r/AdviceAnimals • u/[deleted] • May 20 '12
Actually heard someone say this
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3pd83b/43
u/davidbhayes May 20 '12
YOLO = You Only Live Once.
Maybe I'm just absurdly old in Internet Years, but I was baffled by that.
0
145
u/ADHDLAc May 20 '12
As a 'Buddhist' I dont see any contradiction. It all rests in the definition of self, as what one takes to be self is not self from an absolute standpoint in Buddhism. What is reborn is not what we commonly refer to as self, hence, you only live once.
39
u/reomc May 20 '12
Exactly. I don't claim to have studied the scriptures of buddhism that much, but one passage from the writings of Zen buddhism always stood out for me:
A man walking across a field encounters a tiger. He fled, the tiger quickly chasing after him. Coming to a cliff, he caught hold of a wild vine and swung himself over the edge. The tiger sniffed at him from above. Terrified, the man looked down to where, far below, another tiger had come, waiting to eat him. Two mice, one white and one black, little by little began to gnaw away at the vine. The man saw a luscious strawberry near him. Grasping the vine in one hand, he plucked the strawberry with the other. How sweet it tasted!
7
2
u/LoughLife May 21 '12
I love koans, they're quality comedy
4
u/reomc May 21 '12
Got me confused whether you used an english word I didn't know. If you don't want to take the time to type Kōan, just write Kungan, which is correct as well.
This is no Kungan, by the way. You could argue it is an allegory. A Kungan is meant to confuse, this text is a clear metaphor to life.
3
1
2
0
May 20 '12
[deleted]
3
u/whoopzzz May 21 '12
I woulda kept the vine. Might've come in handy whipping the crap out of the tiger on the bottom.
5
u/scartol May 21 '12
This.
Also, generally speaking once someone claims to be a Buddhist, we're cool with them self-applying that term. There's no beating-in ritual or anything.
3
u/Ecpie May 21 '12
And, not all sects of buddhists believe in reincarnation. If I am correct it is a much more common theravedan/tibetan notion.
5
2
u/SomeoneStoleShazbot May 21 '12
So after my life of selfishness and generally not giving a shit, the guy who
respawnsreincarnates as a dung beetle isn't me?If so, fuck karma and fuck that other guy, I'm living for me!
4
u/ohgeronimo May 21 '12
That would be the point. Rebirth is not reincarnation. The intention is to steer people towards a middle way, while acknowledging the fleeting nature of existence, and that everything in existence is part of the whole.
0
May 20 '12
Fine, I'm not going to argue those stupid semantics.
Can't you just say "Carpe Diem" like everyone else for the past two thousand and some years?
0
u/fuckyoubarry May 21 '12
I went to a buddhist service once, the sermon was all about not being a dick in this life because basically youv only live once and theres no heaven. Then we all chanted gibberish for an hour and spun around in circles till we fell over.
33
May 20 '12
I thought this was College Liberal?
26
16
u/GrayStudios May 20 '12
I'm pretty sure this is a misconception about Buddhism. They believe that your positive influence (karma) lives on, not literally you.
8
28
u/helllomoto May 20 '12
It's like a atheist saying for gods sake. It means nothing.
9
May 20 '12
Or a straight man saying "FUCK ME IN THE ASS!", they usually aren't seriously looking for anal sex.
5
u/DeepCretaceous May 20 '12
Buddhists do not strictly believe in reincarnation, in fact that is probably one of the most significant differences between Buddhism and Hinduism.
4
4
u/supersquidcreature May 20 '12
As a Buddhist, I would like to say that many Buddhists do not believe in reincarnation. That belief is for characteristic of the Hindu faith.
4
May 20 '12
Buddhism is probably the most misunderstood religion/philosophy in the western world.
Contrary to western tendency, Buddhism isn't something that can be used as label. People that identify as "Buddhists" can be as different from each other as fish are from plants.
It's so unfortunate that people see Buddhism as an "all or nothing" type of life; it's really not that simple.
2
May 20 '12
If you were categorizing Asia as whole, defining Buddhism can be difficult, but each nations of Asia has their own distinctive, dominant flavor which can be clearly identified within a country.
None of which are following the Buddha's original teachings.
3
3
3
May 20 '12
Technically correct. If you are a Buddhist practitioner and you die, when you reincarnate, you are not reincarnated as the same person. Rather only bits and pieces of your former self make it through to your rebirth.
And my friends said taking a southeast asian religions class would never come in handy. HA! I showed them.
9
u/BandBoots May 20 '12
I'm a Level Five Laser Lotus in my Buddhist temple, and I can tell you that you do indeed only live once. When your energy gets reformed into a human body, it is really more a continuation of life than a new life. I hope this helps.
2
7
5
u/qkme_transcriber May 20 '12
Here is the text from this meme pic for anybody who needs it:
Title: Actually heard someone say this
Meme: Bad Argument Hippie
CLAIMS TO BE BUDDHIST
SAYS YOLO
This is helpful for people who can't reach Quickmeme because of work/school firewalls or site downtime, and many other reasons (FAQ). More info is available here.
13
May 20 '12
Uhh.. Hindus believe in reincarnation..
Buddhists are trying to escape it..
14
u/creepyeyes May 20 '12
Aren't both ultimately trying to break the reincarnation cycle?
-9
May 20 '12
Who cares, they're both wrong.
1
u/theleftrightnut May 21 '12
Opinions, man.
0
May 21 '12
Well does anybody really believe that a goddess emerged from a giant lotus flower and then created everything?
2
u/theleftrightnut May 21 '12
Millions believe that world is only several thousand years old and others that feeding pieces of stone will give them good fortune.
0
May 21 '12
Agnostic here.
2
u/Kiwi150 May 21 '12
Agnostic here.
why did you feel it necessary to say this..
1
May 21 '12
Well, detective, if should reveal a little about my beliefs so you know where I'm coming from.
1
u/Kiwi150 May 21 '12
I sense some teenage angst. Who are you to say if they're wrong or right, unless you happened to create the goddamned universe?
"does anybody really believe-".. Jesus Christ. Of course there are people that really believe it. There are people that really believe everything in the Bible and Quran. Just because it isn't your cup of shit-tea doesn't mean it's wrong.
1
May 21 '12
You're good. I'm sure it isn't hard to realize I'm a young, naive teenager... what do you believe in, then..?
4
May 20 '12
Yeah, downvote for you, buddy. Buddhists can definitely be of the opinion that reincarnation is bullox.
1
2
2
May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Technically it's not contradicting. Orthodox Buddhism (one that is founded by Buddha himself and the doctrines which were set by also Buddha himself) says nothing of afterlife and reincarnation (Only thing said about these are that those concepts are not worthy of questioning if they cannot possibly be tangibly questioned). Only thing that is required is self-enlightenment and attaining higher plane of thought and thus ridding oneself of worldly suffering.
2
2
2
2
6
2
2
u/BigCatTherapist May 20 '12
There are a large amount of Buddhists that are atheists or agnostic. Most famous one that I can think of off the top of my head is Lisa Simpson. Its rare to find a Buddhist who thinks they'll get reincarnated, and even then they most likely wouldn't see life as stopping after death, just merely a continuation. If you're going to insult someone, at least understand why what they're doing is insulting.
1
u/IAMAHIPO_ocolor May 20 '12
...I think all the 'Buddhists' here are missing the point. I think it's a bit funny how many ignorant pretentious fucks call themselves Buddhists. I think what is most funny about this is that YOLO is all about hedonism and impulsivity, while Buddhism is about eliminating desire...
5
May 20 '12
You shouldn't make such a broad, enveloping claim about a religion that is so incredibly diverse and multi-faceted. Different forms of Buddhism approach life differently, and, likewise, seek to cease the three poisons differently.
1
May 20 '12
Being a buddhist who doesn't believe in karma and reincarnation is like being a christian who doesn't believe in christ or the Resurrection. At that point your using the name but not the meaning. THAT is the point being made here.
1
May 20 '12
It's more like a situation where you either consider Joseph Smith's version the mainstream one or not.
The orthodox Buddhism differ quite radically from the newer versions. It's practically Atheism if somebody invented it thousands of years ago. The original teachings of Buddha contains no supernatural elements, idols, false promises, and afterlife.
It merely says that the life is suffering, and you must live a life of the middle way to rid yourself of it.
Though somehow all those people after Buddha's death got the idea of putting in bunch of stuff to sell the religion to common uneducated folks...
1
u/isntthatrightkiff May 20 '12
Or, they merged Buddhism with their own religions and took their favourite parts of both to come up with, for example, Tibetian Buddhism. Also, "it's pratically Atheism if somebody invented it thousands of years ago". What?
1
May 20 '12
I meant to say what Buddha invented was practically Atheism, but with different name and in his own flavor in his time.
Wasn't trying to say Atheism was invented. That's impossible. Sorry for the confusion.
1
u/Flix47 May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
You need to do your research before blindly assuming you know things. I am a Buddhist. One of our core teachings is that we should pick and choose which of Siddhartha's teachings we should follow based on what our own experiences and knowledge tell us is correct for us.
Karma and reincarnation are very far off from the core teachings of elimination of desire, impermanence, and kindness. It is VERY common for these two teachings to be abandoned because the individual no longer feels they are correct.
Buddhism was designed to be an evolving belief.
0
May 20 '12
All Buddhists believe in karma and reincarnation
I'm a Buddhist and don't believe in karma and reincarnation (as you see it)
You're using the name but not the meaning (i.e.: A true buddhist believes in karma and reincarnation)
Pretty much the definition of the No true Scotsman fallacy there I believe.
0
May 20 '12
that is simply not true, im a buddhist and i dont believe ill come back as a camel or an otter
1
u/isntthatrightkiff May 20 '12
You wouldn't come back as anything, it doesn't work that way. Your karma continues on, not 'you'. There is no 'you'.
1
May 20 '12
i meant that i dont believe i will be reincarnated into a living creature like a cat
1
u/isntthatrightkiff May 21 '12
You wouldn't be reincarnated. That's Hinduism, not Buddhism. Buddhism rejects the concept of a permanent eternal self. In Buddhism your Karma continues, not you - there is no 'you'.
1
May 20 '12
The original teachings of Buddha isn't necessarily about total elimination of desire. It's about moderation - the middle way. Buddha teaches that the path to the enlightenment is through living a life that is without neither end of the extremes.
Buddhism is about self-elimination of suffering through cognitive training (aka enlightenment), and Buddha's thought was that if everyone lived the path of the middle way, then the world will become peaceful.
So technically speaking, hedonism and enlightenment isn't necessarily mutually exclusive. You could be like Tony Stark of Buddhism and still be considered alright.
1
u/Eyulfable May 20 '12
Buddhists don't believe in reincarnation. I'm pretty sure that they don't know what happens after death, nor do they claim to. It's similar to them being agnostic, because they don't know the answer.
1
u/Jsilbs May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Early buddhist texts that most people hear about in American universities understand rebirth as either a metaphor for moving between the stages of enlightenment or a psychologic analogy of consciousness. Tibetan Vajrayana, and Mahayana (which was was more popular among the people you call liberals in the 60s-70s) may believe in a cosmological wheel of life with literal rebirth; but the OG shit is pretty down to earth.
In fact rebirth in buddhism is so understated compared to its other stuff and compared to hinduism, I'm pretty sure you just confused the two.
Edit: In fact, Siddhartha and his intellectual descendants pretty much just trolled anyone who asked about god, reincarnation or anything metaphysical.
1
May 21 '12
Technically buddhists don't believe in reincarnation...
1
u/neocow May 21 '12
right. They can, but buddhism does not ask you to believe in anything. Zen actually wants you to stop beleiving in anything, everything. to shut up and live your life
1
u/syriquez May 21 '12
If they're a spiritual Buddhist, this criticism applies (and that depends on the specific sect/school that is being discussed). If they're a philosophical Buddhist, then it doesn't.
The average college student following some degree of Buddhism is usually the latter.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 21 '12
Most westerners who call themselves Buddhists who weren't raised as such don't actually know what Buddhism is.
1
u/improbablesky May 21 '12
Protip: nowhere in buddhism does it say you must believe in reincarnation to be a buddhist. try doing some research before you put your foot in your mouth.
1
u/neocow May 21 '12
You don't have to believe any one thing or anything that buddah said to be a buddhist.
Also note that karma/reincarnation is more toward "you" live right now, and "you" are constantly dying. There is no "past" "you" and no "future" "you"
When you die you're still there after all, you just stop moving.
1
u/VicariousWolf May 20 '12
OP, there is a HUGE difference in Buddhist reincarnation and HINDU reincarnation.
Buddhist reincarnation simply means rebirth, while Hindu reincarnation is the one being specified in the UTTERLY FAILED meme post.
0
0
May 20 '12
In the West, the version of Buddhism practised by a lot of Westerners is an Atheistic/materialistic corruption of Buddhism. It's kind of like the "atheists who want to meditate" religion. A lot is lost in the cultural translation. So it fits in well with the Liberal Hipster stereotype.
-1
u/Lurk_Noe_Moar May 20 '12
Thank you so much for not titling this college liberal. I now actually find this to be funny. Have an upvote.
0
7
84
u/nondickyatheist May 20 '12
Most Buddhists believe in reincarnation as a metaphor.