r/AMDHelp • • Jul 01 '25

Help (General) Is my CPU dead?

I got short circuit for my ring circuit connected to my computer directly twice today and the computer didn’t boot up at all, CPU debug light was glow on my current motherboard

Then I pulled out my backup motherboard to check anything wrong and this happened

The Debug light flickers and the motherboard cosmetic LED flicker together as well

I also used another working PSU to test the backup board with the CPU and the same thing happens

When I remove the CPU, the board lights stops flickering

My computer spec:

Ryzen 5 3600

MSI X570 Tomahawk (current using)

MSI B450 Gaming Plus Max (Backup)

MSI RTX 2060

Corsair 3600MHz 16GB

PSU: Antec HCG 620M

Many thanks to anyone who can help

62 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

4

u/tissuebandit46 Jul 01 '25

Is the cpu secured in the bracket?

You're supposed to lock the bracket before turning on the system

You also need to plug in the fan 

2

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25

Locked and also plugged a fan to CPU Fan socket

4

u/Fabbs1 Jul 01 '25

Check whether there is dirt in the pins somewhere, whether they are bent, use a CPU cooler, reset Windows and pray that it works l.

2

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25

I found some thermal paste on the pins and cleaned it, same thing happens, checked no bent pins

1

u/DeathRabit86 Jul 01 '25

If thermal paste get inside socket, cleaning it is almost impossible due when trying open socket you probably brake plastic due is extreme brittle .

1

u/GetChopped Jul 01 '25

There are replacement sockets on Amazon for $10

3

u/MrEpic23 Intel 14700k, 7900xtx, 64gb ram, 60tb+ Jul 01 '25

You didn’t lock the cpu in the board…. You just put it in. Lift the arm and lock it in. You could have killed it by doing what you did since some pins didn’t line up and got power that shouldn’t. You will also most likely need a fan plugged into the cpu fan header.

1

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25

Yes I did lift the arm put the CPU in and lock the CPU in the socket and connect a CPU fan to the CPU fan socket as well(I didn’t put the radiator on because I am taking the CPU out soon after test) Thanks for your answer tho

2

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25

One more thing: the short circuit is not caused by the computer, it is caused by one of the electrical appliances connected to the power strip got short circuit and overload the ring circuit, the computer is not connected to the power strip

13

u/ImDistortion1 Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25

Lots of things wrong here. Do not start a pc without the cpu locked down with a fan thermal pasted. Also never ever remove parts from a powered on board or even have any power connected whole changing parts. It’s like running a car engine without coolant. Sure it may work for the first minute but will very quickly overheat. Motherboards can be very prone to short circuit. Never wear socks on carpet or have any power running through the board when touching parts.

1

u/prime38time Jul 01 '25

dont think that applies on the newer cpus, but he is using AM4 as i do and would not be comfortable doing that

3

u/ImDistortion1 Jul 01 '25

It is very important to never run a cpu without thermal cooling. It can overheat In seconds and damage parts.

8

u/Minimum-Poet-1412 Jul 01 '25

Clear CMOS and retry

8

u/tbone338 Jul 01 '25

If all of the mobo cosmetic lights also flicker, it may be the motherboard.

7

u/HankThrill69420 Jul 02 '25

Hello, I'm here to itemize a short list of nope:

  1. CPU powered with no cooler

  2. bread boarding on a plastic bag

  3. there's nothing actually wrong with the way you removed the CPU, I just hope you killed the power first.

  4. that is all

7

u/Professional-Win-230 Jul 02 '25

Just take it to a computer shop because if you keep playing with it you just going to make it worse

1

u/Aggressive-Dot9747 AMD Jul 02 '25

computer shops do the exact same thing what exactly are you smoking?

5

u/kimo71 Jul 01 '25

Take cpu out reseat take ram out try with one stick of ram redo all connections replug in make they they are all plug also check cpu for bent pins or burn marks

5

u/Shamrck17 Jul 01 '25

Wow it must still be high from last nights rave

5

u/innoctua 10thi9, Zen3 PBO 4.7gHz - Zen2 manual OC 4.15gHz - EPYC 32Core Jul 01 '25

The IEC C13 kettle plug must be removed from PSU before pulling out processor.

heatsink.

You can test if there's still power to the board by unplugging C13, then hold power button until lights/fans aren't spinning. Especially when removing a processor while power is still likely to be going through the board.

5

u/Kiseido 5800X3D, 6800XT Jul 01 '25

I got short circuit for my ring circuit connected to my computer directly twice today and the computer didn’t boot up at all

What does that even mean?

Those debug lights each mean something, but I can't tell what is what from your video

5

u/Winters_SP Jul 02 '25

No one with sense, test your CPU without COOLER..??

-1

u/Consistent_Singer_15 Jul 04 '25

Modern CPUs should be able to just throttle down, no?

It's ok just to see if it Posts.  But yeah once you hit the BIOS you want the cooler back on.

1

u/ColdBeerPirate Jul 05 '25

it won't even post with out a heatsink.

1

u/Fantastic_Advantage6 Jul 05 '25

back when i was upgrading from ryzen 1200 to 3600 i remembered that i actually managed to get into the bios without attaching the cooler. I just knew it should'nt normally happened

9

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '25

Why are people powering their mobos like this on bags. Idiots. Goes wrong so easy. This is not anti static. Plastic bags has a very beneficial polarity to create best envoirnent for static electricity.. Good fing job...

7

u/Kiseido 5800X3D, 6800XT Jul 01 '25

Wait a second, what is that plastic that the board is sitting on?

If that is the anti-static bag that the motherboard came in, then you may have damaged the board by laying it on the bag with power connected. Those bags are conductive!!!

1

u/MEGA_GOAT98 Jul 01 '25

well thats probly broken now heh... try another cpu - also make sure your completely unpluged before you put a new one in :)

1

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25

Yeah that’s the annoying thing I don’t have a new CPU to try that

1

u/MrEpic23 Intel 14700k, 7900xtx, 64gb ram, 60tb+ Jul 01 '25

Then why is the arm of the cpu down when you take it out? That doesn’t make any sense.

1

u/brianli408 Jul 01 '25

Oh I lift the arm, took the CPU out, and put it back down before I move my camera to film it

Edit: I tried again, made sure the CPU is locked I pull it a couple times and it is not moving, I jump start it and same thing happens

1

u/MrEpic23 Intel 14700k, 7900xtx, 64gb ram, 60tb+ Jul 01 '25

Yeah something is borked. I usually recommend going to a professional but since this is a real budget system, parts cannon from Amazon might be more economical.

1

u/Abject-Surround1966 Jul 01 '25

Bottom yes but now it's too late boss

3

u/OutrageousCellist274 Jul 01 '25

That's some disco lights there, I've never seen it move that fast.

2

u/ItsMeIcebear4 R7 9800X3D | RTX 5070TI Jul 01 '25

pretty sure thats doa

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 01 '25

Little early to bring out the Christmas lights don't you think?

1

u/Pwheelie420 13700k, Nitro+ 7900xtx, 32gb ddr5 cl32, 1000w Jul 01 '25

same 7900xtx, love the card. do you have any driver issues?

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 01 '25

No, apart from actual expected bugs from the driver. I.e. Youtube stutter when not fullscreen/theater. As found in Known issue of current latest driver.
I modded my 7900xtx nitro. Also my PC is on 2-3 weeks at a time, so it is rock stable.

1

u/Pwheelie420 13700k, Nitro+ 7900xtx, 32gb ddr5 cl32, 1000w Jul 01 '25

how did you mod your card?

just about the only issue i have is it sometimes doesn’t initialize all my 3 displays and shows a error 43 in device manager (Windows has stopped this device because it has reported problems) and then a restart usually fixes it.

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 01 '25

Mod for temp.
I changed all paste/thermal pads.
Used thermal putting for the vrams.
Used PCM-1 for the GPU die.
Scraped the backplate of all the plastic and used new thermal pads.
Put a huge aluminum heat sink that runs on all of the thermal pads connecting the vram and the backplate. Used thermal paste for this (it held well actually and confirmed with thermal gun it works).

Temp of hotspot is within 10C difference.
Vram used to go 90C+, now is 80C max.

Your issue is not related to the modding.
Did you try DDU?

1

u/Pwheelie420 13700k, Nitro+ 7900xtx, 32gb ddr5 cl32, 1000w Jul 01 '25

I know the issue doesn’t relate to modding i just like hearing how people squeeze more perf. from their cards. I used DDU before i reinstalled windows to see if it would fix, but i still had the issue so i reinstalled. i’ve also checked all 3 8-pins multiple times. I’ve been through just about everything that i think it could be a faulty card somehow. When i’m not having the issue i can play endlessly with no issues. Pretty much just happens on startup.

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 01 '25

5 minutes of furmark stress test. Ambient 24C.
The hot spots are creeping up. Not too bad though.
I use phase change, but it is already 6 months old.
People say it gets better overtime. Not for GPUs it doesn't, that was myth busted.
https://imgur.com/a/R01TqXy

The 3 8 pins are separate CPU/PCIE in your PSU right? I.e. not using daisy chain.
Have you tried BIOS update.

43 error can be caused by GPU, PCIE lanes, Power, CPU.
You being a 13700k makes it a pandora box. Though less risk having microcode issue, but its worth a shot trying it on a different setup.

BTW you can restart your GPU with win+ctrl+shift+B, maybe that removes the need for restarting.

1

u/Pwheelie420 13700k, Nitro+ 7900xtx, 32gb ddr5 cl32, 1000w Jul 01 '25

thank you very much for the restart shortcut, i’ll try that next time. I was thinking about also changing to PTM for gpu die and maybe vram, but all my temps aren’t anywhere near concerning so i haven’t yet. Yes my 8-pins are all separate & no daisy chain on 1000w psu. My mobo bios has been up to date since i built the pc, first thing i did. Updated it again recently (version F6e)when i reinstalled windows.

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 01 '25

PTM should be good. I went with PCM-1 due to it having better or similar performance from some tests and cheaper for me.
https://imgur.com/a/233O8NI

2

u/ElephantHopeful5108 9800X3D | 7900XTX Sapphire Nitro | x870 Asrock Pro RS Jul 02 '25

Crap I left the furmark overnight. I forgot to close it. My PC has been stress testing since last night, room is hot now LOL

1

u/Pwheelie420 13700k, Nitro+ 7900xtx, 32gb ddr5 cl32, 1000w Jul 02 '25

space heater was pushing 😂

2

u/Benscko Jul 02 '25

Is that a anti statc bag? 🤣

1

u/tackleho Jul 01 '25

Yeah. Mobo manual usually has light indication messages. I'm pretty sure red 911 sirens means doa

1

u/Trammster Jul 01 '25

Did you check if your bios support that cpu? Might be a stupid question, but I seem to remember that I had the same issue.

1

u/Aggressive-Dot9747 AMD Jul 02 '25

this is what I want you to do

take out the SSD Ram and GPU

only have the CPU and power supply plugged in

then I want you to jump start

if you still see that flickering between diagnostic LEDs that is an indication that either the CPU or the motherboard is the deffective. my best guess would be the motherboard because thermal face gone into one of the holes while thermal face isn't conductive it can also act as an insulator which will prevent one of the pins responsible for post to not occur properly causing that flickering.

if the flickering stops and you get to the diagnostic LED lights where it is pointing to the ram then I want you to plug in only one ram stick in the proper slot.

then continue on forward until you recreate that flickering.

1

u/Repulsive_Shirt_1895 Jul 03 '25

He's not gonna do all that 😂

1

u/Aggressive-Dot9747 AMD Jul 03 '25

only way to fix the PC

1

u/Repulsive_Shirt_1895 Jul 03 '25

He probably gonna screw something else while doing all that 

1

u/Aggressive-Dot9747 AMD Jul 03 '25

then what do you suggest send it to a computer shop like you would?

1

u/Repulsive_Shirt_1895 Jul 03 '25

Where did I say I would take it to a shop? Anyway, watch, this guy ain't fixing. Just give it up Lil bro, you see he has his mobo on a plastic bag. Just face it, dudes mobo is fried 

1

u/Aggressive-Dot9747 AMD Jul 03 '25

that's why you double check and confirm. first time in a troubleshooting form?

1

u/Repulsive_Shirt_1895 Jul 03 '25

Not gonna lie, I just realized I'm in AMDHelp instead of pcmasterrace 💀 My bad. But that guy is still fucked 

1

u/brianli408 Jul 05 '25

Turns out it’s the CPU fried not the board😂

1

u/Professional-Win-230 Jul 03 '25

I'm not smoking at all she can put it she should get insurance with a store to help you with it so if it happens again they have to fix it for free

1

u/Moonblitz666 AMD RX 7800 XT Jul 01 '25

That's what you get for having a cheap PSU in your build, a more reliable PSU would have blown instead of your more expensive CPU.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

Trust I have a b550 went through two motherboards same issue if you take cpu out and turn the power button on you’ll get your lights and motherboard and everything running

6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mysterious_Topic_197 AMD Jul 01 '25

Also arm is up