r/creepygaming • • Aug 21 '26

Strange/Creepy Unknown figure at the bottom of pit in tomb raider 2

4.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Mar 09 '21

Strange/Creepy Well, that's horrifying...

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Oct 19 '20

Glitch I’m not sure if this counts, but this is how my Super Mario Galaxy 2 copy boots with an emulator.

3.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Jun 04 '21

Strange/Creepy In Sherlock Homes Nemisis, Watson doesn't have a walking animation, forcing him to spawn right behind you every time you turn

3.2k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Apr 14 '20

Strange/Creepy The GameBoy Printer had a "RUN" option. If you select it, your console would show you this (among other faces) and ask the player "Who are you running from?"

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Jun 06 '21

Strange/Creepy bobnface.png, a bizarre and unsettling drawing found in 2019 on a developer disk used for Sonic 2 sprite storage

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Aug 31 '25

Obscure Game Disturbing imagery Inside of an obscure DS game🫣

Thumbnail
gallery
2.8k Upvotes

Life Signs Surgical Unit DS is a charming game that is a cross between Ace Attorney and Trauma Center. The game is very innocent for the most part except for your injuries/surgery scenes of course, these caught me off guard because it’s a very different vibe from the rest of the game, 3 scary stories you can choose. Thought it was interesting to share.


r/creepygaming • • Feb 25 '18

Meta I would be laughing if it didn't hurt.

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Dec 04 '21

Easter Egg In the GMod map "Golden City", if you score 6 times at the basketball court, a door will open with a button, press it and then head back outside, this face appears in the sky

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Jun 20 '20

Creepypasta This "mario 64" screen shot I made

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Sep 07 '20

Strange/Creepy the shadow of the colossus game over screens are unsettling, they just stare at you whilst after you died to them.

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • May 25 '20

Strange/Creepy Human Farm is a upcoming obscure game that will let you have a human farm and butcher them

2.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Jul 15 '21

Strange/Creepy This game over screen from Dune (1992).

2.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Nov 29 '20

Strange/Creepy Message in a racing game called "California Speed"

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Sep 16 '20

Strange/Creepy Concept art for some of the enemies in the game Epic Mickey. How these designs were even considered at one point are beyond me

Thumbnail
gallery
2.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Jul 11 '21

Iceberg The Definitive Dark/Creepy/Scary/Disturbing Video Games Iceberg NSFW

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Feb 20 '25

Creepypasta That time my Sims game started calling my real phone at 3 AM

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

So, I recently picked up the 25th-anniversary re-release of The Sims and finally be able to play the original on my modern computer. But when I saw this creepy message pop up, it seriously freaked me out and took me back to some terrifying memories I have with this game. Has anyone else ever been scared or creeped out by The Sims 1? I’ve got a weird story from back then that I still can’t explain…

This happened back in early 2000 when The Sims 1 first came out. I was a broke college student, so I went looking for a used copy at this small shop near my apartment. Found this suspiciously cheap copy, and the seller seemed weirdly eager to get rid of it, practically shoving the dusty case in my face. I noticed these huge handprints all over the case and wiped them off with my sleeve before buying. Should've been my first red flag when the guy looked so relieved to get rid of it.

I got home and installed it on my chunky desktop with one of those massive CRT monitors. Everything seemed normal at first, I was playing with the usual pre-made families like the Goths. Then I noticed this household called "The Graves Family." There was just one guy living there – Malcolm Graves. No job, but he had this weirdly detailed apartment. Back then, without much internet access or YouTube let's plays to check against, I just assumed it was some pre-made household that came with the game. Found out later from friends that there was never a pre-made Graves family, but at the time I convinced myself it must've been some special version or whatever.

That’s when the strange things started happening. The large fingerprints I’d wiped off the game case? They reappeared, no matter how thoroughly I cleaned them. They’d show up again in the exact same spots a few days later. I thought it was just stubborn dust, or maybe the smudges were embedded so deep in the plastic that I couldn’t completely get rid of them.

The really unsettling part was Malcolm’s behavior. Other Sims would act normal, you know, yelling at the screen when they're hungry, throwing tantrums when they needed social interaction, that kind of thing. I'd been keeping all of Malcolm’s needs almost green, but he’d just stand up from whatever he was doing, slowly turn to face the screen, and stare. Not at the camera like Sims sometimes do - at ME. No expression, no movement, no reason. Just staring. His needs were all fine, so I figured it was just a glitch, but the weird thing was it only happened with the Grave household.

You know how The Sims 1 already had this creepy vibe to it, right? Those prank calls, that high-pitched sound when a raccoon shows up - the game could be pretty unsettling when you're alone at night. Well, one night around 3 AM, after playing for hours and completely losing track of time, I got one of those in-game phone calls. Usually it's just stuff like the psychic advisor giving random fortunes or whatever. But this time, the message box popped up saying: "You have been chosen. They will come soon."

I remember getting goosebumps. Then, I swear, not even five seconds later, my actual landline started ringing. I was alone in my apartment, everything dead silent except for that phone. I tried to calm myself, thinking maybe it was some kind of family emergency at 3 AM. I hesitated, but picked it up anyway. The silence on the other end... it felt like someone - or something - was just there, listening. My hands were shaking so bad I almost dropped the phone. When I finally snapped out of it, I slammed that phone down so fast. After that night, I started unplugging my phone whenever I played. Wasn't taking any chances.

But things only got worse. I started finding these big, dusty handprints on my keyboard, mouse, and even my CRT monitor. They definitely weren’t mine - they were way too big. At first, I tried to tell myself maybe they were my own prints, just smudged in a way that made them look bigger. Maybe I hadn’t cleaned them as well as I thought. So I wiped them away. But a few days later, they came back. Same spots, same size - even though I hadn’t touched those places since.

That’s when I started hearing it. Late at night, when everything else was quiet, I’d be lying in bed, half-asleep, and then I’d hear it - random taps on the mechanical keyboard. Not the usual creaks of an old apartment, but clear, deliberate key presses. The first time it happened, I'd lie there frozen in bed, not even breathing, just listening to those keys. You ever get that feeling where you want to check what's making a noise but your body just won't move? That's exactly what it was like.

After what felt like forever, my brain finally kicked in - what if it was a burglar? I shot up in bed so fast, my heart nearly jumped out of my chest. My computer was across the room, completely powered down, the monitor dark. But the sound was so distinct, like someone was sitting there, tapping away at random keys. I had to check. I forced myself up, switched on the desk lamp, and walked over. The keyboard was still. Nothing out of place. No programs open, no reason for any noise. I tried to convince myself I was just imagining it. It only happened a few times, and honestly, I didn’t even connect it to the game. I just brushed it off as my brain playing tricks. So, I kept playing because it was fun.

But then, it wasn’t just the typing. I was sitting there, late into the night as always, the familiar sounds of my Sims chattering away in their nonsense Simlish. But something was off. Every time Malcolm interacted with another Sim, I started hearing something strange. At first, I thought it was just the usual garbled gibberish, but then I swear I heard him say, "Behind…" followed by something like, "Watching…" My heart skipped, and I leaned in closer to the screen, trying to catch the sound through those dual old-school, computer speakers. But as soon as I did, the words turned back into the usual Simlish nonsense.

I tried convincing myself it was just a glitch or corrupted audio. But what really got to me was that the voice didn't seem to come from the speakers at all - it felt like it was coming from right behind me. I kept telling myself I was being stupid, but for days after that, I couldn't help checking over my shoulder every few minutes, even in broad daylight. That feeling of being watched just wouldn't go away.

I'd been playing normally with other households too – killing Sims in classic ways like removing pool ladders, building walls around them and deleting doors. Killed plenty of other Sims and nothing weird ever happened with them. But Malcolm… something was different about this household. Being curious (and maybe stupid), I decided to mess with him. Built a tiny room, added a cheap stove, deleted the door and fire alarm so no firefighters would show up to save him. Made him cook even though he had zero skill.

When the fire finally started, things got seriously wrong. The exact moment Malcolm caught fire in-game, my apartment's fire alarm went off for no apparent reason. No smoke, no burning smell, nothing that should have triggered it. My heart was pounding so hard I could hear it in my ears. I remember my palms were sweating like crazy on the mouse, but I couldn't look away from the screen. Then that same glitch happened again - he just stopped screaming, mid-animation, while still burning. Then he slowly turned to face the screen. Just staring. At me.

I panicked and yanked the power cord. The second my computer went black, the fire alarm stopped. But what happened next might be one of the most terrifying things in my life. I saw someone's reflection in those old CRT screens - this dark shape standing right behind me in the reflection. I swear it wasn't my reflection because it was moving. Not just my own movement, but actually shifting slightly around on its own.

I probably should've just bolted out of there, but you know how you just HAVE to look even when you're scared out of your mind? My heart was hammering so loud as I started turning around, but like... so slowly. Each inch I turned felt like it took forever, and the whole time I'm thinking "please be nothing, please be nothing, please be nothing."

And then… Nothing.

Just my empty room. Same old posters on the wall, same mess of blankets on my unmade bed. When I looked back at the screen… it was just my own reflection staring back at me, looking absolutely terrified.

After that night, I couldn't even look at my computer without my heart racing. Had to sleep with all the lights on for weeks, which meant I was basically running on energy drinks and coffee to stay awake during classes. My grades started slipping bad, I mean, how do you explain to your professor that you can't do your assignments because you're terrified of your computer? lol. Every time I walked past that desk, I'd get this cold feeling in my stomach, like someone was watching me.

My friends kept asking why I was always camping out at the library instead of using my computer at my place. Had to make up all these dumb excuses about my internet being out, or my computer having viruses or whatever.

The next few months were rough. Did most of my work at the library computers, but those restricted hours were killing me. But you know, when nothing scary happens for a while, you start feeling kind of stupid about the whole thing. Plus, I had this huge project coming up, and the library closing at 10 PM wasn't gonna work with these deadlines.

So one afternoon, and I specifically picked the middle of the day, I finally forced myself to sit at my desk. My hands were so sweaty just moving the mouse, and when I saw that Sims icon... man, my throat got all tight. But I had to prove to myself I wasn't crazy. Took me like 20 minutes just to work up the courage to click on it to open the game again, and the whole time I kept looking over my shoulder, half-expecting to see… something.

The game loaded, and there it was Malcolm’s house, saved, even though I had forcefully shut down the computer before. I couldn’t believe it. The message box popped up after Malcolm died, just like it always does when any Sim dies. But it was different this time:

“Rest In Peace: Deepest sympathy! Malcolm has just died. Though the body is gone, the spirit will always remain. watching.”

That was it. The second I saw that, I forced another hard shutdown on the computer, not even caring if my college files were corrupted. I just couldn’t deal with it anymore.

I ended up formatting my computer clean. Thank god my college project was saved on a thumb drive and wasn't messed up by whatever was going on with that Sims game. After wiping the computer, all that weird stuff - the handprints, the typing sounds - it all just stopped. Everything went back to normal.

Maybe it was just some virus, something a hacker injected into my copy of The Sims. But that still doesn't explain the weird things that happened outside the computer. I've been playing the digital re-release of The Sims 1 for a few days now. No weird glitches, no weird messages (beyond the usual creepy prank calls the game is known for) so far, anyway.

Honestly, writing this out now is bringing back that same feeling of being watched. Never found out what happened to that copy of The Sims. Left it in that apartment when I moved out a few months later. Probably should've burned it or something, but I didn't want to touch it again.


r/creepygaming • • Aug 22 '20

Strange/Creepy In Tokyo Xtreme Racer 3, there is an easter egg after the player defeats Death Driver, a racer who is theorized to be a ghost, and unlocks his car. When you start driving his S15, all vans that you'll see in traffic will have ghosts trapped inside of them, looking at you as you drive past them.

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Nov 22 '24

Strange/Creepy I was playing Scarface on PS2 and found this strange guy

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

I was playing Scarface : The World Is Yours when I found this strange dude on Black Sands Island, near Nacho's Casino Tanker.

He's so weird ! He really differ from anyone else from this game and when I try to talk to him he doesn't respond... Is he a reference to someone or something ?

(Sorry for the quality, I was playing on real hardware on my old TV for retrogaming, and took these pictures on the spot with my phone)


r/creepygaming • • Jul 18 '20

Urban Legend Spotted this at my local record store in Michigan 👀

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Sep 14 '20

Obscure Game Drowned God: Conspiracy of the Ages. An obscure PC game where human history was created by aliens and the player must uncover the truth. The creator later went on to stab his wife 30 times, killed his pets, and then stabbed himself to death. Very hard to find

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Sep 01 '20

Obscure Game This Japanese Sega Saturn FMV game about being a cameraman for an IRL rock band with absolutely no horror content has a bizarrely unsettling atmosphere, seemingly by complete accident.

2.0k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Oct 23 '20

Glitch It remembers what it once was

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/creepygaming • • Oct 25 '25

Leaked screenshot from canceled video game adaption of "Air Bud"

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Described as a speed-based dungeon crawler with a story written by controversial figure Kenneth Grant. Development was halted after one play tester picked up a nearby meat tenderizer and "just kind of started going hogwild" on a nearby employee.


r/creepygaming • • Jan 26 '24

Strange/Creepy This really caught me off guard

Post image
2.0k Upvotes