Having listened to Paavo Järvi's new recording of Mahler's Second Symphony. I found myself dissatisfied with Dave Hurwitz's review, as it is not really detailed, I wanted to put down my own impressions. Overall, Järvi's conducting is very compelling: His tempos lean toward the deliberate side, prioritizing textural clarity above all else. That approach is reinforced by very close microphone placement, which brings out inner details that many competing recordings bury.
I. Allegro maestoso
The opening cello soli are among the clearest and most energetic I have heard. Järvi shines in the second theme as well, bringing out a very deliberate, singing line milking all of the expressiveness it offers. The clarity of balance is also amazing. The harp cuts through in passages where it is usually inaudible. My main reservation comes at the massive climax at the end of the development: Järvi takes the Molto pesante at a very broad, slow tempo that feels disconnected from the rest of the movement, and the dynamic impact simply isn't loud or overwhelming enough.
II. Andante moderato
This movement is the biggest miss of the album. Järvi adopts a tempo so slow that it drains the life out of the phrasing, leaving the music cold and static. Mahler intended it to be in 1 because it is in 3/8 instead of 3/4. Whenever the score calls for a rallentando or rubato, the momentum grinds to a complete halt. Compare this to Claudio Abbado's Lucerne Festival Orchestra performance, which isn't even a reference-quality recording, yet maintains the natural lilt and forward flow that Järvi misses here.
III. In ruhig fließender Bewegung (Scherzo)
The Scherzo is brilliantly executed. The solos are packed with character, for example the E-flat clarinet, whose sharp accents are clearly articulated, and the central brass eruptions are genuinely full-bodied. The one drawback is that in passages where woodwinds and brass sustain long whole notes, they never achieve a true pianissimo, a mezzo piano at most, likely an unavoidable byproduct of the close-miked engineering.
IV. "Urlicht"
Mezzo-Soprano Anna Lucia Richter sings wonderfully, using a tasteful, controlled vibrato that comes as a huge relief compared to the heavy, over-wobbly vocal approach that often weighs this movement down.
V. Finale
Following along with the score, this movement is the strongest of the album. Järvi checks every interpretive and architectural box. The characterful phrasing across the orchestra is on full display, the pacing holds the sprawling structure together, and the execution leaves very little to complain about.
I think this is a very great recording, and people familiar with this symphony would find it very enjoyable
Link:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_kfMoxwFM8Jq6I_TmrEw5eZXIGhuRe3Ovo&si=r3igh6ZN2NAuTWkS