This page is meant to publicly organize ideas and proposals for the subreddit. For other information about moons or ideas, see the Moon Wiki and the CCMeta FAQ
Approved for posting
On Deck
The idea is approved but some details, clarifications, or other adjustments are needed for a final draft to be approved. These authors should be in direct contact with mods to get the proposal ready for the next moon week
Admin Queue
Awaiting admin resources (may not need a vote for implementation). Admins will implement these when they can and may consider our prioritization poll. Unfortunately we have no more information about timelines or features at this time.
Mod Queue
Awaiting mod vote, discussion, or feedback
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/wq0sbp/brainstorm_proposal_have_the_option_to_receive/ would need admin approval
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/wppx6k/proposal_add_a_bounty_flair_in_rcryptocurrency/ Requires some KM consideration and possible admin help
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/wvr0w7/separatemore_moon_counts_for_each_user/
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/y0on6x/proposed_updates_to_serious_posts/
On Hold
Mods or admins have not made a decision about polls on these topics yet so they may be proposed in a future month.
Reward engagement in addition to karma - This type of idea needs to be thought through more to prevent abuse
Awaiting Implementation
Declined
Karma and Age - Mods are not currently open to this and admins are unlikely to make this type of change
Remove mods from moon distribution - Answered in the FAQ
Incentivize upvoting or punish downvoting - While it would be good to encourage more quality votes, incentives tend to open up loopholes and bad behavior instead, such as spamming upvotes everywhere. Mods and admins so far have not seen a proposal that solves for these issues
Increase Voting Reward from 5% to 10% - Voted down by mods but may be revisited later
Daily Participation Karma Bonus - Split decision by mods, not moving forward at this time
Update the tipping mechanism to be able to tip with 2 decimals - No objections from mods at this time. Admins indicated this one will be considered once they reach mainnet
Mod removal appeal accountability system - Voted down by mods, objections outlined in comments
All eclipse and lunar cycle related proposals - Voted down by mods. This type of thing adds complexity to the system and at this time we have not seen any that add much value
Limit Moon Rules to 28 - Voted down by mods. This is an arbitrary limit, does not seem to add value or address a current problem, and significantly complicates proposals after a certain point
Limit the number of proposals in each Moon Week - This is done informally already, but we may formalize this at some point
Add a badge for avid downvoters Admins have replied that this is not feasible given the current backend architecture of reddit
No Moons for Mod Posts - Failed mod vote
Allow discussion before voting opens up - Failed mod vote
Notify Users about Gov Polls - The admins are working to make governance polls more visible, such as their own tab instead of notifications which many users may not like
Reduce the 500 character minimum for self posts - Negatively impacts moderation efforts
Remove all negative karma from Moon calculations - Voted down in mod vote
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/vq3jzb/proposal_allocate_a_small_percentage_of_monthly/ - Declined in mod vote
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/vnmeoq/proposal_add_the_ability_for_users_to_vote_in/ - Voting weight for governance tokens is not something admins or mods are open to right now
Passed
See the official list here: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/wiki/ccip
Unsuccessful
(not an exhaustive list, only since Moon Week began. Also these may have simply had too little participation and not been summarily defeated)
Custom Flairs for special membership - We'll be in touch to frame this one around what is possible on a technical level. Not approved yet by mods but I don't expect any issues or involvement from admins on this one
All Governance Polls Should Be Posted By A Shared Mod Account
Reduce contribution points gained from article link posts by 35%
Adjust inflation/decay rate - Admins are not open to adjusting the inflation rate currently
Give voting weight to bought moons - Admins are not open to giving unearned moons voting weight currently
Rejected
(Votes in opposition to this idea reached the governance threshold)