Me again, with this time with another Homtom phone, the S9 Plus. Thanks to Homtom for providing one.
The S9 Plus' name might imply that the S9 is a sequel of sorts to the Homtom S8 I also recently reviewed, though it's more like a cousin. Both have their debut at around the same time, both are the same price (the S9 plus is actually cheaper at gearbest right now), and as you'll see, internally the devices are very similar. To that end, I'm reviewing this more as a comparison between the S9 Plus and the S8, as I assume Homtom intended these two devices this way, to complement each other and not the S9 as a replacement for the S8.
Specs
Mediatek 6750T, 8x A53 in a big.LITTLE 4x 1.5Ghz and 4x 1.0Ghz setup, ARM Mali T860 MP2 GPU
4GB DDR3L RAM, 64GB Storage, MicroSDXC supported
5.99" 18:9 1440x720 IPS In-Cell LCD
Android 7 with more drastic cosmetic changes, feature additions
Sensors: Ambient Light, Accelerometer, Proximity... and that's it.
Cameras: 16+5MP Rear, 13MP front.
4,050mAh battery, unnamed fast charging.
Unboxing, Design & Hardware
The S9 Plus (I'll just call it the S9 from here on) comes packaged almost identically to the S8. We get a minimal black box, with the phone greeting you when you remove the lid. Included with the phone are a spare screen protector (one is also pre-applied), a clear case (hard one this time, that snaps on to the back and sides), Micro USB Cable, 5V 2A charger, SIM tray eject tool and USB OTG cable.
As for the device itself, it's a beast. Whereas the S8 is round and super smooth with curves, the S9 has flat, defined edges with solid sides. It feels built like a tank. It also feels much larger and thicker than the S8, even though in actual fact it isn't.
The midframe is a matte metal with chamfered edges front and back, and both the front and back have a more defined edge with the front 2.5D glass and rear plastic panel, the grip factor on this phone is great, you won't drop it easily when holding it sideways for photos and so on.
Some buttons and ports are in alternate positions from the S8, as on the S9 the power and volume buttons (which are also metal and sturdy) have swapped to the right hand side, and the headphone jack (yay!) has moved to the top. The MicroUSB port is still at the bottom, and it's still upside down :)
This phone's major defining feature though is of course the front, with those slim bezels on three sides and that monster 6 inch display. Side bezels are clearly thinner on the S9 than on the S8 here, though due to its larger display the overall width is more or less identical. The S9 is about 1cm taller despite its thin top bezel, again due to the larger display. The S9's bottom bezel is a little larger than the S8's in order to house the fingerprint sensor, though overall the S9 easily has a higher screen to body ratio.
The earpiece and notification LED, along with the ambient light and proximity sensors still live up top above the display in the trimmed upper bezel, though the front-facing 13 megapixel camera has taken a trip to the bottom left corner.
Speaking of the front-mounted fingerprint sensor, it's also a real button and can be clicked, acting as a home button. Gestures can also be used with it to swap recent apps or go back, meaning if you want to you, can hide the navigation bar and have that huge 6 inch display all to yourself for your apps.
Fingerprint unlocking is very fast on this sensor. The S9 responds with vibration feedback with the fingerprint sensor, hopefully this is also coming to the S8 via OTA. I didn't need to add the same finger twice to get reliable unlocking here, I got perfect unlocking from the get go. If this is just because it's on the front and so I'm using my thumb and not a finger, I don't know.
Overall, I'll say again that the S9 feels well built. It has little extra details here and there, such as the slightly larger 2.5D curve radius at the top, or the metal wire grille earpiece speaker mesh, the radial engraving on the power button to make it feel unique, or the raised camera lens metal discs and their metallic circular inserts. All combine to give the phone a more premium look and feel than its price point.
The S8's CNC metal midframe machining is not sloppy by any means, but the S9's edges and joins are just that little bit more precise and exact.
They have to be, as my last point about the design is that in order to achieve the smallest bezel possible, the front display glass joins directly with the metal midframe. There's no plastic lip here, which is a plus or minus depending on your preferences. If you're clumsy it could mean a broken screen more easily as there's less protection for the glass from shocks, but if you love the sleek subdued look and slimmest bezels, it's great.
Display
I had some slight criticisms of the S8's display with its colour and white balance, something just seemed.. off. Thankfully, I could use MiraVision to tweak it though, so it wasn't a big issue.
I don't see any such need to open MiraVision with the S9; the display is clearly superior. It's still 1440x720, just like the S8, though compared to the S8, whites are whiter, colours are a little more vibrant and maximum brightness is brighter (and with 6 inches, is blinding at night!). Like the S8, minimum brightness is almost invisible. Viewing angles and colour shifting at angles are minimal on both.
(I should add, I'm using an app to draw rounded corners, the display has square corners)
In classic Homtom fashion, the display uses an unusual refresh rate. Past Homtom devices I've used have all refreshed at 53Hz, though interestingly the S9 refreshes at... 61hz. Why not, I guess? They can boast about having a higher refresh rate than 99.9% of of other Android devices this way :)
Perhaps in part due to its even larger size, but fast accurate movements like touch typing are a breeze on the S9, touch response is fast. We get the standard 5 finger multitouch support.
Homtom advertises an In-cell touch display, and it's demonstrable. Standing a flashlight on the display doesn't leak any light whatsoever, there is no seperate digitizer layer. Whereas the S8 display, which is not in-cell, emits a glow around the light as the digitizer requires an additional layer which lets light propogate. Still, we've come a long way from many layers and also large air gaps that give an image ghost effect :)
The only remaining downside of the S9's display is its resolution, since at 6 inches a display remaining "only" 720p makes pixels more obvious, but only if you look for them. Other chinaphones with 18:9 displays are sometimes using 2160x1080 over 1440x720, though of course those devices are priced higher, outside the price bracket the S8 and S9 sit in. Of the 2, the S9 display is definitely my favourite over the S8's.
Software, Performance
The S9 has a more skinned version of Android 7.0 Nougat than the S8. Instead of the regular dark quick settings pulldown, homtom has opted for a fully white one here. Perhaps this was done to show off the slimmer bezels? This light theme also extends to the settings, with coloured icons too. Overall, it looks ok to me. I like the minimal look to the icons.
Features
As is common with homtom, gesture support is implemented far and wide. One criticism I would have is that these gesture options are spread out over multiple seperate submenus, and sometimes the English translation is a little off. Though I guess these things are a set once and forget type deal.
For starters you can do multiple gestures with the fingerprint sensor, along with the sensor itself being a clickable button to go home.
In another menu, bizarrely titled "Kinect", we have the common flipping the phone to mute a call and a few others. If you're a fan of double tap to wake then you're in luck, that's here too in another submenu. And finally we also have the ability to draw shapes to open directly into various actions or apps.
There is also an entry in the settings app named Screen Assistant, which enables a floating menu that opens into home, back etc buttons. It reminds me somewhat of PIE controls, though the button to bring out the menu is always visible.
Also present, just as a seperate app in your launcher, is "Super Power". Opening this app drops the phone into a power saving state, limiting screen brightness and presenting the bare basics for phone usage. It appears to work more than just a simple app, as you cannot press home to exit it, and it seems to prevent or limit background services since you will see certain apps that aggressively try to keep running in the background such as google play services show not responding errors, which I guess means it is working. When leaving Super Power mode, my normal Launcher re-draws and apps that were in ram have to re-load.
Performance - Wireless
Mobile signal stability on the S9 is identical to the S8, I took both with me on a countryside walk and they both lost and regained signal in the same places (where my major brand flagships also lose signal). They both switched between 3G/4G at roughly the same times too. This is with two SIM cards from the same network, Three UK.
Speeds are another story, I was consistently able to get faster LTE speeds with the S9 than the S8, though both were perfectly usable. If you're a heavy downloader or a streamer or something, it may be something to consider.
On the flipside, WiFi speed is only average when using 2.4Ghz on the S9, even right next to the router. Switching to 5Ghz more than doubles the speed though. Nevertheless, while speed is nothing special, at least it remains connected with no problem unlike the Crystal :)
Bluetooth (BT4 and LE supported) is fine, for both LE fitness tracker use and for longer range bluetooth speaker usage.
Like the S8, GPS is great on the S9, locking almost instantly. However unlike the S8 there is no compass, so maps will not rotate.
Performance - Benchmarks
When it comes to synthetic benchmarks, the S9 outperforms the S8 every time. Whereas the S8 just barely reached 39,000 in antutu, the S9 reaches up to 44,000. The same goes for geekbench, the S8 scored 602 / 2353 single/multi-core, and the S9 scores 620 / 2684, despite both phones having the same MT6750T chip.
But synthetic benchmarks don't really translate to real world usage, as in reality both phones perform the same when it comes to opening apps and switching recents and so on. Perhaps the S9's CPU profile allows it to clock higher on more cores simultaneously due to its thicker metal design allowing for more heat dissipation. It certainly can get noticeably warm when running multiple benchmarks successively.
NAND performance benchmarked markedly worse on the S9, with read speeds almost half that of the S8. Write speed is only slightly slower. Again though, in reality there doesn't seem to be any difference between the two in real world usage. On the flip side, the S9's RAM consistently benchmarks much faster than the S8's, over twice as fast.
Performance - Audio
As always, with a mediatek phone one of the things on my list of things to do when setting it up is to enter engineering mode and remove the headphone jack volume limit. After doing so, I can't tell a difference between the S9 and the S8. Either Homtom used the same components, or the drivers are part of the MT6750T, or the same power is allocated by the Kernel, who knows. Audio output seems identical to me, which is a good thing as it has plenty of headroom and an almost invisible noise floor, only audible when in utter silence with closed headphones at maximum volume.
Like the S8, the S9 is more than capable of driving big headphones (I use Sony XB500s) to skull vibrating levels while maintaining clarity, even with a fat EQ and preamp :)
Performance - Battery & Charging
Again homtom provides a 5V2A charger with the S9, and the highest I saw the S9 pulling with my USB power monitor was just under 1.4A, which is slightly higher than what I saw the S8 drawing.
Homtom claims a 4050mAh battery, and this is definitely a hard phone to kill. When trying to run it down to empty it refused to die until the very end of the day after heavy usage, so safe to say you won't have empty battery problems with normal usage on this phone.
Under normal usage (which for me is mostly messaging, some web browsing, reddit client, playing music etc), I got two days out of the phone, with just over 6 hours screen on time, which is great for a device with a 6" display and a 28nm 6750T CPU.
Cameras
Like the S8, the S9 reports having a Sony IMX135 main camera sensor. This sensor used to be common among major brand high end flagships like the Galaxy S4 and LG G3. It's an interesting strategy to use older high end sensors instead of more modern low end sensors when allocating your materials budget to build the phone, but it seems to work well, as just like its cousin, the S9 takes some great pictures.
And when collecting the pictures I took on it, I had to double check which ones are from the S9 and which are from the S8. Both seem to take completely identical pictures in the same situations. If it isn't broke, don't fix it, right? :)
Of course, we still have the somewhat unrealistic HDR (more sensible in lower light), and the software bokeh blur mode. These seem ubiquitous among MTK ISP powered devices these days though.
Autofocus is no issue unlike the Umi Crystal, and white balance doesn't need manually adjusting in my opinion.
The flash is noticeably dimmer; the S9 has just one flash LED vs the S8's dual LED flash. It will do if you're close to your subject, or when used as a flashlight it's only useful up close.
Video
Video on the S9 is a different story compared to the S8, with upsides and downsides.
The upside is that video brightness is higher on the S9, or rather that as the ambient light falls, brightness remains higher for longer on the S9. On the S8, you need a decent amount of light, else videos can come out quite dark. The S9 has no problem recording video with much less light around. Hopefully the video brightness / exposure peformance of the S9 can be ported to the S8 via OTA.
The downsides though, are with the EIS and the sound. While the EIS still works and stabilizes the video a little, the effect isn't as strong. Perhaps this is due to the lack of a gyroscope on the S9. You'll have to make more of an effort to hold the phone steady when recording, and recording video whilst walking is pretty much ruled out.
When it comes to sound, the S9 also has just one microphone, whereas the S8 has dual mics. Audio quality from the mic is also a little worse, being just ok instead of great.
As for the video files themselves, they come out identical. 17mbit/s H264 High profile, at 1080p30 (when using the fine setting), though the audio track is still saved in stereo despite there being one mic.
Interestingly, the S9 also offers a high framerate recording option not found on the S8, giving 60fps video though reducing the resolution to 480p as a tradeoff.
Conclusion
Overall, it seems up to preference if you were going to choose between these two phones. One isn't objectively better than the other, it's up to you what you'd like more. Smooth and curved or hard and blocky, somewhat large or very large display, front or back fingerprint sensor, top or bottom headphone jack, the list goes on. For the price asked, it's hard to fault it.
Hopefully if you're stuck considering, I've helped you decide :)