It might come as a shocker, in our culture of wanting to figure out the "best" way of doing everything--but there is no best method of regenerative farming. Whether you are an advocate of holistic managed grazing, broad scale mixed cropping, or agroforestry farming, all have a place where that system is most suitable and will thrive.
In general, everything is specific. If you really want to help restore land while cultivating it, a good starting point is to examine what type of ecosystem had existed historically (prior to desertification or deforestation) and go from there.
Regenerative grazing advocates have a catchy slogan: It's not the cow, it's the how! There's truth in that. An agroforestry grower myself--with "skin in the game"-- have learned a great deal over the past year about holistic grazing practices and I'm genuinely impressed. I'm writing this pos (with video) in an effort to foster more understanding and cooperation. By and large, I agree with "It's not the cow, it's the how."
But it's also the Where.
When the starting point is a degraded grassland, it makes sense that the finish line is a healthy grassland.
In a temperate climate, a prairie of mixed grasses, wildflowers, clover, vetch and so forth grazed by ruminants is a carbon-sinking optimally-functioning ecosystem.
But in the wet tropical forests? In contrast to the prairies of temperate climes, a pasture in the humid tropics is so sparse with life many refer to it as "the green desert."
Expanding monocultures of soybean and oil palm are most certainly wreaking their own brand of havoc. Yet conversion to pasture remains the key driver of environmental degradation in both Central and South America.
What happens when the same cows, so valuable to the grassland ecosystem, are transplanted to a logged patch of land seeded with non-native grass in the wet tropics? I've seen (and worked) it firsthand: weathered soil that cracks in the sun, collapse of aggregates and microbe populations. Hundreds of thousands of other plant and animal species are also decimated.
The forest canopy in a tropical wet climate is indispensable to the entire system. The canopy intercepts the pounding rains and lessens their impact on the ground. The lattice of tree roots hold soil and leaf fall is a constantly cycling source of carbon and nutrients. Unlike prairie soils, tropical soils are shallow. But an intact forest, where all of the life has evolved according to these conditions, is robust despite the lack of deep soils. Carbon is stored not so much in the soil, but in the woody mass and leaves of the trees.
When the forest canopy is cut, massive amounts of carbon are lost to the atmosphere. Rain hits the ground like a blitzkrieg, causing erosion. Unsuited to the tropics, the cows themselves suffer from parasites, heat stress, and belly bloat from eating wet grass. The farmers struggle financially and work double time to keep the forest from growing back.
For every form of life involved, from microbe to animal to man, the situation is lose, lose, lose.
Context is everything.
Pastoralism on the open grasslands of the earth has a long history and the people who practice it from a place of deserve more respect. There is no tradition of pastoralism in tropical forests, appropriately enough. The "grazing" animals of the jungle, like howler monkeys, also depend on trees.
But people have lived and thrived in the dense tropical forests for millenia. They modified their environment to feed themselves, but they did it without massive deforestation.
They did it with Agroforestry.
Agroforestry is a way to raise abundant food, including complete protein and nutrient-dense superfoods high in fiber, minerals and antioxidants. Agroforestry also provides cash crops like cacao, spices and medicinals.
Do you like good dark chocolate, shade grown coffee, vanilla ice cream, or cinnamon sprinkled on your oatmeal? Or do you drink ginger tea for a cold or take turmeric for joint pain? These are all products of tropical agroforestry.
Agroforestry systems mimic the natural forest in terms of complexity and diversity, but with a focus on perennial tree species producing food, fodder, building material, and/or large amounts of biomass.
For people, the rainforest ecosystem, and the planet, it's a win, win, win.
Tropical and subtropical rainforests account for only 6 percent of the planet's non-frozen land mass. Yet fifty percent of the living plants, mammals, birds, insects, reptiles and amphibians on the planet call this small slice of earth home.
In comparison, grasslands cover forty percent of the non-ice earth. There's no need to clearcut rainforests to put ruminants where they clearly don't belong in rainforests.
Soil regenerators, let's work together to encourage and implement the best practices of regenerative farming IN THE RIGHT CONTEXT. In general, everything is specific. Not excluding and especially ecosystem appropriate farming practices.