r/kpopthoughts • u/Plane_Sheepherder_74 • Oct 24 '21
Controversy Some of you bend over backwards to defend your idols rather than acknowledge that what they did was messed up
I’m actually shocked. Reading some of the things that I’ve seen come out of Kpop stans in light of the whole aespa scandal is shocking.
On the kpop sub and even in posts here, I see an endless stream of people defending giselle. That she’s in kpop, that we look at the world at too much of an American lens and that cancel culture is too much.
It’s actually shocking? Giselle was on Stan Twitter and she went to an international school. I’ve seen some people say that international schools don’t teach American history and I can tell you that’s not true? I’m not saying that all of them do but I went to a British international school in SEA and we learned it in class. Even if we hadn’t, a LOT of us consumed American media and knew the word was notoriously racist. It isn’t just an offensive word in American media, but loads of old literature have these words highlighted for its history.
Also, I’m kind of pissed because some takes infantilise Asians. It makes us sound like we’re this naive group of people. We’re not a one size fits all group of people. I know tons of people in my country who didn’t go to international schools but still know the word to be offensive.
Sorry but there’s no way giselle doesn’t know what the n word is, she was on Stan Twitter. At the end of the day what she said was offensive and I’m not saying that we should cancel her, but it definitely is something offensive that should be acknowledged because it alienates a huge portion of fans. To be honest, with this whole drama I’m less disappointed in her, and more angry at the fans who are doing EVERYTHING to defend her. It hurt doesn’t sit right with me
31
u/pornypete r/GFRIEND | Yuju | Hoppipolla | ADORA | g.o.d Oct 24 '21
I don’t know this particular situation. But Americans expecting the world to cater to their particular history and viewpoint is.. very true. They’re 1 out of 195 countries in the world, all of which find different things offensive, with different views and lines in the sand for what’s okay to say and do.
The thing is, you don’t have to forgive a celebrity if you think they pull something unacceptable. But you also shouldn’t try to police and enforce your opinion onto others, who may look at situations with a different severity. Just realizing that your own personal opinion isn’t fact, or the gold standard, and that it’s a big world out there, goes a long way.
32
u/Plane_Sheepherder_74 Oct 24 '21
I don’t really understand this argument though because the word is still universally offensive to a large population of people.
It’s just down to common empathy imo
Like would we be having this argument if a western celeb said chink? It’s deeply offensive to Asians and I don’t understand how anyone would want to use it knowing it’s used to put down ppl.
Idk that’s just my opinion
41
u/Strange_Elderberry68 Toad Not Shaken Oct 24 '21
I agree with the first paragraph, but disagree with the second one. If something is offending someone else, even if you weren't aware of your actions, you apologize. That is, in my opinion, basic respect and empathy and something that can and should be expected.
However, it is impossible to know about every culture in the world. It even depends on your surroundings if you know about racism in America. It is included in my country's curriculum, but only at a stage where 70% of all students have already left school. Now, if you can't speak English well, you most probably won't find anything about racism in America online either.
The level of awareness that you have might not apply to the rest of the world, and that's okay. We can talk to each other, explain why something is offensive, and if the other person apologizes and learns from their mistakes, that's great. If they don't, and don't change their behavior either, then they're a very unlikable person.
Finally, I am neither defending nor accusing Giselle with this. In fact, we don't know how much she did or did not know. Assuming anything would not be right. But I'd rather judge her by her reaction than her actions, because there is just too much uncertainty.
13
u/pornypete r/GFRIEND | Yuju | Hoppipolla | ADORA | g.o.d Oct 24 '21
Ah, I think I phrased it poorly. By all means voice your opinion towards that celebrity, if you feel slighted. What I meant was, don’t brush off other fans whose reactions to the incident differs from you own. Just because you’re outraged over something, doesn’t mean others should be as well. The OP seems to struggle with the fact that some fans are having different takes than themself.
65
u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 24 '21
I don't understand takes like this at all.
So kpop is allowed to use as much Black culture as they want, from the training system which originated with Motown, to styling to rapping to overall sound and etc.
Many trends in kpop are based in Black culture, music and etc, and kpop uses these. But at the same time kpop artists shouldn't be expected to respect the feelings of Black fans?
Not to mention how groups like Aespa have promotions aiming at international fans, they obviously want international fans so that should mean they should at least try to be respectful. They want the money from international fans but aren't willing to be respectful?
It's not America vs Korea and the rest of the world, it's insanely more nuanced and fans expecting an apology aren't in the wrong at all.
15
u/pornypete r/GFRIEND | Yuju | Hoppipolla | ADORA | g.o.d Oct 24 '21
Isn’t that the root of the issue here? Fans expecting their take to be respected, while having no time/understanding of the world outside their own personal viewpoint themselves? Expecting people on the other side of the world to place the same severity in choice topics as us seems ludicrous to me, especially with how little we in the western world extend that gesture ourselves.
If in this particular case she did call someone the n word, like the other commenter hinted at, I agree that it’s horrible and unnecessary. But I can also imagine someone from Asia having a somewhat more flippant attitude towards it than us, probably not having first hand experience with it, or having all their exposure to it via pop culture. And that in turn might make it more easily accidentally thrown out. Not that that makes it alright. I just think context matters.
5
u/WolfTitan99 Kpop? What about K-popcorn? Oct 24 '21
Yeah context and intent matters the most, but apparently people only see black and white as soon as this conversation comes up?
Like I'm not obligated to think that someones view of the situation is the 'gold standard' because EVERYONE has a different opinion. Every culture and race fights on whats accceptable among their own cultures. Nobody has to listen to me either. Everyone is going to think differently, no matter how much people plead otherwise, because we've lived through different experiences.
Lipsyncing a word thats in a song is the tamest thing for me personally. Like you're going to spend all your energy over this rather than people who are being hateful?
35
Oct 24 '21
The n word isnt only offensive in America, American people arent the only ones offended and black people dont exist only in America, lets cut that stupid rethoric once and for all
18
Oct 24 '21
I think people say that because the word itself comes from the United States, here in Chile, for example, there's really like 0% of black people who care about that word because it's not part of Black Chilean culture.
194
Oct 24 '21
i agree. i don't think international school are as much of a bastion of deep historical education as some think, but she was deeply immersed in stan twitter, and she knew not to do it before -- she likely knows what she did was wrong.
if i had to guess, maybe she thought it would be edited out? it doesn't sit right to me that she worded it right into the camera so confidently. /:
i'm definitely disappointed as a MY, but i'm more weirded out by the people who are being infantilizing in their efforts to defend her. giselle was WELL KNOWN for being very wordly, now she doesn't know what the n-word is? guys, come on.
63
u/Alr3adyTak3nUsername Oct 24 '21
Another day, another situation of k-pop fans willing to abandon their morals and critical thinking skills just to defend their favourite artist. What is new? Absolutely nothing.
-21
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
38
u/No-Committee1001 Oct 24 '21
Nobody ever said Giselle hates black people. I’m sick and tired of y’all looking at posts/comments, over exaggerating them, then getting mad at your clear over exaggerations. I’ve seen people hurt by Giselle, people wishing she would apologize, people tired of this happening again, not people saying “GISELLE IS A FUCKING NAZI AND EVERYONE WHO AGREES WITH HER IS TOO!” like literally what the fuck are you even talking about.
The person you replied to basically just said they’re tired of people being insensitive and this type of things happening in kpop, you made a whole different sentence and thought then got mad at that. You look fucking ridiculous.
138
u/New-Moon78 Oct 24 '21
I wasn't surprised GISELLE & AESPA has a lot of shooters so they see it as a non issue. Look if GISELLE didn't do no wrong SM wouldn't private the video after 1 hr or 2. GISELLE is not stupid, what she did was so wrong
238
Oct 24 '21
Considering she used Paris Hilton’s “that’s hot” for her yearbook (which is something that you won’t really know about unless you’re super immersed into American pop culture), and also how she kinda styled herself as an abg (long acrylic nails and the hearts photobooth filter) predebut I find it very hard to believe she isn’t aware it was a slur.
55
171
u/Strawberryhong 🐰🍋🍚Wonho's lemon rice 🐰🍋🍚 Oct 24 '21
Ok, lets assume she didnt learn the n word from stan Twitter on her school. Even then, didn’t she skip the word that one Tia Tamara song? If this is true (so far from what I’ve seen, it seems true but I can’t be 100% sure) that means she said the n word this time KNOWING it was wrong… if she didn’t know before, she 100% knows now. SM took down the video and so many people have tagged them and aespa on Twitter. Not to mention, on bubble too. Giselle knows what she did is wrong, whether now or before. The question is, will she apologise?
Also, I have another doubt… why did she do it so confidently when she knew she was being filmed? I would assume that even if giselle does use the word off camera (not saying she does), if someone is filming her why would she say it? Either she didn’t know it was wrong, didn’t know the editors would put it in, or just didn’t care. I don’t think it’s the last one, because ethical matters aside, from a business point of view, it would be kind of dumb for a group who’s promoting in the west to say the n word.
102
u/concom10 Oct 24 '21
The second paragraph is literally what I’m so confused about. If we assume she knows she shouldn’t say it but let’s say she doesn’t care, why would she do it in front of a camera even proudly so? Why subject herself to this criticism and hate?? I just don’t get it
74
Oct 24 '21
Hmm...was she confident that SM would edit it out? I can't think of any other reason...
69
u/concom10 Oct 24 '21
That’s such a risk to take tho. Hypothetically speaking if a racist thought like that I’m glad it wasn’t edited out
42
24
u/Strawberryhong 🐰🍋🍚Wonho's lemon rice 🐰🍋🍚 Oct 24 '21
Same here… I thought I was the only one who thought this way lol, I’m so confused. It’s not something that was leaked out, it’s something Giselle blatantly said in front of a camera, she looked right into it too. Either way, I’m quite sure she knows now if she didn’t before, due to all the noise about it on so many platforms. I still think an apology needs to be said, however I’m still confused over the nuances of this situation lol
21
u/Alr3adyTak3nUsername Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
According to what I heard, it is possible that SM isn't letting her publicly apologize and if that is true, they're downright stupid. They're probably doing it so that the situation won't receive anymore attention and die down soon but considering how they're targeting the western audience right now with Aespa, releasing an apology does seem like the best solution from a business stand-point of view, like you mentioned. I'm not even gonna look at this from a moral stand-point of view because it's pointless.
17
Oct 24 '21
i think sm loves rage marketing, cant say its a coincidence that there was so many rumours about karina around their debut and theres a plagiarism accusation every comeback.
68
u/myawithluv you want some sweet juice Oct 24 '21
Best comment in this shithole of a thread. Thank you for actually using logic and thinking. What got me was the leaning towards the camera when saying the word, she really wanted to make sure we really saw it and no misunderstandings, she’s so kind🥰
-12
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
17
u/myawithluv you want some sweet juice Oct 24 '21
Lmao….where to begin with this comment😭. First off nowhere in my comment did I imply any of the shit you spurted in yours, especially in your second paragraph because wow you really assumed the worst about people upset with her.
The whole point of these threads isn’t to start a “smear campaign” against Giselle, you’re being overdramatic. It’s to open a conversation about how some idols just. do. not. care. Giselle is 21 years old, fluent in English, is aware Black slang terms and culture, has rapped songs before with the n-word in it and omitted it and still made this “mistake.” That’s the issue.
Even if it just a slip-up, it was careless and she was literally standing next to her two group members who didn’t lip sync the word so no reason why she couldn’t either. Most people are not expecting an apology from her over this and SM already private the video, people will forget about it eventually, so you don’t have to go bending over backwards in these comments defending her and invalidating the opinions of people who are rightfully upset by this.
24
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
I find the whole situation bizarre. It’s such an ugly word. Would fans accept an apology? Also, I heard the thought that she was just getting too into the song and forgot to stop herself on that part (not justifying it). I think this is a good idea on why, rather then her saying it confidently all the time off screen
24
u/Strawberryhong 🐰🍋🍚Wonho's lemon rice 🐰🍋🍚 Oct 24 '21
Copy pasting my other reply:
That could be what happened, her getting carried away. but like I would imagine after saying it that I would be like “oh shit” and have a shocked face. Giselle just looked like she was vibing. But tbh, that clip was quite short iirc, so maybe she did realise only later. It makes the situation more understandable, but I still think it was wrong of her and she should apologise.
23
Oct 24 '21
Maybe she got carried away by the song.
50
u/Strawberryhong 🐰🍋🍚Wonho's lemon rice 🐰🍋🍚 Oct 24 '21
That could be what happened, but like I would imagine after saying it that I would be like “oh shit” and have a shocked face. Giselle just looked like she was vibing. But tbh, that clip was quite short iirc, so maybe she did realise only later. It makes the situation more understandable, but I still think it was wrong of her and she should apologise.
-10
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
6
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
9
Oct 24 '21
black people (and not americans) are the ones using the word because it is their community and history and they are allowed to reclaim it. what's not clicking?
-5
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/kimchi-cohen-barf Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
what the fuck? nobody is saying non-black people shouldn't be listening to black artists? non-black people shouldn't say the n-word because of it's extensive history regarding racism and slavery, period. it's not hard to not utter a single word, everyone should be allowed to indulge themselves in other culture's music, but there are still lines that should be crossed.
If that's the logic, then non-Koreans should stop listening to K-Pop because it's not for them and they're not Koreans and do not belong to the Asian community.
what the fuck are you even saying here? there is literally nothing of correlation, you're comparing non-black people using a RECLAIMED SLUR by another race to a specific song genre from another country.
and why are you acting like black people exist EXCLUSIVELY in america? black people literally exist around the fucking world. europe? asia? australia? why is it that whenever kpop redditors like you tackle on black issues you use america as an excuse to defend your statement?
-2
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
3
62
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
Fans are always the worst part of scandals and that is nothing new, first we have the WEIRDOS who inmediatly jump to use the scandal for fan wars, when i tell you i woke up to multiple dms of people calling me a hypocrite because i hadnt said anything about Giselle (when i didnt even know what had happened) but had called out other idols for similar behavior was ridiculous, mind you, i literally have 2 followers, i can only imagine the inbox of people who have larger following.
Then we have the people who try to make it seem like its our fault that idols say or do racist thing, the amount of people blaming SZA for having the n word in the song instead of being upset at Giselle for mouthing it has been stupid.
And lets not forget the people who use the opportunity to out themselves for being racist, bullies, homophobic, mysoginist and other wise horrible people.
Another thing that i hate and find very insulting that fans do is claim that "asians" are ignorant to certain issues, not the idol in question but asians as a whole, i dont know why but i find this rethoric to be pretty gross and racist.
And lastly we have the "lets educade them" crowd, sorry but im not educating anyone on anything, im not a teacher, if they want to learn from their mistakes they can do it on their own, they are adults not 5 yo children that need to be walked by the hand
The pathern that kpop fans follow every time there is a controversy is the same and its the thing that really enrages me when this things happen
.-Deflect:"American fans are always trying to force their ideals into kpop" because we all know that social issues (in this case racism against black people) dont exist in Asia and every person in the world is american (expect for the people who agree with you of course) and black people do not exist outside of america,europe and africa, DEFINETLY not in asia am i right?
-Minimize:"it was years ago" "they already apologize" "I'm x-race/culture and I'm not offended" "it's not that big of a deal, i don't understand why x-race/culture has to exaggerate everything" "they don't have to apologize"
-Hide: "trend x-idol best boy/girl to show our support even though what we really want is clear up the searches" DMs tw/insta accounts and threatens to mass report them if they don't take down their post about the situation, Doxes people who refuse to do the previous thing
ETA: thanks to whoever sent the reddit care massage, you are really mature
65
u/tyongyoil Oct 24 '21
I really am disappointed and surprised about giselle. I expect that everyone of giselle’s age would know about racial slurs by now because they grew up in social media. I’m from SEA and I’d just like to add that most of the people I know learned about racism against black people through social media and consuming American media. Schools didn’t teach us about this, they don’t even teach us properly about our own country’s history lol. I don’t know about international schools in Japan but I would assume it’s similar.
But given how Giselle was on Stan twitter and I’m assuming she has consumed a lot of American media and being surrounded by foreigners in an international school, surely she should’ve had atleast some knowledge.
51
u/Breezyrain aespa | RV | f(x) | SNSD | Twice | Mamamoo Oct 24 '21
I’m not defending Giselle, she definitely messed up and should apologize but it’s not just MYs defending her. Kpop fans as well are coming out of the woodwork to admit they sing the N word and exposing their questionable to racist tendencies.
For as much as Kpop fans try to claim they’re woke and knowledgeable about larger issues, many of them really aren’t. This is not new, as evidenced by every other scandal of this nature, it’s not exclusive to aespa.
21
u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 24 '21
Kpop stans use racism like Pokémon cards on an effort to claim they’re more morally superior. In this case I think a lot of them that aren’t her fans are thinking that if she can get off the hook for saying it, even without an apology, then their faves probably can, too. A bunch of them are also definitely just racist and want to be validated because they say it.
59
u/concom10 Oct 24 '21
Realistically speaking it’s kinda hard to know whether she was taught about it or not. We can’t know whether that specific international school in Japan teaches American history in depth and even if they do, this doesn’t mean they were subjected to this slur. I attended an international school (in another part of the world) and though I was taught some American history incl. slavery, I was never taught about this specific word. The first time I discovered it was wrong to say if you’re NB was on kpop twt. Secondly, we don’t know how frequently she actually goes on twitter. She mentioned to some Mys she saw some tweets but that’s about it. The assumptions about her being a stan twt regular or even that she lived in the US is just misinformation. Either way, she has to apologise. She definitely knows about it now, I hope SM doesn’t just silence her on SNS.
16
u/suryuaf youre my crush, i got a crush on you Oct 24 '21
the way every time an idol does something offensive there’s a post like this one.. kpop stans never learn
19
u/army__mali RV | Heize | æspa | NCT | itzy Oct 24 '21
Whether you believe she should’ve known better or not, there are a MILLION reasons why this shouldn’t have happened. Why it shouldn’t have come out of her mouth, or been caught on tape, or published online. Yes ok, let’s assume she’s simply ignorant (which is already cutting her a lot slack). Why were there no cultural sensitivity training sessions before debut? Why did no editor catch it? Why did someone upload this online? There is simply no excuse. The bottom line is that if SM or giselle or anyone REALLY cared about this issue, it either wouldn’t have happened in the first place or we would’ve gotten an apology immediately.
I’m tired of people arguing about whether her experience, background, or education was enough to know better. Honestly that isn’t the point. With how many times this has happened in the kpop industry specifically and the fact that sm targets the west in particular, this is just unacceptable. Stop trying to soften the blow and accept that what happened was just plain wrong.
26
u/Aggravating_Voice847 ✨✨kpoopheads is the best kpop sub🗣🗣🗣 Oct 24 '21
Twitter is full of people asking her to apologise. Most of the fandom is.
41
Oct 24 '21
Waiting for her fans to report this harmless post and lock it down 😣 OP you are absolutely right but I am afraid kpoppies aren't ready for this conversation...
13
u/1lifeSucks2 Oct 24 '21
Can I say, I'm from a country where people are predominantly black, and here we've got our own racial slurs that could get you into legit deep trouble. I was never aware of the negative connotations the word had( many people here and worldwide still don't) but once I was informed and found out more about it, I acknowledged that it's something that one shouldn't say lightly--- even if you aren't saying it negatively( since some people here used and still use the word as a addressing someone as their bro or something.)
Also, just because you aren't aware of something doesn't mean you shouldn't be informed about it, so that you can rectify your mistakes.
60
Oct 24 '21
its honestly jarring, people say “not the whole world know abt american history” kpop companies do and they should educate their idols considering the fact they’re seeking western validation cough sm and yg
62
u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 24 '21
Seriously everyone going like "America isn't the center of the world" confuses me.
Kpop idols are now signing with companies in the US, marketing there, hoping to break into mainstream and etc. They want international money and attention, and so it's not out of left field for kpop fans to expect them to be respectful.
41
u/Alex_BP_555 Oct 24 '21
>>They want international money and attention
America is not the center of the world and "international" not a synonym of "American", not even close, please stop using it this way - it is very colonialistic. And Kpop was international from its birth - it was always popular in EA/SEA countries - and this is almost 1/3 of Earth population.
But I agree, if Kpop want not only international but an American money too, then they should be respectful of American culture the same way American artists who are going to sell their albums, movies, games etc. to Asia should be aware and respectful to Asian culture and local traditions.
9
u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 24 '21
You realize that the n word isn't just disrespectful to Americans though?
Like it's not just America in this case, and also lmao that mindset is coloniastic?? I'm not even from America, or the West, I've immigrated here but my family is from Asia.
13
u/Alex_BP_555 Oct 24 '21
Of course, not only Americans familiar with this word, but also the subjects of an American cultural colonisation (you and I are obvious examples).
A mindset that implies that American or Western culture is a global culture.
-12
Oct 24 '21
Most Americans don't care though, because most Americans are sick of the endless outrage.
10
u/airaK_666 i go to skool boii Oct 24 '21
I think that’s the thing though- not the whole world knows about American history, as in normal people in random cities around the world. However, with kpop companies targeting American markets and putting out content for fans across the world to see- they do have a responsibility to know exactly what they’re putting out.
These companies and idols do have a responsibility to not say racial slurs, especially if you think about the fact that they’re consuming content from prominently black artists. Tbh no one should be saying these but it’s a little more understandable if they genuinely were never exposed to it. I think the whole America argument is valid when you think about a regular Joe going about his life in a different country- with idols and kpop companies it’s a bit different.
3
18
u/jjirithae Oct 24 '21
Even she if she didn't know what the word was, she needs to apologize. I usually give the benefit of the doubt because for the longest time I didn't know the word was bad either and I can understand if someone that doesn't know much about american culture doesn't know about it but let's be honest, Giselle definitely knows. I'm very upset because she's my bias but if she doesn't apologize I'm definitely dropping her.
7
u/Technical_Capital_19 Oct 24 '21
I thought she did a previous song cover (by doja cat if I'm not mistaken) that had the n word but she didn't say it and people were praising her all over
11
u/Hungry-Magazine-2543 the 'k' in kpop is for kwangya Oct 24 '21
Did giselle say she was on stan twitter? Everyone keeps repeating this but at this point I don't know where it comes from
21
Oct 24 '21
Honestly, Even as Black person, The more people talk about this, the less I'm starting to care. Why? If the people who are supposedly angry really do care, I doubt they'd be acting the way they are now. I wanna have a true discussion on the matter, not just ya'll mocking giselle.
The black people who are the ones hurt acting more sane than the rest which says ALOT.
10
u/skykey96 Oct 24 '21
Every time someone do a cover with the "n-word", it feels like the reactions from people are as if the artist literally screamed to a real person some slug and treat them like garbage, which is not the case. And it bothers me how we can't separate a real offense from singing a song without further intention.
Reactions are disproportionate and it frustrates me a lot.
5
u/curiousmind1950 Oct 24 '21
Ngl it was a personal revelation when that white girl got shit at a kendrick lamar concert when he brought her on stage and she sang along to the lyrics, which contained the n-word. I’m an immigrant to America from Asia so didn’t know the sensitivity - but i remember i was shocked cause that girl basically got in trouble for violating an unwritten rule that only black people know about (the rule being: black people can call each other that and a comedian even called Obama that at his last white house correspondence dinner, but for non blacks its basically high treason). Someone should forward this video to Giselle so she learns
She probably didn’t mouth it in the tia tamera video cause it is considered a curse word and so couldn’t mouth it while filming knowing bros, maybe? I think to prevent this company should stop letting their idols sing songs that have n-words to avoid controversy, even though that can be hard since all the popular songs nowadays do. Maybe start covering taylor swift and justin bieber again lmao
4
u/Project-Rich Oct 24 '21
Not some people defending her and blaming the song for having n word! Dude SZA can say that cause she is a black person. But Giselle is not! No matter if it's in a song or not..the word is a slur. I am sure people who are defending her are non black and anti black people.
6
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
People have full rights to be offended. But. This whole “we need to reeducate them” reeks of “we are holier than thou art and we need to save you from your ignorance”.” It does add to the hero complex image people have of us Americans and is fairly totalitarian. “We need everyone to think like us because only we are right”
52
u/misteryflower Oct 24 '21
But this is not an issue of only American culture. It's an issue of race. Black people exist outside of America. Everyone should try to understand and educate themselves in order to not hurt the people around them.
50
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
wanting people to avoid saying racial slurs is "fairly totalitarian"? if you wanna defend giselle do it with your chest, don't make embarrassing reaches like this. some people don't even want to educate her, because they realise that this girl probably does know that the n-word is offensive. but, even if she didn't know and people want to inform her, there is nothing wrong with that. it is not a matter of conforming to the exact same beliefs, its a matter of showing basic respect. besides, racism exists worldwide, not just in america, so to frame this as an "americans think the world revolves around them" issue is disingenuous at best. in the context of kpop, that argument doesn't even make sense, because these companies are trying to break out in the us. it would be practical for them to be aware of these things.
do you also accuse the south koreans who call out international fans for ignorance or racism of "having an american saviour complex"?
-12
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
No, forcing people to agree with you and accept your demands is totalitarian. The fact that most of the counter arguments are “that’s embarrassing for you to say” (trying to make me feel bad about my different thoughts) proves my point. You can ask for basic respect. You shouldn’t continue to harass people or groups after asking, nor because you believe they don’t actually believe in your cause and just complied. That’s mob mentality.
I never said America only thinks about themselves, now you’re generalizing. I never said it wouldn’t be smart to consider what is offensive or not to break out in the us. I’m just saying re-education is a terrible mind set and two wrongs doesn’t make a right.
48
u/AhGaSeNation Oct 24 '21
For the love of God when will you people stop acting like issues like this are somehow exclusive to America?? Like black people don’t exist or face racism outside of the states. We hear all the time about black people facing racism anywhere they go in the world but somehow y’all find a way to reduce it to being an American issue that no one else need concern themselves with.
It’s not acting holier than thou to expect BASIC respect and sensitivity. It’s a single racial word that non-black people need to keep out of their mouthes really not asking for much and it’s very telling that some people find it difficult to do even that. Or worse try to justify why they don’t feel the need to do that. And it’s strange that some of you don’t think it’s necessary for your idols to even learn to not be offensive. I wouldn’t outright hate an idol for doing something like this but I would absolutely appreciate it if they learned from it and showed that they understood that what they did was offensive. Because that alone let’s me know they actually give a shit and are growing from it.
And the last part of “we need everyone to think like us because only we are right”…I don’t know how you can come to that conclusion when people are just asking someone to not use a racial slur. And I don’t know how anyone can “be right or wrong” about racism. If I was told that something was racist I wouldn’t be like “Well I think you’re wrong I don’t think it’s very racist”, because it’s not my place to decide what’s offensive for someone else. Your comment should’ve ended after the first sentence.
-12
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
I agree and think racism is global
I agree idols and celebrities and anyone shouldn’t say it
I agree you have a right to say that it hurt your feelings HOWEVER
I never stated that I think it’s an American issue, I’m commenting and criticizing the re-education aspect, so the method not the purpose
YOU have no right over another to force them to agree with you. You can state your sentiment and hope they will understand what they did wrong, but not to continuously track them down until they surcome to your demands. Some people don’t believe in your sentiments, even though it is morally just. Some people just aren’t 100% understanding, and you just have to leave them. You don’t just re-educate them, you leave them. They don’t need to be in your life. Bad people/ good people who do some bad things are all over. You need to learn that you’re never going to get rid of that, nor are you just for trying to change another for that.
And btw, you can totally disagree with someone about what is racist or not. You can disagree without disregarding another’s opinions. “While I don’t think that is racist, I am sorry this made you feel this way.” Racism is wrong. That’s not what I’m arguing against. I’m just saying the mob mentality to force other people to agree with the idea (even though it is just) is wrong too. Doing something wrong to a bad person doesn’t make it right (not saying Giselle is bad, I’m just generalizing)
9
u/AhGaSeNation Oct 24 '21
You’re right I can never force anyone to agree with me but I am NOT wrong for standing up for what is right just because they’re too stubborn or morally compromised to see that I’m right. If someone IS racist I am not wrong for telling them so that’s just absurd.
If you think it’s better to let people carry on spreading their insensitive/hurtful ideologies just because they probably won’t ever change their mind then you do you. I know that when I encounter someone racist or sexist or otherwise morally compromised there is only a slim chance that I can change their mind, but that doesn’t mean I will stay silent and not make them face their moral shortcomings. Most people carry racism with them from a young age so I know that it’s difficult to make them unlearn that but that doesn’t mean I’m not gonna tell them they’re racist and everything else wrong with the way they think. They may not change their minds but they will at least be confronted with the fact that there is something wrong with the way they think and it’s not socially acceptable. If they choose to continue to be that way then that’s their business but they’ll do so knowing that it’s wrong.
As for your last paragraph I disagree for a number of reasons. First: A non-black person telling a black person that a racial thing against black people is not racist is absurd. How can a non-black person tell a black person that them saying the n-word is not racist, when the n-word was always used as a racial slur against black people?! Can you not hear how insensitive that sounds?
If I said something offensive/racist and someone of the offended race informed me that it was racist, how insensitive would I have to be to say “Oh well that’s not racist but I’m sorry you feel that way”. Saying you’re sorry they feel that way is not an apology btw it’s almost worse than not apologizing at all because you’re not taking responsibility for anything, it’s just rude and condescending.
4. Again it’s is NOT wrong for me to call someone out on their problematic mentality. If someone is being racist I am not wrong for telling them that and telling them why. Don’t villainize people for telling racist/problematic people what they don’t want to hear because it conflict with their fucked up ideologies. We’re not doing a bad thing to bad people, we’re doing a necessary thing. But it doesn’t seem like you feel it’s necessary at all to straighten out the racists of the world. If everyone was the way you were then the racists would simply be allowed to run rampant and unchecked. Feel free to carry on that way but not me.
26
u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 24 '21
You're reaching so bad.
Yes we need to reeducate people that saying the n word is wrong no matter the circumstance, which is what op is saying.
Your weird removing it from context is what makes it sound totalitarian.
-13
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 24 '21
People literally are just wishing they could educate her on why that word is disrespectful and hurtful. Maybe reeducating isn't a great word choice, but you're way over exaggerating.
No one is saying they're going to tie her to a chair and force education, but that they wish she'd listen and learn. Y'all getting way too into this whole "American centric", "totalitarian" "thought police" and etc are being obtuse.
We are allowed to have expectations for other people and their behavior, that's not totalitarian.
20
Oct 24 '21
hot take: i don't think it's political to tell someone using a racial slur that isn't yours to use is wrong. it's really too bad if people think it is, because it's not. it's basic human decency not to do that.
as for whether or not it's wrong for black people to reclaim their own slur, unless you're black, that's not really a conversation either of us should be having. again, not really political.
6
u/AhGaSeNation Oct 24 '21
You’re being dramatic. They just want non-black people to not say a racially charged word that is not even meant for them in the first place. That’s all. If you’re not black, don’t say the n-word. Such a simple thing yet causes so much controversy amongst certain people. It’s not even about being more enlightened than anyone it’s about wanting basic human decency and respecting other races.
You’re villainizing an already marginalized group of people by saying they’re “enforcing their opinions” or “policing” them when really they’re just sticking up for themselves. It’s fascinating how you and other people on the kpop subs are acting like people are demanding so much when really all they’re asking for is a little sensitivity and decency.
3
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
Legit question. Why can’t we just drop the word together. No group says it. It’s not a good word to try to reclaim
6
u/AhGaSeNation Oct 24 '21
It’s not YOUR choice. Not your word, not your choice. Not your place to tell people what they can and can’t reclaim. So what you’re saying is you’re only willing to not say the word if they don’t either? If you can’t have it neither can they type of deal? That’s not how it works. You should respect what THEY want since it’s THEIR word. Again it’s about respect which you seem to lack.
0
Oct 24 '21
[deleted]
2
u/PoyuPoyuTetris Oct 24 '21
“Giving her a chance to learn” doesn’t that sound a bit “I’m know better than you?” Also sounds like a threat. “Give you a chance to learn or else.” The more reasonable way would be to state your sentiment respectfully, and stop supporting them if they don’t apologize, not to harass them until they do.
4
Oct 24 '21
I’m ready for all the non-black people and their fake outrage to go away. Y’all wanna be offended so badly, and for what? Y’all are weird.
3
u/nadjp Oct 24 '21
I know i will get punished for this i can take it, but this panic culture because of a word is so so weird and honestly kinda annoying to me. I came from Europe from a country where no one had to do anything with slavery. We learned about it in schools ofc but never understood the taking of n word where black people are allowed to say it, but others are banned. (I know the meaning and the context of it) but really. Objectively thinking for a second. Its not weird if u listen in a radio u can jam to it but if u lip syncing you deserve to be cancelled suddenly? Until a black person uses it in a song it's all cool, but if it's a white person you suddenly feel like u committed a sin listening to it ... Why we don't ban the world for everyone? Or lets ban non-black people from listening song containing the n word...
1
u/sladeshied Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
Let me explain, there are two n-words. One with the -gger ending, and one with the -gga ending. The -gger one was used for centuries as a slur against black people. So by using the one with the -gga ending, black people are taking back that word.
When black people say n - gga, it means friend, dude, guy, brother. So you hear it a lot in rap, used in a good way. The original word means something very awful for them, which is why they don’t want non-black people to use it. Understandable. Hope this helps.
People like OP, who isn’t black, barely know the difference but they want to make posts like these, so I don’t blame you for being confused.
8
u/nadjp Oct 24 '21
Is it? I knew this thing but if they use it as a let's say friendly way between each why it's instantly a rude word from others? So for my mentality slavery was never be a thing in my country but suddenly i got introduced to the n-word from basically black artists using it for every occasion and im just not allowed to use that slur (which i would never use/known of) because people reacting like I'm the one who invented slavery. Don't get me wrong what happened is one of the worst thing in history of humanity, i got it. But for me this 'we can use this word but u cant' is just simply so childish and keeps up a difference between people... I dont know a solution to this situation but to sing a song and getting a backlash for lipsyncing the actual lyrics is just so unrealistic/weird for me.
7
u/eldritchironhorse Oct 24 '21
I mean, "we can use this word but you can" is the point. Black people are saying that the centuries of oppression they faced, which included the n-word being a slur, make them uncomfortable with non-black people saying it. I don't think it's childish to ask non-black people to be aware of the history of the word. Like the other comment said obviously not all black people have the same opinion, but when the majority have been saying for a while to not use that word and someone uses it anyway, I would call that racist.
3
u/sladeshied Oct 24 '21
Not all black people find it offensive when a non-black person uses n - gga, though. I have met black people who were totally fine with their non-black friends using this word whenever they want to. The problem is, it’s hard to generalize and out of millions of people, of course opinions will differ. Depends om the person. But for the majority of black people, this word is an absolute no-no for people outside their race.
2
-6
u/alfmrf Oct 24 '21
don't you guys think that the n-word, the f-word, etc. should be banned from lyrics as a whole and censored even on explicit versions? i think so.
It's a bit paradoxal you have the nastiest word being sang and played by top artists but when people sing a long they are racists and should censor themselves. Sometimes ignorant people just read the lyrics and repeat.
I'm not defending her here. Even though i don't think it was a big deal. She was following the song so it could be an honest mistake. Some people make it seem like she was calling people n... all around and that was def not the case here.
It's def an issue that needs some sort of education on SM's part and management. On the other hand some people calling her racist, saying she did it on purpose or dont care.. wtf dude? how can you assume that?
3
u/eldritchironhorse Oct 24 '21
I think it's kinda ridiculous to suggest that all curse words should be banned from songwriting just because some people listening might not know the context of those words. The n-word has a history that makes it painful for black people to hear, even when it's said (or mouthed along to) by someone ignorant of that history. That's not that person's fault, but black people have the right to be hurt and to discuss that hurt.
And yeah, her mouthing the word is not the most racist thing in the world. But at this point, idols have been called out countless times for using that word inappropriately. It's very unlikely that idols fluent in english are completely unaware of all the times fans have been upset about this.
0
u/QuietIllustrious Oct 24 '21
WHAT why should it be banned because people not of color cant help but say it. Black people could because the people singing it are black so we black people can say it. That also means that non black people cant say it duhhhh what is so hard to comprehend about that
If you want to sing it so much I dare you to sing it around me or other black people see what will happen youll get beat up over it some people even die over saying it
1
u/alfmrf Oct 24 '21
you missed my point, buddy... i don't think an ultra offensive word like this one should be said at all. And even less on media people consume and repeat without knowledge. I know black people can say it and others can't. I'm also a person of color and i would rather have offensive words towards my race and others getting banned.
-13
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
Well, this may be an unpopular opinion but it's not her fault that the n-word is in the lyrics. Yáll Americans are so quick to cancel or accuse every non-black who sings songs with the n-word in it, labeling them as "racist". Guess what, believe it or not, most people in the world who aren't American don't care about American history. If yáll American people couldn't care about Asian History (Korean history for K-Pop Fans), Asians couldn't care less with whatever history you have in the US. Just because American pop culture and media are worldwide famous does not mean the world revolves around America. The world doesn't revolve around America so quit that mentality that people have to know about your history or whatever.
If you do not want non-blacks to blurt out the n-word while singing, then do not use such words in your songs. You Americans keep putting that in your songs but get offended when non-Americans sing to your song with the word as lyrics? That's quite ridiculous.
6
u/sladeshied Oct 24 '21
It’s because n-gga can mean friend, brother, dude, or mate to black people. So it’s understandable why they use it in their music. But bc of its racist history, its also understandable why non-black can’t say it. So just don’t say it. Or don’t listen to songs with it.
14
u/kimchi-cohen-barf Oct 24 '21
how hard is it to just... not say a word people cant reclaim? im not even black and i understand how black people feel about the word so i dont sing it.
-6
Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
how hard is it to just... not say a word people cant reclaim? im not even black and i understand how black people feel about the word so i dont sing it.
Just my two cents regarding the issue and I don't care if people would agree or not.
How about black songwriters refrain from using words that were historically meant to oppress them, even if it's meant as like "bro"? I mean I would never use "chink" if I were an East Asian songwriter, even if became a popular slang for a friend ( or chingu in Korean) among the Asian community. If they want everyone (including Asians, whites, latinos, etc) to listen to their music, then don't include words that would make non-black listeners awkward or feel uncomfortable to jam onto it. It's their responsibility to empower their own people in any way or form, but to include the n-word in their songs when there are alternatives?
This is why I don't listen to black music, it's too much of a gray area and I know I'm not welcomed in their community and would be accused as racist just for jamming into their songs.
5
u/sladeshied Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
gb_20, I get what your point is. The thing is though, most artists, singers and rappers, use music as their form of expression. They don’t want to filter themselves or refrain themselves to not use this or that word, just because some people won’t feel included. For example, Ariana Grande has millions of fans, many of whom are probably young children, but does that stop her from singing about sex? Nope. That’s her expression, she’s free to express herself in her music. And like you said, just don’t listen to it.
-8
Oct 24 '21
I don't care what idols do. I literally just don't care. Just make good music, dance well and create good content. I don't GAF what kind of person they are outside of work. Because it's a job. By the way, how is your moral compass?
0
Oct 24 '21
[deleted]
25
u/wjcult Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
simply, sza is a black woman. if she wants to say the n-slur it's her prerogative. giselle is not. stop trying to make the weight of both of them saying it equal because it absolutely is not. i can't believe i have to explain this at all.
0
Oct 24 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 24 '21
Hello /u/CheesecakeThat153. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
Oct 24 '21
[deleted]
14
u/WolfTitan99 Kpop? What about K-popcorn? Oct 24 '21
Would it be the same if you didn't speak english? Just curious as to what the reach is. Would you say all of your friends know about the word or even your parents?
I feel like its a very generational thing and it depends on how connected you are to the english side of the internet. I'm just curious lol
22
u/sladeshied Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21
Since you’re Asian, OP, I just want to clear up your misinformation.
The n-word (with the -gga) is only offensive in certain contexts and when non-black people say it. When black people call each other the n-word, it is usually not offensive and is a term of endearment, similar to saying friend, like guy or dude or bro. So you hear it a lot in rap songs. And the ending (-gga) DOES matter. It is not the same as -gger, which is, to this day, extremely offensive. I agree with everything else though.
Please understand that words have nuances, evolve over time, and differ in cultural and social settings.