r/uhccourtroom • u/CourtroomPost • Aug 27 '19
Report UHC_ - Report
Player Name:
UHC_
UUID:
3553c6197b1a47aca0697dca53b491e0
Accusation:
Harassment
First Time Offense?: Yes
Evidence:
2
Upvotes
1
Aug 30 '19
Honestly don't think this should be a ban, just ban him off your server and tbh that is a solution to this.
Not paticularly nice words but yeh, very soft to ban for this.
1
1
1
u/Jezzerdo4 Aug 27 '19 edited Sep 06 '19
The guidelines states the following:
I'm going to do it in a weird order, so where it is in my list doesn't correspond to the guidelines.
In this case (as we can see) the accused as just been killed, however, it is directed at a player (in this case the host) and it is not attacking their playstyle (which would be hard, as they're spectating), therefore, it meets this requirement.
It takes please in a UHC, therefore, it meets the requirement.
The evidence is a screenshot, therefor, it meets the requirement.
The host doesn't reply to them anywhere, thus they cannot be provoking them, therefore, it meets the requirement.
I'm going to group the last two into one point as it'd be a bit hard to separate them, essentially, is it enough evidence. I'm going to break down each thing said:
On the one hand you have the accused essentially telling the host to kill themselves, yet, on the other, you have them adding a lmao at the end.
The accused calls the host a 'silly little nigger', which would fit into the racist category. However, they create a friendly tone by adding 'silly little', like you're saying it to your best mate as a joke, but, it also seems childish and immature. Having said that, it also doesn't fit the theme of what else they say.
The suicidal encouragement, something your don't joke about, yet they seem to have been just joking before, which is contrary to the first part. Isaac puts it best 'Telling people to die and slit their wrist over a hosting decision is incredibly disrespectful. Mental health isn't a joke and even the smallest of words can drive people over the edge.' Regarding of if it's a joke or not, it's not something you say to someone, without expecting repercussions.
They end with saying 'lmao', which would again link in with the fact that they're joking.
They spam helpop with it, wishing for them to die, but, not threatening them. This could maybe be considered excess profanity, however, the only swear word used is 'shittest', which is not a particularly "strong" swear word. As for the 'die of cancer' I don't believe simply saying that is enough, even multiple times, therefore, it does not meet the requirement.
As for the first message, whilst most of it's a joke, suicide is NEVER a joke and due to what it's about I believe that, despite not explicitly being specified, it does fall into the 'etc' and even as a one off it meets the requirement.
As it is a one off, it's not enough for three weeks, yet I feel two is still too much, but, one too low.One And A Half Weeks.Evidence 3 is self-explanatory, they think it through what they're going to do and make a decision, with intent to harass someone, that they're going to go into discord and encourage someone to commit suicide.
Evidence 4, I'll break down each thing he says:
This is sexist, using outdated stereotypes and also racist, both are mentioned in the guildlines.
Self-explanatory; if you don't know what it stands for I'll save you the displeasure of knowing.
This is a thought out message, not just simply typed out of anger.
The amount of times they say it is completely unnecessary and the wording used is quite clearer intended to be racist (which it is).
Evidence 5 is a combination of what was said in evidence 3 and 4, but to summarise what hasn't been:
Racism and sexism.
This is repeated multiple times. I don't anyone can reasonable argue this is anything but suicidal encouragement. This is serious, admittedly, at this point, they don't care what happens, they just want to let out their anger at someone, by the more hurtful means possible.
Whilst not directly threatening them, these are definitely very hurtful remarks.
At the end they then again say 'kys' and use other sexist terms.
The fact that they use racist and sexist terms, repeatedly, is bad enough, but added with the suicidal encouragement, which is ILLEGAL (and whilst you've probably not going to get prosecuted for this, you could, under this act and others), 3 months doesn't even seem like enough.
Having said that, as going above 3 months isn't an option and 3 months has to be reserved for cases even more disgraceful than this one, I'll go less. Whilst, harassment is like this is serious 2 months doesn't seem enough, why? Let me explain:
X-ray results in a ban for 2 months. Seems fair enough? Yeah, but, what are the effects on others of your actions? If you're caught before PvP, none, it doesn't effect someone else's game. After, then maybe you ruined the fun for some people, which isn't nice, and 45 minutes for their time. On the other hand, encouraging someone to commit suicide could cost that person the rest of their live, and up to 14 years of yours, yet it you get banned for the same length of time, that doesn't make sense.
Other things tat are illegal carry harsher sentences, 12 months normally, yet harassment is a maximum of 3 months? That doesn't quite make sense.
In conclusion, 3 months has to be saved for cases even more disgusting that this, but 2 months simply isn't enough. That leaves me with really only one option, 2 Months, 2 Weeks.
P.S. I haven't proof-read this, so please tell me if there are any mistakes. Also congrats if you read all of this.