r/Bitcoin • u/[deleted] • Nov 13 '17
PSA: Attack on BTC is ongoing
If y'all check the other sub, the narrative is that this was only the first step. Bitcoin has a difficulty adjustment coming up (~1800 blocks when I checked last night), and that's when they're hoping to "strike" and send BTC into a "death spiral." (Using their language here.)
Remember that Ver moved a huge sum of BTC to an exchange recently, but didn't sell. Seemed puzzling at the time, but I'm wondering if he's waiting for that difficulty adjustment to try and influence the price. Just a thought.
Anyway, good to keep an eye on what's going on over in our neighbor's yard as this situation continues to unfold. And I say "neighbor" purposefully -- I wish both camps could follow their individual visions for the two coins in relative peace. However, from reading the other sub it's pretty clear that their end game is (using their words again) to send BTC into a death spiral.
EDIT: For those asking, I originally tried to link the the post I'm referencing, but the post was removed by the automod for violating Rule 4 in the sidebar. Here's the link: https://np.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/7cibdx/the_flippening_explained_how_bch_will_take_over
19
u/amallah Nov 13 '17
The fact that this drama is possible makes cryptocurrency no better than fiat and therefore still too early for mass adoption.
→ More replies (1)2
83
u/LgnOfDoom Nov 13 '17
"However, from reading the other sub it's pretty clear that their end game is (using their words again) to send BTC into a death spiral."
I do not think that the r/btc sub has an end game. They are bitcoin cash maximalists that want the bitcoin market cap. Bitcoin maximalists want the Bitcoin Cash market cap. Anyone seeking store of value and not exactly certain as to what the proper diversification is, will want as much market cap as can be, right? So, if you thought that BCH was about to death spiral, with BTC absorbing market cap, then would you be content? Competition for store of value coin is not really ideal, IMO.
230
u/iiJokerzace Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
I do not think that the r/btc sub has an end game.
This is BCH in a nutshell.
They think all they have to do is plug a 10 tb hard drive into their miners and boom, problem solved right? The problem is that you would have to then be capable of validating more memory and it has to be done before the new block comes out. Eventually you will get to 1 gig blocks and for something to process 1 gig per block EVERY 10 minutes would need much more powerful hardware to validate the network. Making the network harder to validate reduces the network's security and most importantly decentralization.
People are easily fooled because increasing block size instantly relieves congestion in the network and speeds are fast again and fees are low which is what I want too but increasing the block size is no different from a bail out. Its going in the wrong direction. If possible we want to make the 1 mb smaller so more and more devices can validate bitcoin's network thus making bitcoin's security indestructible and way more decentralized. Sure this doesn't relieve pressure to the network but increasing block size is very risky hoping our hardware will keep up and even if it does, that means EVERYONE would have to keep up to reduce centralization, and again you cant just go to your local Best Buy and buy a hard drive, your hardware would have to process all that memory in under ten minutes. 24/7. Eventually this will lead to only a few players being able to validate blocks and boom there's your 51% attack.
We have no choice to find another solution for the sake of decentralization. The network must become easier to run, not more demanding.
83
u/ba1oo Nov 13 '17
I didn't understand the argument against increasing the block size until this comment. Thank you
28
u/Zepowski Nov 13 '17
This is the video that galvanized it for me. I'm not sure why there isn't more math presented at the top of reddit. Even in Andreas's simple language, it drags the scaling debate back to it's roots.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AecPrwqjbGw32
u/iiJokerzace Nov 13 '17
I hate to say this but finding the correct information on reddit is a needle in a haystack. I too couldn't understand how it is not the solution. It seems so simple. But as a wise engineer once said, "The simple answer is only temporary." Had to do a lot of digging to find why we can't, even risky for a simple 2mb. If we do just a 2mb upgrade just for now to keep people happy, then imagine the fun big block supporters will have probably saying, "SEE TOLD YOU BIG BLOCKS IS THE ANSWER!" and this could fool people more into thinking that big blocks IS the way to go! We are all still very new to this technology and yet to completely understand the scaling issues but we like to act like we know what we are talking about, especially with all this money involved.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (25)11
u/abend2 Nov 13 '17
Andreas gives a good talk on the subject. I've started the video where he gins to discuss block size but the whole video is good if you have the time to watch it all.
→ More replies (17)23
u/govdo Nov 13 '17
man i have been giving people this argument for months now and not one single meaningfull answer. Lets recap this in simple math..... So BCH can do ~30tx/s (yeah its like 24-35 but lets make it a round number) with 8 MB blocks. If it REALLY gets adopted and people start to transact with it for buying normal stuff 30tx is absolutely nothing. Visa can do more than 40k TX/s SO for bch to become visa-like you would have to raise the blocksize a whole lot! Lets do some basic level calculus: 8mb 30tx, 80mb 300tx, 800mb 3000tx, 8gb 30k TX. Lets say 30k is visa-like. That would mean that each 10minutes the blockchain grows 8gb, thats 48 GB/h, 1.152 TB/day, 34,56 TB/month, 414tb/year. Guess who would be the only interested parties running full nodes? Just take the hard disk costs, + since there wouldnt be that many nodes it would be very important for full nodes to have some kind of backup raid system if disks fail. Add to that to that the electricity, the personel, and just the sheer phisical space to store all these hard drives... Who would be interested doing that pro bono? Exactly - banks, other financial institutions and governments, eventualy corporations....big players seeking to have controll in the system. We got crypto so that hopefully one day we can say "fuck off banks" and now we want to crawl back under their dominator boots, im not doing that!
→ More replies (3)7
Nov 13 '17
Somebody give this guy some BTC. You should make this post a thread of it's own. I'll be honest over the last few days I was warming up to the bigger blocks. To me it was what's so bad about to pick up blocks if all they contain are transaction data. I understand more now.
4
u/iiJokerzace Nov 13 '17
I don't have good luck with posts and thanks man. My only wish is or all of us to come out winners here. Here's my btc address. Cheers.
16S1QD1fpSn3KzGmshuWTfz6ke75yasF7S
edit: spelling
6
Nov 13 '17
Thank you. I’m new to Bitcoin. Bought at ATH last week then bought more at the dip. This post makes me feel better about sticking with Bitcoin as a former Peter Schiff Gold acolyte who rebuked Bitcoin in 2015.
Great informative post.
→ More replies (1)16
Nov 13 '17
this isn't even getting into the whole fact that the new blocks have to be transmitted over the network. at 1mb you don't see it be that bad.
ever connect to a Chinese website? shit takes forever, even on my gigabit connection. Do they just have shitty internet? No...the connection literally has to go across europe/africa to then cross the ocean to get to the united states.
People think that storing big blocks is cheap because storage is cheap are being idiots. The Chinese miners will have a huge fucking advantage if they are able to make larger blocks. No one would be able to build the next block on the largest chain because it will take them so long to even get the block from china.
→ More replies (18)11
u/rankinrez Nov 13 '17
Latency is why a website takes so long to download from China.
However downloading a 1GB block, once the first bytes start arriving after 300ms, should be able to go fairly fast, provided the TCP stacks both sides are configured to work well under high-latency conditions.
→ More replies (15)6
u/AndreLinoge55 Nov 13 '17
Agree with your logic but I don’t understand how BCH would end up with 1GB blocks - are you saying that the 8MB current blocksize, with the addendum on the official Bitcoin Cash site for ‘massive future increases [in the blocksize]’ that ultimately the miners will continue to opt into BIPs that increase the blocksize or that because of the inherent code the blocks will need to increase to 1GB? Want to understand where 1GB/block came from.
7
u/rankinrez Nov 13 '17
People are testing at that level currently which I guess is why:
https://news.bitcoin.com/gigablock-testnet-researchers-mine-the-worlds-first-1gb-block/
→ More replies (5)7
u/iiJokerzace Nov 13 '17
I'll be honest they probably won't need to make them that big until a few years. We obviously know right now, there is but a tiny tiny amount of people on this world using cryptos for transactions. Eventually, slowly but surely, massive amounts of people will start using crytpos. Remember only 1.5 billion people have the luxury of using a bank. we are trying to reach the whole 10 billion people out there and currently we have .0001% of those people on crypto right now. People that have never used a bank account in their life now are able to by downloading an app. thats how easy it is for someone to jump on the network ad add more transactions to it. Eventually two things will happen.
BCH will get to 1gb or people will realize before then that this isn't going to work for decentralization and switch back to BTC
They copy bitcoin's solutions and literally have their users scratching their heads saying, "why do we even need a BCH if it's just copying what BTC is doing?" and switch back to BTC
Right now these increases seem minuscule but as more user come in (and they are coming), then they will need to keep increasing the size year after year eventually getting to that 1 gig. By that time you can argue we'll be super duper human advance civilization so it will be okay and perhaps they are right, but the issue now is decentralization since Even in that time, people will have to have that new and extremely powerful hardware (and connection) to process all the memory from the past and it increases every 10 min. And it all must be done in 10 min before the new block. How many people you think could afford to keep up with it? Instead, how about the network stays so small that in the future, even your smart watch is capable of validating blocks and securing the network? What seems more decentralized to you?
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (37)2
u/MinerJA3 Nov 13 '17
Thank you for answering one of my questions that never gets answered. Now my other question is what is wrong with having difficulty re-evaluated more often so we don’t care so much when miners come and go?
→ More replies (6)4
u/paulajohnson Nov 13 '17
Difficulty measurement has unavoidable random noise in it. You need enough blocks to get a statistically sound estimate. Otherwise you could get an exceptional number of blocks (high or low) during a measurement period and have the difficulty set too high or low as a result the next time. I haven't run the numbers myself, but I strongly suspect Satoshi did.
42
u/romromyeah Nov 13 '17
I would have thought Bitcoin Cash would want to coexist. But it's becoming more clear they want to destroy Bitcoin. Seems quite the noble quest they are on
5
u/outbackdude Nov 13 '17
they want to save bitcoin by destroying bitcoin if you get my drift.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)12
31
u/Alan2420 Nov 13 '17
The kooks on r/btc don't want store of value. Read what they write. They despise store of value. They want to spend all of their BCH on low-fee coffee transactions!
42
u/Alan2420 Nov 13 '17
And the strangest thing of all is, there's no transactions to speak of on BCH. So they only want to spend the BCH on low-fee coffee transactions in theory. They don't even like coffee!
39
u/Marcion_Sinope Nov 13 '17
They hate Bitcoin and coffee?!?
What kind of sick mongrels are we dealing with?
→ More replies (2)14
u/eastlondonwasteman Nov 13 '17
That's because it's a newborn altcoin which nobody gives a flying fuck about.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (12)42
u/ArisKatsaris Nov 13 '17
They want to spend all of their BCH on low-fee coffee transactions
Just like Satoshi then, who wanted bitcoin to be electronic cash, and AFAIK didn't talk about it as 'store of value'.
If BCH enables low-fee coffee transactions and BTC doesn't, that's a point in favour of BCH, not against it.
Perhaps you should focus on making BTC better, or criticizing BCH for where it's actually worse -- rather than mocking BCH for the points where it's better.
→ More replies (19)12
u/pkop Nov 13 '17
Arguing against store of value outs you as an economic illiterate. We already have money that is a bad store of value. What purpose would a new currency that doesn’t store value serve us?
Satoshi damn well knew the value of sound money else he wouldn’t have limited the money supply.
→ More replies (6)3
Nov 13 '17
Competition for store of value coin is not really ideal, IMO.
There is no thing like "store of value" on a digital currency.
Gold is a store of value as there's a very limited amount of it (you could barely fill a tennis court with it) and it has lots of use (especially in electronics, but also in chemistry and medicine).
Bitcoin's not a store of value. For all we know exchanging bitcoins (or any other crypto, including Cash) could be banned (as it is in China) and at that point there's no way to exchange it back for money.
→ More replies (11)
100
u/AstarJoe Nov 13 '17
Hrm. Now I wonder what the Winklevii and their immense stash of BCH think of this plan...
I mean, it wouldn't be like they had a huge incentive to protect their main investment by dropping a massive dump truck of BCH on the market at any (unforseen) moment, eh?
You got that r/btc?
54
u/mx_js_reddit Nov 13 '17
This crazy war only affects those who bought after the BCH fork, or those who are all in on one of the two.
The winklevoss have both coins cause they have coins since before the forh, hence if one goes to zero and the other one wins, they are still rich.
148
Nov 13 '17 edited Aug 09 '18
deleted 0.2058 What is ^^^this?
69
u/why-this Nov 13 '17
Jesus THIS. Bitcoin is the foundation off all of this. This is clearly evident by these attacks by people trying to make a quick buck off of forks. Not only is it not making any lasting damage, it STRENGTHENS the faith we have in Bitcoin.
→ More replies (50)43
Nov 13 '17
They won't succeed but if they did you're right, the whole things over. Cryptocurrencies will lose all legitimacy and be seen as crazy speculation. No-one would trust anything to hold any kind of value again. We have to keep resisting them even if this goes on for weeks and months.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (21)14
Nov 13 '17
Whats even more amazing is that some of these people actually have millions of dollars invested in the ecosystem
14
u/45sbvad Nov 13 '17
Why would anyone trade their BTC for BCH?
If one believes that transaction throughput is holding Bitcoin back; why choose BCH over other coins with a much longer history of stable development and community support?
If somehow BTC is actually threatened by BCH there is no way in hell I'm trading BTC for BCH.
I'm either going down with BTC or divesting into Alts. BCH is as offensive as USD to me.
→ More replies (1)16
u/dik2phat Nov 13 '17
I'm also going down with the ship. I didn't get into crypto for the money, I already have plenty of that (not trying to humble brag, many people here would be completely fine in a financial sense if bitcoin crashes) but for a better future for my children. I don't want goverment having control of our money and everything else. The problem is that our history shows that we are willing to give up our freedoms for convenience and perception of safety. America has been a case study in this regard since 911 happened and I plan on not making the same mistakes twice. Bcash is trying to lure people in with lower fees and other bs while at the same time being a centralized coin with a CEO. I hope people wake up and become smarter than that. Dealing with the fees now is a very small price to pay for financial freedom and security in the future. Plus, I have zero doubt that BTC will scale, whether it's now, 2 years from now, or 5 years. It will happen. The only thing that matters here is decentralization.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (3)4
u/F6GW7UD3AHCZOM95 Nov 13 '17
Not true. Uncertainty takes a toll on both chains. Holding both doesn't protect you. In this case 2+2 = 3.
3
u/calaber24p Nov 13 '17
Im sure they are going to hold onto it. They have a huge stash of ethereum as well and probably arent going to pick sides. They have always stayed pretty neutral.
3
42
u/texasgov Nov 13 '17
You see this is why I am embarrassed to introduce new people to Bitcoin. This is why we cant have nice things in life. Instead of enjoying Bitcoin and the altcoins, we now have to worry about what comes in the future due to these couple of greedy bastards.
9
u/mvanvoorden Nov 13 '17
It's all part of the game. This is how Bitcoin gets tested, and what won't kill it, will make it only stronger. Without all the resistance, it would have never been able to grow to where it is now.
→ More replies (15)3
53
u/oddity95 Nov 13 '17
The thing is, if bitcoin drops people buy more of it since they know it is this REAL bitcoin with a solid core dev team.. while bitcoin cash has a 1 man dev team and the lazy block size fix to today's problems.
Bitcoin layer 2 and LN is going to make bitcoin cash look like an 80s Buick in today's standards as far as cryptocurrency efficiency and practicallity goes. There's literally no comparison of the two.
If you buy into btc because of its price, you probably don't care about the technology too much. If you TRANSFER WEALTH to btc for its technology, you won't care about price too much.
→ More replies (4)15
u/mrj0ker Nov 13 '17
It's there any timeline for LN?
I see the timeline for the opposition is now
13
u/earonesty Nov 13 '17
Lightning is proceeding slowly but surely... like everything else in the real world. It isn't a "now" thing. It's a "when it works and is secure" thing. Probably a few months before all the pull reqs are merged and a mainnet beta version is OK .... in my opinion. I'm guessing Jan/Feb announcement that lnd tests are happening on main net. Whether BitPay announces support for it.... well that's another story. Those guys are getting really weird about lightning.
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (2)3
Nov 14 '17
Bingo, there was ZERO excuse for not putting in a block increase to alleviate short term pain while still working on LN. That blunder by core is responsible for pandora's box of alt coins opening.
What happens if LN turns out not to be the golden parachute everyone thinks it is? Then Bitcoin is actually dead.
7
u/ggggideon Nov 13 '17
I think the WSJ summed up the whole situation very well this morning:
Still, the reality is that the original bitcoin has been in use for about nine years, and has a community of businesses, developers, and miners around it. Bitcoin Cash has existed for a few months, and, despite its positioning for payments, has few—if any—retail outlets that accept it for that. It isn’t clear whether Bitcoin Cash can create the kind of network effects that bitcoin itself has over the years.
2
31
u/Alan2420 Nov 13 '17
I agree. The bcash EDA change is happening today. If Roger Ver wants to sell all of his BTC and walk the order books down to the bottom, then today should be his day to lose all of his money. Be strong Bitcoin hodlers. Hodl!
https://www.bitcoinabc.org/november
Excerpt:
Algorithm The new DAA algorithm seeks to accomplish the following objectives:
Adjust difficulty to hash rate to target a mean block interval of 600 seconds. Avoid sudden changes in difficulty when hash rate is fairly stable. Adjust difficulty rapidly when hash rate changes rapidly. Avoid oscillations from feedback between hash rate and difficulty. Be resilient to attacks such as timestamp manipulation.
This algorithm is based on a 144-period simple moving average. The difficulty is adjusted each block, based on the amount of work done and the elapsed time of the previous 144 blocks.
To compute the difficulty, we begin with the three topmost blocks, and choose the one with the median timestamp of the three. Next, the process is repeated with blocks 144, 145, and 146 (blocks of 144-146 height less than the current) and a median timestamp block is again chosen from those 3. From these 2 blocks roughly 144 blocks apart, we define W as the amount of work done between the blocks, and T as the elapsed time between the blocks. A high-low filter is applied so that T has maximum value of 2 days and a minimum value of .5 days. This prevents difficulty from changing too abruptly. (Normally 144 blocks takes approximately 1 day).
We can then compute: Wn = W * ExpectedBlockTime / T . G = (2256 / Wn) - 1
This is our difficulty target. Lastly, a final filter is applied to enforce a maximal target.
Activation of the new consensus rules will be done on a median time stamp basis on blocks that occur after timestamp 1510600000, which corresponds to November 13th, 7:06 PM GMT. This activation code has been merged.
13
u/Motoko-Kusanagi Nov 13 '17
So the algo goes live at 7:06 gmt? This is when he might dump? Cheers for posting.
14
u/BitcoinAlways Nov 13 '17
If he wants to sell his Bitcoin then that is great news as there will be plenty of buyers.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Alan2420 Nov 13 '17
My theory is that they plan to try to dump the BTC price so it's more profitable for miners to mine the lower difficulty coin. The only way this is effective is if people sell. If everybody had limit sell orders at or above where we are now, or just stays off the order books entirely, then even a whale can't do much harm. People just need to know so they don't fear the attack.
→ More replies (11)5
u/ARCHA1C Nov 13 '17
The only way this is effective is if people sell.
But people will immediately buy on any substantial dip, and demand will spike again, and when the losing mining efforts wane, BTC will rally again.
3
→ More replies (19)2
6
u/giszmo Nov 14 '17
The post is provided by:
User u/Gregory_Maxwell: Redditor since: 09/26/2017 (2 months) Post Karma: 4,852 Comment Karma: 3,067
Clearly this is not our u/nullc and I wonder how one can get to nearly 8k posts/comments in 2 months. In full time job terms that is 8 weeks or 40 work days for 8000 posts/comments? That is 25 posts/comments per working hour?
8
u/nullc Nov 14 '17
It's an imposter, as you note. Reddit won't do anything unless there is public backlash. I think it fits in perfectly with rbtc being a total cesspool of misinformation.
38
u/cryptomartin Nov 13 '17
Yeah, I don't think this is over either. Stay vigilant, educate newbies, point out the lies and propaganda of shitcoin shills and con artists - and hold your bitcoins.
6
u/Psychohorak Nov 13 '17
Why shouldn't I sell now and then buy back once we drop again. Genuine question, new to all of this.
I understand its hard to predict but if an attack is incoming we can assume the price will drop and then rebound again as it did today, no?
25
u/BeardPatrol Nov 13 '17
It doesn't work like that around here.
Basically what ive gathered from this forum is that you should never sell because you cant predict the markets.
However you should always buy, because you can always predict the markets.
You should really not rely on this place for anything resembling rational decision making.
7
u/swinegums Nov 13 '17
you should never sell because you cant predict the markets. However you should always buy, because you can always predict the markets.
Haha I liked this, very true.
Selling: Trying to time the market is risky and difficult and will likely result in losses.
Buying: HODLing has historically proven profitable and there's likely a ways to go before that maxim won't hold true.
TLDR; HODL.
→ More replies (2)6
u/SloppySynapses Nov 13 '17
Yes, if it's a guaranteed price drop you should sell and buy back unless you're extremely committed to supporting bitcoin to the point where you forego profits.
Only thing is you can't be sure if it's going to go down
→ More replies (3)6
u/earonesty Nov 13 '17
No way to know if the attack will be timed for tomorrow or two weeks from now. If you sell now, and the price runs up to 9k on news that CFTC said OK to CME.... then you're left trying to game some bullshit small time Roger Ver move... and missing out on the big game... institutional custody of assets. Just hang on to your hats.
→ More replies (2)4
u/cryptomartin Nov 13 '17
If you want to spend your time with speculation and day-trading, go for it. I think it's a waste of time, I prefer to buy bitcoins, hodl them and to keep educating myself instead of trading. It's less risky and more rewarding.
0
Nov 13 '17
[deleted]
3
u/Elise_xy Nov 13 '17
Yeah, being a newbie and owning only a fraction of a coin, this weekend has just made things bananas to understand.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)5
5
20
u/n0mdep Nov 13 '17
Honestly, calling this an "attack" gives it too much credit. It has barely made a dent. Bitcoin DGAF.
→ More replies (11)2
13
9
u/usatka120 Nov 13 '17
Rather simple retaliation: run a BTC node yourself and keep being vigilant. When the price of BCH bottoms, buy in and dump at hight again ... Koreans who follow Ver and Co will gladly pay for my steak dinner again, and again...
This brings us nowhere, but ok... if they want a trench-war, they'll get one ...
2
u/coinfeller Nov 13 '17
"The other sub" you sound like a cheated spouse
3
Nov 13 '17
my post got removed for mentioning r/btc originally. Wanted this to get through. Moderation here is shooting itself in the foot.
3
u/coinfeller Nov 13 '17
I don't understand why there is such a heavy moderation here. Bitcoin is about freedom, not about being banned if you don't fit the narrative.
12
u/dsettini Nov 13 '17
It would be interesting if China banned crypto mining as well..
→ More replies (1)
4
u/casualcryptouser Nov 13 '17
Where is this narrative? Can someone give me a link? Generally interested, but I go over there and see info about how this sub isn't talking about high fees, about how btc is getting impossible to trade, or how a bunch of 'shills' from this sub are joining over there.
Dont care to discuss whether any of this is true or not (at least in this thread) but I would love to read their narrative that they are attacking bitcoin. I feel this info is very important to reveal, and would help shape public opinion on both coins. I just can't find it.
→ More replies (2)
4
4
4
u/violencequalsbad Nov 13 '17
FUD. he sold some of them, not all because he's not actually a moron.
the attack has been intense and coordinated up until now.
i can't see what else they might have left, but vague threats don't bother me.
4
Nov 13 '17
"Ver, if you don't like Bitcoin, why do you still hold BTC?"
"Ver, don't sell your BTC, it's an attack!"
1
u/DeathByFarts Nov 13 '17
(Using their language here.)
Not doubting you ... But do you have a reference for that ? I just can't spend 8 hours a day reading bitcoin news.
1
1
Nov 13 '17
Tried to link in original post but it got removed by automod -.- not a fan of the rules in this sub. Hence the vaguery
9
Nov 13 '17
I don't like death spirals for anyone...
0
Nov 13 '17
[deleted]
2
Nov 13 '17
What exactly are you suggesting? I think everyone agrees that the market would be thrown into chaos for a (long) while but the tech is still fundamentally sound and it's not like blockchain technology would just cease to exist.
→ More replies (3)7
u/robbie5325 Nov 13 '17
The moment bitcoin death spirals and becomes completely unstable without recovery is the moment crypto - currency ceases to appeal to new customers.
As an outsider, I wouldn't invest in any crypto currency if THE bitcoin was to fall, doesn't seem safe longterm after that.
→ More replies (1)
9
18
6
u/Kooriki Nov 13 '17
Kinda sucks that a couple sketchy whales can tank the market at will.
→ More replies (3)
6
u/askme2b Nov 13 '17
Ver is not even a minor challenge to MoneyBadger! Everyone is gonna know that soon.
2
3
3
3
u/Mortimer452 Nov 13 '17
Actually it's my understanding there's more than just a diff adjustment - they are changing the diff adjustment algorithm so it will adjust more quickly from here on out.
3
u/notthematrix Nov 13 '17
25000 is nothing bithump burned more then $25.000.000.000 and thats more then 25000 BTC... so I think these 25.000 BTC is long gone.
3
3
u/Godspiral Nov 13 '17
btc had a very recent difficulty adjustment. The mining attack was this weekend when "free" bch could be mined. Bch is going to later today start getting a stable hash rate. Possibly in the 20%-25% range.
Its likely that btc averages 6 or so blocks per hour for the next week and a half, but then both chains are likely to be 6/hour from hereon out. btc fees will attract hashrate.
Selling is not an attack. Hashrate manipulation is. But btc fees is protection against hashrate exodus.
3
u/lolhat Nov 13 '17
Can you maybe post links to where this is stated in r / btc? It would certainly make your post more credible... Right now you are only pouring gasoline on the fire with these undocumented statements.
What I'd like to know is, why aren't fees being discussed here? It's a huge thing many other places, but in this sub there's radio silence about it.
3
3
u/Experience111 Nov 13 '17
Would someone explain why it's not profitable to mine Bitcoin anymore ?
→ More replies (2)
3
u/NicolasDorier Nov 14 '17
Wish them good luck. They better try to break an iron wall by banging their head against it, higher success rate.
3
u/mjh808 Nov 14 '17
FYI, you will only hear that kind of talk from people who have gone all in with BCH, I believe most on /r/btc still hold both and many believe displacing BTC at the top would be damaging to crypto in general. With the recent difficulty upgrade they can co-exist just fine but it's really up to Blockstream what happens from here.
→ More replies (12)
3
u/terr547 Nov 14 '17
Start your own node, fire up your miners, report bitcoin.com for false advertising (https://safebrowsing.google.com/safebrowsing/report_badware/), stop this attack now!
→ More replies (1)
3
u/xcaddz Nov 14 '17
how cool would it be for the Winklevoss twins to come on the scene and dump their BCH and use proceeds to buy BTC during one of these attacks.
3
u/patriotswin04 Nov 14 '17
Okay I kinda thought the BCH stuff wasn't really an attack was a bit over blown but then I started noticing bots. Tons and tons of bots posting about how terrible BTC is.
Look at think user
https://www.reddit.com/user/EatAssOnSecondDate
Theres tons of them on reddit. Spreading the word how BTC is terrible and shit.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/JK-9000 Nov 13 '17
From Ver's Twitter I gathered he'd already graciously redistributed his coins yesterday?
5
u/hendrik_v Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
OK, I enjoy a bit of hypothesizing, and I am still pretty new to the scene... So please anybody, correct me if I am wrong here. I really want to understand this!
Suppose that there is a complot of chinese miners that effectively want to put the bitcoin chain into a death spiral and they plan to do so right after the next difficulty adjustment (in ~1800 blocks according to OP). This will cause the blocks to become superslow, let's assume 1 block per hour (dno if this is realistic or if it could still be even worse). The difficulty is adjusted every 2016 blocks, so it would take 84 days before the difficulty is adjusted downwards.
Questions and observations that I have:
Game theory says that even with extremely slow blocks, there will still be miners on the chain because they will have a higher chance of getting block rewards. That is assuming that the price stays high enough. According to this link, the cost for mining a bitcoin is between 500$ to 1500$ depending on cost of electricity. Are the people who care enough about decentralization to keep bitcoin above that price? Despite a superslow network? After all, if it fails, it means that it was not decentralized enough and an organized party was able to destroy it and then you are left with Paypal 2.0 (not my analogy, but I like it a lot).
A lot of bitcoin has been traded since the bitcoin cash fork on the first of August. If the main bitcoin chain dies, it means that a lot of people will lose it all. All the fiat they have invested. That's a lot of money and I recon that the interests of this group are too great already to let the chain die (whatever it may take).
After the difficulty adjustment (after 2800 blocks), the difficulty would be so low that 51% attack on any of the new blocks would become a possibility (afaik?).
On the other hand, it leaves bitcoin community 84 days to react. I'm not that technical, so I don't know what the possibilities would be. Implement a new hashing algorithm in those 84 days to make sure that the Antminers can no longer be used for bitcoin mining? Is this even feasible? It would make the miners that are still active on the bitcoin chain very very unhappy of course...
One other measure that the bitcoin chain could take is to make segwit a hard fork rather than a soft fork, thus eliminating the asicboost. It wouldn't save anything on the short term, but longer term it would.
In the end, bitcoin is your/my/our coin. You decide how you want your coin to be. And if you want your coin to have 8MB blocks, that is fine too. I want my coin to be censorship resistent, and resistant to miner concentration though.
Anything I missed? I'm just tired of writing this :-)
EDIT couple of words and a point about segwit.
2
5
u/Darnegar Nov 13 '17
Wonder why they are so full of hatred though...get a life people the world is big enough for everyone
→ More replies (1)
10
u/bkunzi01 Nov 13 '17
Ver's window is very small. Once layer two solutions are released his alt coin will be the least relevant alt on the market. Until then, be ready to buy his coins lol
→ More replies (4)13
u/morgawr_ Nov 13 '17
>very small
>layer two solutions
Aren't those technically at least a year (if not two or more) away still?
4
→ More replies (2)5
4
u/keatonatron Nov 13 '17
that's when they're hoping to "strike" and send BTC into a "death spiral." (Using their language here.)
Source?
4
u/2002bmw2002 Nov 13 '17
How is this an attack?
2
u/descartablet Nov 13 '17
We call attack to risking money in the intent to kill the other coin. We know it's not illegal, nor it violates the Geneva Convention.
4
u/ghoulguys Nov 13 '17
I'm relatively new to crypto, so it may just be me but, this is so counterproductive for crypto as a whole. If we want mainstream adoption we can't have petty shit like this happen. For the regular person just getting into crypto it's already confusing, then you add in bitcoin cash, bitcoin gold, bitcoin whatever, not to mention hundreds of other Alts. It's like if we all worked together we could accomplish amazing shit. But nah let's attack the main coin that is the only reason bitcoin cash exists... makes sense. Smh
2
u/illfatedtruck Nov 14 '17
It's not petty it's just nature taking its course and redditors getting really excited about it
4
u/relgueta Nov 13 '17
Bitcoin was born to survive!!!
If it can survive this idiot attack then we can't defeat the banks.
Trust in Bitcoin people.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/BitcoinAlways Nov 13 '17
Let them know that we are expecting them to try and attack us again but that we have a few little plans in place as well.
→ More replies (3)4
2
u/jarede312 Nov 13 '17
Probably but BTC isn’t being traded. It’s BTC futures that will be regulated. The underlying cryptocurrency won’t be.
→ More replies (2)2
u/AXS20 Nov 13 '17
You will have trading institutions both selling futures contracts and buying the underlying bitcoin in order to hedge
2
u/chuckleberryfinnable Nov 13 '17
This whole thing is fucking bizarre. Sending BTC into a "death spiral" would be catastrophic...
2
2
u/wildmaiden Nov 13 '17
Where are these discussions on the other sub? I'm not seeing them, curious to know more.
2
u/KindaCrypto Nov 13 '17
There is huge value in crypto now, and people like money. Attacks will be ongoing forever.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
Nov 13 '17
If BTC could be attacked by pushing it into a death spiral, so can BCH be attacked the same way in the future. It would put doubt into the mind of all investors crashing the price of not only BCH but all other POW cryptos as well.
No rational crypto investor or crypto businessman would do this.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Hopongoldtrain Nov 13 '17
My BTC is probably going to be stuck in limbo for the next 48 hours. Hopefully it doesn't go out of control.
2
2
u/Selfkey Nov 13 '17
I just know that I can't trust a movement that openly states that is attacking bitcoin
2
u/Drewken Nov 13 '17
Can you please explain how is this an attack? Who is atacking and how? I am new, please ELI5.
2
u/mrcrypto2 Nov 13 '17
I hate to say it, but I think I might have attacked bitcoin a handful of times in the last few days as I moved coins from hitbtc to my ledger. I am sorry.
2
Nov 13 '17
Very new to this, just bought my first $100 worth last night. Can someone link me to a post a noob could understand as to what happened this week?
→ More replies (1)4
u/mongo_chutney Nov 13 '17
Remember when wwf and wcw had beef in the 90s? Like that but with worse actors.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Graphite1994 Nov 13 '17
Seriously guys, why cant both of subreddits work toward the actual goal bitcoin instead of attacking each other?
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/morph1ne Nov 14 '17
I'm here to share what I found. That is important. Anyone who didn't know yet about MASSIVE preparation was planning from NYA. The guy who made this post 30th July after NYA predicted 100% perfectly this massive BCH conspiracy. That was a 100% inside information. Check also Roger Ver's wiki page The thing is that I was looking to buy antminer s9 and I was checking Bitmain.com orders since August 2017. Right after New York Agreement - Jihan Wu's Bitmain excluded BTC from Bitmain's payment method and added BCH instead. So Antminers and Bitmain production was selling after NYA for BCH only. Antminers S9 was hotsale for all that time. I wonder how many thousands BCH they collected for this time. Thats why BCH is so easy to pump when people who planned that conspiracy collected huge amount of BCH. Almost the same time BTC hashrate was attacked by bch miners(include Roger Vers pool and Bitmain), SegWit2x cancelled (it was never gonna happen), Roger Ver who knew all inside information and highly promoted SW2X profited a ton of money on selling SW2X Futures before DUMP now highly promoting BCH just before the massive pump that becomes obvious.
Sorry if I made grammar mistakes, English is my second language. Let me know what do you think about the biggest cryptocrime in history?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/W111n Nov 13 '17
Just honest question: how many people here are just investors or speculators and how many have deeper commitment to BTC?
I'm not sure if there's a war. From an investors perspective I only care about whether my coins will go up, when it'll fall, and when it'll bounce.
I'm not into conspiracy theories.
3
u/Bipolarruledout Nov 13 '17
I have a deeper commitment in seeing wealth disparity flattened. hashtag paradisepapers
→ More replies (3)
3
u/paulajohnson Nov 13 '17
This, definitely. If you look at https://fork.lol/ you can see how close they came. It doesn't look close on the graph, but at the point when the difficulty adjusted BTC became about 2.3 times more valuable to mine. If BTC had stayed down at $5,500 and the other coin had stayed up around $2,600 then we might have had a scenario where BTC was still less profitable to mine. In that case we would still be watching the mempool and fees increase. Bitcoin would have entered a death spiral of falling value leading to lack of mining leading to falling value.
3
u/gangblockchain Nov 13 '17
You have to realize some of these people on these reddit posts are 14 year old investors talking nonsense
5
u/thezerg1 Nov 13 '17
There are always extremists. Please don't take what you read on reddit by anonymous individuals seriously, on either side. The last few days were not an "attack". To me it looked like people who held onto the dream of onchain Bitcoin scaling until its final death rotating into crypto that is more aligned with that vision.
I wouldn't be too worried short term though if I were you. The coverage of Bitcoin in the media seems to be ensuring that for every person heading to the exit there is someone waiting for entry (see coin.dance volumes). But if there is a psychological max tx fee and wait time, Bitcoin may maintain its price, acting instead as the "gateway currency" to the larger crypto world (although, this psychological limit is more realistically a "chilling effect" proportional to the tx fee and inconvenience, not a hard limit).
In effect, the shall-not-be-named fork IS onchain scalability for Bitcoin. Long time holders, change tip, satoshi dice, and daily use can move to it while Bitcoin finds its place as digital gold. This situation may persist until a transacton alleviating technology (lightning?) matures and gains user adoption, or until Bitcoin loses its first-mover network-effect premium.
Its unfortunate that Bitcoin could not scale onchain until technologies like lightning alleviate block space demand. If it had done so, I think that a significant portion of the market cap of the major alt-coins would be instead priced into BTC.
6
u/thieflar Nov 13 '17
Why are you spouting lies like "Bitcoin could not scale onchain" when we just activated SegWit, which significantly increases on-chain capacity?
Oh, right. Almost forgot: you're a known liar.
I remember when you photoshopped images to make it seem like Core nodes went down when really it was just BU/Classic nodes that did. I also remember when you wrote an article to try and make fun of Bitcoin Core's code, and accidentally wound up revealing the fact that you didn't understand any of the code you had been breaking. I remember when you kept trying to blame Peter Todd for catalyzing attacks against your hilariously vulnerable code, even though you had been told, multiple times, with accompanying proof, that the attacks had started before Peter Todd had ever said a thing. I remember when you doubted that a fork on your big-blocks testnet even occurred, after you were already provided plenty of trivially-verifiable proof of the fork.
You are not intelligent, and you are not honorable. You lie all the time. You come around trying to spread misinformation and trying to deceive newcomers who don't know any better, saying things that don't have any basis in reality. Give it up already, you sad little man.
→ More replies (6)
2
u/texasgov Nov 13 '17
How can I send a personal message to these ass clowns that are creating all of this chaos? Can some one link me directly to them so I can give them a piece of my mind.
→ More replies (2)
2
Nov 13 '17
How's that an attack and why people would need to be worried?
If Bitcoin Cash is a scam and Core is better the markets are gonna kill it regardless.
If a guy wants to buy Bitcoin Cash with his Bitcoins I think it's a free market.
It's not like whales and institutions don't manipulate BTC's price regardless.
→ More replies (14)
2
u/adampsyreal Nov 13 '17
*is "Lightning" really a good solution? -Shouldn't a better coin prevail due to the impracticality of BTC's transaction time?
7
Nov 13 '17
I have no trouble at all using bitcoin chain, especially using segwit compatible wallet. The only time you have any issue is when there is an attack going on by those that want to take btc market cap. Devs and random people from BCH space have openly admitted of doing such manipulation
3
u/adampsyreal Nov 13 '17
What is the advantage of using a segwit compatible wallet?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)6
u/Alan2420 Nov 13 '17
The only problem with BTC transaction time is when its under attack by altcoin miners. Otherwise, it works just fine. "Better" is not just fast transaction time. Learn more about why Bitcoin exists.
→ More replies (10)
1
u/arganam Nov 13 '17
Why doesn't Bitcoin change the difficulty re-targeting system to eliminate the "death spiral" possiblity?
What is the drawback to calculating difficulty based upon the average hashrate of the last N blocks?
I believe BCH is doing the last 144, but that's an arbitrary number, it could be anything.
I assume there is some drawback to doing this but I can't think of it off the top of my head.
1
1
1
1
1
u/hgmichna Nov 13 '17
Has BCH not just hard-forked and installed the D601 difficulty adjustment algorithm? This means that difficulty adjustments will be much more gentle, so both coins can coexist peacefully.
With this new difficulty adjustment it is not so easy to "send BTC into a death spiral."
1
1
1
u/ducksauce88 Nov 13 '17
Good luck, all Thai volume is fake as hell and i bet a majority of people are using it as a vehicle for more BTC. Let them pump...it's all smoke and mirrors. Lol they are in complete denial.
1
Nov 13 '17
However, from reading the other sub it's pretty clear that their end game is (using their words again) to send BTC into a death spiral.
I feel like both communities feel threatened by the other one.
Bitcoin Cash might work as a better alternative for payments and Core supporters feel like this could damage what they now see as a store of value in Bitcoin.
But then Bitcoin Cash cannot really be a payment method if there aren't people accepting it in the first place.
People say this is bad for both Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies, I personally believe that it's actually a very interesting moment that can benefit both communities, even if one may die (more likely to happen to Bitcoin Cash).
I also have another question, why there are no proposals on swapping bitcoin to PoS?
I fear like if a PoS Bitcoin movement would get traction it would be killed by all the people feeling it as a threat to Bitcoin's fiat value, regardless of the technological (and decentralization) implications it might have.
→ More replies (2)
1
Nov 13 '17
I bought some BTC 2 years ago and never paid much attention till the last few weeks. It looks to me like these guys have way too much control on the market. Why wouldn't they just keep cracking the whip, staying one step ahead?
1
Nov 13 '17
How is this attack going to work if BTC mempool is overpopulated, so no arbitrage opportunity or flooding the exchange with bunch of coins?
How is this going to work too if BCH is about to fork and it's risky to do transactions during fork?
1
1
u/_The-Big-Giant-Head_ Nov 13 '17
I am pretty much sure Japan has laws against malicious and criminal attacks against multi billions financial network and assets.
He could get locked for a long time for that.
You got your coin, concentrate on your shit.
1
1
u/rai2017 Nov 13 '17
What will happen until November 15: Will be delivered the bitcoin gold token. You will then have 3 bitcoin: BTC, BCH and BTG or Gold. Bitcoin will have its value diluted among these three, everyone will use the same technology.
1
1
u/papermoonist Nov 13 '17
This round was an excellent illustration of the fact that, while people can easily manipulate price on an exchange (in the short term), they can't manipulate "the market"... Many think that those are one and the same because most of the markets we're used to dealing with are so liquid and well understood... But they're not... Price is only a reflection of the underlying market...
1
u/alfonso1984 Nov 13 '17
What you guys are not taking into account is that the last attack was extremly expensive for the pumpers. There was somebody (or a group of powerful actors) pumping Bcash all the way up to $2400 who now lost a lot of money. I think they will think twice since if they don't succeed they are going to keep losing money. And succeeding to replace BTC is nearly impossible so is just a way of throwing money away.
3
u/hcf27 Nov 13 '17
pumping Bcash all the way up to $2400 who now lost a lot of money.
What makes you think they lost money?.. they could have pumped it and sold at the top and now they have even more money for the next pump..
→ More replies (1)2
u/alfonso1984 Nov 13 '17
The pressure they were fighting was down, that's why it readjusted so fast, they were the buyers when the rest was selling
1
u/TotesMessenger Nov 13 '17
1
u/superthrowbtc Nov 13 '17
Don't know, don't care. Please Roger Ver, make the price of BTC great again so I can stock up!
1
u/pprimase Nov 13 '17
What's their motivation to boost BCH by throwing away BTC? They don't have more BCH than anybody else before the split. Why throw away BTC?
2
u/postslongcomments Nov 13 '17
It's actually a fairly good plan by them.
They saw the 7400 as the peak of a curve. Add on top of that Segwit. It allows them to double dip on a scale of epic proportions. They knew that if they popped the bubble one of two things happens A. Bitcoin recovers, B. Bitcoin dies. They hedged their bets (as they do with sell high/buy low).
They had a fuckton of miners mine BCH. If BCH succeeds they make a fuckload. If BCH fails they can pump and dump.
So they divest a mass amount of bitcoin at a predictable peak (Segwit fork). They know they can always get back in the game and know that once the fork was called off people would sell anyways. They also invest a fair amount in BCH knowing it's the agenda they'll push.
Doesn't matter which pony wins, as they own both of them. They have the ability to tank BCH if necessary. And they have the ability of knowing when the high sell was and can buy in low at any point they really want.
1
1
1
u/akb78988 Nov 13 '17
Honest question from someone trying to learn. Are reddit subs the “Wall Street Journal” of cryptocurrencies? I mean can a post here sway the price of bitcoin or other cryptos?
The only reason I ask is because billions of dollars are on the line and someone named bojangles can sway that? This is not meant as a negative. Just asking.
1
1
1
Nov 14 '17
AFICT the next Bitcoin difficulty adjustment is so far expected to drop not increase...
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Aliencorpse_ Nov 14 '17
You guys remember what Wikipedia did to Microsoft Encarta?
We have nothing to worry about.
1
Nov 14 '17
You guys think there will be another big bch pump? If so, I want to prepare for buying the btc dip.
1
u/petearvo Nov 14 '17
Yes! I saw what they were upto as well.. Need to let all BTC holders know this and to weather the storm that will hit..
301
u/Richo262 Nov 13 '17
Good, sounds like a great opportunity to buy more coins.