r/AMA • u/[deleted] • May 05 '15
I was on Judge Judy as a plaintiff against my fiancé's aunt AMA I'm doing this because of a post on r/funny where everyone seemed to think its a legit and legal show and she's an actual judge, my case and answers I have can prove otherwise, I was screwed over on the show and fed lies
24
u/MoshPotato May 05 '15
An hour in and you still havn't explained how "they switched it around making me a cheater and liar instead of sticking to my car and the case".
I didn't think anyone thought Judge Judy was currently a proper judge. It was always clear to me that she was a retired judge.
-4
May 05 '15
Again if you read my answers that I've given I was assured I would be paid the amount I was seeking from the show. They assured me my case was good and would win, they also notified me she wasn't a legal judge it's a show she has no legal power, they said it was who she sided with. With the story given from her aunt about me being on fb and talking to women they completely dropped my car and made it about that situation. I was told to bring pictures a quote for the damages for her to see that was the actual amount these were examined by producers not by Judy and I was told on TV those would be more as props but they needed to be sure that was an actual amount for damages not some bs made up by all of us
28
u/Nygmus May 05 '15
Sounds to me like you should have read the contract you signed in more detail, and not trusted the bullshit you were fed by some producer.
12
u/HitlerWasASexyMofo May 05 '15
when OP talks to a US Marines recruiter, much hilarity shall ensue. "Yeah, sure kid, you gonna be a fighter pilot, juss sign here."
2
u/Lampshader May 06 '15
If you're misled about the content of a contract, isn't that possible grounds to have it ruled invalid?
1
u/Nygmus May 06 '15
Not a lawyer. Not sure. I have to think that signing is an affirmation that you accept the contents of the contract.
3
42
u/CivEZ May 05 '15
On a scale of trailer park to your dad is your brother, how white trash are you?
12
May 05 '15
Nice try I'm a dirty job stealing spic
No seriously tho I was born as well as my parents but my grandparents hail from Puerto Rico
26
u/vkashen May 05 '15
Yes, but how well were your parents born? That part wasn't clear.
-32
May 05 '15
Ask yer mum how me n her made you M8 n dats how me nan and me papo made me folks ya cunt
3
u/vkashen May 05 '15
Wow. English isn't even my first language and I word better than that. "A" for effort, though!
0
May 05 '15
[deleted]
15
7
u/thebumm May 05 '15
I'm thinking Judy got confused by his grammar... Judy, my car with my aunt as well as money in the states legitimately owe me?
Uh... sure pal.
30
8
u/tryllast May 05 '15
AWESOME!!!! I guess my question is the details of the complaint, why were you "suing" and what was their idea of a defense?
-7
May 05 '15
I was suing for damages done to my car, which was witnessed by two people who went to defend me. Her defense was blaming on her niece even after the whole family gave her up but they flipped the switch and changed it to a completely irrelevant topic
11
May 05 '15
Given the production company pays all fines levied on that show, you're definitely better off being the accused on that show than the plaintiff. Only way accused can lose is if they forfeit property, which almost never happens.
-6
5
May 05 '15
Tell us about your case.
0
May 05 '15
Well the story is I was at my fiancé's family's party where liquor was involved in an argument broke out and I voiced my opinion I was too intoxicated to drive home I was picked up received a call from my fiancé and found out what happen to my car, they say she did it because I had women messaging me on Facebook but she did it because I called her out for being the person she proved to be by damaging my car. The show called reassured me I'd get paid the money needed to fix my car so I went, got there and Judy made it about my Facebook
38
May 05 '15
Im so confused.
-1
May 05 '15
I went to small claims to file a claim against my fiancé's aunt, who keyed my car, she also smashed the window and broke the radio antenna. The courts sell cases to producers for any judge show(I was called by Mathis and the people's court) the producer told me I had a strong enough case to win, whah I didn't know is Judy is retired and has no legal power so they switched it around making me a cheater and liar instead of sticking to my car and the case
-5
May 05 '15
Which part id be happy to clear up any confusion
30
u/Torkin May 05 '15
The entire thing. If this is how you present your case when you have time to write it down I can only imagine how it sounded coming out of your mouth. Punctuation and structure are your friends.
"...where liquor was involved in an argument broke out..." That makes no sense and indicates it was the liquor that was actually arguing.
13
May 05 '15
Sorry I was cooking and used speech to text. The story was that we were all drinking on Memorial Day. I was verbally attacked by her and other members of the family, they basically belittled me to distract the attention from her cousins ex, so I stood up for myself, said some hurtful things but true and told them after 7 years enough is enough. I hitched a ride to go home due to drinking, got a call in the am about the car being vandalized and here we are
15
2
u/beccafool May 05 '15
So what reason did Judy use to justify the idea that they were not liable to pay?
1
May 05 '15
Her argument was that because of her hearing that I was talking to other women on fb she felt no reason to give me or the case any further review, but reddit being reddit everyone thinks they know it all, I was told on by her people to argue with her, they told me before hand she's not a legal Judge and holds no legal power anymore I couldn't be arrested or charged with anything from her.
4
5
1
6
u/originalsinner702 May 05 '15
Your sentences ran on and kind of all went in different directions. Take the time to really explain your story in one comment so we all have something to reference, and so you don't have to keep repeating it.
1
May 05 '15
Sorry this is my first time kinda over whelmed I didn't expect so much interest in this lol
1
May 05 '15
what happened to your car? Why did it happen to your car?
5
May 05 '15
Take advise from me don't drink with white trash. My fiancé's aunt is immature, she damaged my vehicle because I called her out for being a terrible person. The night I did I was drinking and hitched a ride home and when I left she took my words out on my car. Her entire family gave her up as well as witnesses and her bragging that's how I found out it was her
5
-4
May 05 '15
She's also very sexist if you watch any episodes about 95% of cases of men versus women all women win
154
u/WiretapStudios May 05 '15
/r/titlegore. I'm taking you to title court.
9
May 05 '15
Quiet in the courtroom! Please tell me why the defendant did.
23
u/WiretapStudios May 05 '15
Please tell me why the defendant did.
Objection: /r/commentgore
16
May 05 '15
Overruled!
Reddit rules in the favor of the plaintiff!
As decreed by our ancient customs I hereby decree Op is a faggot.
5
11
May 05 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Daloowee May 16 '15
What's title gore?
1
u/WiretapStudios May 16 '15
Uh, just go to /r/titlegore and find out? (It's not gory, it's about wordy titles).
1
28
u/A_Cave_Man May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
11
4
11
u/measureofallthings May 05 '15
I too was a on Judge Judy, as a defendant against my ex-girlfriend's mother. The litigation was legit. Her judgement was legit. It is sort of a legit show, but not always. I also belong to an audience casting company that sometimes has auditions for courtshow litigants because apparently they have trouble getting enough legitimate cases they have to make some up sometimes and have some people act them out.
2
u/I_smell_awesome May 05 '15
What are your favorite pizza toppings?
0
-2
u/HitlerWasASexyMofo May 05 '15
what the fuck does that have to do with anything?
15
u/I_smell_awesome May 05 '15
IT'S AN IMPORTANT PIZZA RELATED QUESTION, HITLER.
-3
u/HitlerWasASexyMofo May 06 '15
How can I be Hitler when we all know he lives in South America, and I don't?
4
2
u/poohbear85 May 05 '15
Is she the overwhelming bitch in person as she is on tv?
2
May 05 '15
That's an understatement, neither me or my guest were allowed to talk to her or even ask for pictures, he found comedy in what happened to my vehicle and the fact that me n my fiancé cannot afford to live together at the time
13
May 05 '15
I met her and her husband away from the show last year and they were extremely nice to me. She was on holiday at the time, obviously bitch mode disabled.
4
May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Just to add my old roommates stepfather did a lot of construction work for her. She paid really well, was a great person to work for and was really nice from what he said. We were all friends and hung out w. weekend bonfires / crawfish n beer and his coworkers who worked w. him at her house came by a few times.
-20
May 05 '15
Yes she's very fake. What you see on TV is her
30
18
1
2
u/PowerOfGamers01 May 05 '15
Did you went to an real cout at somepoint?
-3
May 05 '15
Yes I did, that's where they find the cases. Courts apparently have a deal with the producers where they send them small claims for a fee and then chose which seems more appealing, this was all told by the actual producer
1
1
u/oldspice75 May 05 '15
Can you link to the episode?
-2
May 05 '15
Don't want to due to identities of the people involved but just remember the story
7
u/A_Cave_Man May 06 '15
You are worried about the identities of people who voluntarily appreared on a television show?
-4
May 06 '15
One of the contracts we all signed was a hush we couldn't speak anything about it or give any details as to what happen or what we were told
3
u/oldspice75 May 05 '15
Did you have your witnesses with you there?
Did you make comments about the case or the defendant on facebook that were used as evidence against you?
Was there a counterclaim? Did either side receive money? Did you get compensated in some way even if you lost your case?
-2
May 06 '15
Had witnesses who told the same story
Made comments offered pics and a quote for damages
The aunt lied and pinned it on her niece even tho we all had similar stories
Even with the aunt blaming my fiancé it was still directed and focuses more on my fb and making it about me being a supposed cheater all which the producers told her aunt, her cousin went with as a witness to side with us when she told this to the producers they didn't allow her to speak on the show
3
u/oldspice75 May 06 '15
I've watched plenty of Judge Judy. I've always known that her show is an arbitration, not an actual court, which is obvious. I've never seen her as being biased in favor of women (especially compared to other daytime TV personalities like Dr. Phil etc.) Obviously she can be mean and rude on the show but anyone who has seen it knows that. So I think that there are probably two sides to your case, and you're bitter about it. And you didn't answer my question about getting money. If you want to change my mind, pm the link to me. Thanks.
2
1
u/Bdizzle420247 May 05 '15
I'm guessing based on your answers, that you are still together with you're same fiancé? If so, what kind of relationship do you have with her family now? Especially the aunt. Any good holiday stories? Lol aside from the Memorial Day one that ended you up here. And sorry to hear about your car and shitty experience trying to get it fixed, that truly sucks dude.
-2
May 05 '15
Thank you I appreciate it, ever since then me and my fiancée have a stronger relationship than ever and me and her family are doing good now except for the aunt we don't talk no more she ended up cheating on her husband and now her and my fiancée have a strained and nearly non existent relationship
4
u/Bdizzle420247 May 05 '15
Wow. That aunt sounds like a real piece of work. I'm glad it didn't hurt your relationship with your fiancé though. It's good to hear it's made you two stronger if anything. Congrats on your engagement and good luck to you both in the future! I hope your marriage is a happy one.
2
1
May 06 '15
They cut a lot out of the show one witness was in the marines and she belittled him because he lives with his parents, they also cut out her aunt studdering like porky pig when Judy began to question her which to me shoulda been a sign she was guilty
1
May 06 '15
Thank u I was beginning to lose hope with this site, no matter what as someone who grew up on Chicago and saw things like that it's never ok to do something like that to someone's hard earned property
3
u/Bdizzle420247 May 06 '15
Yeah man, I fully expected to get down voted to hell when I was typing my comment just based on everyone else's. But oh well, fuck em, strangers on the internet won't ever cause me to lose a bit of sleep. And take some comfort in knowing you have a girl that obviously cares about you a lot while the Internet haters are probably in moms basement angrily pounding away at their keyboards with Cheeto covered fingers just to tell you how dumb you are lol.
1
u/squeel May 06 '15
Here's the link to the episode:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=906j0yM2XGA
Judge Judy dismissed his claim because he didn't have any evidence, and the witnesses he brought didn't actually witness anything -- they were operating based on what other people told them. She took the fact that his girlfriend had just found out that he cheating into account, and reasonably concluded that she probably vandalized his vehicle in retaliation.
2
May 05 '15
Did they give your episode a catchy title? Like, "Aunty drank too much and smashed my car!!"?
2
2
u/joequin May 06 '15
This subreddit is filled with the nastiest people on Reddit. It's like I'm in a 4chan thread and its very common on here.
1
1
May 05 '15
You keep writing that the people on the show "reassured" you that you had a good case. Are you aware that encouraging someone to go in a certain direction is not promising them anything definitively?
1
u/joequin May 06 '15
Just because you can legally persuade someone to do something not in their best interest that will make you a lot of money it still makes you a scum bag. The op didn't claim that it was illegal.
1
May 06 '15
From the title: "[E]veryone seemed to think its a legit and legal show ... I ... can prove otherwise" [Bold mine]
Besides, if you are talking to people connected to a show and you assume they have your best interests at heart instead of their own, you cannot be that intelligent. It's not like you don't know their jobs. They're not legal consultants, they work on a show, for entertainment.
1
u/joequin May 06 '15
That's obviously not what he meant when he said it's not a legal show.
And yes believing them was foolish. That doesn't mean they aren't scummy pieces of shit for doing it. You also shouldn't be taking the opportunity to insult him because you think it's easy.
1
1
0
May 06 '15
[deleted]
-7
May 06 '15
Seriously how much of a dick do you have to be to think any person deserves to have something like this happen? You guys will bitch about looting and rioting in Baltimore or praise protectors of stores and homes but when one guy gets his car messed with to the point of it needing repair? And who's the bigger asshole the one doing the shit AMA or the asshole who has time to bitch about it? Her aunt and her saw me messaging women on fb regardless of how or what my intentions were me and my fiancée are still together and getting married next week so wouldn't you agree what they found or I didn't wasn't bad enough to end a relationship of 7 years but bad enough to to inflict $3200 of damage to the body alone? Shit at least on 4chan they don't pretend to like each other
12
May 06 '15
I just watched your case. Your girlfriend clearly did it. You are a cheating scumbag, and you got caught. Suck it up. Bragging about messaging other women on fb is pathetic. Hold on to this chump, because no self respecting, or non visually impaired, woman will want you
-10
May 06 '15
Judging from your post history you were cheating on sorry that happened to you, as for my situation there's more to it that what you assume from the show. Sorry you have hate in your heart towards men but I'd bet money your a hambeast and a tumblr feminist
11
-8
May 06 '15
The point was to tell you all how I knew the show is fake and unreal just like Maury or jerry reddit users are just as bad a religious buffs, I have 6 people who heard what I did who were told what to say and who were told they were gonna stretch the story to get ratings we were all paid off 300 plus the trip plus flight and cab fair, no real judge or court would do that unless they got something outta it and they did, ratings
2
u/JD2005 May 06 '15
Actually you're pretty wrong, Maury and Jerry have fake guests, you're a real guest with a real case. It's not the world's fault you don't understand what arbitration is. Just because it's on tv and they dress it up like a court room doesn't mean she's not deciding on your case with a legally binding contract. I watched your case, legally you deserved to lose.
0
May 05 '15
[deleted]
3
1
May 06 '15
I feel like you're making this up.
1
u/JamesMcCloud May 06 '15
It's french. It's the same as the difference between "blond" and "blonde", "gros" and "grosse", etc. Adjectives for females usually end in e.
29
u/airJordan45 May 05 '15
well, what can you say to prove that it is not a legit, legal show and Judy is not an actual judge?