r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • Sep 13 '20
Announcements Resignation from the bench
I resign from the position of Chief Justice. It has been an honor to serve with my colleagues, and I wish them all well
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • Sep 13 '20
I resign from the position of Chief Justice. It has been an honor to serve with my colleagues, and I wish them all well
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/BloodyChrome • Mar 05 '21
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • Jul 27 '23
Question
Whether the NT Times committed defamation against BellmanTGM with its Twitter statements, Petioner's petition may be found here
Next Steps
The Court has agreed to admit the case, and thus what will now happen, is both parties will have a chance to present the case before the Court through a written submission on or before 5 August 2023. Extensions for deadlines can be requested and will be granted on a case-by-case basis.
Up to one rebuttal submission is permissible per party up to 5 August 2023, Extensions may be requested.
Any those who are interested to intervene in this case, as a third party, in favor, against, or taking a neutral position, may submit their Submissions to the Court on or before 5 August 2023. We look forward to getting more briefs in. All of these briefs must be modmailed to this subreddit or via discord PMs to Lucifer(.lucifermorningstar).
After this stage, the Court will have a hearing from 6 August 2023 to 10 August 2023, where both parties will have a chance to ask questions, respond to questions posed by the other side and the Justices of the Court, and debate submissions.
Notes
Under a new scheme trialed by us, to bring about more participation in the Courts, we will not be asking for any form of formatting to be abided by when briefs are made. The only restriction is that you use Times New Roman, and font size 10.
Further, the High Court Rules of 2021, nor the forms will be applied in this case. We're basically trying to see how this simplified Court would work, so do participate! DM me if you need any help with the Submissions or if you have any questions otherwise.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/ohprkl • Feb 12 '21
Whilst I was only appointed to the High Court a short while ago, I am now stepping down. I am determined not to sit on the court as an inactive Justice, only concurring with the opinions of my colleagues, and unfortunately the stress of my job and other irl commitments have left me with little spare time. Whilst I have a good understanding of British law, I simply have not had the time to do the required research on Australian law and as such, I feel it is wrong for me to continue as a Justice whilst only being active enough to concur.
I would like to thank my colleagues for their support and understanding in my time as a Justice, and I look forward to taking on a new role better suited to my skills and availability.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/DirtySaiyan • Jun 26 '20
Today I am announcing my resignation from my role as Chief Justice. It has been an honor and pleasure to have continued serving this great nation in such a role. Thank you to my esteemed colleagues who have done an exemplary job of carrying out the duties of the bench.
Sincerely,
The Hon. DS
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • May 01 '20
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • Apr 24 '20
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/tbyrn21 • Jun 15 '19
Dear Attorney General,
I write in regard to the following conversation we have had over the last few weeks concerning the appointment of a new Justice of the High Court of Australia.
As you are aware, the current bench comprises of just two judges. However, the minimum prescribed under the Australian Constitution is 3.
There are sigifnicant legal issues if this situation is allowed to continued, for the maintenance of a strong democratic system of governance.
The Justices of the High Court of Australia emphasise the important role of the High Court of Australia and beseech you to appoint a judicial mind to the Court.
Signed, tbyrn21 CJ, General_Rommel J
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/General_Rommel • May 23 '19
ORDER ORDER
The Court is now in session, with the Honourable Justice General _Rommel presiding. Chief Justice tbyrn21 also presiding.
The High Court of Australia, sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns, has received a petition from /u/n4ziporriidge.
Exhibit A: Petition
The High Court of Australia shall hear from the petitioner and the Commissioner (or legal representative). The High Court of Australia may hear invitations of leave to appear. Leave may or may not be granted, on the discretion of the Court.
It is anticipated that the Court will sit for 5 days on this matter. However, this may be shorter or lengthened depending on the requirements. The Court shall endeavour, per s 363A of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918, make their decisions as quickly as possible.
A copy of the petition shall be relayed to the Parliament Clerks per s 369 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918
Hon General Rommel J
Justice of the High Court of Australia
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/PM-ME-SPRINKLES • Feb 17 '19
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/PM-ME-SPRINKLES • Oct 29 '18
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '21
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Apr 02 '21
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Mar 23 '21
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Mar 21 '21
Order, Order!
The Court is now in session, with the Hon. Justice. /u/NeatSaucer presiding. Also presiding are Chief Justice /u/BloodyChrome, Justice /u/Winston_Wilhelmus and Justice /u/Jayden_Williamson.
Accused:
/u/TheTrashMan_10, Member for Melbourne
/u/arles2464, Member for Sydney
/u/stranger195, Member for Cunningham
/u/ThanksHeadMod, Member for Lingiari
/u/cool_santa, Member for Mayo
General Charges:
Breaching the Regulations laid out in Pages 7 to 9 of the AustraliaSim Standing Orders as identified in House Activity Check 19.03 held for the period from 8 March 2021 to 22 March 2021.
Specific Charges
/u/TheTrashMan_10 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days
/u/Stranger195 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days
/u/arles2464 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days and Requirement 2 on not miss 10 or more votes in a row.
/u/cool_santa - Breached Requirement 2 on not miss 10 or more votes in a row
/u/ThanksHeadMod - Breached Requirement 2 on not miss 10 or more votes in a row
Determination:
If the Judiciary finds the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must issue a warning to the elected representative to meet the activity requirements.
If the Judiciary again, after another referral, find the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must expel the parliamentarian.
The Judiciary may choose to not warn or expel the parliamentarian if there are exceptional circumstances which prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating which:
Prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating;
Prevented the parliamentarian from being active in a Meta and Canon, except to make it known they were unable to vote and debate; and
Were out of the control of the parliamentarian; and
Were circumstances which were not foreseeable, such as an accident, a medical condition, a natural disaster, a long-term internet outage or a loss of accommodation.
Submissions:
The accused, the Attorney General and the Chair(s) who made the referral may make submissions. They should either attempt to disprove the referral by fact (showing the MP or Senator debated) or show there were "exceptional circumstances". Submissions are expected within 48 hours.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Feb 23 '21
Order, Order!
The Court is now in session, with the Hon. Justice. /u/NeatSaucer presiding. Also presiding are Chief Justice /u/BloodyChrome and Justice /u/Jayden_Williamson.
Accused:
/u/Captain_Kate_2258, Member for Moncrieff
/u/arles2464, Member for Sydney
/u/stranger195, Member for Cunningham
/u/Winston_Wilhelmus, Senator for Northern Territory
/u/CardboardGradient, Senator for Western Australia
General Charges:
Breaching the Regulations laid out in Pages 7 to 9 of the AustraliaSim Standing Orders as identified in House Activity Check 19.01 and Senate Activity Check 19.01 held for the periods till 21 February 2021
Specific Charges
/u/Captain_Kate_2258 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days and Requirement 3 of voting atleast on 25% of the votes every 14 days
/u/arles2464 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days
/u/stranger195 - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days
/u/Winston_Wilhelmus - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days
/u/CardboardGradient - Breached Requirement 1 on Debating once per 14 days and Requirement 3 of voting atleast on 25% of the votes every 14 days
Determination:
If the Judiciary finds the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must issue a warning to the elected representative to meet the activity requirements.
If the Judiciary again, after another referral, find the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must expel the parliamentarian.
The Judiciary may choose to not warn or expel the parliamentarian if there are exceptional circumstances which prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating which:
Prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating;
Prevented the parliamentarian from being active in a Meta and Canon, except to make it known they were unable to vote and debate; and
Were out of the control of the parliamentarian; and
Were circumstances which were not foreseeable, such as an accident, a medical condition, a natural disaster, a long-term internet outage or a loss of accommodation.
Submissions:
The accused, the Attorney General and the Chair(s) who made the referral may make submissions. They should either attempt to disprove the referral by fact (showing the MP or Senator debated) or show there were "exceptional circumstances". Submissions are expected within 48 hours.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Feb 17 '21
Order, Order!
The Court is now in session, with the Hon. Justice. /u/NeatSaucer presiding. Also presiding are Chief Justice /u/BloodyChrome and Justice /u/Jayden_Williamson.
/u/ThanksHeadMod has applied to the Court for leave to be granted for a case against /u/Youmaton as a Moderator, whose petition can be found here.
Upon due deliberation with the members of this court, it has been decided that there will in fact be a hearing, as it has been found that there is enough of a question of law here to warrant our attention to the matter at hand. Therefore, the case will be considered.
The present thread shall serve as a hearing as well, where we encourage both parties and the Justices to do their questioning in the comments however all of you must ping the party from whom you want a response. The Court might request for further evidence which we hope parties will provide us upon request.
The Parties may provide, and we highly recommend that Parties provide further submissions as a part of their in-hearing submissions. The in-hearing submissions must be provided by 48 hours of the case being put unless an extension has been requested. Without an in-hearing consideration, the Court will not get a chance to hear your views in detail to make further sense.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/_slothsworth • Oct 25 '20
Order, Order.
The Court is now in session, with The Hon. Justice u/_slothsworth presiding.
Given the urgency of the matter, and the similar circumstances of the two applications, the court will hear both cases at once. Please clarify at all top-level submissions below as to which application you are submitting for.
As such, both applications for leave are granted. The court will proceed with the hearing.
The court is now calling on submissions from the Applicants and Respondent.
The Applicants' submissions can be found here, and here.
The court gives 5 days for any submissions to be made (Friday, 11:55pm AEDT). 2 days for any submissions to be made (Tuesday, 11:55pm AEDT). 5 days for any submissions to be made (Friday, 11:58pm AEDT). Yes, those 3 minutes will make a difference.
Update: Application from J Williamson's representation for submissions to be required by Tuesday the 27th of October, 11:55pm AEDT has been granted.
Update 2: Submission deadline is now Friday 30th October, by 11:58pm AEDT.
Update 3: The court will take the submission of the Former Prime Minister as that of evidence. Given the submission time, the court will extend the hearing by a further 2 days until Sunday 11:55pm to allow for time for the applicant or respondent to examine the submission.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '20
Order, Order.
The Court is now in session, with The Hon. Justice u/Sir_Stuart_Brown_QC presiding. Chief Justice u/jarjar_the_sithlord and Justice u/_slothsworth also presiding.
Accused:
Requirement 1 - A MP or Senator must debate at least once per 14 days.
/u/Gregor_The_Beggar /u/GHagrid
Requirement 2 - A MP or Senator must not miss 10 or more votes in a row.
Requirement 3 - A MP or Senator must vote at least 25% of votes every 14 days.
Activity Check 4 - 20th August - 3rd September
Determination:
If the Judiciary finds the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must issue a warning to the elected representative to meet the activity requirements.
If the Judiciary again, after another referral, find the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must expel the parliamentarian.
The Judiciary may choose to not warn or expel the parliamentarian if there are exceptional circumstances which prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating which:
prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating;
prevented the parliamentarian from being active in a Meta and Canon, except to make it known they were unable to vote and debate; and
were out of the control of the parliamentarian; and
were circumstances which were not foreseeable, such as an accident, a medical condition, a natural disaster, a long-term internet outage or a loss of accommodation.
Submissions:
The accused, the Attorney General and the Chair(s) who made the referral may make submissions. They should either attempt to disprove the referral by fact (showing the MP or Senator debated) or show there were "exceptional circumstances".
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/jarjar_the_sithlord • Aug 16 '20
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/jarjar_the_sithlord • Jul 23 '20
Re: dennisfoxmp
Order, Order.
The Court is now in session, with The Hon. Justice u/jarjar_the_sithlord presiding. Chief Justice u/advancedgaming12 and Justice u/slothsworth also presiding.
Accused:
Requirement 1 - A MP or Senator must debate at least once per 14 days.
Activity Check 1 - 8th July to 22nd July
Determination:
If the Judiciary finds the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must issue a warning to the elected representative to meet the activity requirements.
If the Judiciary again, after another referral, find the referred MP or Senator is in breach, the Judiciary must expel the parliamentarian.
The Judiciary may choose to not warn or expel the parliamentarian if there are exceptional circumstances which prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating which:
prevented the parliamentarian from voting or debating;
prevented the parliamentarian from being active in a Meta and Canon, except to make it known they were unable to vote and debate; and
were out of the control of the parliamentarian; and
were circumstances which were not foreseeable, such as an accident, a medical condition, a natural disaster, a long-term internet outage or a loss of accommodation.
Submissions:
The accused, the Attorney General and the Chair(s) who made the referral may make submissions for the next two days. They should either attempt to disprove the referral by fact (showing the MP or Senator debated) or show there were "exceptional circumstances".
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • May 23 '20
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/advancedgaming12 • Apr 10 '20
Order!
The Court is now in session, with The Hon. Justice /u/advancedgaming12 presiding. Justice /u/_slothsworth also presiding.
The court has received the following, Exhibit A.
The Applicant has requested an injunction against the item which they have taken to court, for the duration of the hearing. The injunction is approved with immediate effect.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/Anacornda • Mar 01 '20
The Court is now in session, with The Hon. Justice /u/Anacornda presiding. Justice /u/_slothsworth also presiding.
Act: Standing order p 7 to 9
Outline of Claim:
Requirement 1 - A MP or Senator must debate at least once per 14 days
Activity Check 3 - 13th Feb to 30th Feb: TheAudibleAsh, later_slater1407, umatbru
Previous Warnings:
Umatbru
Judgement:
The Hon. Justice Anacornda
umatbru - In breach for Activity Check 3 and ejected.
Umatbru was ejected, because it is believed they were capable of debating, as they voted.
later_slater1407 - Not in breach for Activity Check 3
It was brought to the Judiciary’s attention that the Senator had in fact debated, and that has led us to not warn the Senator.
The final case, the case of TheAudibleAsh. The main factor going into the judgement here is that the Member was on leave from the 11th February until the 22nd February, meaning that the member only had 4 days to debate, something that isn’t very realistic. This led us to the decision of:
TheAudibleAsh - Not in breach for Activity Check 3
The Judiciary has decided that we will only warn or eject people from Parliament if they were available, that being not on leave, for at least 5 days of the 14 day time frame, or about 33%, this is something we believe to be realistic for most people.
r/AustraliaSimHighCourt • u/tbyrn21 • Jun 03 '19
Order! Order!
Chief Justice tbyrn21 presiding, Justice GeneralRommel also presiding.
The court has received the following, titled Exhibit A.
It is unknown how long this will take to resolve, but one would imagine atleast a week.
The Applicant has requested an injunction against the item which they have taken to court, lasting the length of this hearing. Given the timeframe and importance of this, I am approving this injunction with immediate effect until a decision is made.