r/ledzeppelin • u/PaperVinnie53 Many times I've lied, Many times I've listened • Aug 14 '19
Could we ban posts relating Greta Van Fleet and Zeppelin?
I’m sorry but it’s starting to get exhausting seeing these posts every other week. We all have our opinions, and we’ve discussed them all here a million times over. I really think we could benefit from a cease of that discussion. Maybe I’m overreacting, and if I am I’ll simply take down this post, but I’m curious to see what others have to say.
53
u/OldMoby2 Hey, fellas, have you heard the news? Aug 14 '19
I agree with you. GVF has nothing to do with Zeppelin, and sure, theyre fun to rag on, but at this point it isn’t necessary.
20
u/Ziggy_from_Texas Aug 14 '19
Agreed, they're what, 18-20 year old kids having fun and not 25-30 year old musicians? That's not a very fair comparison, imo.
-2
u/FloppyChicken772 Rivers always reach the sea Aug 14 '19
plant was 18, bonham 17, page 20 and JPJ 22
when led zeppelin first started out.
plant's voice tore down by the time he was 30... this is not a good argument.
19
u/PaperVinnie53 Many times I've lied, Many times I've listened Aug 14 '19
Bonham is older than Plant by about 3 months, and Jimmy is older than JPJ, so I have no clue where you got these numbers from. They were both born in ‘48, Led Zeppelin was formed in ‘68. Plant and Bonham were 20, Jones was 22, and Page was 24 in 1968.
Also Plant gave us plenty of great vocals after he turned 30, look at Frankfurt ‘80 and Berlin ‘80.
-15
u/FloppyChicken772 Rivers always reach the sea Aug 14 '19
I Read it somewhere... but even so, my point still stands, they were still kids, and so are greta van fleet...
2
u/Ziggy_from_Texas Aug 14 '19
They didn't reach their peak right away though. It takes time for artists to do that, even Zeppelin. Still, we can't compare the music GVF has now to LZ's whole discography.
0
12
u/themerinator12 Aug 14 '19
The posts are exhausting. It’s either Greta bashing, circle jerking, or a weekly post asking for all the same opinions of LZ fans because they haven’t looked at the first 100 GVF opinion posts.
5
u/HeyKid_HelpComputer Aug 14 '19
I agree but I haven't seen any GVF posts for a while until this one?
2
u/PaperVinnie53 Many times I've lied, Many times I've listened Aug 14 '19
There was one yesterday man, sort by new.
36
u/doc_noc Aug 14 '19
Couldn’t agree more, who cares if they sound similar, I’m just glad there’s new bands still making this kind of music
9
25
u/ThisGuitarGuy Aug 14 '19
100% agree. I’m sick of people saying GVF reminds everyone of Zeppelin only because of their vocalist.
6
u/AndrewUnknown Aug 14 '19
I also agree with him, but it’s not just the vocals that are similar to Zep. The guitar work is not unlike what Page would do
4
7
Aug 14 '19
Gotta agree, take an upvote
Edit: nothing against GVF but as you said by continuing to discuss a comparison it’s beating a dead horse
8
u/simms419 Aug 14 '19
Found Robert Plants reddit account
0
4
4
u/EyesLikeBuscemi Aug 14 '19
Especially since 99.9% of them are shitposts and/or memes. Haven’t seen much actual civil and intelligent discourse with regard to the comparisons etc.
4
3
u/DarkestJediOfAllTime Aug 14 '19
This is an overreaction. If I see a GVF v LZ comparison post, I just avoid it. I don't read every post here. I only read the ones that interest me.
1
1
-1
u/j3434 Aug 14 '19
I think GVF is fair game for memes, jokes and so on . It is so bothersome to hear people claim they are not influenced by Zeppelin... or are as good ( or better??) as Zeppelin and silly nonsense like that. They are a hack Zeppelin copy band with that singer doing the Plant “babe” scream - and has the nerve to deny how they copy Zeppelin. As I see it GVF brought this on themselves. If they would have simply been humble like the Beatles and praise their influences there would be no shit talk. But they are so full of BS they deserve it.
If you don’t like it - down vote and the sub should take care of itself . But it seems that the GVF jokes are popular as they are a joke copy band and the youngsters need to learn this . If we don’t tell them who will ? Don’t censor us please !
-5
Aug 14 '19
Then we should ban discussion of all bands except Zeppelin.
8
u/PaperVinnie53 Many times I've lied, Many times I've listened Aug 14 '19
I would disagree. There’s nothing wrong with discussion of other bands, especially within the context of Led Zeppelin. The issue here is that we’ve been beating a dead horse with this GVF comparison ever since the band entered the spotlight. Many of us are clearly tired of hearing about it.
0
Aug 14 '19
[deleted]
5
12
u/wwinny7 I see the candle burning low Aug 14 '19
possibly the dumbest comment ever in this thread
6
1
•
u/Lurker2115 The darkest depths of Mordor Aug 14 '19
I actually proposed a rule to the other mods a while back with this in mind. The rule essentially was that only posts that featured GVF discussing or covering Zeppelin directly (or vice versa) would be allowed. One other mod was in support of it, but another one felt that it was unnecessary given how there had only been 3 or 4 posts about them in the last month. No other mods chimed in, so we essentially couldn't come to a consensus.
I'll tag some other mods here, but I have a feeling that the same thing will happen. /u/BonzosLiver, /u/merlinus, /u/MrDanger, what are your thoughts on this?