r/sffpc • u/godbq • Jun 26 '22
Build/Battlestation Pics Project ultra-silent gaming PC "Monolith" with Intel Core i5-12400F
/gallery/vla1et38
u/MyUserNameIsSkave Jun 26 '22
I feel torn as ever between my desires for a powerful PC and... that
7
u/drsakura1 Jun 27 '22
if I only need to do school work and run my small business, then I'd take that PC in a heartbeat cause I don't need the graphics power and the CPU is still quite powerful. For gaming though? My headphones block the sound of my PC just fine (despite how much I still obsess with getting it quieter)
12
u/LemmeGetUhhh Jun 26 '22
Disappointed there’s no strudel resting on that heatsink
Seriously though, great photography, great design. Awesome
14
u/pimpenainteasy Jun 26 '22
I'm guessing coil whine from PSU is the loudest thing in this setup...
7
u/Regular_Longjumping Jun 27 '22
I would rather have the sound of air moving from silent fans tbh...and a much more power pc too
4
u/xander-mcqueen1986 Jun 26 '22
Miss the kalm x range. Had the 750ti version not to long ago.
2
u/mornaq Sep 11 '23
it's a shame Palit always released them late and expensive
and it's a shame there's no card they could base it on nowadays
though if someone really wanted to there's no reason to not get AD104 and config it like 4000 Ada SFF with no pro tax and no ECC... that'd be an amazing card for a price of 4070-4070Ti
4
u/c_gfer Jun 27 '22
Why Noctua can't release all their products in glorious Chromax black? :( ...BTW, nice build!!!
3
3
u/Die4Ever Jun 26 '22
I'd be worried about RAM or VRMs in a truly fanless system, I tried to make a fanless system and a RAM stick died after just a couple years of light use. Could've just been bad luck idk.
1
u/drsakura1 Jun 27 '22
good VRMs will probably be fine, seeing as this PC is relatively low power. I could see RAM being an issue tho. was your case open air?
1
u/Die4Ever Jun 27 '22
nah it wasn't open, I know that makes a big difference without fans, but the ram here is tucked under the heatsink and next to the gpu
3
u/genericthrowawaysbut Jun 27 '22
I love fully passive builds like this but I’m always the one that wants the most power and sadly it means bigger heatsinks, but I still REALLY like the idea
2
2
2
2
u/HerpDerpenberg Jun 26 '22
Hopefully coil whine isn't bad. I couldn't stand my GPU, with 2x CPU fans and stock GPU fans going with the case opened up because of the coil whine at high frame rates. Having zero fans would make it even
2
2
2
u/MaintenanceSpirited1 Jun 27 '22
Use RTX A2000 please!
1
Jun 28 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/mornaq Sep 11 '23
I wonder if the KalmX heatsink can be modded to fit these cards, mounting on SFF models is pretty weird
personally I have Accelero S3 on my A2000 but it's a tad long, and Morpheus seems even longer
2
u/unevoljitelj Jun 27 '22
This is awesome but i have to ask. Lets say you use 12mm fan or two. One for cpu one for gpu, and set fan curve to minimum, even with smaller cpu heatsink. Is it going to audible? I mean i have 120mm fan on cpu and two 120mm on my gpu, open case and its barely audible when full load, just a slight hum. And keep in mind i wasnt trying to make it especialy silent, so zero effort. How sensitive are your ears and is this compromise worth it?
2
u/kulayeb Jun 27 '22
This is cool but the main purpose no fan cooling like this is actually industrial. Imagine a workplace full of metal dust/ chemicals etc hence passive cooling = minimal airflow and particles into the pc.
This kind of application for gaming is not practical but just cool and fun. Lowest setting fans especially noctua or something good quality is going to be below background noise levels.
1
u/mornaq Sep 11 '23
strapping A12x25 on P1 and running it at 600RPM would improve the performance a bit, but not really much
for the card there isn't even a point as KalmX already handles all the power you can get through PCIE
0
Jun 27 '22
[deleted]
1
u/unevoljitelj Jun 27 '22
that's negated with an open air design. You'll still have dust settl
you are right about ambient noise. but i dont have anything against this kinds of builds, acctually love to see what ppl come up with, but trying myself i found that theres too many compromises. there is no mini pcs that are both cold and quiet, its either or :) same here, low power card, medium range cpu and its all ok until its time to upgrade to more powerful parts. one thing tho, open air pcs dont really attract that much dust, i even have a cat and no problems.
2
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 26 '22
Hiya! Please post more details about your build! Here are some (non-exhaustive) prompts for you:
Are the case's advertised compatibility numbers accurate?
How easy is cable management?
How effective is the cooling setup?
Would you recommend your parts overall?
If you did a custom mod, how did you do it?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
u/giant4ftninja Jun 26 '22
I remember this case. Its awesome to see improvements made to the build. Looks great!
1
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 27 '22
I'd like to build something like this with ECC memory and HBA as a NAS and/or container host.
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 27 '22
Beauty.
How did you paint(?) the heatsinks? I am actually trying to make a "silent", or rather a really quiet pc based on the same GPU heatsink, but the color is really limiting my choices when it comes to CPU coolers. It would be nice to match it with the black ridge, for example.
0
u/Isaac8849 Jun 27 '22
I know this is for gags but why not just big high quality fans, it will literally be silent
-1
u/panzerbeorn Jun 27 '22
Like it overall but you’re really limited on what games can play at high settings.
0
Jun 26 '22
[deleted]
20
13
u/FartingBob Jun 26 '22
OP said system consumes 150w, so any branded 200w power brick would work perfectly fine.
163
Jun 26 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
44
u/_peter_parkinson_ Jun 26 '22
• Case: my 3D Model
Do you mind sharing the STLs? please :)
3
Jun 28 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
4
2
4
4
2
u/RaXXu5 Jun 26 '22
Did you anodize the heatsink?
Even one chromax A12x25 would look cool and be near silent.
2
Jun 28 '22
How did you finish your 3D print? Or is that straight off the bed with only light sanding? Looks almost matte, not sure if I can see any print lines. Also, no concern with sag from heat? Must be thick walls?
0
Jun 26 '22
[deleted]
65
u/wrathek Jun 26 '22
Next gen is going to be even crazier power hungry, well known at this point sadly.
7
u/Attainted Jun 26 '22
I think on the top end yes, but for the low end surely the die shrink should still help right?
24
u/gtorelly Jun 26 '22
Maybe, but there were no 2030, 2040, 2050, 3030, 3040... The low end is just not interesting for Nvidia, otherwise I believe we would have very efficient low end GPUs
5
u/iama_bad_person Jun 27 '22
The low end is just not interesting for Nvidia
Eh, that's not the reason. The silicon shortage meant there just wasn't any left for them to make anything lower than the 2050 or 3060, if you can sell a 3060 chip for full price why would you go any lower?
4
u/gtorelly Jun 27 '22
if you can sell a 3060 chip for full price why would you go any lower?I agree, that's covered in the "not interesting for Nvidia" part of my response.
4
u/Attainted Jun 26 '22
At a certain point of improvement though you can still take a low ish watt card though and downclock/undervolt enough for this though right? Like even a 6600xt?
4
4
u/TheCreat Jun 26 '22
Since 30-series, Nvidia didn't have any production capacity left to spend on low end. I mean we all know high end (or rather "any end") was in short supply for 2 years. Maybe with new plants coming online this changes, but low end requires higher volumes to be profitable. With production capacities in as high demand as it is, that might be years before that becomes viable again...
7
u/imzwho Jun 27 '22
Honestly the lower end amd cards sip power this gen. My rx 6600 routinely runs on silent passive cooling mode when playing older games or less demanding games and has never gone over 120 to 130 watts per afterburner for whatever that is worth.
9
u/metakepone Jun 26 '22
AMD is supposed to make a mid tier card with the same power as the 6900xt that runs at 220 watts so there's that.
6
u/ShadewoodChair Jun 26 '22
I would love if some company would make a much more beefy vga design, I would imagine that surely 100w+ would be possible. A passive 6600/xt if undervolted would surely be possible. Though maybe the small die size relative to power draw would pose more of a challenge...
3
u/styrg Jun 27 '22
Came to talk about the 6600xt. Delightfully cool and power efficient. 100W is an easy place to get it and the powercolor fighter version was very quiet.
0
Jun 26 '22
[deleted]
2
u/metakepone Jun 26 '22
Ah, didn't realize the goal was a passive gpu too... Maybe the 1630 might be able to do that... the 6400/6500xt are as small as thumbnails but their tiny fans are the loudest of all the cards this gen....
0
3
u/Bytepond Jun 26 '22
I mean they undervolt really well. I dropped ~80W of power consumption from my 3070ti without losing any performance. And then you can push it much further and lose some performance.
58
u/a12223344556677 Jun 26 '22
You can't just post the images without showing what's inside the base and how you made the heatsinks black!
Honestly I think test bench-style open frames look great and you can have truly infinite clearances without worrying about balance. Great job. The photo taking skills are superb too.