r/comicswap • • 22d ago

[US][H] An Updated Rule [W] Your Attention

202 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Earlier today, we had a post in which the seller posted prices for their books. One book in particular was very coveted, priced below market value, and, naturally, attracted a lot of attention. Many people commented to buy it. One buyer offered more than asking price and the seller, flippantly, accepted, commenting that the highest bidder gets the prize.

This is absolutely NOT how we run this sub. With the combination of rule #1 (DON’T BE A DICK) and rule #3 (No best offer posts), you’d think people would naturally assume that this sub doesn’t do auction style posts. Were other buyers offered a chance to match the offer? Offer more? We don’t want to go down that toxic path. There’s a place you can overpay for things online that has an auction-style setup.

We’ve updated the rules to explicitly ban this behavior and anyone breaking the rule will deal with repercussions that could include banning. I get it. We all want our collections to be awesome, and I wish no book ever went out of print. But that doesn’t mean we can be absolute jerks to each other when a rare book is posted for a reasonable price.

Be good people.


r/comicswap • • Jan 07 '22

[US-OH][H] A request [W] A response from the community

155 Upvotes

I’ve noticed in a lot of threads people will erase a price on a book and just mark it “SOLD” after a sale. I’m pretty sure I have done this in the past as well.

I think it would be good practice for the community to leave the price up and just cross it out or write sold next to the price instead of replacing it. I think this community is a good resource for gauging pricing on books along with eBay.

Just curious what everyone’s take on this is. Thanks!


r/comicswap • • Oct 05 '17

[Announcement] We lost a swap brother.

151 Upvotes

Its with heavy heart that im tasked with informing you all that our Mod /u/bournetocutmeat passed unexpectedly in his sleep the other day.

His name was Carey and this dude loved comics. He had some of the highest flair on this sub and he really truly cared about all the users here. He grew up in Florida but recently moved to the west coast which is why he hadnt been active here for a little bit.

After getting to know him on reddit, we exchanged numbers and started hunting for deals for each other in various comic shops. We became friends. He flew from florida to Massachusetts to attend one of my irl comic swaps. He brought me gifts. He stayed with me for a week. He was always so happy and so quick to laugh at a joke.

His death remains a mystery. No foul play, no drugs, no alcohol.

He will be sorely missed. There is now a void on this world that will never be filled. Rest in peace, friend.

Update from careys brother:

This is Careys brother. All of the love and support that my family have recieved is unbelievable. So many people have come out of the woodwork to hug us and cry with us.

I am not a comic book fan but I am going to start reading a lot of his comics (he has a lot 😀). My brother was working on a comic book tattoo sleeve with spiderman, venom, the green goblin, j Jonah jameson, and mary jane. I am now planning on getting a spiderman tattoo on my arm in his honor.

You guys should also know that he was happy with his life and he died peacefully in his sleep. His family were all in touch with him very recently. He recently purchased a ticket to visit us in Florida for the first time since he moved out west. The day he died he played soccer (he played since he was 4) and came home to watch anime and hopefully reas some comics. All of the things he enjoyed most.

Live your life to its fullest. Talk to your loved ones on a regular basis. Do what you love regardless of money.

We will miss him more than words can express. Thank you all for your kind words. Live life and be happy.


r/comicswap • • May 12 '21

[CA] [H] NEW RULE : ALL ITEMS OVER $100 MUST HAVE CURRENT TIME STAMP OR REDDIT NAME [W] SAFE ENVIRONMENT

123 Upvotes

Hello

Because of the influx of scammers a new rule must be put into place.

Currently we have not asked for 'proof in hand' as much as we should.

This will stop now.

From here on, if you post s book worth over $100 you must include a currently dated photo. Not a generic one.

Pain in the butt? Yep. Still gotta do it.

Sorry for the inconvenience, blame it on the people after your money.

Thanks


r/comicswap • • Aug 14 '21

[H]Sketchy Activity [W]common sense

113 Upvotes

There has been an influx of sketchy activity. From Idiots who think we aren’t smart enough to know when transactions aren’t real to people confirming posts in less than 3 days. Some people confirming posts the same day - who clearly don’t live in the same neighborhood. Oh and let’s not forget about people who get called out and say “oops sorry it was off thread” or “oops it was in a different account.”

The goal is simple - This is a safe space to swap. That’s it. If you you’re acting sketchy you’re getting banned. Any action that puts the goal at risk, whether intentional or not (because accidents do happen) is getting banned. No fucking around. No temp bans. We have rules for a reason and they aren’t meant to find loop holes to pretend your safe and then pull off a scam. Our mods don’t have time to research dozens of PMs pointing to accounts and proof and messages and look here’s this person second account. If you act sketchy you’re getting banned. So take your posts and our rules seriously Because we are.


r/comicswap • • Jun 10 '21

[MOD]Stop commenting on prices.

107 Upvotes

Don’t be a dick. Don’t thread crap. It’s super simple. It is not your job to “protect buyers from scalping.” It is not your job to find the lowest price on the internet for that item. It is your job to keep scrolling, upvote, downvote, I don’t care. The mods are the only ones who can gently nudge with “you should check eBay sold or IST”.

It is not your job to inform anyone that you think the item is too expensive.

If a seller lists an item for too much, people won’t buy it. The GSX, The 1st spider Gwen, teen Titans omni. Which, btw were completely inaccurate - and were reported multiple times, incorrectly. And then resulted in “but I found this here” “oh did you see this sell in the UK?” “This was on sale during Memorial Day”

I’m done with it.

We’ve been banning people who violate dick/crap rules with temp bans. If this doesn’t stop they’ll be permanent.

Oh, messaging a mod directly or sending them a chat to argue your case is never going to work and will be ignored. Use the mod mail feature, it’s there for that reason.

TLDR; You do you, stop trying to police other people’s prices.


r/comicswap • • Aug 21 '21

[US][H] announcement [W] Beware! NSFW

104 Upvotes

Supremexoverlord is a scammer and generally awful human. Beware! Wanted to make sure everyone was aware of this person. I have been a member here for a little while at this point. Never seen anything like this in all the business I do with reddit, FB and other sites. The community has seen brighter days...

Edit- apparently the name and address on the packaging belong to another Redditor that has done business with this guy. Covered info for security per their request.

Also, I am Caucasian. Wanted to make it clear that the hateful words that were written were general and I don't believe they were addressed to me, specifically.

https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=13LEyiU-jGq-Bb795XoR5_nodSQd0CCXT


r/comicswap • • Aug 26 '20

[NY] [H] A very happy and excited 9 year old [W] to thank HikaruParker!

102 Upvotes

A little while back I posted on here looking to buy a reader copy of Edge of SpiderVerse 5, for my 9 year old son, he was enthralled by Peni Parker after watching Edge of the Spider Verse. Hikaru reached out to me in messages and offered to send him a copy, and not only that but sent him a pile of the other Spider Verse comics all for free.

To say my son is excited would be an understatement, he holed up in his room last night to read them, and has been rereading them throughout the day, he and I both wanted to say thanks!

https://imgur.com/a/MoxIO7d


r/comicswap • • Nov 22 '17

PayPal fees may be annoying, but imagine having to pay even more just to swap your comics. Speak up for Net Neutrality!

Thumbnail
battleforthenet.com
102 Upvotes

r/comicswap • • Oct 15 '19

<-- RULES - READ THIS!! [PSA] READ FIRST PLEASE!! Flair bot, Rules, Paypal G&S, etc...

98 Upvotes

Hello all!

If you are new here, welcome and please familiarize yourself with the information on our sidebar as well as this post before proceeding!!

If you are an existing user here, welcome back!!


The purpose of this post is to get out important information that has been posted over the past few months all compiled into one.

The reason for this is we are almost at 10k subs, and we are constantly seeing/hearing about similar issues and reports popping up.

PLEASE READ THROUGH THIS IF YOU HAVEN'T ALREADY!!


MODMAIL

(Click section title to send us a modmail)

First of all, if there are any issues, questions, etc.

Please message the mod team using modmail.

DO NOT message individual mods privately. This stops the mod team as a whole, from having access to the message history thread.


Comic Swap FLAIR Bot

(Click the section title to see the original flair bot instructions post)

Our flair bot doesn't seem to be having any issues at the moment, and no reports.
We just want to make sure you folks know how to use the bot so please click the section title or read the following instructions.

A user can get trade feedback with the following process:

  • User A makes a thread on r/comicswap which follows all of the sub rules

  • User B comments on that thread, initiating a trade and following all of the sub rules

  • Users A and B complete their trades following all of the sub rules

  • Once the trade is complete, User A makes a top level comment (new comment) on their original post tagging both the user they traded with and /u/Comic_FlairBot .

    • DO NOT COPY PASTE THE BOT'S NAME. Reddit does some weird stuff with markdown and if you copy and paste the bot's name, it will create a markdown hyperlink instead of actually tagging the bot, so the bot will have no idea you're trying to summon it. Please just type it out. It is supposed to be easy to remember for a reason. You can check if you messed up the formatting yourself by going to old reddit (on desktop) and clicking show source under your comment. If your comment looks like [u/Comic_FlairBot](https://www.reddit.com/u/Comic_FlairBot) then you did it wrong. Please delete the text in your comment and manually type out the bot's name.

  • User B replies to that comment by saying “confirmed”

  • Comic_FlairBot picks up the interaction and gives credit to both users, changing their flair accordingly and leaves a comment indicating as such.

  • If User A messes up their top level comment, Comic_FlairBot will do its best to notify User A.

There are automatic checks in the code to detect anyone trying to cheat the system. If the bot detects anything suspicious, it will alert the moderators for manual review. Manual reviews will be conducted periodically without prompting from the bot as well. Anyone found abusing (or attempting to abuse) the system will receive an automatic ban.


Automoderator (Bot)

Thanks to u/RegExr we now will get the bot to post a comment on every single post with the amount of trades that has been done by the original poster.!


Paypal G&S MANDATORY

  • Only Paypal G&S must be used

    • Paypal F&F, Google Pay, Venmo, etc are no longer allowed.

  • Fees must be covered by the seller, please be sure to calculate for this in your pricing.

    • No more "add 3%" allowed!

    • No adding fees after the advertised sale price!

      • For example: "Books $25 + Shipping & Fees" ❌

      • For example: "Books $25 (fees included) + Shipping" ✔️


RULES of Comicswap

(Click section title to get to our WIKI index)

We have our rules listed and available on our wiki as well as our sidebar.

Please be sure to follow the rules prior to making your posts.

One of the most important is to always keep discussions in COMMENTS prior to moving to PM for shipping/payment info.

This helps cut down on scammers leading to my next point...


SCAMMERS & the UNIVERSAL SCAMMER LIST

(Click "universal scammer list" to get to the search page of USL)

This is important because no one wants to be scammed. Thus our rule #7.

Please do your due diligence and check users out prior to finalizing sales. When in doubt always trust your gut!

You can always check a username to see if they are banned or not by using the USL search system.


PRINTING VARIATIONS / VARIANTS

(original PSA can be read in full HERE)

Due to all the printing variations and general variants out there, we ask that sellers mention exactly what variant/printing version their goods are.

Also, when listing a series that has more than ONE of the same name, make sure you include all the info a person needs to distinguish which series it is. Such as year, writer/artist, arc, etc.


Well that's it for this collected sticky post for the time being.

Thanks for sticking by this sub, we love you all.

Happy readings!

-r/comicswap mod team


r/comicswap • • Mar 10 '26

[US-MN] [H] Scammer chiefbadtouch [W] Paypal

93 Upvotes

PSA

User Chiefbadtouch tried scamming me tonight with Avengers Omnis. He went straight to DMs. It was immediately obviously a scam, but I played along until he sent a terrible photoshop. Did a search on his name and he has tried scamming people in this subreddit multiple times in the past. I'm blocked by him now, but his account is definitely still active.

Be safe out there.


r/comicswap • • Nov 24 '22

[US-IN] [H] A Happy Thanksgiving [W] You To Have One Too

88 Upvotes

Happy Thanksgiving to all who are celebrating today! Chill out, eat too much, read some of those comics you've swapped! You've earned it!


r/comicswap • • Sep 02 '22

[USA] [H] Suggestion [W] Nothing

83 Upvotes

When you've sold a book, PLEASE don't replace your sold price with "SOLD" or something, wiping out the original price. It's useful to be able to see what books sold for in this marketplace to gauge what I should be asking for when selling or expecting when buying.

Thanks.


r/comicswap • • Oct 27 '21

[H]Scammer u/Teddyrose13 [W]you to be careful

78 Upvotes

He was banned today for acting like a petulant child when he was second inline for a book and didn’t get it. He then started reporting comments and posts for various reasons. We jumped in and told him to stop reporting them because he felt entitled instead of seeing that u/bingbonged showed interest in it 14 minutes earlier, OP delivered pics and swap was made and taken to PM. I see nothing wrong with the way this went down.

Then he screamed at me for calling him out on it and still didn’t look at the very visible time stamps. He then took to modmail and reported over a dozen posts for sexual content and inciting violence against redditors.

I banned him and this was his message.

https://imgur.com/a/0ONJh9W

“I also have open transactions THAT I WONT BE SHIPPING. Thank you for the $$$$!!!!”

(Which I read in the alamo drafthouse Magnited Entitled girl’s voice)

I’ve reported him and tagged him as a scammer so that all groups that use the same flairbot (all BST) - know that his intent is to steal people’s money now. I would suggest you reach out to him and decide your next course of action with PayPal, etc…


r/comicswap • • Dec 25 '24

[Cali] [W] EVERYONE TO HAVE A MERRY CHRISTMAS (OR YOUR FAVORITE CELEBRATION) [H] AVING ONE OF MY OWN.😁

76 Upvotes

Whichever holiday or tradition you celebrate, may you have a wonderful one.

I hope each and every one of my extended family here, which is all of you, a most joyous time, now and throughout the new year.

May all your troubles be small, and blessings be huge.

Also, I hope everyone gets at least one of their grails, if not for the holiday, then at least sometime in 2025. 🤗


r/comicswap • • Feb 26 '21

[TX] [H] Boxes of comics to give away [W] Nothing, all free, give them a good home

76 Upvotes

UPDATE: All boxes taken and recipients contacted. Again, apologies if I did not get back to you, got a ton of replies. All the best. Keep reading!

UPDATE: Thanks for the many responses! I will review the messages and will respond to the recipients over the weekend. I know people are asking if all the boxes are taken. Sorry, I don't know and won't until I get a chance to review all the responses. I am glad these comics will have good homes!

Hi all,

I have 12 boxes of comics to give away. The descriptions of the boxes are below. If you want a box:

(i) Send me a message (not a chat). The last time I did this, a few asked how to message-- click on my username; under “chat”, click on “More Options”; then click “Send Message.” (The messages are easy to keep track of for something like this, chats are not.)

(ii) In the message:

  • Tell me which box you want,

  • Tell me your name, phone number and address (for shipping),

  • Give me your word that you won’t sell the comics, and that they will be for you or someone you to know to keep and read (for at least the foreseeable future),

  • Confirm you are 18 or older (I won’t mail anything to kids so if under 18, please get your parents to message me).

I will pay for shipping.

It will generally be first come, first serve. But also I am kind of a sap. If you have a real love for one of these and are in the top few for that box, you will probably get it.

Forgive me if I don’t reply to your message. The last time I did this, I got a ton of replies. But I will let you know if you are getting a box (tomorrow or over the weekend).

I loved collecting these. Give them a good home and have fun with them!

Info on the boxes is below--

Punisher Box

  • Punisher (87 series), issues 2 – 25

Ultimates 2 Box

  • Ultimates 2 full series run, issues 1-12

  • Some bonus Cap issues

PG-13-Rated TPB Box

  • Cowboys and Aliens (TPB)

  • The Highwaymen (TPB)

  • Irredeemable vol 1 and vol 10 (TPB)

  • Top Cow’s Best of Michael Turner (TPB)

  • GI Joe: Cobra (TPB)

  • Astro City: Life in the Big City (TPB)

  • Flaming Carrot (TPB)

  • Hitman: A Rage in Arkham (TPB)

  • Hitman: Ten Thousand Bullets (TPB)

R-Rated TPB Box

  • Sin City: The Big Fat Kill (TPB)

  • Sin City: Booze, Broads and Bullets (TPB)

  • Aliens: Dead Orbit (TPB)

  • League of Extraordinary Gentlemen vol 2 (Hardcover)

  • Crossed (TPB)

  • Wolfskin: Hundredth Dream (TPB)

  • Orc Stain (TPB)

  • Saga (TPB)

  • Kick-Ass 2 (Hardcover)

Marvel TPB Box

  • Marvel Visionaries: Jack Kirby (Hardcover)

  • Wizard: Spider Man Masterpiece Edition (Hardcover)

  • Thor Visionaries: Walter Simonson (TPB)

  • Swamp Thing: Book 1 (Moore) (TPB)

  • Swamp Thing: Book 3 (Moore) (TPB)

  • Marvel Zombies vs Army of Darkness (Hardcover)

Image Box

  • 35-40 issues of early Image (Spawn (including 9 and 10), Dragon, Shadowhawk, WildCats); a few number ones (Savage Dragon, Stormwatch, Supreme, Tribe); Spawn 9 and 10

  • Bonus Ninjak #1

Batman/Superman Box

  • Batman: Son of the Demon (Hardcover)

  • World’s Finest (TPB)

  • 30 issues of Batman and Superman titles from 90s through modern era

Wolverine Box

  • Note on this one: These meant a lot to me. If you want this box, please let me know you have a real Wolverine love.

  • Wolverine (1988 Series) 17-57 (missing only one or two issues)

  • Wolverine: The Scorpio Connection (Hardcover)

  • X-Men (Jim Lee/Claremont) #1

  • Alpha Flight #51 (First Jim Lee Marvel)

  • Marvel Comics Presents 72-83 (but missing 79) The Weapon X series.

X Box

  • Old Man Logan (Hardcover)

  • Ultimate X-Men (TPB)

  • 50-60 issues of 90s-modern X-titles (some X-Men, Wolverine, X-Factor, X-Force)

Serenity and Angel Box

  • Note on this one: Yeah I know. No judgments if you want this one. I still like the shows too.

  • Serenity miniseries (Cassaday covers)

  • Angel After the Fall (TPB)

  • Spike (TPB)

  • Spike Asylum (TPB)

  • Astonishing X Men 1 (TPB)

  • Serenity Still Flying (softcover coffee table book)

Ellis Box

  • Gravel: Never A Dull Day (Big Hardcover; signed by Ellis and Wolfer)

  • Gravel: Bloody Liars

  • Gravel: The Major Seven

  • Crecy (little TPB)

  • The Authority vol 1 (Hardcover)

  • Transmetropolitan vol 10 (TPB)

  • Doktor Sleepless vol 1 (TPB)

  • Supergod (TPB)

  • Planetary vol 1 (TPB)

Star Wars Box

  • Vader Down (TPB)

  • George Lucas: The Creative Impulse (big hardcover coffee table book)

  • From Star Wars to Indiana Jones: The Best of the Lucasfilm Archives (big softcover coffee table book)

  • The Art of Star Wars Episode I (hardcover)

  • Star Wars: The Making of Episode I (softcover)

  • Clone Wars Season 1 (blu ray box set)

  • Clone Wars Season 2 (blu ray box set)


r/comicswap • • Aug 11 '20

[US-MO] [H] Had Hernia Surgery [W] To Thank Everyone For Their Support/Buy Some Good and Cheap Reads

74 Upvotes

Post surgery celebration pic: https://imgur.com/a/wxwyZsS

Hey all! As I posted about, I had my hernia surgery yesterday. I am already back home, but very sore. It went successfully so now I’ll just be recovering. I may not have any posts of sales for a week or two, but may be commenting on any posts with great reads I may wanna buy while I’m here at home sitting about or should you have a good cheap comic or trade I might like to buy feel free to comment. I just wanted to say how much I appreciate all of you and love this community. You all rock and I appreciate your well-wishes and support!


r/comicswap • • Mar 26 '26

GIVEAWAY [USA-OR] [W] Giveaway [H] Y: The Last Man 1-10tpb complete

Post image
72 Upvotes

UPDATE: recipient confirmed: u/eliasmejia

Greetings,

This week's giveaway was donated by the patrons of the 11 O'Clock Comics Podcast. I have been a member of their community for years and recommend checking out the show.

**Please read, new entry rule -- to enter: comment with the last comic you read and whether or not you liked it/recommend it**

US shipping addresses only. I reserve the right to disqualify entries if shenanigans are suspected. A recipient will be selected via random number generator on Sunday 3/29.


r/comicswap • • May 31 '25

BOUGHT [Location] [H] Whale acquired …friend made [W] Scalpers to stop

Post image
72 Upvotes

This community rocks!! This seller u/frijolie is by and large one of the coolest cats out there. Totally legit totally not an a$$, nor a scalper super fare and by far amazing. He reached out on a comment a made randomly and said he had the one I’ve been after. What an amazing soul!! Cheers to you 🍺 May you be so lucky to meet people like this. Karma is a real thing.


r/comicswap • • Jan 06 '26

SELLING [AZ][H] Custom Bound Green Lantern 5 volumes [W] Paypal

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

This is a set that was custom bound for me by Herring & Robinson back in the day. It is the Geoff Johns Green Lantern Saga. It goes from Rebirth to The End. It contains all the issues of Green Lantern, Green Lantern Corps, as well as in volume 5 The New Guardians & Red Lanterns. They are custom bound in reading order by story arc. (Typically 5-6 issues of GL then 5-6 issues of GLC then GL again.)

$500


r/comicswap • • Sep 04 '26

[US-OR] [W] Giveaway [H] 3 IMAGE HCs

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

UPDATE: Recipient confirmed and package sent: u/moeezatif

Greetings!

Giveaway is for the pictured 3 Image hardcovers.

To enter: make any comment.

US shipping addresses only. I reserve the right to disqualify any entry for shenanigans. A recipient will be selected via random number generator on Monday 9/7.


r/comicswap • • Oct 08 '25

[US-OR] [W] Giveaway [H] 71 issues of ALL-IN Superman

Post image
64 Upvotes

UPDATE: a recipient has been confirmed: u/batmax25

Greetings,

This week I am giving away 71 issues of the ALL-IN Superman Family mainline. This is near complete - not included is Absolute SM, the Krypto mini, the recent Book of El mini - other than that, I believe it is everything Superman since the ALL-IN initiative launched. A great jumping on point.

Batman/Superman: World's Finest 30-42
Action Comics 1070-1090
Superman 19-30
Justice League Unlimited 1-10
Superman Unlimited 1-5
Supergirl 1-5
Superwoman Special
Lex Luther Special
Summer of Superman Special
Justice League Dark Tomorrow Special

I think that's it, I'm not going to do the math. I am going to ship them in this order, which is chronological by release date, so that you can read the whole line in the order it was released.

Rules:
-Make a comment to be placed in the raffle.
-NO FLIPPING. I can't really enforce this but it is the type of thing that will stop me from continuing these giveaways.
-US postal addresses only.
-These have never been bagged, they are not going to be bagged, they are coming in their natural form in a DCBS box. Raw dog. I will rotate each issue to prevent bending.
-I will use a random number generator based on number of comments next Tuesday and reach out to the recipient. Please confirm your details within a day.

EDIT: I'm disappointed that I need to return to say this: 1 entry per person (including using multiple accounts). Gaming the numbers will probably result in disqualification.

thanks,


r/comicswap • • Sep 04 '25

[USA-OR] [H] 3 Giveaways [W] Nothing

Post image
63 Upvotes

UPDATE: All winners have been confirmed:

  1. u/Find-random-stuff

  2. u/Dunkmunk

  3. u/FoxHoundDavid

Greetings, I have 3 giveaways:

  1. 5 indie TPBs as show

  2. 5 issues of the underground anthology Clusterfux

  3. Birthright Book One

To enter: comment which of the three you want to be considered for.

Rules: One entry per household. I’ll reach out to winners next Thursday. I was doing giveaways on IG and quit when I ended up sending two lots to the same address (they used multiple accounts to increase their chances). It soured the experience for me - until the package is in the mail I reserve the right to select a different winner. Shipping to US addresses only.

I’m not promoting or selling anything. Just looking to give comics away. If it goes well there will be more in the future.

Cheers,


r/comicswap • • Jan 07 '20

[USA-TX][H]Original David Finch Moon Knight Art [W]$$$/keys/slabs

Post image
63 Upvotes