r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 31 '25

News & Culture Local lobsterman who has been selling lobsters from his house since 1975, has been ordered to stop sales due to a neighbor complaint

482 Upvotes

Jon Tolley has been selling fresh lobsters from his home in West Yarmouth since 1975, and his father did the same for nearly 30 years before that from the same house. Now he has been told to stop.

“I’m 66 and I have been a fisherman my whole life,” Tolley said. He fishes out of Sesuit Harbor in Dennis. “Everyone knows I sell lobsters,” he said.

Yarmouth Building Commissioner Mark Grylls has ordered Tolley to stop selling his lobsters from his home at 23 Iroquois Blvd. in West Yarmouth because retail sales in a residential zone are not allowed under zoning regulations. “I have to follow the regulations,” he said Wednesday. The town received a complaint about Tolley’s sales from a West Yarmouth resident, Grylls said.

Tolley is seeking to overturn Grylls’ order and will ask the Zoning Board of Appeals on April 10 to allow him to continue selling lobsters from his home.

“The town is trying to say that no one has sold lobsters in the history of the town,” Tolley said, and recalled his father and his grandfather, who sold fish from his home in Yarmouth Port from 1930 to 1972.

“It’s not right,” Tolley said.

Tolley said he was told at a previous zoning board meeting that his business from his home was grandfathered in.

He has lobster pots in his yard, but Tolley said neighbors have not complained.

He has a large customer following based on many photos on his website. He said he has sold his lobsters to local police, town staff and thousands of others and received no complaints, except for one in the early 1990s about a sign in front of his house. He now puts out a temporary sign for two hours on Route 28.

The location of temporary signs must be approved by the building commissioner, according to the regulations, and a permit and fee are required. Grylls said Tolley is not seeking release from the sign regulations.

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 23 '26

A Cape Codder's Idea of the U.S.A.

Post image
309 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Jun 14 '25

Community & Local Life Orleans hosts first-ever Lower Cape Pride Parade

Post image
287 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 08 '26

On Cape Cod, hunger hides in ‘paradise’

Post image
208 Upvotes

By day, she baked for locals and summer visitors at a pair of popular Cape Cod cafes. At night, she pulled her car into a nearby parking lot and tucked into a sleeping bag, trying to stay out of sight.

Victoria, who asked that her last name not be used, slept in her car for seven months over the last year, from the height of the Cape’s annual tourism boom in July through the depths of the regional hibernation in February.

Even in the full swing of the summer, when she worked as much as 50 hours per week, affording a one-bedroom rental at Cape Cod prices seemed impossible.

When one of the cafes where she worked closed for the winter, and the other laid her off for the season, her local food pantry became a lifeline.

Beneath the veneer of comfort and wealth in one of the Northeast’s most popular vacation destinations, thousands of working residents on Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket labor to make ends meet — and afford enough to eat.

A confluence of factors is responsible: the painfully high cost of living, an extraordinary housing crunch and an economy that blossoms seasonally but leaves many workers without consistent income in the off-season.

As jobs, income and circumstances change, local food pantries and other aid organizations step in to help, stretching limited resources as far as they will go.

“I know plenty of people who have left because they can’t afford to be here. Some of them were oystermen. Some of them were landscapers. Their families are here, and their friends are here, but they can’t afford it,” Victoria, 34, said in a recent in-person interview.

The unemployment rate fell last summer to about 4% on the Cape and Islands, below the statewide rate of 4.8%.

But while the statewide unemployment rate stays largely steady as winter sets in, the rate in the Cape region more than doubles, according to state data.

Continue Reading


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 10 '26

First right whale mothers and calves of the season spotted in Cape Cod Bay

Post image
168 Upvotes

Center for Coastal Studies aerial observers marked an important annual milestone Monday, spotting the season’s first North Atlantic right whale mothers and their calves in Cape Cod Bay.

This was the busiest survey of the season so far, with an aggregation of over 40 right whales observed deep diving in the southwest corner of the bay, likely feeding below the surface.

Two mothers and their calves were sighted in the middle of the bay, traveling southwest, likely on their way to join the feeding aggregation.

The first right whale mother was identified as Millipede, a 21-year-old female first seen as a calf on New Year's Eve in 2004. She was with her third calf, which was first observed Dec. 3, 2025 by Florida's Fish and Wildlife Research Institute. Millipede last calved in 2021. Her last calf, was documented by the CCS aerial team in Cape Cod Bay March 2.

The second right whale mother was identified as Mantis. Mantis was first documented in 1986, but her age is unknown. This is her eighth calf, which was first observed Dec. 26, 2025 by the Clearwater Marine Aquarium Research Institute's aerial survey team in South Carolina.

Mantis last calved in 2022. Her 2015 calf was also seen in Cape Cod Bay March 2.

According to Ryan Schosberg, aerial observer and right whale researcher at the Center for Coastal Studies, “about two and a half hours into a busy survey documenting a large aggregation of right whales in the southwest corner of Cape Cod Bay, we noticed what appeared to be a lone whale outside the dense group we had been working on. As we approached, we saw a second, smaller dark shape beneath the surface. When the calf finally surfaced, it confirmed we had found the first right whale mother-calf pair in the bay this season. We immediately identified the mother as Millipede due to her distinct boat propeller scar on her right flank.

Not even an hour later, we spotted another pair directly below the plane, our second mom-calf pair of the day. Seeing two early arrivals is exciting, and we’re hopeful that more mothers and calves will follow as they make their way north from the calving grounds.”

North Atlantic right whales calve off the coast of the southeast United States in winter before migrating north to New England and Canadian feeding grounds. Each year, Cape Cod Bay is host to one of the largest feeding aggregations of right whales during winter and early spring.

This season, researchers from the Center for Coastal Studies have already observed more than 100 individual right whales in the bay. The first right whale sighting of the 2025-2026 field season was on Dec. 5. On Jan. 10, CCS researchers observed 33 North Atlantic right whales, a record for January.

North Atlantic right whales are critically endangered. Their population is estimated to be just 384 individuals. So far this year, researchers have observed the highest number of calves in 15 years, an encouraging statistic.

“We have been eagerly awaiting the arrival of this year’s mothers and calves in Cape Cod Bay, and it is always encouraging to see them after their long and hazardous journey north through some of the busiest shipping waters on the East Coast," said Daniel Palacios, director of the Center’s right whale ecology Pprogram.

"Conditions in the bay appear favorable this season, with a strong food supply that we hope will support these mothers as they nurse and care for their calves. Each calf represents an important addition to this critically endangered population, and we are hopeful that many of this year’s mothers will spend time in Cape Cod Bay and that this year’s cohort will grow and thrive in the years ahead."

Ship strikes represent one of the greatest threats to North Atlantic right whales. Important efforts are being taken to reduce this danger. During right whale season, the state requires that vessels travel no faster than 10 knots in coastal waters and Cape Cod Bay where the whales aggregate.

Boaters, kayakers, paddle-boarders, swimmers and light aircraft and drone pilots are reminded that it is illegal to approach a North Atlantic right whale within 500 yards without a federal research permit. However, whales often feed very close to shore, offering watchers on the beach unbeatable views of one of the rarest of the marine mammals.

CCS right whale research and response operations are conducted in partnership with the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries and NOAA under federal permits issued by the National Marine Fisheries Service.

Support also comes from the Massachusetts Environmental Trust and contributions from other foundations, businesses and CCS supporters through the Center’s Right Whale Emergency Initiative.

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 04 '26

NOAA to rollback North Atlantic right whale protections

Post image
166 Upvotes

The National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration has announced plans to roll back protections for North Atlantic right whales as part of the Trump Administration’s ongoing efforts to deregulate across multiple government sectors.

There are fewer than 380 right whales left in the world, with roughly 70 females capable of bearing young. North Atlantic Right Whales, one of the most endangered species in the world, are frequently spotted by the dozens in the Gulf of Maine.

Vessel strikes and equipment entanglement are the leading causes of death, Rachel Rilee of the Center for Biological Diversity told Maine Public.

“NOAA Fisheries has determined that one death a year is too much for this species to be able to recover,” she said. “So they really are in dire straits.”

Rilee said reducing vessel speeds in endangered whale habitat has been proven to work. The speed limits have been in place since 2008.

“It has impacted mainly shipping companies, but those shipping companies have been in compliance for almost two decades now, she said. ”It’s built into their timelines, and they don’t have an issue with compliance.“

NOAA said it will explore new alternative tracking technology to protect the endangered species.
But Rilee said the nascent technologies aren’t proven and that reducing vessel speed in mapped areas is one of the only proven ways to reduce deaths.

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 10 '26

Anyone want to chip in on a slightly used ferryboat? At $325k, it's cheaper than most houses

Post image
162 Upvotes

A ferryboat that has plied Cape Cod waters since 1998 could soon leave them, after Steamship Authority officials on Tuesday voted to consider the potential sale of the M/V Governor.

The 242-foot-long, decades-old vessel is a back-up for carrying up to 250 passengers and freight between the Massachusetts mainland and the island of Martha’s Vineyard.

But the Steamship Authority has another standby, M/V Sankaty, and has said the 12-boat public fleet needs only one reserve.

The Sankaty is a larger and much newer boat, built in 1981.

The Governor launched in 1954, when it was known as the Crown City and ran a route off San Diego, according to historical records. In 1969 the boat was renamed as the Kulshan and shuttled among islands in Puget Sound, Washington – while being featured in the 1982 Oscar-winning movie, “An Officer and a Gentleman.”

The boat later transported passengers to and from Governors Island, off lower Manhattan, hence the name. The Massachusetts authority purchased the vessel in 1997.

The Governor “has far exceeded its useful life cycle,” wrote SSA General Manager Alex Kryska in a memo on Monday. With recent renovations to other vessels, he said, the Governor is redundant and should be put up for sale.

“Maintaining excess spare capacity results in approximately $1.5 million annually per vessel,” he wrote.

But at Tuesday’s meeting of the authority’s Port Council, some members questioned whether the Governor was the right choice – or at least if there was hard information to support it.

“You really want to have data,” said council member Eric Dawicki. “My gut says no, and folks on the Vineyard really love the Governor.”

Council member Nathaniel Lowell said, “I understand the nostalgia – the nostalgia is real. But if we have to pick, we have to pick the Sankaty [to continue service].”

The Port Council is an advisory body to the board of the authority, a quasi-public agency chartered by the state as the Woods Hole, Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket Steamship Authority. That's where the final decision will reside.

It’s not unusual for the authority to sell or buy ferryboats, as needs for service change and the watercraft eventually wear out. In 2024, the SSA sold two aging freight vessels, the Katama and the Gay Head, for a total of $250,000.

The Governor could ring a price tag of around $325,000, according to Krska, but the numbers are uncertain.

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 02 '25

Epic moment when a pod of dolphins join on our sail off Provincetown

158 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • May 12 '25

Lobsterman blocked from selling at his Cape Cod home: ‘Screwing my heritage’

156 Upvotes

A lifelong Cape Cod lobsterman says he feels like he’s in an “endless circle with town politics” as his local government is blocking him from selling lobsters this summer at his home, where the family business has operated for nearly 70 years.

Yarmouth resident Jon Tolley has to settle on a compromise with town officials in having to find a business on Route 28, the town’s main corridor, that will let him sell on their property. Lobster season starts within the next three weeks, he said, putting the businessman in a time crunch.

“The town is screwing around with my heritage, the Tolley family name, the history of Yarmouth being a fishing village, and the grandfathered rights of a citizen of Yarmouth,” he told the Herald on Saturday.

Tolley, his lawyers and hordes of supporters have argued over the past month that it doesn’t have to be this way for the lobster business, a community staple.

The battle with the mid-Cape town, of roughly 25,000 people, began late last August when Tolley received a violation notice that he said has startled him ever since: Retail sales in a residential district are not allowed under Yarmouth’s zoning regulations.

An unnamed West Yarmouth resident complained about a business sign Tolley put out on Route 28, prompting the fight, according to town officials. Tolley has argued that the complaint came from a Yarmouth police officer.

The complaint is the only one that Tolley said he remembers from over the decades.

The 66-year-old has caught lobsters out of Sesuit Harbor in Dennis and sold the fresh crustaceans from his home in West Yarmouth nearly his entire life. As a youngster, he helped his father, Fred, run the business on the same property before he took over operations in 1975.

Up to 1982, Yarmouth allowed the retail sale of fish as a commercial use in the residential district by right and without further permission, Tolley’s attorney, Jonathan Polloni, has emphasized.

Tension escalated at a chaotic meeting in April when the Zoning Board of Appeals shot down Tolley’s second appeal for a variance that would have let him continue selling the locally harvested lobster from where his father opened up shop in 1957.

The ZBA didn’t allow Tolley and his attorney to argue that the retail sale of lobster is protected as a pre-existing and permissible accessory use at the residence. Board Chairman Sean Igoe said their application was defective and repetitive from one submitted in a failed bid last fall, when Tolley represented himself.

Town officials have since offered Tolley a compromise: The Planning Board will draft an amendment to the zoning bylaw over the coming months that residents will then vote on at a fall special town meeting, in October or November.

If all goes smoothly, Tolley will be allowed to operate his business again from his property in the 2026 season. But for this summer, he will have to find somewhere else to sell from.

Tolley told the Herald that he learned through Town Administrator Robert Whritenour that no board can override current zoning bylaws. Whritenour did not immediately respond to a Herald request for comment on Friday.

“This is putting a financial burden on me, and the town can’t do anything about it,” Tolley said Saturday. “We need to have a change in Yarmouth town government.”

In an email to the Planning Board last week, Town Planner Kathy Williams outlined provisions that the board can consider to mitigate a commercial use in a residential district: limited to those with a commercial fishing license and commercial fishing retail license, businesses can only sell what they catch, among others.

Planning Board Clerk Will Rubenstein told residents who attended last Wednesday’s meeting that he was “quite pleased” about “reasonable conversation” being held after the “bizarre” ZBA meeting last month.

In that meeting, the ZBA chairman, who participated remotely over Zoom, ordered police to clear the room due to the tension between the board and residents.

Rubenstein acknowledged that board members are not aware of every single bylaw in town, and that conversations with the community are important for education building.

“I am a little frustrated because as much as I support you, both in the long term and short term,” he told Tolley, “I am not sure that this board can give you the short-term relief that you are looking for.”

Sales start in the middle of June when Tolley typically opens up his two driveways for patrons to stop by and grab their lobsters between 4 and 6:30 p.m., seven days a week. The lobsterman has a permit from the state Division of Marine Fisheries to sell to the public and restaurants, averaging 3,000 pounds sold a season, which ends in late October.

Tolley said he follows his family motto: “Fishing, farming, family, friends, and freedom on Cape Cod forever.” His grandfather, Walter, began the multi-generational business in the 1930s when he sold lobster from another residence in West Yarmouth.

“I don’t understand how one person made such chaos out of a simple situation,” resident Sally Johnson said of the complaint that has jeopardized Tolley’s business. “He is doing nothing wrong. He has been doing it for decades. You are taking a livelihood away from someone. … We have lost our way.”

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 05 '25

News & Culture Three federal workers fired at Cape Cod National Seashore: 'We're really concerned about the lack of staffing'

Thumbnail
bostonherald.com
141 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Jun 17 '25

Beaches & Nature Yesterday morning at Skaket Beach, Orleans

134 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Jan 25 '25

I used ChatGPT to turn our town slogans into postcards and the results are hilarious

Thumbnail
gallery
133 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 15 '25

Blasch House in Wellfleet is 100% gone (before and after video)

130 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Apr 11 '25

Community & Local Life Chaos ensues as Yarmouth Zoning Board refuses to hear Lobsterman's appeal, police called to clear the room (begins at 47:50)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
127 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Apr 10 '25

Cape Cod Lobsterman shut down by single complaint will face Yarmouth Zoning Board of Appeals today, April 10. Complainant unlikely to attend.

124 Upvotes

People looking for fresh lobster know where to go on Cape Cod. For 50 years, third-generation fisherman Jon Tolley has welcomed customers to his Yarmouth home, where he offers the day's catch. His father did the same thing at the same home, using a home-based business model that Tolley's grandfather pioneered in 1930 at a different location near the Bass Hole boardwalk.

The town of Yarmouth should celebrate this entrepreneurial spirit, and yet, the town ordered Tolley to cease and desist operations in March 2025—weeks before the start of a new season.

The reason has nothing to do with public health, safety, sanitation, or environmental concerns. Tolley has commercial fishing and retail licenses, and he complies with all requirements. Nor has the town mentioned traffic or parking concerns. Tolley has two massive driveways that easily accommodate his customers, including many who just walk from nearby.

Instead, the town is citing a zoning ordinance that prohibits sales in residential neighborhoods. The ordinance has no exceptions, even for fresh-caught lobster sold by a lobsterman in Cape Cod, where families have stayed afloat this way for centuries. According to the town, someone complained to authorities, but they will not say who.

"Everyone in the town knows I have been selling there my whole life," he writes on his Facebook page. "I have sold to building inspectors, Town Hall employees, selectpersons, police, firefighters, and residents of Cape Cod and beyond."

On March 7, Tolley was issued a violation notice for selling lobsters at his home, and Yarmouth has threatened him with daily fines of up to $300 if he does not cease operations.

For his part, Tolley only has heard support, and he does not intend to go away quietly. He will fight back at a Zoning Board of Appeals meeting on April 10. It is unlikely that he will face the person who issued the complaint.

Besides the economic implications of this move, the Building Department should consider the Constitution. The Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause does not allow arbitrary infringement of property rights. People can use their property in normal, productive ways, and the government cannot stop them without good reason.

Cities and towns routinely try this sort of thing. Home-based enterprises make popular targets, and the results can be ironic. Zoning officials ordered Lij Shaw to shut down a recording studio that he operated behind soundproof walls at his home in "Music City" Nashville, Tennessee. If Palo Alto, California, had taken this approach with Hewlett-Packard and shut down the region's first "garage startup" in 1939, Silicon Valley might never have emerged.

Once local inspectors take out their clipboards, even modest dreams can die. Zoning officials ordered single mom Bianca King to close her home-based daycare center in Lakeway, Texas. They ordered Art and Kimberly Dunckel to close a farm animal sanctuary on their rural property in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. And zoning officials blocked Peter and Annica Quakenbush from opening a green cemetery on their private woodland preserve in Brooks Township, Michigan.

We have seen just about everything at our public interest law firm, the Institute for Justice, as part of our Zoning Justice Project. Far too often, what is missing is common sense. Nobody wants a tannery, nightclub, or fireworks factory next door. But people rarely cross boundaries like these. They generally regulate themselves because they want to live peaceably with their neighbors.

Tolley shows how. He listens for community feedback and makes adjustments when necessary. All good businesses do the same. There is no other way to survive in one location for 50 years.

Code enforcers can step in when necessary. They have a role to play. But they should not rock the lobster boat, inventing problems that do not exist.

Source


r/CapeCodMA • • Oct 07 '26

Lady freaking out in Osterville

119 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Jul 02 '25

Beaches & Nature Beautiful Orleans, Ma

107 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 14 '26

Yuck or yum?

Post image
89 Upvotes

Cape Cod Potato Chips unveils limited-edition lemon herb butter potato chips for spring rollout.


r/CapeCodMA • • Aug 07 '26

Dennis Flock Cameras

87 Upvotes

The Dennis police department ended their Flock contract early summer 2025. Yet two Flock cameras are still operated in the town. Contact the non emergency number to help get them to remove these private cameras that are collecting data in public spaces. No one wants this. The non emergency number is 508 394 1315. Press 4 for the dial by name directory, 272#, then 1 for Chief John Brady.


r/CapeCodMA • • Apr 17 '25

Beaches & Nature Nauset Beach

85 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Apr 19 '25

It's that time of the year 🚿

84 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Apr 15 '25

Beaches & Nature The Cape Cod Museum of Natural History has an Osprey nest live stream

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 04 '25

Beaches & Nature Taking a break from the news to daydream about summer

84 Upvotes

r/CapeCodMA • • Mar 02 '25 Wholesome Seal

Activities & Events One of these things (you can borrow from the library!) is not like the others….

Post image
78 Upvotes

Anyone feel like a little light GHOST HUNTING?