show the Blob G that was invisible at the other end of the bridge in the original video, now right behind them, and Abby saying "is he behind me? Don't leave me here! Could that be a gun?" where there was no audio before.
Note: apparently people in court didn't actually hear any of that despite Leggit telling them it's there, but they did see BG only 60ft behind them now. I guess they forgot to make his mouth move, based on what defense said about it?
Anyway, Ligget followed this masterpiece up by completely tanking his credibility, so that's nice.
🔸️🔸️🔸️
Today's Updates
✨️Andrea Burkhart live 24th October https://www.youtube.com/live/PF774_N0ycs?si=CUiZ3eHvyRCqNxmG
Transcript https://files.catbox.moe/di0hve.txt
✨️Defense Diaries live (go to 1:10:00 mark to hear about the "stabilised" video with "mention of a gun) 24th October https://www.youtube.com/live/JndLLL7kius?si=nytZKoETqhX1UeXo
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/ge261a.txt
Explanation of the video: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/H4VesIAxEH
✨️Lawyer Lee live 24th October https://www.youtube.com/live/B013KmgU764?si=6SPNoZ7OHsOGYbP8
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/gp1l2h.txt
✨️CriminaliTy Live 24th October https://www.youtube.com/live/hwotG4GattA?si=9ifyoNBtqCNp42B3
https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Ri93JPb15k
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️WishTV Day 6 Live Blog https://www.wishtv.com/news/crime-watch-8/delphi-murders/delphi-murders-trial-day-6/
✨️Dave Bangert Day 6 https://www.basedinlafayette.com/p/steady-turnout-greets-lone-day-of#%C2%A7delphi-murders-trial-day-update
✨️Delphicase Day 6 https://delphicase.com/article/trial-watch-day-6
🔸️🔸️🔸️
Afternoon
✨️Max Lewis (I'll add the screenshots in a thread tomorrow) https://x.com/MaxLewisTV/status/1849619045990998242?t=Sk4nlvtPpcsVt6SPK9XN2g&s=19
✨️Carrol County Comet https://www.carrollcountycomet.com/articles/attention-to-detail/
✨️Kyla Russell https://x.com/KylaBRussell/status/1849632287895249163?t=vWttZtBGg5Pei5R8a_lnUw&s=19
✨️WishTV https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/lYlj5ddN1a
✨️CJHoytNews Ligget testimony https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/W8K6dlLVWH
✨️CriminaliTy Live https://www.youtube.com/live/hwotG4GattA?si=9ifyoNBtqCNp42B3
✨️Barbara MacDonald https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/VdKDhCZOxT
✨️ Fox 59 https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/zFlvuhcQxo
✨️Fox59 - Mullin on the stand https://fox59.com/delphi-trial/delphi-murders-misfiled-report-from-2017-put-allen-in-investigators-sights-in-2022/
✨️Jurors asking the real questions https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/XLnKtJTEhY
✨️Yellow bearing facts https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/3KVKUD8a0d
🔸️🔸️🔸️
‼️If you are unfamiliar with Dan Dulin other than his involvement with the lost tip here, you need to watch this. RIP Jesse Snider.
https://youtu.be/TBc0Al05ay8?si=sclF4VlELsFNGHG8
Moth Live https://x.com/RMproductionsX/status/1849511194341802041?t=lpIqw9dXFjC3CXPwuLmvZw&s=19
AllEyesOnDelphi- Dan Dulin at it again https://www.youtube.com/live/xIOpA_Yw4Hs?si=I7x-GWF6RejGlPkQ
🔸️🔸️🔸️ Mid morning
✨️Donnie Burgess https://wibc.com/479962/from-cleared-to-charged-delphi-trial-day-six-so-far/
✨️Kyla Russell https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/GilblvE1Ql
✨️Dulin, Rozzi cross https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/kkCTtFzsT9
✨️Alli Motta live with Bob's notes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCjj7Z7YxDk
✨️Russ McQuaid via CJHoytNews https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/PA0xKugcw4
✨️ Bob Motta https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/zuLW6BX9nA
✨️Moth upcoming LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/08I6lgcmCiM?si=q_6VkYUNuJtST_7r
✨️Dulin meet-up map https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/KbrrEAzYjY
Pre-Court
✨️Useful timeline info: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/85t2HnY7Pr
✨️Dave Bangert https://www.basedinlafayette.com/p/delphi-murder-trial-day-5-autopsy?r=2fe&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
✨️Michelle After Dark https://youtu.be/ASPCo-tAd40?si=0znwCWbezpJnLcuU
✨️cbsnews https://www.cbsnews.com/news/delphi-murders-richard-allen-trial/
Yesterday's Recaps
•
✨️Links to yesterday's lives with day's recaps and transcripts
https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/WDdmrri0DQ
✨️ Evening update https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/KNMOzMySPM
Afternoon
• ✨️wthr https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/JO6Hb6Uu5a
✨️wibc, Kohr and Carbaugh testimony https://wibc.com/479139/the-autopsy-another-bridge-guy-witness-whats-happened-so-far-in-delphi-day-five/
✨️Russ McQuaid via CJHoytNews https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/0Lj8MQCjUQ
✨️Fox59 https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/xMjfsnjO3Y
✨️Defense Diaries updates: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/id5W4oOon9 https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/dotgekLbas
✨️Dave Bangert updates: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/GTHHNFhZII https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/88JWf5xalI
✨️WishTV Day 5 blog https://www.wishtv.com/news/delphi-murders-trial-day-5-live-blog/
🔸️🔸️🔸️
Community resources:
✨️JURY QUESTIONS https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/157St-gd9pac0CGyuK4SiDtVFcKs6ZAxH0RrYGDUimFs/mobilebasic
✨️WITNESS LIST https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1WZBEbkHfBHcvHAB838QQYxeRnh2lFDYRUWz8PqGa_ig/htmlview
✨️MEDIA MATRIX https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/bGj2A6zxbk
✨️CS SKETCHES https://www.reddit.com/u/Alan_Prickman/s/IhBjwDMJpp
✨️INVESTIGATION DROPPED BALLS https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/yDJZPspNKc
🔸️🔸️🔸️
💜Please let us all remember at all times why we are here - the girls, their mothers and everyone else who loved them, and all innocent parties to this case. Justice is only justice if served r the person or persons that perpetrated this crime, and to achieve this, it should be pursued with full transparency and open to public scrutiny. Let's all do whatever little we can to help achieve this.
The dead speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard. speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard.💙
18
18
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 24 '24
I had to step away this afternoon, and the fishing license thing was making me crazy anyway. Was wondering if I was going to come back to actual confession bombshells. Seems like no? Maybe tomorrow, or is Friday the no court day?
12
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 25 '24
There's court even on Saturdays, although only from 9-12. Confessions might be coming in tomorrow, and the bullet examiner.
70
u/CJHoytNews Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
Today on the stand, the State asked Liggett about watching and listening to the video. Liggett says he heard Libby say, "that be a gun." The defense objected and asked for that to be stricken, which Judge Gull granted. As far as I can tell, this is the only mention by any witness that the word "gun" is heard on the video. The video was played in court and the audio technician who testified about it never said anything about a gun (nor was he asked). So why did Liggett mention it? Well... it was an important part of the Probable Cause Affidavit that he filed where he wrote, "As the male subject approaches Victim 1 and Victim 2, one of the victims mentions, "gun."
Did I miss a report from any other people in the courtroom that they heard "gun" from Libby on the video?
8
u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 25 '24
"that be a gun" Excuse me. I'm sorry. I don't care how country you are, you don't say "that be a gun" when you see a gun unless you're in a comedy movie (disclaimer haven't watched whatever source you are referencing yet)
8
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 25 '24
Bob reports the claim is "could that be a gun"
But guys
They filled in the bits when camera was pointing down at the bridge, and now BG is right behind them, less than 60ft, Abby is begging Libby not to leave her, wants to know if he's still behind her, and there is a gun
55
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
No you did not. It was never heard by ANYONE. Thank you CJ. That is unreal
65
u/FreshProblem Oct 24 '24
Murder sheet, they heard exactly what was in the PCA somehow, imagine that.
No one else.
30
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
lol when they got called in by the publisher to announce their points are now such they will be paying the publisher
24
6
u/Early-Theory7620 Oct 24 '24
Why are the Murder Sheet folks so pro-prosecution? I have listened to them for years, but their bias is really starting to show and it gets in the way of getting the facts.
15
9
u/somethingdumbber Oct 25 '24
Why are we talking about Mr. Bigot? Oh that’s right because he’s part of the same clique that loves Norse runes and the number 88.
11
0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
→ More replies (4)29
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
Indeed. Before ANY of this happened I watched the debate, then listened to the extended thing, and 100% I knew there would be an arrest before the election or Liggett was going to lose.
→ More replies (9)17
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 24 '24
I saw BC say that at the time - I didn't know her yet then - and I thought "if she is right, then everything I ever believed about this case is just RONG"
Everything I believed about the case at that point was wrong.
→ More replies (1)0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
11
u/i-love-elephants Oct 25 '24
Go back further to the Kk times. They just so happened to be looking at the docket for the 2 minutes that some KK document was uploaded and they grabbed it before it was taken down.
→ More replies (2)
10
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 24 '24
13
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
7
u/Complete-Signal6266 Oct 24 '24
can you ELI5 why this is a problem?
14
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
Sorry no I cannot. I can direct you to the docket to review.
There was a dispute over property which includes the security system and CCTV during the time in question
→ More replies (2)0
26
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
Andrea didn't act like the height thing on the fishing license was anything at all. Good.
17
u/Secret-Constant-7301 Oct 25 '24
How do we message mods for a mega thread for Andrea’s reporting every night?
20
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 25 '24
You send a modmail to ask mods about stuff like that, but the answer is going to be no I'm afraid. We are not allowing new threads except for legal filings and a very occasional exception like the line sitters call on any day the court is in session. Moderating any additional threads in addition to the already exceptional traffic is simply beyond the capacity of the moderating team.
10
u/Lindita4 Oct 25 '24
Also it takes away from her views and interaction on YouTube which reduces her income. We don’t want to do that to her..
8
12
u/i-love-elephants Oct 25 '24
The mods are doing a lot with the 3 daily threads already. I think the best we can hope for is a pinned comment.
→ More replies (1)16
u/LearnedFromNancyDrew Oct 25 '24
It really isn’t in my opinion. I have fudged my weight soooo many times!
20
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
For men it’s height, for women it’s weight. And possibly age.
As I said earlier, I myself am 28, and 125lbs.
→ More replies (2)14
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
Confession: The last time I tried to fudge my weight at the DMV the lady gave me the "be real" look.
11
u/ZekeRawlins Oct 25 '24
I’m still confused on the “lost” tip.
24
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
You mean how his (cleared) file was magically found around the time of the election?
13
12
u/ZekeRawlins Oct 25 '24
The information should have already been in Orion. A file would have been automatically created when the tip came in and it would have stayed open until someone closed it. The story doesn’t track.
0
38
u/bferg3 Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24
watching bob live they literally lied about Rick travelling west. He was asked how he gets to the trails and Rick said he typically goes through the city heading east. Mullins asked again and rick said he typically goes east. Mullins asked is it possible you could have taken the country road and Rick says "it's possible". They turned that into he was traveling west at the time arriving instead of leaving.
ETA: Rick also said in this interview it was possible he was driving his Gray. 2006 Ford Five Hundred.
Rick went to his mom's this morning, grabbed a jacket at his house and went to the bridge. Pretty normal thing to kill two girls after going to your moms
36
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
I'm running out of ways to say wtf.. so I'm going to stick with wtf
12
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
I would say maybe try a different font, but...🤷🏻♀️
14
20
52
u/FreshProblem Oct 24 '24
Imagine being on the jury and presumably hearing for the first time mistake after mistake after mistake made in the investigation.
36
u/LGIChick Criminologist Oct 24 '24
I just completed reading today’s news articles, the major three reporting in this case, and I have to say, today takes the cake. Not only is the reporting in some parts incomprehensible, they also left out 4 major points about what happened today.
To me, these points are so important, I decided to share those here.
A big shocker supposedly happened in court today. Dulin stated that RA had changed his height in April 2017 (!) from 5’4 to 5’6 on his fishing license.
Let me start off by saying that I’m not even sure what the bombshell would be, because if anything, law enforcement was looking for an average build, possibly 5’10. If anything, being as short as 5’4 was a big advantage, because at the time, that pretty much excluded you from being “BG”.
Regardless, we found out that Dulin’s statement on direct was very misleading and it actually got cleared up on cross.
Rozzi asked if there were several references on previous licenses to Allen being 5’6”. Dulan said, “Yes.”
No, he did NOT suddenly change his height in 2017.
2) many people have insinuated that RA had called the tip line in 2017 to basically take the wind out of their sails in case someone had seen him and/or to insert himself into the investigation, BEFORE the picture of “BG” got released. Further speculating what a dumb move this was by RA, because back then he had no idea he had been caught on Libby’s video.
The following timeline we learned in court today:
2/13: murders of Abby and Libby
2/14: bodies are found
2/15: picture of BG is released
2/16: RA calls the tip line
2/18: RA is interviewed by Dulin
RA called the tip line AFTER the picture of BG had been released. In fact, it looks like he had 3 days to either come up with a better story or decide to not say anything at all to Dulin.
He volunteered his information at a time, when half the state was looking for “BG”.
3) law enforcement received over 50,000 tips in regard to this case.
The only tip about RA came from RA himself. No one in the town of Delphi for several years, even thought it could be RA.
Instead, he called himself in and met with Dulin.
Dulin obviously didn’t recognize or even assume RA could be BG when face to face, although that picture had already been released. RA didn’t hesitate to give information as to the fact he had been there, his clothing, where he had parked and who he had seen on the trails that day. In fact, he even gave Dulin his cell phone.
4) one very important statement was made in court today that got mostly swept under the rug.
RA’s own tip from 2017 that was taken in, processed, filed and in big, fat, green letters had “CLEARED” written on it, caused havoc in 2022.
Law enforcement immediately knew “this had to be the guy”, because it stated that “RA had seen those 3 girls”. They could “never identify the man that the 3 girls had seen” and they “were sure this man was BG”.
There’s a pretty big problem with this. In fact, that problem is twofold.
For starters, none of these “3 girls” could even remotely describe RA.
The real big problem is though, that they can’t establish that “the 3 girls that saw BG” are “the 3 girls that RA had seen”.
Why? Because “3 girls” were indeed 4.
Today’s very important statement that got mostly swept under the rug, was Dulin saying that RA mentioned “seeing 3 girls. One was older, like she was babysitting the other two”.
I had always speculated that RA was simply asked in 2017 whether he had seen “3 girls” because LE knew at the time they could be very important witnesses. And RA simply answered, yeah I saw those 3 girls. If he hadn’t paid attention to them, but knew he passed a group at some point, and that’s all he saw, giving this answer to a specific question, would make a lot sense.
Later on, LE finds out the girls in question weren’t a group of THREE, but rather FOUR girls. So what, right? The tip is filed away, doesn’t seem like there’s any significance to it.
But NOW there is. It’s very significant actually. RA did pay enough attention to have said on 2/18 that he saw 3 girls, one being older and seemingly babysitting the other two. He did establish there were only 3 girls by themselves. It doesn’t sound like he was speculating or that he was led on by a suggestive question.
So who did RA see that day? And who was the man that the FOUR girls saw, that was much taller, younger and wore the BG clothing?
22
u/LearnedFromNancyDrew Oct 25 '24
I found the 3 girls with one described as babysitting the other two very interesting. He was observant enough to note that one was older. Who are they?
0
Oct 25 '24
[deleted]
10
u/LGIChick Criminologist Oct 25 '24
I believe three of them were around 16 years old (they were Kelsi’s friends) and the 4th girl in question, was the sister (?) of one of those. For some reason I wanna say she was younger. Don’t quote me on that though…
9
u/FreshProblem Oct 25 '24
One of them was definitely a younger sister, and tbf in a group of young teens like that you could easily have 1 that looks much older than another even at the same age, so I'm not sure it means that much either way.
→ More replies (4)
33
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 25 '24
Mitch Westermans charges were dropped today.
FYI
Trial giving me Deja Vu.
31
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
NM objected to Baldwin reading from the transcript - sustained
NM objected to Baldwin not reading from the transcript - sustained
listening to andrea. This was when baldwin was crossing Mullins on the route RA took driving to the trail
27
u/scottie38 Oct 25 '24
I let out a FFS when she shared that.
No wonder they didn’t want this televised! It’s not a good look for anyone! Not the prosecution, not law enforcement, and it is crystal clear not the judge. What an embarrassment for the criminal justice system.
18
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
I hope the jury sees it for what it is
20
Oct 25 '24
Andrea suggested that the jury may have heard Gull yell at and scorn the public members right before lunch break. I feel the state has lost the jury...
→ More replies (1)14
u/scottie38 Oct 25 '24
Me too. I’m tempering my expectations, though.
One thing I think we can say is that the defense team is serving RA well.
17
u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 25 '24
They can do something about this right??? She very clearly is just taking it out on Baldwin and Rozzi. I don't remember the supreme court reinstating them and being like "ok it's fine to take out ur revenge now"
10
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
Been asking myself that for like a year and half. I guess nothing unless it goes up on appeal after a conviction.
13
u/dogkothog Oct 25 '24
Every jurisdiction is different. But these objections are made all the time. In my jurisdiction you are not allowed to read into the record or even suggest a prior deposition. But you are allowed to impeach with it. For example:
At Deposition:
Q: When you went into the intersection, what color was the stop light.
A: It was red.
At trial:
Q: When you went into that intersection, what color was the traffic light?
A; It was yellow.
At this stage you would pull out the deposition (dramatically of course) and say something like:
Sir, isn't it true that on xx/yy/zz you were deposed?
A: Yes.
Q: And I was there, you were there, there was a court reporter there?
A: Yes.
And on that day, you swore an oath to tell the truth, didn't you.
A: Yes.
(You hand them the transcript)
I'm directing you to page 68, do you see that. (yes)
On that day I asked you the following question: (dramatically read deposition question)
And then you get the choice of having them read the answer, or reading it yourself (and 99/100 times you will read it yourself and do so dramatically)
Finishing the example above... you would say "And when I asked you that same question on xx/yy/zz you admitted it was red.... didn't you).
*
I don't know what Indiana's procedure is on this-- I would assume Baldwin and Rozzi know this better than I do. But I thought the questions were fairly loose if identified accurately by Andrea Burkhart.
7
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
Thank you for that! Were you listening to Andrea when she went through the whole thing of what was said?
26
u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
25
u/skruffywuffy Oct 24 '24
Thank you for the video on Jesse Snider... don't know how Dan Dulin sleeps at night
9
u/LearnedFromNancyDrew Oct 24 '24
Yes! I could only watch that once. How that man and the rest of them still have jobs in LE just baffles me!
47
u/hossman3000 Oct 24 '24
How does LE not take possession of the Hoosier Harvestore video in 2017 and try to identify and track down every vehicle on the cam in the time frame in question. At a minimum, should be able to account for/eliminate vehicles from Carroll county. If they saw a dark colored small SUV, it wouldn't be that difficult to validate the 100 or so small dark SUVs in Carroll county.
33
Oct 24 '24
I feel like these questions keep getting asked ad nauseum. There's a problem in Carroll County...
32
u/Secret-Constant-7301 Oct 24 '24
There’s a problem in America. Police are just government sanctioned gangs. They aren’t even legally required to help or protect people.
20
Oct 24 '24
We had a self defense seminar at work many years ago led by a police officer. I’ll always remember him telling us that most cops are not good. There’s a few good ones but the majority are not. This was in downtown Indy. He wasn't with IMPD but worked for another city close to Indy.
→ More replies (1)24
u/ZekeRawlins Oct 24 '24
The feds had it.
23
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
And the new owners sued the old owners. Good Times at the Hearvestore
12
23
u/LGIChick Criminologist Oct 24 '24
I’m even wondering how they were able to obtain it after 5 years? Someone help me out…
Where was the video “stored” between 2017-2022? Who was in possession? Why did they keep it so long?
23
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
Carroll County Comet: report on newspaper's Facebook page: Jerry Holeman testified Rick Allen repeatedly said "It doesn't matter, it's over" when offered a form for reimbursement after his home was searched.
/CarrollComet/videos/518349494342466
36
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
His neighbors were taking pictures through their windows and calling media. He was right
0
23
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 24 '24
Maybe he just meant the search was over? And didn’t expect to get his stuff back?
3
0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
26
Oct 24 '24
Exactly. I mean, he said when he was interviewed that he was upset that this was going to affect his life no matter the outcome.
Hell, if he gets off, he’s gonna be treated like shit by most people. They will still call him a murderer and make his life hell if he stays near that town.
15
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
Surely. And that's what these forums are all about! 😊It will be interesting to hear how the other reports see it.
13
u/The2ndLocation Oct 24 '24
Omg, that was the first confession! Wonder why Assholeman didn't arrest him on the spot?
→ More replies (4)13
Oct 24 '24
Definitely. I’m sure people who live in Delphi know the cops are corrupt and have heard stories.
5
21
u/bferg3 Oct 25 '24
omfg liggett on the stand admitted that all 3 witnesses described someone that did not look like RA and Rozzi replied "Exactly"
You have to watch Andrea coverage of at least the Liggett/Rozzi its so good.
Witness are BB, the 4 girls and the last witness (can't remember her name)
39
u/maybeitsmaybelean Oct 24 '24
I'm curious if people in this sub will think twice about calling a tip line if it places them within the vicinity of the crime. I never would have thought talking to a conservation officer would require a lawyer, but here we are. And since notes get destroyed or lost + interviews taped over, can we record the interaction?
15
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
As crazy as this sounds being wrongfully imprisoned is one of my odd irrational fears. I'm a white female, so I'm among the least at risk of this, but I've never ever thought it was something that couldn't happen to me, to the point that I often use it as a gratitude exercise. Like when I'm having a garden-variety crappy day, I'll imagine it's my first day out of prison, even if I was only there for a short time, and how incredible this otherwise mundane cup of coffee would taste. The luxury of getting to shower by myself again and sleep alone in my comfortable bed at night and choose what I eat or watch on TV.
So, yeah, it's gonna be a real crossroads for me if I'm ever faced with this choice!
13
u/FreshProblem Oct 24 '24
I think it would be wise to think twice. But I think a normal impulse is still to want to help if you can.
23
u/Otherwise-Aardvark52 Oct 24 '24
I’m already in the “never talk to cops if you can help it” camp. I did have to call 911 once though - a few years ago an obviously mentally disabled woman who I’d seen on occasion in my neighborhood knocked on my door and told me she was being held captive in a home down the road and had escaped. I called 911, they talked to her on my porch and eventually had an ambulance take her away. The next day her sister (who it turned out she lived with) came over and explained that she lives in the house with her and a cousin and they care for her and she’s just disturbed. I saw her again a few other times but I think they moved not long after.
But on another occasion my mom was over and was pressuring me to call police about a neighbor who was acting erratically in his yard. But my thought was - he’s not doing anything illegal. It’s not against the law to rant and rave and act weird in your yard. Nothing good to come of calling police in that situation. Guy is a minority too. Worst case scenario someone gets shot. Haven’t seen any weird behavior from him since.
13
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
I get this. I am 100% on the side of don't talk to the cops.
I have had to call 911 a few times. My neighbor beats his wife. When I hear her screaming and the kids crying. Fuck it I am calling. I about needed counseling over it. They deescalated it the couple/few times I have called. Whatever, I guess, a very sad situation that I can't do much about other than call the police.→ More replies (1)14
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
I'd be getting stabbed in the face and I probably wont call the cops
24
u/The2ndLocation Oct 24 '24
I am serious if you need help just call the fire department they are brave and they almost never shoot anybody because they thought they were the fire.
→ More replies (1)10
14
0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
5
u/__brunt Oct 25 '24
Never, ever talk to the police unless you absolutely have to, and then do it with representation. It doesn’t matter what state or country you’re in. Period.
0
Oct 24 '24
[deleted]
12
u/mtbflatslc Oct 24 '24
Even PW (one of the third party suspects) went on at length talking about how corrupt local LE and politicians are in an interview last year. I think locals understand that there are two boogeyman’s in the area and to not get mixed up with either. Gang/drug associated criminals, and criminals moonlighting as businesspeople, LE, prosecutors, judges. Everyone else is just trying to get by.
19
u/scottie38 Oct 24 '24
I'm listening to Bob talk about Liggett testifying about this "stabilized" video the state showed. I don't even know what to think after hearing this. I am curious to see what Andrea says.
22
u/FreshProblem Oct 24 '24
If he was describing it accurately I'm kind of dumbfounded. I've never heard of video enhanced that way being admitted and it should kind of terrify anyone.
12
u/Secret-Constant-7301 Oct 25 '24
What’s going on with the video?
14
u/FreshProblem Oct 25 '24
He basically described a third version of the video (different from the original and the first enhancement they saw the other day) and in this version BG is... much clearer and much closer to them? Not "zoomed in" closer but actually closer? And suddenly there's brand new different audio in it (though he still couldn't hear anything about a gun).
I want to hear what others say about it, but I hope that since the defense didn't fight it tooth and nail that it means they have some other way to counter it later.
→ More replies (5)12
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 25 '24
It's wild to me these LE creative productions are admissible.
100 bucks says when it's all said and done the human words they added being spoken will just be the sound of wind and birds chirping barely audible in background.
18
u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 25 '24
Hi all,
Watching Andrea's live. Is there anything we can do about Gull?
Can we keep track of her rulings as a spreadsheet to show the inequity or something??
Aghfjf
12
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Hey now, I think she actually sustained one defense objection today. I’m not certain, but maybe.
10
u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
Question re Andrea's remarks this evening:
If people go out of the courtroom now, they may lose their seats completely? Or they may just have to sit in a different place? Can new people get into the courtroom, say after lunch?
18
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
I watched a bit of a Lawyer Lee video and she said she couldn’t get in on the morning session of some day (despite getting in line at 4:30am), but was able to get in after lunch. She described a chaotic scene of people who had to wait on the first floor (for hours) all running up the stairs to the third floor once they were allowed to try to get in after lunch.
Apparently Gull enjoys these mad max style shenanigans
10
14
u/Peri05 Oct 25 '24
I mean honestly people should just start shitting their pants in their seats at this point. If she wants to make ridiculous rules about leaving then why not ? Jesus Christ she’s from the pits of hell
→ More replies (1)13
u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 25 '24 edited Oct 25 '24
YES
this woman (gull) is made of spite. period.
Edit: My response was not clear. The line re-forms, so people may start lining up after court had started. Meaning spots can be lost.
10
10
u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
Thank you... so this means we have to have line savers ready for Andrea at every break, if she wants to eat and drink?
→ More replies (1)10
Oct 25 '24
sounds like a new line after each break and lunch now. Gull wants someone killed falling down those marble courthouse steps.
10
u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
This is really asking for problems and trouble IMHO. I can see the idea of wanting more people to be able to attend, but is there not a better way to do this?
ETA like broadcast the trial?
→ More replies (2)0
8
Oct 25 '24
Allen County can vote her out when it comes up. I have no idea when that is.
8
Oct 25 '24
Not enough people are aware of what she's doing to vote her out. They will see an ad about how she has 30 years of experience and vote for her.
→ More replies (1)
17
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Did the dumb thing and clicked on a post on another sub.
Someone, while explaining that RA is obviously guilty (except they say BG, heh): “one of the girls is heard on the video saying “is he still behind me?””
Did anything like this actually get presented in court along with the video?
19
Oct 25 '24
This was another manipulated video of the original video.
17
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Do they just keep running it through Adobe Premiere and show it every day until they get the results they want?
14
Oct 25 '24
Andrea even said the witness said when she zoomed in on BG. lmfao. After all that work to get the BG video we all saw.
9
6
u/nakedm0lerat Oct 25 '24
Yes, today
7
7
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
I’m looking around, can you tell me where you heard this? I’m surprised this audio portion isn’t being discussed here.
6
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Ok, I have apparently missed some updates, or people are only reporting via YouTube (which I can’t handle). Thanks!
12
u/nakedm0lerat Oct 25 '24
It’s annoying that we will probably never see the video and be able to work it out ourselves. I don’t really trust how every person there seems to hear something different
→ More replies (1)9
u/FreshProblem Oct 25 '24
You should give Andrea Burkhart's video recaps a try. Incredible level of detail, factual, easy to follow.
→ More replies (1)
16
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24 edited Oct 25 '24
Can’t do YouTube, I get sensory overload. I’m trying to find a mainstream (text) news source explaining this new “is he still behind me” audio, so far no luck. But I did want to share some WTHR headlines:
Sheriff admits Richard Allen doesn't match witness descriptions of 'bridge guy'
'I don't know' | Investigator describes unexplained gap in data from Libby's phone
13
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
I've not seen anything about "is he still behind me" audio. Im very interested in that. If I find a text I will let you know.
17
u/bferg3 Oct 25 '24
Tony ligget testified he heard that on the bridge guy video. Even though no one else has testified that and when they played the fullk video in court no one heard that
→ More replies (2)12
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Thanks—I’m hoping there wasn’t an actual bombshell and it caused everyone to go quiet and not acknowledge it. I’m obviously feeling a certain way about this case almost a week in, but I still want to know any actual verifiable facts, even if they’re facts that point a different way.
12
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
The state said that there is a way they can "stabalize" the video. That even if the camera is pointed straight down it can show things not in front of the camera. So they showed the BG video after "stabalzing it" It showed bridge guy a lot closer. One of the girls said something about a gun and you hear a gun rack. This is fucking me up.
8
u/LegalBeagleEsquire Oct 25 '24
According to Andrea Burkhart, Liggett said he listened to enhanced audio through headphones hundreds of times. This is his opinion of what he heard:
Abby says, "is he right here? don't leave me up here."
Libby says, "see this is the path."
Libby whispers, "that be a gun."
Libby's tone changes, "there is no path here. we have to go down here."
Man says, "guys"
Libby and Abby say, "hi"
Liggett hears a gun rack. (stricken from record)
Man says, "down the hill"
8
u/FreshProblem Oct 25 '24
7
u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 25 '24
Thanks, still doesn’t quite fit (and also why aren’t they showing the video instead of having people say what’s on the video?)
Carroll County Sheriff Tony Liggett testified about the process of enhancing the video on Libby’s phone. For example, Liggett said the video was “altered to be upright all the time.”
The prosecution showed the video to the jury again. Liggett described what he heard in the video:
Abby: “Is he right here? Don’t leave me up here.”
Libby: “This is the path, that be a gun, there’s no path here.”
”Bridge guy”: “Guys.”
Girls: “Hi.”
“Bridge guy”: “Down the hill.”
12
u/FreshProblem Oct 25 '24
They did show it + they let give his own color commentary because Gull is poison.
→ More replies (1)
32
u/Coldngrey Oct 25 '24
Quick observation: Nobody should ever want to meet with police at their home if given a choice.
People claiming that is a ‘red flag’ are silly.
25
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
They are the "Why do you care if you have nothing to hide" about warrantless wire taps people. They are stupid.
18
Oct 25 '24
“If he got arrested, he’s clearly guilty. The police wouldn’t arrest an innocent man” type shit.
→ More replies (1)
15
Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24
I pulled this gem out of some clever Google Searching for those who wanted an original reporting on the incident: (2/15/2017)
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4229606/Picture-person-released-Delphi-police.html
A few more:
https://fox59.com/news/police-expected-to-release-new-information-in-case-of-missing-carroll-county-teenagers/
https://cbs4indy.com/news/new-information-expected-in-case-of-missing-carroll-county-teenagers/
21
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
Oh watch that video 15 out of 19 in the gallery. Look at Mullin and Leazenby faces when Riley says the FBI is there.
0
14
u/Expert_University295 Oct 24 '24
Do we know when they are getting to the "confessions" and unspent bullet stuff?
22
u/rosiekeen Oct 24 '24
Holeman started it by saying Rick said “it doesn’t matter it’s over” twice during the execution of the warrant. I’m not sure if they’re counting it but definitely trying to get the jury to see it that way.
19
Oct 24 '24
I’m really wondering how if he confessed 60+ times, none of this was written or recorded in a clear way. At least not what we’ve seen so far. They all seem like you have to reach, assume, and fill in the blanks.
→ More replies (3)16
u/rosiekeen Oct 24 '24
They will have transcripts to phone calls I think. They should be coming in soon I’d think. But the only in writing one we saw looked… very different than his previous letter he had written to the court.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)10
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
I've seen multiple tweets on twitter trying to act like this is a big deal...or "bombshell" as they said.
12
u/rosiekeen Oct 24 '24
Yeah I’m trying to figure out why this is a big deal. If my house is being searched I already think it’s over.
14
u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24 edited Oct 25 '24
Gull's two modes:
Playing with her computer
Tilting her head back, glaring down her nose at the audience
per Andrea Burkhart's live tonight https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PF774_N0ycs
11
7
35
u/The2ndLocation Oct 24 '24
Liggett said he heard Libby say "that be a gun" that child might have been the smartest person in that town. I seriously doubt that is what she said.
36
24
u/rosiekeen Oct 24 '24
Insulting Libby’s memory saying this honestly
14
u/The2ndLocation Oct 24 '24
That's how I feel too.
17
u/rosiekeen Oct 24 '24
From everything we know about her she was very intelligent and talking like that would be so out of character
→ More replies (1)9
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
It wasnt talk like a pirate day? Did anyone check?
6
13
u/BlackLionYard Approved Contributor Oct 24 '24
It's academic given that no one else seems to have heard it, but something still nags me. A long time rumor is that one of the girls, usually Abby, asked "is that a gun?" I wonder if in a similar vein someone thought they heard Libby ask "could that be a gun?"
Academic, but I sure would like to someday know the basis for any claims of any use of the word GUN.
15
5
u/black_cat_X2 Oct 25 '24
His entire version of what he claimed the video says was nothing like anything else reported. I would normally say I'm baffled at how he could come up with what he did, but not anymore.
16
Oct 25 '24
10
6
15
u/KamrynKade Oct 24 '24
Do we know if the discrepancy in time from HHS video might be because it did not take into account daylight savings? Back in 2017, I wonder if this type of camera had to be manually set.
18
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 24 '24
I heard earlier the HH footage is 54 minutes ahead. But that came from Mullin. Sooo
11
u/LGIChick Criminologist Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24
I was confused about that the other day too. So the time of 1:27pm already takes into account the 54 minute time discrepancy then?
7
21
u/Flippercomb Oct 24 '24
Something I was typing in the locked thread about the opinion that "RA got scared he had been spotted, so he told LE he was on the trails that day to cover his own ass"
‐‐-----‐‐‐‐-------------------------------------------------------
That's certainly an opinion.
Not to completely disparage this poster's opinion because it's one that appears to be circling around the pro-guilty group, but it just defies all logic when any scrutiny is applied.
If I robbed a bank and they circulate a blurry photo into public that I know is me, I'm not going to the cops and telling them "yeah I was in the bank at the same time but I swear that's not me." At most, im trying to shore up an alabi that shows that wasn't me in the photo.
On the other hand, if I'm innocent and I was at the bank that day and a photo is released to the public that might be me, I would probably contact the police to A- clear up any confusion and B- try and help to say what I saw, even if it's nothing.
After cases like this, though, I'm definitely not going to the police for anything without legal representation.
9
u/JellyBeanzi3 Oct 24 '24
Hi that was me! Yeah i think this was my impression because i have frequently heard how murderers will insert themselves into investigations in a way to deter suspicions. I’m also not tied to this idea and am open to being incorrect.
7
Oct 25 '24 edited Oct 25 '24
Not allowed to make a post for this lengthy comment, so I've been instructed by Mods to make a comment. It will span multiple replies since it is long. (I probably should've waited to post this prime time tomorrow hah)
The Case for 2 Bridge Guys
I'm proposing a case for there being 2 bridge guys.
We have to assert some givens just for the sake of this discussion. I'm not saying these are established, indisputable facts. They are claims that we will hold as if true for this discussion. All information is derived from the PCA:
RA's vehicle is captured on HH cameras heading Westbound at 1:26PM.
BB says she witnessed 4 girls on the FB as she passed underneath.
4 girls say they were at the FB at 1:26PM.
BB's vehicle is captured on HH cameras heading Eastbound towards Mears Farm at 1:46 PM.
AW and LG were dropped off at Mears Farm at 1:49 PM.
I wasn't able to include images of mapped routes, but I mapped some walking routes:
MF->FB->MHB = 25 minutes or about 1.2 miles. (taken by RA by his own admission)
MF->MHB->MF = 16 minutes or about 0.7 miles. (taken by BB)
CPS->FB->MHB = 20 minutes or about 0.9 miles. (LE route for RA)
MHBTH->FB->MHB = 18 minutes or about 0.8 miles. (taken by MIB)
Major points:
BB arrives at MF around 1:46 PM.
She walks from MH to MHB.
At MHB she witnesses BG at the first platform.
She turns around and walks back towards MF.
Half way back to MF, she encounters AW & LG, who were heading towards MHB.
She finishes her walk at MF and is seen leaving by 2:14 PM.
Take-aways:
BG was at the bridge before BB or AW & LG arrived at the MHB.
This means that AW & LG either had to pass BG to get on the MHB, or BG had left the MHB by the time the girls got there.
By the time BB got back to MF and was leaving, AW & LG were already snapping pictures at the far end of the MHB...
8
Oct 25 '24
BG was already at the MHB
I wanted to fact check this claim. We know the group of 4 girls reported seeing BG after 1:26PM. And we know the State claims that RA passed the HH at 1:26PM. The distance from the East side of the FB to the North side of the MHB is ~0.7miles which Google estimates would take about 16 minutes to walk. Therefore, that places BG at the MHB by 1:52PM. The walk from MF to the half way point of MHB is ~0.2miles, or a 4 minute walk. If AW & LG arrived at 1:49PM, at 1:53PM, they'd have been at the half way point. This means there is no chance that they didn't encounter BG between the MHB and the path to MF.
BG was parked at Freedom Bridge Trail Head
The 4 girls took pictures of the East-side FB bench at 1:26 PM, and when they started back across FB, they claim to have encountered BG. This means that BG either parked in the FB trail head parking lot on the West side of FB, or he parked near the old CPS building, and first went across the FB before deciding to double back.
The big problem with this second statement is that the 4 girls claim to be taking a picture of the East side bench at exactly the moment RA is passing the HH store. After they take the pictures, they head across the FB and encounter BG on the FB. Thus, RA couldn't be BG because he was passing the HH store, unless he didn't park at the old CPS building either...
So, we must then assume that BG was coming from the parking lot on the West side of FB. Which is not a location that anyone has RA parking at.
BB witnesses 4 girls at FB
When BB passed under FB, she claims she saw the group of 4 girls crossing the bridge. We know this had to have been when the girls were walking back across the bridge after having taken a picture of the bench at 1:26 PM. We know it couldn't have been earlier because she arrives at the MF by 1:46 PM and she would've passed under the FB on HWY 25 a mere 3-4 minutes earlier. Why didn't she see BG? BG must have already passed the girls and been on the path to MHB...
BB didn't see an odd vehicle at the old CPS building until she was leaving
According to the timeline, this BG character should already have been out and on the ground before BB even turned off of HWY 25. Yet, she didn't report seeing any odd cars at the old CPS building until she was leaving...The only other report of an odd vehicle at the old CPS building also came around 2:10 PM...
I hope people are seeing the problems here. The BG reported by both BB and 4 girls simply could not have been RA. This BG was clearly not parked at the old CPS building nor the Mears Farm. Therefore, he had to have been parked at what is labeled on Google Maps as the MHB Trail Parking/Trailhead on the West side of the FB.
11
Oct 25 '24
Conclusion: There are 2 BG's
I have been saying the last couple of days, based on information coming out of the trials, that I now believe that RA is the BG from LG's video, but that he isn't involved in the murders, and was totally oblivious to the girls. At first, I was writing this post with the thought in mind that I would just blow apart the witness statements totally, and prove them nonsensical. Instead, what I realized is that it opens the door to a theory I haven't seen before: that there were 2 BG's that day. RA is the BG seen on LG's video. But he wasn't the only BG that day...
I've shown that the witnessed BG (let's call him MIB for man-in-black) beat BB and the girls to the MHB, and was already on the first platform by the time BB witnessed him. I've shown that the 4 girls would've already been crossing the bridge before RA could've even parked at the old CPS building. I've shown that AW & LG would've had to encounter MIB on their way to the bridge because they passed BB before the fork to MF.
Therefore, either AW & LG passed MIB on their way out across the bridge (seems unlikely) or he was already across the bridge when they got there. MIB is the BG heard telling them "guys, down the hill". The BG in the video is RA coming down the MHB trail 5-10 minutes later, being filmed in the background, oblivious to the girls and MIB at the other end of the bridge, and turns around and goes home.
I'm not sure if this means MIB was someone they were there to meet up with, or if he ambushed them at the other end, but it now seems likely to me at least that MIB threaded the needle between BB and RA to meet AW & LG at the high bridge.
→ More replies (2)
17
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 25 '24
I'm shook by the fact that a lot/all of bridge guy might just be a deep fake. I don't know how to process this. What the fuck just happened? Someone explain? There is no technology out there that can show stuff that the camera isn't point at. Thats not a thing, but they are claiming its a thing in court?
1:05 in
https://www.youtube.com/live/JndLLL7kius?si=Ub9uEAq-npHmd42M
7
u/whattaUwant Oct 24 '24
Do we know for a fact that when Alan’s home was getting searched that he was sitting in a car and said to the detective “it does not matter.. it’s all over.”
I understand the detective is under oath… But how would we ever know if he is actually violating oath or not? In this instance is the jury required to believe this exchange occurred?
3
u/Strict-Media-6405 Oct 24 '24
Do we have any idea whether the defense plans to call the “…other people who were on the trail that day after 2:13pm” but did not see BG? Assume this is DF(FSG), Cheyenne & the couple? And at least the couple and Cheyenne were toward the southside of the bridge between 2:30 and 4:00? And maybe the people SC saw at mears lot was this couple? The state of AW’s “pristine” condition really threw me. If LG’s cellphone was in its final resting place at 2:32, they went straight there off the bridge right? 15 minutes down the hill, across the creek to scene. Then he killed them, waited 20 minutes. Then do they think he carried AW from scene to creek to clean her after death then back to scene to dress and stage? And then back to creek again to dump clothes? How does any of the state’s timeline work? It doesn’t, but does anyone disagree? And no defensive wounds? Is it possible he drugged them? I don’t recall hearing any toxicology results.
2
u/whattaUwant Oct 24 '24
Does anyone remember the timeline for when Richard Allen went to rehab or a mental health facility or something for like a month? I remember hearing this somewhere.















36
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 24 '24
This is a PSA
Next person to mention Occam's razor is getting blocked
If you are that desperate to continue the back and forth, take it to DMs.