r/computerscience • • Mar 14 '24

The Realities of the AI Developer

221 Upvotes

Ever since Turing the idea of human-like machine intelligence floated around, but with recent advancements in computing power neural networks have deepened. The inclusion of GPT techniques have allowed the pushing of the Deep Neural Network (DNN) to heights never before seen. And now with the announcement of Devin, the AI Software Engineer, the nails in the coffin of the profession that nearly all CS majors end up in is finally being hammered in. I hope to convince you of the opposite: many of the companies behind the push aren't the humanists they claim to be, and their claims are exaggerated or even completely fabricated.

Neural networks have been around for quite some time, the idea dates back to the 1950s. But the fundamental concept hasn't really evolved since. Sure, the techniques have gotten more clever, but essentially we're still relying on the fundamental perceptron design. Which, if it works it works. And it does quite well as a statistical learning technique. However, the important distinction that a while these are called neural networks they are massively different than human brains, both in operation and fundamental structure. You don't have to take my word for it, though.

In 2021, Dr. Melanie Mitchell published a paper titled Why AI is Harder Than We Think, in a direct challenge to the AI researchers of today. While I wholly endorse reading the paper in its entirety, Dr. Mitchell brought up four fallacies that AI researchers fall for (and as a consequence, the population that listens to them).

  1. Narrow intelligence is on a continuum with general intelligence

  2. Easy things are easy and hard things are hard

  3. The lure of wishful mnemonics

  4. Intelligence is all in the brain

Dr. Mitchell further argues that AI springs are common and followed by an AI winter. We are presently in an AI spring, and an AI winter is coming. It's powerful logic that's mostly been ignored by the larger AI community, who insist that AGI is right around the corner.

But self-driving cars are still not a reality, and they were promised as early as 2015. We were promised by Elon Musk that they were going to take over. Ten years later we're still waiting and trillions of dollars have been spent on what seems to be the new fusion. So maybe it's time we stop listening to billionaires and start listening to real computer scientists, like Dr. Mitchell.

But truly these companies have made some very great advancements in the field of AI. And it's true, but i has come at a massive cost. The electricity demands are massive in a time when power consumption should be optimized on the dangerous precipice of a warming planet. The datasets used by OpenAI, Google, and Microsoft were hardly ethically obtained. And so we're left with a troubling realization that it certainly seems like this is just the new business craze (remember NFTs? Blockchain?) instead of a truly humanist pursuit. And those that cheer on them on hoping for the tech utopia of their dreams is just another form of wishful thinking.

So no, AGI isn't upon us, no matter how many times the company who tried to trademark GPT tries to will it to be through marketing materials. An Apple esque-bar graph is hardly scientific, and these companies are not ethical. They are out to make money, and have an invested interest in making the grandiose claims you see plague the news.

Thank you for coming to my TED talk, I'll have a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. And no, I'll make it myself, the AI keeps confusing the marmite with the jelly.


r/computerscience • • Jan 21 '24

Discussion Is an operating system a process itself?

221 Upvotes

Today I took my OS final and one of the questions asked whether the OS was a process itself. It was a strange question in my opinion, but I reasoned that yes it is. Although after the exam I googled it and each source says something different. So I want to know what you guys think. Is an operating system a process itself? Why or why not?


r/computerscience • • Oct 19 '20

Discussion New to programming or computer science? Want advice for education or careers? Ask your questions here!

221 Upvotes

This is the only place where college, career, and programming questions are allowed. They will be removed if they're posted anywhere else.

HOMEWORK HELP, TECH SUPPORT, AND PC PURCHASE ADVICE ARE STILL NOT ALLOWED!

There are numerous subreddits more suited to those posts such as:

/r/techsupport
/r/learnprogramming
/r/buildapc

Note: this thread is in "contest mode" so all questions have a chance at being at the top

Edit: For a little encouragement, anyone who gives a few useful answers in this thread will get a custom flair (I'll even throw some CSS in if you're super helpful)


r/computerscience • • Jan 06 '23

Discussion Question: Which are the GOD Tier Algorithms, and what do they do?

219 Upvotes

Just wondering about which algorithms are out there and which are the ones that represent the pinnacle of our development.


r/computerscience • • Jan 04 '21

What compsci lectures are a must watch?

219 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Dec 10 '21

Why do computer scientists (and mathematicians) use the worst variable names in proofs and papers?!?

218 Upvotes

Sorry if this post doesn’t quite fit this sub but this has been bothering me for ages and I’ve recently hit a breaking point for my frustration.

It just pisses me off that there are 26 letters in the alphabet and 325 pairs of letters you can choose and for some reason the pair that we all seem to use is (i,j).
There are literally no two letters that look more alike and that could get more easily mixed up but for some reason whether it be in code are in my case here in proofs and papers these two letters are always used together.
Why should I have to use a magnifying glass to read a damn proof from a paper that couldn’t have the decency to at least use a better font?

And it doesn’t stop at (i,j). We also love to use (m,n), (p,q), (u,v).

Like I get it, it’s more clear that the variables are related when they look alike, but it should certainly be more important that people don’t mix them up???


r/computerscience • • Sep 24 '20

I made an open-source web app where you can fine-tune your music preferences and create a playlist directly to Spotify. Check it out!

218 Upvotes

[Will remove if not allowed, please let me know]

I frankly got tired of Spotify's algorithm, especially when looking for workout songs, so I made this thingy.

Let me know what you all think!

Note: You need to login to Spotify so it can save the playlist and load the tailored recommendations. The login is all handled through Spotify's end and I don't have any access to your private information (nor do I care for it).

Link: https://personal-dj-app.herokuapp.com/

For all my fellow nerds: Built on Node.JS, calling the Spotify Web API. If you're interested in contributing, the GitHub link is in the website footer.


r/computerscience • • Jul 11 '20

Article FREE Computer Science Curriculum From The Best Universities and Companies In The World

Thumbnail
laconicml.com
218 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Jan 23 '22

Article Human Brain Cells From Petri Dishes Learn to Play Pong Faster Than AI

Thumbnail
science-news.co
217 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • May 29 '19

Wish me luck

217 Upvotes

Hello, I am finally going back to college to get a degree in CS. I am ~40 and a self taught programmer (been developing professionally for the better part of a decade on the global market) and I fell this has held me back.

Can’t wait to get started!


r/computerscience • • May 03 '19

Help How are these created? I'm a complete beginner here and would love to know where to begin/look into first.

Thumbnail
gfycat.com
217 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Jan 14 '18

The internet in the 1990's....

Post image
217 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Oct 20 '19

What is happening when I open an incompatible file in Notepad and get this gobbledygook?

Post image
216 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Jan 25 '24

I feel like I’ve been cheated

215 Upvotes

I’m soon done with my bachelors, which is a combined degree in Computer and Systems Sciences and Business Administration. Officially I will get two degrees, one in each of the two subjects. So technically, I will have a Computer and Systems Sciences degree. But I feel like I know nothing about CS. I knew going in that I wouldn’t go as deep into either subject since it’s a double degree, but so far, the only real CS related stuff I’ve done is: intro to compsci, object oriented analysis and systems design, one course in programming, requirements engineering, information security, ERP systems and HCI. No math at all. No algorithms. No data structures. I don’t really feel confident or comfortable saying I’ve studied CS when it feels like I haven’t even touched a lot of the stuff the comes up here. Am I doomed? Do I have to compliment my degree with even more studies? That’s kinda what I feel like I have to do now.


r/computerscience • • Nov 06 '25

Discussion What happens to computing when we hit the atom?

213 Upvotes

Eventually we can only shrink transistors to be so small. Once we get to the size of the atom; we are really done in terms of miniaturizing them

Does computing proficiency then end entirely or will there be workarounds to make even more advanced computers?


r/computerscience • • Mar 01 '21

Advice Am I naive for actually enjoying CS?

213 Upvotes

I’m only on my fourth semester as a CS student but... I’m really enjoying it? A lot of people online and a lot of my CS friends at other schools often complain that they don’t like the work and they’re just doing it for job security and good pay. Now I know that over-saturation in any industry can lead to burnout, but I’m finishing up data structures and moving towards algorithms and UI dev next semester and I’m just still absolutely fascinated by the material. I have a good background in math and programming can still definitely be a pain in the ass and has given me some gray hairs, but it’s also immensely satisfying when things come together and things run right. Am I just being naive and in for a rude awakening in my near future, or are there some developers/engineers that actually enjoy their jobs and the challenge?


r/computerscience • • May 28 '20

General Springer Opensourced 100s of Computer Science books

213 Upvotes

Springer has opensourced many computer science books that we can download for free. It covers several topics like Big data,Data structure,Data Analysis and more.

I have put a CSV file in my github repository, https://github.com/sourabhsinha396/Springer-Opensourced-books

Hope it helps :)


r/computerscience • • Sep 15 '19

In a Huge Milestone, Engineers Build a Working Computer Chip Out of Carbon Nanotubes

Thumbnail
sciencealert.com
213 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Oct 11 '21

General Computer disease. Richard Feynman on his first computer experience in the 1940s.

212 Upvotes

I'm reading Richard Feynman's book "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!". There is a chapter on working on the first atomic bomb (The Manhattan Project) and how the first computers hit the scene. I was amazed that despite the past 80 years, the attitude towards computers has not changed at all.

Well, Mr. Frankel, who started this program, began to suffer from the computer disease that anybody who works with computers now knows about. It’s a very serious disease and it interferes completely with the work.

The trouble with computers is you play with them. They are so wonderful. You have these switches—if it’s an even number you do this, if it’s an odd number you do that—and pretty soon you can do more and more elaborate things if you are clever enough, on one machine.

But if you’ve ever worked with computers, you understand the disease—the delight in being able to see how much you can do. But he got the disease for the first time, the poor fellow who invented the thing.


r/computerscience • • Mar 25 '20

What's your favoured programming language?

212 Upvotes

I know most of you would use different languages for different purposes, but say there was a quick problem you wanted to solve or something you wanted to test; which one would you use?

I thought it would be interesting to see the spread on this subreddit!

4659 votes, Mar 30 '20
994 Java
2080 Python
378 C
767 C++
385 JavaScript
55 Ruby

r/computerscience • • Mar 26 '18

Morning laugh

Post image
212 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Nov 10 '25

General Are you measuring your productivity, and how?

Post image
211 Upvotes

r/computerscience • • Apr 25 '22

Discussion Gatekeeping in Computer Science

211 Upvotes

This is a problem that everyone is aware of, or at least the majority of us. My question is, why is this common? There are so many people quick to shutdown beginners with simple questions and this turns so many people away. Most gatekeepers are just straight up mean or rude. Anyone have any idea as to how this came to be?

Edit: Of course I am not talking about people begging for help on homework or beginners that are unable to google their questions first.


r/computerscience • • Sep 28 '19

C++ dereferencing and indexing; it's hilarious if you're used to rigid structure for arrays

Post image
211 Upvotes