501 The Fiery Cross - Following celebrations in honor of Brianna and Roger's wedding, Governor Tryon reminds Jamie of his obligation to hunt down and kill Murtagh Fitzgibbons.
502 Between Two Fires - As Jamie continues to hunt Murtagh with the aid of the zealous Lieutenant Hamilton Knox, he's forced to consider whether or not he's on the right side of history.
Ulysses question to her after Roger leaves makes me think Jocasta just wanted to see how Roger really felt about Jemmy, but I wasn't sure if that was her only motive.
Though Brianna didn’t have exactly a nice welcome party to the 18th century, Roger looked like he was thrown from the sky with everything that happened to him and how little (or nothing at all) he was prepared… let alone meeting the cruel Bonnet as the first person he met after traveling. It made me question how much prepared I would be if I was in his place though…
That’s a good point. I often forget just how sus Roger’s appearance must have been for all characters, I wish it had been discussed more, even in a joking manner.
I feel bad for Jocasta having no heirs to leave her life’s work to. I totally understood her wanting to have Jamie, then Bree, & finally Jem as her heirs.
Yeah I think so, Tyron is very aware of Jamie’s abilities (he wouldn’t have given 10 acres to a novice) and his own desire to get the hunt results makes him put pressure on Jamie even on his daughter’s wedding day.
“The letter writer that is parsimonious with his words” is now my favorite snide remark.
How snarky of Tryon to even show up at the wedding! His remark that he didn't want to talk to Jamie on the day of the wedding about hunting Murtagh so he waited until the next day was so wrong.
I LOVE that quote. That exchange is so damn good! (Both of their scenes together are; I love how Jamie starts squirming in his coat when Tryon tells him he needs to track Murtagh down at the end.👌🏼) This episode gives me such a huge appreciation for Tim Downie.
This episode gives me such a huge appreciation for Tim Downie.
He’s so good as Tryon; he totally elevates the crumbs of his character we got in the books. And kudos to the writers since most of his dialogue is completely original. I also think the fact that Tim and Sam have known each other for so long helps the dynamic they built for their characters.
I don’t know if it was a threat or more of a rising suspicion. I don’t get the impression Jamie has not done much to make it feel like he’s trying to find Murtagh
I think we can all agree that the drinking game is an absolute chef’s kiss of an addition to this episode. The best thing about big event episodes is that we get a robust view of what an awesome ensamble of actors the show has.
One of my smaller favorite parts are:
Claire and Bree talking about Jamie doing the Mash Potato
the work in progress house is such a great choice. I feast my eyes on this set, no I don’t care that it’s fancy, it is a work of art!
Germain 💙 forever
Bear, Bear, and more Bear McCreary.
the shot of Jamie’s boots and kilt as The Fiery Cross theme plays… I mean…come on 😍
Addition: I love the first glimpse at Claire’s surgery and her way of attending her patients. When Jamie bows to her goodbye I could swoon!
Marsali really stands out to me in these two episodes, her drinking game skills and her reaction to Claire doing the autopsy asking if she is a witch was too funny.
I LOVED that Jamie put the kilt back on and that Moch Sa Mhadainn played. It's probably my favorite song out of the whole series.
Yes! to be completely honest Marsali during the drinking game is brilliant but she does feel a little too modern, in 502 though, Lauren Lyle hits all of the notes with her delivery when she’s talking to Claire in the surgery. The way that she’s shocked at Claire’s proposition and not so much at the bloody body on the table is brilliant. Also, when she’s butchering the pig she gives Claire the most empathetic smile, knowing how hard Claire is on herself about not being able to help her patients…it’s just beautiful.
to be completely honest Marsali during the drinking game is brilliant but she does feel a little too modern
That’s what I thought this time around too (also had that feeling before when she looked Claire up and down on the ship in 309). The story about their filming those scenes at the wedding is absolutely hilarious, though (“Lauren plays a great drunk” 😂).
Also, when she’s butchering the pig she gives Claire the most empathetic smile, knowing how hard Claire is on herself about not being able to help her patients…it’s just beautiful.
I love that smile as well. Their relationship’s progression throughout this season is so beautiful.
I think it was already mentioned several times, but I have to repeat it and say it as well, the way they both bonded through the season made Marsali one of my favorites… much more than Brianna. Well Brianna was never a favorite of mine to be honest, but that’s a whole other story.
Yes I agree ! The drinking game was so much fun to witness. Marsali is absolutely brilliant and steals the show in every scene she's there in in these two episodes. Love little Germain boy❤️
I like the wedding cake scene. Roger and Brianna are from the same century, but I sometimes forget that they’re from different countries with different cultures and traditions.
But on this rewatch, I also enjoyed the conversation between Claire and Brianna about Frank - how he would be glad she married an Oxford man, and how they speculated she would marry a Chip or a Chad. Seemed natural to remember the father who’s not there on your wedding day.
But I guess I can understand where he is coming from. Having lost so much in Culloden and being indentured for as long as he was would make any man with strength left devoted to fighting oppression. I can’t say I agree with their methods, but I think the Regulator’s cause is easy enough to sympathize with (as Jamie points out to Knox). I guess beyond the tarring, it’s the suddenly ultra political Murtagh that bothers me. Yes, it’s a great storyline to have Jamie and Murtagh at odds, but we knew a Murtagh that was extremely reserved, maybe being apart from Jamie and his promise to Ellen pushed him to find another purpose and to care for others just as passionately.
I can’t say I agree with their methods, but I think the Regulator’s cause is easy enough to sympathize with
Exactly, I absolutely understand their issues and they were for sure getting the raw end of the deal. But tarring and feathering someone is brutal. I get why Murtagh is a part of the Regulators, I just wasn't thrilled with the level of violence that went on.
I felt 502 was a bit heavy on the violence with the tar & feathering, & also with Bonnet slicing up the man’s eyes/face ( could not watch that). Sometimes I cannot believe how brutal times were, & that people actually lived with disfigurement or survived these injuries.😢
Oh my goodness I couldn’t watch that scene either… Bonnet was incredibly cruel and cold hearted. He was what we call nowadays a sociopath. Though his upbringing didn’t help at all, he was evil to the core.
I guess beyond the tarring, it’s the suddenly ultra political Murtagh that bothers me.
I think it’s a natural progression of Murtagh’s character, and I have really enjoyed it. I don’t think he’d ever be involved in something he wasn’t genuinely passionate about (which for most of his life was protecting Jamie), and standing up for his people has always been close to his heart. Remember that moment at Maison Elise when he questioned BPC on why a crofter would join the Jacobite cause, only to “place a more sympathetic arse on the English throne”? Or when he criticized the English for taking away the Scots’ tartans, thus making them unidentifiable at Ardsmuir? (Isn’t his wearing the scrap of tartan a political act in a way?) The hatred for the English, combined with wanting the best for himself, his family, and his fellow Scots, has always been a part of Murtagh’s character, even when his objective was only protecting Jamie. A man who’s seen gross injustice his entire life would not stand for it if he had a chance to stand up against it.
And yes, Murtagh had usually been reserved, but I think the years of injustice against Scots during the Rising and instability during the Clearances, followed by years of imprisonment and indentured servitude, definitely shaped him into a person that appreciated the little taste of freedom he got after his indenture ended (and that is probably true for most of the Scots who’ve also experienced the repercussions of Culloden and then moved to America). For this freedom to be put at risk by unjust taxes and corruption would make anyone more inclined to get involved in politics.
Very true. I suppose it’s important for the story and the viewer to have a character such as Murtagh to be representative of that sort of mindset as the revolution approaches.
I think it was necessary for Claire. If she wasn't trying all she could to help everyone around her in the way only she can, she wouldn't be Claire. Five seasons in, I don't find this surprising at all. Losing someone to something as curable as Appendicitis was clearly very difficult for her , and her resolve to do something to prevent such fatalities must now be stronger than ever considering there's Bree Roger and little Jemmy now also living at the Ridge.
How do you think doing an autopsy would help someone though? I get why it was helpful to teach Marsali, but it's not like Claire can operate on anyone who needs their appendix removed.
Why don't you think she can operate? I think she believes she can operate on Appendicitis patients but with help from someone who knows what they're doing, hence trying to find an apprentice in Marsali. And the only way to prepare her for surgeries like this in the future is by familiarizing her with the insides of the human body.
Also I think because Mr. Farrish died before she could confirm Appendicitis, the only way left to confirm it would be to cut him open.
I was going off more that she doesn't have anesthesia to cut someone fully open for an appendectomy. I know she operated on that guy at the play, but that wasn't cutting him open and removing something.
I get having Marsali learn anatomy from the body though.
Yeah I hear you, I know nothing about operating on someone but from what Claire says to Marsali, it seemed to be like she was sure she could perform appendectomy on someone. Maybe get them drunk? Have someone hold them down? I don't think it's impossible but of course very difficult. There were in fact surgeries performed before anesthesia was discovered.
I think the autopsy is as much about learning how to help others as it is about Claire’s thirst for knowledge and a resolute stance to continue her practice. We know she doesn’t let the century she is in dictate her limitations, so for Claire it would be only natural to find out exactly how the man died of via the methods she knows best. Was it the wisest choice? Probably not, but I think the harmful practices that were being used by the Ridge folks and their terrible results outweigh the risks of the autopsy.
Brianna and Claire are still under the assumption that they are changing things, but how is treating someone with penicillin any different than Claire using much less complicated methods and ideas brought from the 20th century to save lives? How is it any different than Claire using penicillin in 1766, the penicillin she stole from the Boston hospital? It’s also not like penicillin (in its raw form) hadn’t existed up until its discovery and Claire brought it from the 20th century (which could, in theory, mess with the “cosmic balance,” but then if she had, would it be any different than traveling in her 20th century clothes—with modern stitching, fabrics like polyester and all that—and bringing them to the 18th century? She brought the plastic wrapper there, after all); the Penicillium mold certainly existed before Fleming discovered its properties.
Somebody (Claire) could’ve been using it long before Fleming and his students; it just hadn’t made it into the history books. I kind of look at it through an “anti-Columbus” lens: just because people in Europe hadn’t known about America, it doesn’t mean it hadn’t existed up until its discovery.
And I think drinking “mold juice” is not as preposterous for the 18th-century folk as some of the other ideas Claire promotes; after all, blue cheese had been around since medieval times 😅
I see your point but I think it maybe easier to make that kind of rational judgement when you're removed from the situation, like we are here. Though I do agree with you that Penicillin is not any more preposterous than other radical ideas Claire has, I think Bree being scared of this particular idea is justified too. I think It's because Penicillin is a huge thing in itself compared to, let's say ,the hernia procedure Claire performs during the play in S4. I can see why Bree is hesitant on having Claire try to make Penicillin. I also think that maybe Penicillin and it's discovery would have been a bigger deal for Bree considering the time she was born in, unlike for us where we sort of take it for granted.
It's like let's say someone from the future time travelled to 2021, and decided to advance the discovery of COVID vaccine, it would no doubt do the world good but I am sure the time travellers would take a moment to wonder about what kind of ripple effect it would have. I'm in no way saying they shouldn't do it , I'm saying to me it makes sense that they would have some doubt about their actions in terms of would it get them unwanted attention, how would the preparedness of the world in delivery of the vaccine play a part etc. Did that word-vomit make sense?
Yes, I totally see what you mean about the time travelers’ perception in the story vs. ours, especially when we’re largely of the opinion that there isn’t anything the time travelers can change because even the smallest things can have a ripple effect.
I get where Brianna is coming from, but I find it odd that she has an issue with Claire making penicillin when she didn’t raise the issue when Claire decided to take penicillin with her to the 18th century—Bree and Roger applauded the idea, if not encouraged it; the same goes for the plastic wrapper (I am also thinking of the coins they give Claire to take with her—if they were manufactured, say, in 1765, then they would certainly still be there in 1766 when Claire arrived with the same set of coins that just sat in the world for 202 years?! Let’s break our brains again, u/Arrugula).
Then, of course, Brianna will go on to make matches (which were actually invented by accident IRL) in S6, again using all the materials that already are there in the 18th century, just adding modern knowledge, and they are also quite a big deal, so I wonder if she will have similar reservations.
Ok, RD. You asked for it! Let the brain breaking begin!
I suppose the easiest bit to process would be that the coins would have had to been minted sometime after Claire's return, otherwise there would be two sets of the exact same coins existing in the 18th century, which (as far as I know) is not something that is able to happen in the Outlander TT universe. As much as I love the idea of the coins disappearing from some poor soul's pocket in a hilarious turn of events, I don't think this is possible within the parameters of the story...watch me be completely in the wrong per the dumb change in the obituary in the books, but since I don't understand that a 100% yet I'll play dumb for the argument's sake.
Sooo, if the coins were minted after Claire's return we can assume they lead their completely ignorant coin life until they find themselves in a 20th century antique shop. Besides the bonkers realization that the coins are technically time travelers (?!) I don't see how using these coins would disrupt any timeline or event (even if small in consequence) enough to alarm Bree, Roger, and Claire; In fact, the coins kind of follow Claire's same TT path, don't they? Minted after the date of their entrance into 1766 Scotland via CND just as she was born in the future and is hurtled through time to the past. Now (and get ready for some crazy nonsense) by this theory...that would mean that every single coin would have had to end up in the same antique shop where Roger and Bree found them... every single one. I know the antique shop location changes drastically from book to show, but the question remains...did Claire spend all the coins in Scotland? Did she take some on the Artemis? Did some even make it to Jamaica?
It's just bonkers, but hey, I didn't make there rules ('cause there are absolutely no rules.)
I can see where Bree is coming from. Like she says it's one thing to make small changes that don't affect the larger populace but the discovery of Penicillin is a milestone in the history of the world, and messing with that timeline seems like it would have grave repurcussuons and a much larger ripple effect than what they can even perceive at this point, but having said that, I'm totally with Claire on this one :
You go ahead and be badass Claire, we'll be with ya through it all.
I hated all the ridge women dissing Claire, in favour of their male doctor, but I loved that Claire was even more determined to help them by writing the Dr Rawlings sheets, even though it will come back to bite her.
The whole time I'm thinking Claire would have known to use wild echinacea, usnea, garlic and a dozen other plants. They must have fired their plant person...Also the Spanish Moss in the trees on the Fraser's property was LOL.
This might be unpopular, but I don’t love the wedding episode. It’s very campy and part of it feels like fan service (aka all of the couples doing it at the same time, Jamie finding the something borrowed, blue, etc)
I'm not a big fan of the wedding episode either but for different reasons. I don't feel the connection between Jamie and Brianna due to which all their scenes leading upto the wedding seems forced and staged. I do love the montage to Love and I don't mind that they showed three couples making love. It wasn't weird for me even though I've never liked Roger/Bree love scenes.
I don't feel the connection between Jamie and Brianna due to which all their scenes leading upto the wedding seems forced and staged.
Yes, I agree. We haven't seen them bonding to have such an emotional reaction to each other. It's one my few complaints about season five, not much Jamie and Bree time.
Agreed! Almost everything in the run-up to the wedding... I can’t with this dialogue (or with the amount of close ups). It really did feel forced. But it's so sweet that they incorporated L-O-V-E, and even when Claire brings up Elvis. It's so cool (and natural) for them to bring up things from their own time.
I agree, I call it the Hallmark episode! Although as previously mentioned I like the drinking game! My fave thing is Jamie saying Fergus is “son of my name & my heart” ♥️
I see what your saying, I do think it’s very important to have this lighthearted episode considering the overall arch of the season though. The episode was very successful in establishing the Frasers - tenants relationship and draw us into the ties with the British.
I know even the first few seasons had kind of themed episodes as well, but I felt there was a better flow, than in later seasons, when each episode tends to be more separate with less intersecting pieces. Am I making sense? Partly because we have more time jumps, & less coincidental characters showing back up?
I love S5 so much! It’s just so rich in texture, music (the ambience!), people… It feels so alive in comparison to S4 for me.
I had a huge grin on my face pretty much all throughout the wedding. It’s a bit cheesy but they deserve a day of ease and happiness after all they’ve been through in S4.
I love Jamie’s teasing Roger (“like father, like son”) just as much as I love Claire’s “we’re your family, Roger.”
The use of “Moch Sa Mhadainn” (“The Fiery Cross”) in 501 (along with the kilt making a comeback) is one of my favorite moments (not only musical) in the entire show. I had it on the loop for an hour after I watched that episode for the first time.
“So time, space, history be damned” I just love Claire’s resolve.
The use of “Moch Sa Mhadainn” (“The Fiery Cross”) in 501 (along with the kilt making a comeback) is one of my favorite moments (not only musical) in the entire show. I had it on the loop for an hour after I watched that episode for the first time.
I love the line "if he wants a Scot I'll give him a Scot." So good!
The use of “Moch Sa Mhadainn” (“The Fiery Cross”) in 501 (along with the kilt making a comeback) is one of my favorite moments (not only musical) in the entire show. I had it on the loop for an hour after I watched that episode for the first time.
This season is such a good one, I'm so excited to start this rewatch! I feel like the show finally got back on track, after I nearly quit watching.
I love these opening credits! Opening with their individual shots from the back looks awesome (and I'm fond of the fact that they moved the shot of Claire running down to their producer credits). Plus, it comes with a beautiful rendition of the Skye Boat Song, which had me on the fence at the beginning but it might be my second-favorite version now.
But in contrast, RDM’s new credit at the end of each episode gives me Dick Wolf vibes in the worst way.
Jamie Fraser said, “If there’s not going to be class participation then I’m going to start calling on students by name.” (I do love that Roger knew the oath and Jamie was like “whoa.”)
I love Bree and Roger out for target practice. I like the conversation and then he promptly ruins it, but I feel it’s meant to pose a contrast to the end of the season, as we start with "You and Jemmy are my family. James Fraser is my colonel." That being said: “You don’t want to leave them.” WELL OBVIOUSLY, why would you expect any different?!
Dick Wolf vibes 100% 😭 RDM stans come get your man that suggested the season 1 wedding insert because he also thinks of his wedding when invited to other’s weddings.
Way to make yourself relevant, Isaiah Morton. Jamie didn’t want to pick you for the first oath but I guess you’ll do.
Lol I don't begrudge the man his credit, but I do just want to sit with whatever just happened in the episode for a few more seconds without feeling like I just finished an episode of SVU.
suggested the season 1 wedding insert because he also thinks of his wedding when invited to other’s weddings
Omg he did, lol?? We would have gotten the point without the flashback — it was overkill!
I cannot believe I haven’t mentioned the intro when I’m the self-professed devotee of that acapella choir “Skye Boat Song.” And all of the shots are perfect as well. I just had to put that on record 😅
Yes, yes, yes. 🙌🏼❤️ It’s such a wonderful arrangement, and paired with the visuals… I love that they come up with something special every season, and this season is a standout.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 06 '21
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.