Posts
Wiki

Monday Methods

Monday Methods is a a bi-weekly feature series on r/AskHistorians where we discuss, explain, and explore historical methods, historiography, and theoretical frameworks concerning history. The post will be for people to respond to regarding primarily methodology or historiography, but can also outline general academic practices and advice for studies in the humanities.

2018-2019 Schedule

DateAuthor/Topic
Dec 17u/commiespaceinvader
Dec 31Holiday
Jan 14u/Snapshot52 - Why the dictionary is problematic
Jan 28u/commiespaceinvader
Feb 11u/Snapshot52 - Cosmological Lenses
Feb 25-
Mar 11-
Mar 25-
Apr 8-
Apr 22-
May 6-
May 20-
June 3-
June 17-
July 1-

Brainstorming topics:

u/commiespaceinvader's suggestions:

  • Orientalism and Balkanism

  • What is the "other"?

  • Historical "accuracy" and historical accuracy

  • How to write a historical text

  • Social History: Discovering history via statistics and its limitations

  • Allohistorical/alternative history fiction

  • Historical Discourse Analysis

  • What is Nationalism?

  • Writing history: Critical or affirmative?

  • Totalitarianism

  • "history is written by the victor"

  • Global history

  • Discussion post: How to best organize research? Practical tips

  • The problem of Biogrpahies and Bourdieu's persona

  • history of taste and Bourdieu

  • Memory studies

  • Regional studies, historie crosse and the study of borderlands

  • Migration studies

  • What in the world is Critical Theory?

u/Snapshot52's suggestions:

  • Indigenous Statistics and Research

  • Intergenerational Trauma and Indian Education

  • Contemporary Issues with Historical Roots (blood quantum, relates to racial understandings)

  • Holism (Relationality) - Room for the metaphysical?

  • Indigenous Identity: Diversity or Pan-Indianism?

  • American Indians and American Politics: A History of (Mis)Representation

  • An Indigenous Oral History: Storytelling

  • Colonial History: How colonization has impacted its victims

  • Why the dictionary is problematic

  • Cosmological Lenses

  • Metaphysical Aspects

Suggested Topics by Flairs and others

Topics that have been suggested by the flair community

  • rt History for non-western contexts and the overlap between art history and semiotics

  • Interdisciplinary Dialogue

  • How does a historian deal with the moral aspect of history - of course I'm not talking about passing personal judgement - but how does one deal with groups, powers or institutions that presented themselves as "moral"? When the focus is no longer on fact and factual evidence but with claims or the nature itself of institutions?

  • 'Doing History on Reddit' - How does our approach differ to doing academic history and what methods etc. do we employ on the internet

  • How about the difference between history and the past - and non-western notions of the aforementioned?

  • Handling the non-human in history (ecology, geography, animals, etc)

  • The pitfalls of popularization

  • The intentional fallacy in an historical context (problems involved in divining what historical people wanted/believed as opposed to what they said/did)

  • How should historians talk to people in other disciplines?

  • Does "the Anthropocene" matter as a concept?

  • Is "history" as a field left-leaning, and is conservative historiography possible?

  • Antiquarianism and the Study of History

  • Modernism vs. Modernity

  • Origins of the Popular Culture (we could get u/ancienthistory in on that one?)

  • Years, Dates, and Calendar Reform

  • u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part I

  • u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part II

  • u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part III

Previous Questions

DateQuestion
October 20, 2014Useful Methodologies
October 27, 2014Integrating Archaeology and History
November 3, 2014Difficult Primary Sources
November 10, 2014Taking advantage of Historical Linguistics
November 17, 2014Postmodernism and Studying the Human Past
November 24, 2014Outreach, Experiences and Plans
December 1, 2014Critical Reading and Criticism ( Full Credit to this exchange for the idea)
December 8, 2014Tax vs Tribute vs Gift
January 5, 2015Limitations of Expertise
January 12, 2015Complexity
January 19, 2015Organising Research
February 9, 2015AskHistorians
February 16, 2015Unfamiliar Fields
March 2, 2015Fictional Depictions
April 6, 2015Definitions of Tribe
April 20, 2015Disproportionate Attention
April 28, 2015Describing Empire
May 4, 2015Search Engines, the Library, and fonts of knowledge.
May 11, 2015Comparative Histories
May 18, 2015Longue duree
May 25, 2015Planning a history curriculum
June 1, 2015Can the subaltern speak?
June 8, 2015Manuscripts and primary sources
June 15, 2015Oral History
June 22, 2015Conveying information with maps, charts and graphical data
June 29, 2015Charting a course in the Digital Humanities
July 6, 2015Counterfactuals as a tool of historical inquiry
July 13, 2015Defining Power
July 20, 2015Storing and Sharing Chronologies
July 27, 2015Defining Legitimacy
August 3, 2015Drawing Historical Parallels with Modern Events
August 10, 2015Human Spaces
August 17, 2015Incorporating contributions from Amateur Enthusiasts
August 24, 2015Material Culture
August 31, 2015Combining Activism and Academia
September 6, 2015Managing the Examination Gap
September 13, 2015Looking at History from the Bottom Up
September 20, 2015Commemoration and Historical Memory
September 27, 2015How does Technology Impact Methodology?
October 12, 2015Continuity and Catalysts
October 19, 2015Studying Historical Diseases
November 9, 2015Literature as Historical Artifacts
November 16, 2015Finding Secondary Sources
November 23, 2015Understanding Secondary Sources
November 30, 2015Reading Primary Sources Critically
December 7, 2015Troublesome Primary Sources
December 14, 2015Writing Your Paper
December 21, 2015Specific Primary Sources
December 28, 2015Alternative Historical Narratives and Identity
January 11, 2016International History and the Regional Framework
January 25, 2016Accounting for Choices Not Made
February 1, 2016Structure and Agency
February 8, 2016Black History Month Special
February 15, 2016Body and Disability
February 22, 2016Video Games for teaching History
February 29, 2016Post-postmodernism: where does Historiography go next?
March 7, 2016Applying Modern Terminology to the Past
March 14, 2016How does Periodization affect our Perspective
March 21, 2016What do Historical Accounts look like?
March 28, 2016Social Class in History
April 4, 2016Earlier Standards of Scholarship
April 11, 2016Quantitative History
April 25, 2016Womens History
May 2, 2016Local History and Historical Societies
May 9, 2016Bridging Academic and Popular History
May 16, 2016Getting the most out of Conferences
May 23, 2016Historical Reenacting
June 6, 2016Lenses of History
June 13, 2016Going beyond Secondary Sources
June 20, 2016Finding Scholars to Follow
June 27, 2016Getting Published
July 4, 2016Reading Historical Fiction
July 11, 2016Writing Historical Fiction
July 18, 2016Organizing your Digital Library
August 8, 2016World System theory and looking beyond the Nation State
August 15, 2016The Past is a Foreign Country
August 22, 2016Grad School Applications pt 1: should you apply and under what conditions?
August 29, 2016Grad School Applications pt 2: getting started with your application
September 12, 2016Applications pt 4 and 5: Strategizing plan B/what happens when I am in?
September 19, 2016Violence
September 26, 2016The Annales School
October 3, 2016Research Trips Abroad
October 10, 2016Do we Learn from History?
October 17, 2016Combating Holocaust Denialism
October 24, 2016Online Sources by u/WARitter
October 31, 2016History of Emotion
November 7, 2016Return of Video Games
November 14, 2016Role of Historians in Society and Politics
November 22, 2016Marxism and Hegemony
November 28, 2016Oral History Interviews
December 12, 2016History, Narrative and You
December 19, 2016Race as a Concept in History
January 16, 2017Comparison as a Historical Method
January 23, 2017Women's and Gender History
February 6, 2017What is Groupism?
February 13, 2017An Indigenous Approach to History
February 20, 2017Literature as a Source
February 27, 2017Eric Hobsbawm and the Invention of Tradition
March 13, 2017E.P. Thompson and the Making of the English Working Class
March 20, 2017What is a Method?
April 3, 2017Historical Fiction
April 17, 2017the Hunt for Sources
April 26, 2017Sigfreid Kracauer and Film as a Historical Source
May 1, 2017Great Man Theory, Trends and Forces, Capitalism, Socialism, and how we write history
May 8, 2017Is research value-neutral?
May 22, 2017A special episode of our podcast and a discussion post regarding: Post-modernism and history. How do we engage with it? Where do we go from here? What is the history of the future?
May 29, 2017Visual History and a quick guide to how to use photographs as a historic source
June 12, 2017Factual literacy, the limits of interpretation and public history
June 26, 2017"Indigenizing" a literature review
July 3, 2017American Indian Genocide Denial and how to combat it
July 10, 2017American Indian Genocide Denial and how to combat it (Part 2) - Understanding genocide in law and concept
July 18, 2017Understanding contemporary concepts from different perspectives - An Indigenous view of technology, science, and history
July 31, 2017We talk about actual human beings and "get your feels out of history" is wrong – on Empathy as the central skill of historians
August 7, 2017Discussion post: "History in popular media" (or Dunkirk and Videogames 3: Beyond Methoddome) by u/commiespaceinvader
August 21, 2017Collective Memory or: Let's talk about Confederate Statues.
September 4, 2017History interpretation and how to get some by u/itsallfolklore
September 11, 2017Discussion post: Non-human things in history
September 18, 2017Critical Theory
September 25, 2017Interdisciplinary Dialogue by u/Commustar
October 2, 2017Ethical Engagement: Researchers and Tribes
October 9, 2017Indigenous Peoples Day and Columbus Day: Revisionist?
November 20, 2017Discussion post: "It's actually about ethics in historical research" – Questions on ethical engagement with the field of academic history.
December 4, 2017Using Secret Sources by u/restricteddata
December 18, 2017An Indigenous Pedagogy