r/SRSDiscussion • u/Willrich354 • Mar 08 '12
[Effort] Kony2012, Imperialism, and the White Man’s Burden
(I originally wrote this for my activist buddies and for my personal blog, but I think based on the Kony 2012 thread below this ya'll would enjoy this)
If you have been on Twitter or Facebook you have probably seen some post, link, or picture that has Kony2012 in it. On twitter right now there are 3 trending topics that concern this tag. Joseph Kony is the leader of the Lord’s Resistance Army in Uganda who has the goal of creating a theocratic government based on the Ten Commandments. You can look at the linked Wikipedia arguments for more information on the man and the group. This post isn’t meant to be another in a long line of responses decrying his use of child soldiers or the killing of civilians but to put Kony, LRA, and the campaign to take him out (led by Obama militarily and Invisible Children socially) into its proper context.
President Obama on October 15th last year, a few days before Mummar Qaddafi was killed in Sirte, Libya, told America and the world that it was going to send 100 US soldiers and advisers to Uganda to help fight Kony and the LRA. This act was seen along with the Libya intervention as the first real push for humanitarian military intervention since the Clinton era. Along with that announcement within a few days he also authorized military action in the Central African Republic, Congo, Kenya,and Somalia, for similar stated reasons.
5 months later and we see Invisible Children, an organization dedicated to child solider advocacy, launch a campaign against the same people Obama sent in the military to fight. They posted this page with a petition, and this video to drum up support for the cause of taking out/arresting Kony. Over the past few day this video and the attached cause has become viral and has now infected every Twitter and FB feed on the internet.
What issue can one have with this campaign or the people behind it? A lot actually. Now before I write anything else I want to let all of you know that I as much as anyone else wants to do somethings to Kony and the LRA for the abuses they have wrought on the African people. With that said the people who are leading the crusade against him are as much part of the problem as the LRA is.
Let’s look at Obama and the US. He is going into Uganda to help crush this terrorist and evil man to help preserve the stability of the nation and that part of Africa. I question those motives based on past “humanitarian” interventions America has done and the context within which they have happened. There is alot of evidence (that would constitute a book within itself) that alot of what we call humanitarian interventions are nothing more than America flexing its muscles in places where the chaos can give it or its allies an upper hand. We seen it in Bosnia, Libya, Somalia, Haiti, and many other nations. There’s also the issue of launching this campaign right after the west had overthrown the only government in the northern half of Africa that has had a consistent anti-imperialist foreign policy (Libya) that would have resisted US incursions into the continent.
Invisible Children although not as organized in their profiteering as America when dealing with human crisis has a nice rap sheet of its own. According to many sources, including the Better Business Bureau, Invisible Children is not as open with it’s financials as it should be and base on many of its actions and statements supports military intervention into these situations. This blog post goes into much more detail about the issues with Invisible Children.
Now the reason why I mention all of this is not because I’m trying to debunk the organizations themselves but because they highlight the failed thinking that is still pervasive in westerns about world conflicts. There’s an undertone in the IC video and in the writings of those who are supporters of Kony2012 that if we don’t do something that this will never stop. It’s a very typical “white man’s burden” mindset on the world. Most of us look out into the world and see the issues of Uganda, the rest of Africa, and other poor parts of the world and see them as either savages that need to be taught to act decent or as poor souls who are victims of some vague evil of life. Both of these points of view and the idea that we somehow in America and Europe have the right and responsibility to represent the child soldiers and people of these places is a serious problem for me. It continues the paternalistic attitude that enables America and the west to intervene into places which in more cases than not are a result of previous actions by the same nations that are coming to “save” it.
The WMB mentality also covers up not only closeted forms of american exceptionalism and racism, it also covers up the imperialistic roots of these conflicts. Before the west enslaved and kidnapped millions of Africans and stripped the continent of it’s resources, religious fanaticism like we see here was not prevalent. Nor was starvation, or war, or poverty, or even AIDS. All of these (at least at the levels they are today) are a result of European colonialism. By making the story of some crazed religious fanatic that we should hate it distracts from the Ugandan dictatorship which is a major cause of much of the suffering of the people there and the US government who has supported the regime for over 20 years. It also hides the desperation due to neo-colonial destruction of Africa’s economy that has pushed people to join organizations like the LRA. All of this is hidden if we focus all the attention on making Kony “famous”.
What are we to do then? How do we advocate for the child soldiers, innocent civilians, and others affected by these conflicts? Well for starters we should ask the people of Uganda and African what they want. I can’t say I have seen any sources that give a wide point of view on the conflict and what the people are feeling about it and the US intervention into it but if anyone does please link it in the comments. I would also say if there is going to be intervention into the conflict that it ought to at least come from the African Union not from the US, EU, or UN. None of these institutions have the right to dictate to these people or anybody for that fact how they should deal with their problems. We can give moral support but most military interventions that aim to bring peace end in new dictators and criminals or they end with mass civilian deaths due to the intervention (Iraq and Afghanistan are examples of both results). When we see these campaigns against some “evil” person in some other nation let’s be careful to put that person, their organizations, and the conflict into their proper contexts. Without doing so we are no better than the generations before us who allowed imperialism to gain a hold over the world in the name of first God, then civilization, then freedom, and today democracy and wet it’s wheels with the blood of humanity.
As an aside, it stands to note that this whole campaign may be irreverent based on the fact that Kony hasn’t been active in Uganda since 2006. So America sending troops over there can’t be to help win the conflict because it doesn’t exist there anymore. The statement was made in the Huff Post article about US sending troops to Uganda that “The U.S. doesn’t have to fight al-Qaida-linked Shabab in Somalia, so we help Uganda take care of their domestic security problems, freeing them up to fight a more dangerous – or a more pressing, perhaps – issue in Somalia. I don’t know if we would necessarily say that but it’s surely a plausible theory…” Just something else to think about…
10
u/scartol Mar 09 '12
I agree with many of your concerns. However, I can say that — as a teacher — this is the first time I've ever seen students even a little bit interested in current events in Africa.
Meanwhile, the campaign (for all its faults — to which they have, incidentally, responded) is emphasizing the need for people around the world to care about war and genocide (and other issues; IC has partnered with organizations that are building schools and the like).
As I told my students, I get nervous when US "advisers" go into foreign countries — it didn't work out so well in Vietnam. But I have also been involved in human rights work for 20 years and seeing people get excited about grassroots consciousness-raising and Congressional lobbying (about Africa, no less) is an excellent thing to see.
Now I want to make sure those of us who have been involved for years can show the new fish how to dig in and stay committed.
1
u/Willrich354 Mar 09 '12
Agreed, I'm glad people want to help but sometimes good intentions turns into ugly actions. Look at Australia and the indigenous population, they wanted to help the poor children in the indigenous communities and what they do? Kidnapped them and forced them to act Australian which was devastating blow to the indigenous population and it's continuity. Basically the point isn't to shit on the parade for the sake of it but to open people's eyes to the context of all it so they can make better decisions about donations and actions on such things.
1
u/scartol Mar 09 '12
Yeah, but I think it's quite a stretch to compare this campaign — which is mostly about raising awareness about Africa, a place that gets zero notice from most media outlets in the US — to the Stolen Generations in Australia.
the point isn't to shit on the parade for the sake of it but to open people's eyes to the context of all
And this is something I am totally behind.
1
u/Willrich354 Mar 09 '12
I mentioned that extreme example to show the logic of it is the same. We see "suffering" people (suffering is very subjective at times hence the quotes), we want to help, we have paternalistic/ "white man's burden" mentality, we appropriate the free will of said people (occupation, military intervention, kidnapping) based on this flawed logic of "we'll fix it for them", we do more damage than good. This is the line Kony2012 may be walking based on initial comments and responses to the campaign.
2
u/dat_kapital Mar 09 '12
which is mostly about raising awareness about Africa
awareness alone obviously does absolutely nothing. its what is done with the awareness that matters. and to that point the video is not simply about raising awareness. IC supports the Ugandan military, which has its own horrendous track record or rape, violence, and theft.
a place that gets zero notice from most media outlets in the US
this is completely false.
3
u/gabjoh Mar 09 '12
The point of working with the Ugandan military is it's the only local one that's been at all effective against him (hence, why the LRA is no longer actually in Uganda).
But I'm also going to share what my friend wrote:
First, a quote:
“Don’t let a real, complex issue become a meme. Do your own homework on this. Understand it on a level that a charity like Invisible Children doesn’t get into. Remember: Activism can become an easy salve to serious problems, but what happens in a week, and then after April 20, when Invisible Children’s campaign fades into the ether? It’s easy to focus on something when it’s right in front of you.”
— short form blog
I support this statement 100%. The fact that IC has gained such a large number of followers and supporters over the past few days may not actually be a good thing. It could be dangerous if these new supporters embark on their activist journeys with an incomplete view of the situation in Central Africa, and more generally, an incomplete view of what human rights activism, conflict resolution, and peace-building really entails. People typically do a lot of research and seek exposure to many people, projects, and ideas centered around these topics before they have a real grasp of what it means to be a part of IC and similar organizations, and what the implications of their actions with those groups are. So, hopefully, learning about how often human rights violations and mass-atrocities are committed in the world today will be a starting point for these new followers; hopefully it will be the impetus for them to actually become educated advocates for peace, justice, and human rights.
That being said, I want to make it clear: IC, with all of its flashy campaigns targeted at young people, does do valuable work in some respects. I think it’s rash to completely discredit the organization, which is what I’m seeing many, including more experienced activists, doing. While much of the criticism is well-grounded, we have to remember that IC does a whole lot to support affected communities, whether it be by providing funds/markets for small businesses or providing educational opportunities (ie college) to children who would never have had them otherwise. The radio tower system that they helped to implement is something Ugandans operate largely by themselves, for themselves. Whether or not these programs are completely sustainable, I do not know—but from what i have seen, they have been for the past few years, and consequently have impacted the affected communities positively. Credit should be given where it’s due.
Continued, on her blog.
2
u/Willrich354 Mar 09 '12
Yea for me the sustainability and the unintended consequences of groups like IC intervening in African affairs is what worries me. If they go, all these things may wither away without proper funding. And as we seen with the US involvement in Uganda, lobbying the US army to do something may be well intentioned but void of thought about what happens in a military conflict involving foreign troops. But I like the quotes you included, I would still be meh on the last line or two about giving credit. Yea they've done some good in the short term but we have yet to see the long term political and social effects of their involvement so I will withhold judgment until then.
3
u/dat_kapital Mar 09 '12
The point of working with the Ugandan military is it's the only local one that's been at all effective against him
you mean these guys? funding them sure is a funny way to stop rape and pillage.
3
u/kmeisthax Mar 09 '12
I think most of the people supporting the KONY 2012 campaign thing have this idea that if they like and retweet it enough, the problem will be solved. It's another feel-good slactivism campaign which won't solve the underlying problems.
1
u/HertzaHaeon Mar 09 '12
Is "white man's burden" a figure of speech or is there any reason why it's specifically white men and not white people who are affected?
9
Mar 09 '12 edited Mar 09 '12
Take up the White Man’s burden—
Send forth the best ye breed—
Go send your sons to exile
To serve your captives' need
To wait in heavy harness
On fluttered folk and wild—
Your new-caught, sullen peoples,
Half devil and half child
Take up the White Man’s burden
In patience to abide
To veil the threat of terror
And check the show of pride;
By open speech and simple
An hundred times made plain
To seek another’s profit
And work another’s gain
Take up the White Man’s burden—
And reap his old reward:
The blame of those ye better
The hate of those ye guard—
The cry of hosts ye humour
(Ah slowly) to the light:
"Why brought ye us from bondage,
“Our loved Egyptian night?”
Take up the White Man’s burden-
Have done with childish days-
The lightly proffered laurel,
The easy, ungrudged praise.
Comes now, to search your manhood
Through all the thankless years,
Cold-edged with dear-bought wisdom,
The judgment of your peers!
0
Mar 09 '12
[deleted]
2
u/Willrich354 Mar 09 '12
Exactly! I wrote a post (I think it's on this subreddit actually) about the Libyan war and how it plays into this chess game with China and Russia the West is having in Africa.
1
u/croc_lobster Mar 09 '12
many of what you see written in the west about the Chinese<-->Africa involvement are the dog-whistling fears of the Chinese spreading "colonialism" in Africa.
Could you explain that point a little bit? I didn't quite understand what you were saying there.
6
u/Willrich354 Mar 09 '12
Basically the undertone is that China is manipulating "false" hatred of the west to get these contracts and deals with African nations and the US knows that the more independent China and these nations become in relation to it, the more likely it is that we may lose control over strategic resources such as oil and coltan. Basically in addition to a resource war with China, the US is also fighting a moral and rhetorical war with them too.
4
u/moscowramada Mar 09 '12
I have an objection to this, namely that (unless you can demonstrate otherwise?) Kony 2012 wasn't really promoted by ambitious civil servants. It was basically college students who didn't have a clue about international politics who made it go viral, and average Americans who then took up the baton. It's basically a coincidence that the West is trying to get in good with Africa at the same time that Kony 2012 took over Facebook.
If you can demonstrate otherwise though, it would be news to me.
24
u/veganbisexualatheist Mar 09 '12
What? And how was the existence of this so called anti-imperialist government a good thing?
There do exist savages like Kony who need to be fought and there do exist horribly oppressed people stuck in some very clear (hardly vague!) dangerous situations. I don't see how trying to assuage this equates to some supercilious white man's burden.
Even if it is as paternalistic and high handed as you make it out to be, if it gets rid of Kony then I, as a non-American from an ex colony, fully support any such actions. The US government has an obligation to its citizens to further its interests, and if upholding human rights and common decency against people like Kony intersects with other geopolitical advantages in Africa I will make a value judgement and say its a win-win for human rights.
What? So religion and religious warfare was invented by white people? Is that what I am hearing now?
Really? None of this stuff existed outside of colonialism? Also, how did western imperialism lead to AIDS? Other than the fact that disease transmission is fostered in globalized societies I don't see a morally actionable connection here, or really in any of the grandiose and vague claims you are concocting.
This is true, but you can recognise that economic factors underlie most of the conflicts in Uganda and the rest of the region, and also realise that a faster, more efficient fix to the suffering can be obtained from military action - or so the theory goes.
I pretty much agree with the rest of your post, with the caveat that I would prefer an American led intervention to stop Kony and those like him over no intervention at all. I think when we discuss geopolitics we have to realise that there has to be some ulterior motive for an intervention, otherwise it would never be considered by any rational government. The real question is whether that ulterior motive can fuel a victory for human rights in the region at hand. At this point I really don't know enough about what Kony is actually doing to say, but I just felt the need to point out some of the more glaring inaccuracies and distortions in your post.